Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout43-City Clerk CITY OF SAN BERNARDlNO - REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION From: Shauna Clark REC'D.-AlIIN. OPF. 1987 May -4 PM 4: 24 Subject: Records Management Program (Records Retention Program or RIM) Dept: City Clerk Date: May 1, 1987 Synopsis of Previous Council action: Legislative Review Committee has been looking at proposed records management program. (All materials which have been given to the Legislative Review Committee are attached following this staff report) . Recommended motion: Authorize the implementation of a Records Management Program as outlined and authorize the City Clerk to go forward with the understanding that all equipment purchases and other expenditures will be brought back before the Mayor and Council for approval. ~2///?~.-aM / Signature Contact panon: Shauna Clark Phone: 383-5109 Supporting deta attached: Staff report, Records Mgt. StuCWard: l;OSt: J:;st:~mat:es FUNDING REQUIREMENTS: Amount: $60.000 "Quipment. Additional labor. Source: (ACCT. NO.) To be determined ;It (ACCT. DESCRIPTION) Finance: hit':. c~ Council Notes: ~ Prc.r........O .co_ ,,,: pp",o-..Jl.-I . " . , (~"f,~,,+... f"o ", L"'+-'~ /'\lOI.?Y ( '"J""t.i ~, II 6 ~ it',l .;~...+~g '-' ...,.( . ,/...... '" .i'J - J' r iJ - .P'y< ~ !;::i' 1~ An..nri. I t.rn Nn . . CI{:} OF SAN BERNARD.~O - REQUE~r FOR COUNCIL AC\:'DN STAFF REPORT The City Hall Office Space Study concluded that 6,000 square feet of City Hall space is dedicated to records storage. The study also estimated that one-third of this space is being taken up by obsolete records and another one-third is being used by duplicate records. Destruction of the records is the best solution for freeing up the space. Unfortunately, our records management study showed that no department in the Ci ty has a schedule or a plan for destroying records, and that departments don't realize that many records they store that are also stored in other departments. ' A Records Management Program would create space within City Hall, help departments make decisions about records, reduce records to a more sui table form such as microfi 1m, index records for faster retrieval and reduce labor costs. 75.0264 . o o o Records Management Page 2 May 1, 1987 Implementation Plan The Records Management Program would be implemented through the following steps: 1. Survey the records of each department within City Hall. 2. Work with each department in developing a record reten- tion schedule. 3. Reconcile the department's records retention schedules to identify duplicate and obsolete records. 4. Classify all records as: (a) active (referenced once per month or more) (b) inactive (referenced less than once per month but required to be on file for more one year) (c) archival (historical records that must be kept indefinitely). 5. Develop an overall records retention and des- truction plan which will be adopted by the Mayor and Common Council as official City policy. 6. Once official City policy is adopted, each depart- ment with help from records manager, will sort out and destroy obsolete and duplicate records. Inactive records will be transferred to the records center. 7. Begin records staging. Inactive records are trans- ferred to records center where they will be sorted catalogued, indexed and in most cases, copied on microfilm. (If microfilm is approved). 8. Purchase necessary equipment for records manage- ment, which may include microfilm cameras, a small computer for indexing records, a microfilm reader/ printer, and a high density filing system. . o o o Records Management Page 3 May 1, 1987 The Costs of a Records Management Program Purchase of equipment: Approximately $60,000 Labor: Records Manager $24,000 year (approx.) Additional Clerical help if needed: $19,000 per year Supplies/Maintenance: $8,000 per year Savings generated by Records Management Space: Based on present City Hall space rental. Rate: $60,000 per year Labor: Unknown at this time because we haven't determined how much labor in City Hall is dedicated to filing and retrieval of obsolete and duplicate files. Using industry standards the amount is estimated to be $810,000 per year. . , o o o { ,~ " RECORDS MANAGEMENT STUDY . . (--- ,~~":: . .'~"" Prepared by Shauna Clark, City Clerk July 9, 1986 ( ...... . ( ~ I. II. . , III. IV. I C,-, V. VI. VII. \ '-' o o TABLE OF CONTENTS DEFINITIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . RECORDS MANAGEMENT PROGRAM RECOMMENDATION . . PHOTOGRAPHS OF RECORDS STORAGE AREAS IN BASEMENT OF CITY HALL AND CITY YARDS . . . BENEFITS OF RECORDS MANAGEMENT PROGRAM~ . . . .... 7~.', ':l. DRAFT ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING PROCEDURES GOVERNING THE MANAGEMENT OF CITY RECORDS . COpy OF RECORDS QUESTIONNAIRE AND A SUMMARY OF THREE RESPONSES . . . . . . . . A. DUPLICATE FILES . . . . . . . . B. VITAL RECORDS . . . . . . . . . . . . C. MICROFILM: BENEFIT OR DETRIMENT . MICROFILM COSTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . o Page 1 2 4 7 8 15 17 20 22 23 . ( -' I ' c'-' (- o o o DEFINITIONS Archives :.: Those records that are worthy of permanent pre:': servation because of the importance of their information for continuing administrative, legal or fiscal purposes or for historical or other research. (Minutes, Resolutions, Ordi:': nances, for example) Inacti ve Records - Records referred to less than once per month. They are still needed occasionally for government business, but they do not need to be retained in their offices of origin. Records Center - A central location within City Hall where inactive records are maintained. Records Center Manager The person responsible for the records dispos i tion schedule anc:t: for the Records Center. Records Disposition Schedule - A listing of records series indicating for each series the length of time it is to be maintained in office areas and in the Records Center. The schedule constitutes authority for the destruction of records listed thereon, after required retention periods have lapsed. - 1 - . o o o RECORDS MANAGEMENT PROGRAM RECOMMENDATION The Ci ty Hall Space Study concluded 'that "a lot of valuable office space is used for records and supplies stor~ age. Departmental active records are presently stored with inactive, records, and are often scattered about in various department locations". As a result of this finding, it was recommended that a microfilm study be undertaken. At the request of the City Administrator Ray Schweit- zer, the City Clerk's Office assumed the responsibility for the microfilm study. In the process of looking at micro- film, we found that there are two important elements to making a micrographics program successful: 1. A good records management program 2. A good indexing system for the documents placed on film. ----- Before any conclusions are reached with regard to micrographics, the records management needs of this City should be considered. The pressures of everyday responsi- bilities have left little time for most departments to address records problems. Limitations on space, staff and other resources have discouraged action. As few officials have assumed direct responsibility for the care and organi- zation of records, records have become everyone's problem, but no one's clear responsibility. If you look at the photographs of 'the records storage areas in the City Yards and Basement of City Hall, you will see how our archives are "managed". Our survey found that: No department in City Hall has a compre- hensive records disposition schedule Most departments do not separate active and inactive records Many departments have duplicate records No provisions have been made for protecting vital records or reconstructing records in the event of a disaster (See Findings). .......' - 2 - o o o o ........ The City Hall Space Study determined that 6~000 square feet of space within the building is occupied by filing equipment (both in general office and storage rooms)., If construction of replacement space for a public building were estimated at $100 per square foot, the value of this space would be $600,000. The Space Study also reported that an estimated 2,000 square feet could be saved in records des:': truction alone ($200,000 worth of space). Another way to calculate the value of the space used by file storage is at City Hall's full service rental rate of $1-.25 per square foot. The rental value of the space now occupied by filing equipment is $90,000 per year. If a 33% reduction of this space can be obtained through destruction of duplicate records, the value of the space saved would be $29,700 per year. I I 'I I Before departments begin to clean out and destroy records, guidelines must be established and someone must be designated to oversee the records program. I am recommend- ing that the following action be taken by the Mayor and Council: ~ 1. Approve the Records Center concept - a Records Center would be located within City Hall where inactive records are managed 2. Adopt an ordinance establishing a Records Management Program for the City of San Bernardino - a sample ordinance has been prepared for your perusal 3. Designate a Records Management Official who will: I I I a. Oversee the preparation of a Records Disposition Schedule for all City records b. Manage the Records Center c. Take the necessary actions to preserve historical records d. Advise departments and oversee the destruction of City records e. Fulfill the micrographics needs of the departments. ....... - 3 - - . o o Q ~' BENEFITS OF A RECORDS MANAGEMENT PROGRAM Save Tax Dollars ~ By preventing the creation of unnecessary records; by d iscourag i ng unnecessary copy i ng; by transfer": ring inactive records from office space to a records center; by destroying obsolete records; and by permitting the re~ cycling of filing cabinets and other records storage equip~ ment and reducing purchases of new equipment. Cut Future Costs - By ensuring that expensive new equipment such as microfilm cameras are purchased only after careful analysis and planning determine that they will contribute to the government's information management needs in a cost effective way. :' '"",-" Save Space By removing inactive records from crowded offices where space is at a premium; by systematically dis- posing of obsolete records; and by microfilming selected records and disposing of the originals. The space study determined that 6,000 square feet of City Hall office space was used for storage of documents. Save Time - By ensuring that records are well organized and maintained so that employees spend a minimal amount of time and effort in locating needed material. , Help Managers - By making it easy for departments to locate and use information to monitor programs, ensure admini- strative continuity, and make decisions. Protect the City - By ensuring that contracts, agreements and other records of the Ci ty' s legal rights and responsi- bilities are well organized, well protected and easily located when needed. Support Historical and Other Research - By ensuring that records of enduring value are, identified and preserved and by providing a public access point for research of public records. ........... - 7 - . . o o o --- ORDINANCE NO. ORDINANCE CHAPTER MUNICIPAL MANAGEMENT OF THE CITY OF, , ARTICLE CODE AND ESTABLISHING OF CITY RECORDS. SAN BERNARDINO AMENDING OF THE SAN BERNARDINO PROCEDURES GOVERNING THE THE MAYOR AND COMMON COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO DO ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Chapter , Article of the San Bernardino Municipal Code is amended to read as follows: "PROCEDURES GOVERNING THE MANAGEMENT OF CITY RECORDS "-" Section Purpose and Intent It is the purpose and intent of this Section to estab- lish procedures for the ongoing management of City records. Section Policy The policy of the City of San Bernardino is to provide for efficient, economical and effective controls over creation, distribution, organization, maintenance, use and disposition of all City records, to provide to the public and to City departments correct information in the right order, at the proper place and time, at the lowest possible cost. The (Records administration of assisting all City Official) shall be a uniform Records departments. responsible Management for the Program Section Definitions (a) 'Appraisal' - The process of determining the value and thus the disposition of records based upon their (1) administrative, legal, fiscal and historical uses; (2) relative activity; (3) relationship to other records; and (4) evidential and informational value. '-' (b) 'Disposition' Actions taken with regard to records and nonrecords following their appraisal. These actions include the transfer of inactive records to the Records Center or the destruction of records or nonrecords no longer required in the course of the City's business. - 8 - o o o o (c) 'Duplicate Record' :: Copies or reproductions of original records; whether or not the same physical form as the original, which are retained for personal reference or for operational requirements. (d) record. 'Maintain" Provide custody and care for a (e) 'Nonrecord':: Material which is not retained in the regular course of business or is a temporary aid, not created for the purpose of preserving its own documentary or informational content for future reference. This includes but is not limited to: (1) Transmittal letters and acknowledgments which do not add any information to the material transmitted. (2) Requests for printed material after the requests have been filled. (3) of letters, basic steps I nformal notes, worksheets and rough drafts memoranda or reports that do not represent in the preparation of documents. ---- (4) notebooks have been Shorthand and stenotype transcribed. notes, including stenographic tapes and dictating media which (5) Miscellaneous notices of community affairs, employees meetings or holidays. (6) Stocks of publications or unused blank forms that are kept for supply purposes only. (7) Tickler, follow-up or suspense copies of correspondence. (8) Extra copies of documents already in an official file. (9) publications or reference materials received or acquired from outside sources such as professional organizations, conferences, seminars or workshops. (f) 'Official information relating to prepared, owned, used regardless of physical Record' Any record containing the conduct of the public's business or retained by any City department form or characteristics. - (g) 'Original Record' The documentation, that of which anything reproduction; or, a duplicate record documentation. first else with or is a any initial copy or original - 9 - . o o o (h) 'Record' All books, papers, maps,' exhibits, cartridges, magnetic or paper tapes, photographic films and prints, punched cards, and other documentary material regardless of phys ical form or cha racter i s tics, produced, recei ved, owned or used by a ci ty Department and preserved because of the informational value of data in them or as evidence of the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations or other activities of the City. (i) . 'Record Copy' A reproduction of an original record which is retained in lieu of the original record as the official record of the City. (j) 'Records Disposition Schedule' A listing of records series by department, indicating for each series the length of time the record is to be maintained in office areas and in the Records Center. The Schedule constitutes authority for the destruction of records listed thereon, after required retention periodS have lapsed. r I I I I I , I (k) 'Record Series' - File units or documents arranged in accordance with a filing system or maintained as a unit because they relate to a particular subject or function, result from the same activity, have a particular form, or because of some other relationship arising out of their creation, receipt or use. R'ecord series may consist of records of a single type or format and can be described, handled and disposed of or retained as a unit. (1) 'Wr i ti ng' Handwr i ti ng, typewri ti ng, printi ng, photostating, photographing and every other means of recording upon any form of communication or representation, including letters, words, pictures, sounds or symbols, or combination thereof, and all papers, maps, magnetic or punched cards, discs, drums and other documents, retained in the ordinary course of business. Writings are record or non record material. Section Records Disposition Schedule The Records Disposition Schedule will serve as the basis for the City's Records Management Program. The head of each department shall prepare a Records Disposition Schedule for his/her department and any subsequent proposed amendments thereto. With the assistance of the (Records Official), this preparation shall include: A. A physical inventory and appraisal of to determine their administrative, fiscal, historical value. all records legal and - 10 - o o o o -' B. Identification of an official record series title for all department records and specific and accurate descriptions of records listed thereunder in accordance with guidelines developed by the Records Management Officer. Terms used as record ser i es ti tIes or as descr ipt ion of files on the Records Disposition Schedule or any revision thereto, shall be descriptive. They shall not include the use of the words "miscellaneous" or "various",' or words of similar connotation; nor shall any such schedule or request bearing such nomenclature be submitted to the Records Management Officer and the City ,Attorney for their consideration and approval. I,. C. they are Schedule. A periodic review or audit of records to make sure properly covered by the Records Disposition Following the review or audit, the (Records Official) will be notified of any proposed amendments to the Records Disposition Schedule that are needed. Such amendments may include the addition of new record series titles to the Records Disposition Schedule, or requests to have superseded record series titles removed from the Records Disposition Schedule. I Final approval of the Records Disposition Schedule shall requi re the wr i tten con'sent of the department head, the City Attorney, and the (Records Official). The Records Disposition Schedule must then be approved by the City Council by resolution. Amendments and revisions thereto shall require' the written consent of the department head, the City Attorney and the Records Management Officer. I Section Responsibilities A. The (Records Official) shall: 1. Be responsible for the maintenance Records with the following exceptions: of all Off icial I I I I I I I I I i (a) Records identified pursuant to this ordinance in the Records Disposition Schedule, which are en- trusted to the custody of other City officers or de- partments. (b) Newly created or unidentified record series, which shall be the responsibility of the originating department, until properly identified within the Records Disposition Schedule. I ~ 2. Be responsible for the administration of a uniform Records Management Program assisting all City Departments, and for the development, administration and coordination of procedures thereunder. - 11 - . o o o 3. Administer economical storage, City records. a Records Center maintenance and for the efficient and servicing of inactive 4. Appoint a Records Management Supervisor, who shall serve as the head of the Records Management program. B. The Records Management Supervisor under the direction of the (Records Official) shall: 1. Provide effective control over the identification, appraisal, maintenance, protection, preservation, transfer, retention and disposition of all City records. This shall include: (a) Providing assistance and departments in the preparation of their tion Schedules and amendments thereto. guidelines to Records D i sposi- (b) Establishing proper procedures for necessary revisions to the Records Disposition with the approval of the City Attorney. securing Sched u Ie, :, (c) guidance specific providing direct technical assistance to departments that will aid in resolving files .and related records problems. and 2. Operate efficient manner. the Records Center in an orderly This operation shall include: and (a) providing information, assistance and records to using departments to ensure optimum utilization of the Records Center. (b) Notifying using departments periodically when records held by the Records Center are elig ible for destruction. (c) Causing to be destroyed records held by the Records Center only after receiving proper authorization from the responsible department head. C. Each department head shall: 1. proper Records Cooperate with the (Records Officer) to administration and implementation of the Management Program. assure City's 2. Ensure the proper application of the Records Dis- position Schedule to his/her department's records. 3. Ensure that records are transferred to the Records Center for storage at the end of the office retention period listed in the Records Disposition Schedule. - 12 - . o o o -' 4. Review the Records Disposition Schedule and recom:': mend to the (Records Official) any amendments thereto which are necessary due to changing requirements. 5. Comply with procedures mentioned in this ordinance regarding the destruction of records and nonrecords. 6. Appoint a Records Coordinator between the Records Management Officer and to assist in the implementation Management Program. to serve as liaison and the department of the Records Section Destruction of Records No record shall be destroyed until it has been properly inventoried, appraised and entered in the Records Disposition Schedule. Furthermore, before a record is eligible for destruction, the department head must first make the following determinations: 1. The record is maintained by said department. 2. Required retention periods listed in the Records Disposition Schedule have lapsed. ~' 3. The record is no longer required to fulfill any administrative, fiscal, legal or historical interests of the City or the public. 4. The record series title is descriptive and does not include the use of the words "miscellaneous" or "various", or words of similar connotation. B. Procedures Before records are destroyed, the department head shall : 1. In compliance with the Records Disposition Schedule, exercise a final review over all records eligible for destruction for the purpose of determining any further administrative, fiscal, legal or historical needs. 2. Ensure that if the Records Disposi t ion Schedu Ie does not specify records for transfer to the Records Center, the records shall be destroyed at the end of the listed office retention period in compliance with the Records Disposition Schedule. 3. Ensure that if the Records Disposition Schedule does speci fy records for transfer to the Records Center, and this has not occurred, the records shall be destroyed, providing they have exceeded their total retention requirement (office plus Records Center). - 13 - o o o o 4. Destroy duplicate records and non records when they are no longer needed in the course of the City's business." I HEREBY CERTIFY adopted by the Mayor Bernardino at a the day of vote, to wit: that the foregoing ordinance was duly and Common Council of the City of San meeting thereof, held on , 1986, by the following AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: City Clerk The foregoing ordinance is hereby approved this day of , 1986. Mayor of the City of San Bernardino Approved as to form: City Attorney - ,,, - . . . 0 0 III '" ... ., 0 Q,) " ... '" ... "- .... 0 " u 0 .; '" ~ ., " "" .... ... ... " - - .... 0 ... w . w - U ., .... .01<' ~ ,., ., ... ~ .,~ '" ... .. .. 0 ",," c: ... ~~ ~ U ..- . " "U .. ci-: w "" ., w~ a: .. .... " ... "a .... ,., 0 " C uZ "- 0 ., '" 0 ..... U U ., > .... ., " "" III .."" .. C "'.. 0 " 0 U ..'tl U ., I-< C ., '" .- ~ ~ - ..J III ~ .. .... " 0 p., I " p., I .... ,., '" - u a: p., I I p., I '" Z '" 0 '" .... ., ., o-J Z U ... U U w C " C .... " ... ... ell ~ w ... " . ... ... a: ell ... .. ell ..... .... .... " .c ,< U " .... " U ell - . .. 0 ,., ... " ... ..... u ... . .,.... C ... . - .. .... " III " d " ell '" w ..... ... " U u ... ., " f- a .... .... " "', .. . .... " z 0 III .. .... " " .. " w " ..... u u u " Z .... >>u ., .... >>u f- a 0 0 ....... <::.... 0 a: .. .. .. 0 -< .... ... .. ~ ~ Ii ... " .. .. 0 ... " .. ;; ... Ill.... >>"d ... "'.... w 0 0 .. .. .. C .. <:: .. .. .... '" > '" .. "'.... '" > . .... I o! U 0 III I .... E '" C . C .. ~ ... 0 .... .. 0 p.,"'oo "" .... ... 0 .coo .... .. . .. ... '" " 0. c....'O co " ... ..'" ... 0 .,........ ... .. " ............ .. . " u ... U .. oo "'... .... u"" - I>- .. " " C <:: " C d .0 C .. ~ . 0 "'... ... ....'tl " > "'0 ....... w "'.c'tl .... .. . ".... .. ... >> 0: o-J :> .. '" .'tl 0 00.... .0 CJ .. ,., III .... W w < ., E .. C "' C .. u<.:> .. . ... ... ~ ..... " '" " .. ".... "'... .. " ... as ::> 0 U ...... 0 " "-< " u > " ... .c C ., a: ........ "".... " x ....... .. . 0 u ., 0 0 I>- " e ., .. <.... .c >>'" ... E"d W u 1>-'0 0 " .. . .... " " .. ~ c <:: w 0'" U ., ".... III 0 .c C u" ... .. :c a: "" .. ... 0'0 . U 0'" " .. >> V "- '" c.al .r; ... " ..'tl .... e e"d ., >'" '" '" '" C.... ., 0 u " .c :> 0'" 0 VI 0 .... u... C ... U C ... :> ... CJ ... .. "'''' u ., Z U .. "'c " " u ., 0 .,.... .... .... oo Z 0 '" ... ... . ... CJ "oo .. "d "'.... III .... 'tl " ;: o-J 0 co " Ii C.... ... lD ... "" ~ '" 0 .... .. 0 0 eo "'.... 00-. "-,,"" 0 .. 0 .. "--'" C C 0 0 " cr I U~ e ... " "" " .... ... ... " ;; .... c u .. t- u '" '" " .. ... .,.... .. "- " .. "" . .. 0 ... .. .. ~ '" .. "" u ... " .. 0 .. 0 ".... '" ... ... .... .. .. VI w '" .. . C "'.... .. u "U .. ,.,"" c ... ... -- .. 0 0 ::0 " .. "'.... .. .. " .... '" ...:>.... 0 as ... .... ... 0 '" " u 0 . .. 0 Ii .. ... ,.,.... " U N .. .. .. 0..' Z 0 0'" . 'tl U .. <:: .. ... ,.,u .....c c u VI <: o-J ........0 C ..'tl C .... ... . ... ...... .. CU .... .... U u.... M 0 > C "d '" C '" U 0.... .. . " .. .... - w '" " O~""..,..j " C >> .... " .... .... " '" ...... .... '" 0 ..J ... ..... .... ... CJ ".0 ... 0 c.. " u.c '" ... .. .. " ;: ClCl 0 . '" u . 0 U .... .:C)~ ., ~ 0 C 0 Cl VI "'0 C " '" .. >> '" ....... "'" .... 0 . Z C .... "''' C "" .... U .... 0 U >>.. . U t.O"O~ -,..t " C.... . . '" ,.,.:> .... ....... . . 0:: .. ........ CJ '" '" 0 " " as .0 '" .0 " 0.... G.... ... " .::> 0 < " ... " " ".... ... u ,,"a: .. U 0 ~ ~ "-u e "d .... 0'" - "" 0 " ~ V . e " " C"d e ., '" " ~ ~ u CJ .. W U ".... 0 0 0 C " " <... UU u ....0::.0:: UU " .... ... e " e.o U " " U"''' 0:: u 0 . Z ,,::: 0 .... N w .... .... .... !:: , . o o June 13, 1986 o MICROFILM STUDY QUESTIONNAIRE Instructions: Please have your responses to the questions typed on a separate piece of paper corresponding to the same numbering system on the questionl).aire. Please return the questionnaire and answer sheets t6 the City Clerk's Office by 4:30 P.M., June 27, 1986. GENERAL INFORMATION 1. Does your department/division have one central location where all records are stored? (including maps and plans) 2. How many employees are assigned to maintaining the records? 3. A. Does your department have a Records Retention and Disposition Schedule?, If so, please forward a copy. B. If not, please explain how and when you dispose of obsolete records. 4. Do you know how long (legally) your records have to be kept? 5. Do you separate active and inactive records within your files? 6. Where do you store inactive records, i.e. City yard, basement of City Hal:1? RECORDS MEDIUM 7. A. What kinds of media or documents is your information stored on? (e.g. paper [specify sizes of paper, i.e. 8~ x 11, and other sizes], microfilm, microfiche, cartridges, etc.) B. For each medium, please tell what records are stored. 8. Which kinds of documents or information are retrieved most often to answer questions of the public and/or other departments? 9. Which documents are only for use within your own department? (e.g. personnel records) 10. A. Do you have any documents that are left open for public review? , If so, what are they? B. How often are they accessed? C. How are they viewed? (e.g. microfiche reader) DUPLICATE RECORDS 11. If your department/division maintains files that are also maintained in another area or department, please list these documents. (For example, certificates of occupancy are on file in Building and Safety and the City Clerk's Office.) - 15 - ~ '. " o . . I r o o o 12. Please list any documents that are maintained in duplicate within your own department. Reasons for such a practice. VITAL RECORDS 13. In the event of a natural disaster, which departmental documents would be most necessary for reconstruction of the City? 14. If you have any documents that require special security or confiden- tiality, please list them and explain? MICROGRAPHICS 15. Please give us any comments on how you feel microfilm or microfiche would benefit or be a detriment to your operation. 16. If we have any questions concerning your responses to this study, who should we contact and what is their phone number Survey completed by: Name 'Department ,,,', - 16 - r . o o o RECORDS STUDY FINDINGS DUPLICATE FILES , 11. If your department/division maintains files that are also maintained in list these documents. pancy are on file in Clerk's Office.) another area (For example, Building and or department, please certificates of occu- Safety and the City Administrator's Office Council Agendas Redevelopment Agendas Resolutions Misc. Cash Receipts Street Banner Applications Employee Grievances Sewer Capacity Rights Applications Attorney's Office Leases Resolutions Council Minutes Redevelopment Minutes Ordinances Street Closures Parade Permits Filming Permits Agreements Ordinances Building & Safety Department Certificates of Occupancy Engineering Grading Release Letters Cemetery None City Clerk Planning Change of Zone Applications Conditional Use Permits Tentative Tract Applications Annexation District Files Council Office ~ Complaint Forms - 17 - Personnel Records plans Claims Against City Correspondence I . o o o Emergency Services/Risk Management None Engineering Traffic Report Forms Project Files Tract Information Traffic Accident Data Finance None Mayor's Office Council Agendas Council Minutes Copies of Incoming Correspondence for Mayor's Information Parks, Recreation & Community Services Resolutions Finance & Accounting Documents Finance Computer Listings Paid Purchase Orders Conflict of Interest Forms Correspondence Engineering Documents Payroll Documents Council Agendas Council Minutes Personnel Department None Planning Department Certificates of Occupancy Lot Line Adjustments Maps Legal Property Descriptions Parcel Maps Tentative Tract Maps Annexation Files Ordinance Amendments Public Buildings/Security & Parking Control Correspondence Resolutions Personnel Files Contracts - 18 - . Ci ty Payroll Accounts Payable o o Public Services Department I None Treasurer's Office , Computer Printouts - 19 - o . o o o RECORDS STUDY FINDINGS VITAL RECORDS 13. The following records were identified by the various departments as being vital to the reconstruction of the City in the event of a disaster: Administrator's Office Sewer Rights Agreements Petty Cash Vouchers Travel Authorities Purchase Requisitions Miscellaneous Cash Receipts Requests for Payments Budget Transfers Attorney's Office Legal Opinions Court Pleadings Building & Safety Department Building Permits Engineering Data Board of Building Certificates of Occupancy Personnel Records Commissioners Files Cemetery Internment Records Pre-Need Accounts City Clerk Resolutions (13,000 originals on file which include deeds, easements, agreements) Ordinances (4,000 originals on file) Council Minutes (50 volumes, approximately 35,000 pages) Current Business License Records (10,000 accounts) Historical Business License Records Election Records (more archive than vital) Minute Index - A card catalogue which cross references minute action (resolutions, ordinances, agreements) in order to find a particular action. Council Office Tape Recordings of Council Minutes of Meetings ~ 20 ~ . o o o Emergency Services/Risk Management Resources Data Liability Claim Files Insurance policies Workers Compensation Files Inventory Engineering Department Plans Records Maps Finance Department Payroll Records Accounts Payable Records General Ledger Records Insurance Records Mayor's Office Personnel Records Correspondence Parks, Recreation & Community Services Department Project Case Files Accounting & Finance Records Facility Case Files Planning Department Case Files General plan Maps planning Commission Minutes zoning Maps Assessor's Parcel Maps Public Buildings/Security and Parking Control Personnel Records Parking Citations Public Services Department Sewer Maps Refuse Bi lling Treasurer's Office Investment Records Financial Information Bank Statements - 21 .- . o o o RECORDS STUDY FINDINGS BENEFIT OR DETRIMENT 1-, 15. Please give microfilm or microfiche your operation. us any comments on how you feel would benefit or be a detriment to BENEFIT Building & Safety Department Cemetery City Clerk's Office Emergency Services/Risk Management Finance Mayor's Office Parks, Recreation & Community Services Personnel Department Planning Department Public Services Department Treasurer's Office DETRIMENT Attorney's Office Council Office NO EFFECT Administrator's Office Engineering Department Public Buildings/Security & parking Control I I I I I I I ~ I . I - 22 - . o o o MICROFILM RECORDS SYSTEM COSTS Minimum Cost Estimate for Microfilm Storage: Camera and Reader/Printer: $13,000 used mostly for microfilming of retrieval activity.) to $15,000 dead files - (This system very light Reader only: $3,000 (Reader/printer is only about $200 more, not very many "reader onlys" sold) Minimum Cost Estimate for CAR Microfilm Records System: Computer Assisted Retrieval: $35,000 to $40,000 system is used for active retrieval of documents) (This I' ~' Minimum Cost Estimate for CAR System Used with City's Computer: $18,000 to $20,000 (This system, uses the City's computer as an index for microfilming.) The cost estimates are quotes from Dave Swindle, represen- tative of Martin Business Machines. He stated that Martin Business Machines offers to "come in and do the legwork" at no fee and no obligation. They will gather information from all departments, determine which departments have more docu- ment retrieval and duplication of records and complete the survey. The survey will then be sent to an individual company for a financial analysis. This analysis would compare the costs associated with a "paper base data system" as far as labor costs for retrieval and reproduction versus cost/savings of a "computer base data system". The analysis would,show the costs and/or savings over a five-year period of time and then either justify the expenditure for the microfilm system, or show if it would be more cost effective to remain with the "paper base data system". -- - 23 ~ . o o o OPTICAL DISK Minimum Cost Estimate for Laser Scanner System: $100,000 to $500,000 This system uses a laser to scan documents, digitizes infor~ mation and stores information electronically onto a disk. It reflects the actual representation of the document as far as signatures, etc. For retrieval, the computer would have the laser printer print out a hard copy. This system is for extremely active storage retrieval only. I I '- - 24 - CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO C 0 - MEMO~ANDOM 0- o To Jack Strickler, Chairman Legislative Review Committee Subject Records Management From Shauna Clark City Clerk Date Apr il 28, 1987 Approved Date Cost of Equipment Attached is a cost-estimate of some microfilm and computer equipment for a centralized records management program. The pricing was done by a 3M dealer who also did a cost benefit analysis of central records management. . The analysis uses industry standards for costing labor as this City has never done a comprehensive survey on the time each department spends on records. Industry standards for an operation our size show that the annual labor cost involved in filing documents is $810,000. It would be unfair to say that a microfilm and computer re- trieval system will save this amount of money, because realistically, departments are not going to cut staff when records management is fully operational. However, we are going to save space, and make information more easily acces- sible to all departments and the public. ' If you looked at space savings alone, the system would pay for itself in two years. Additional Labor Since someone has to coordinate the records coming in from departments and help departments with records retention pro- gram, the City will have to hire a records manager. I be- ,lieve a records manager would be paid about the same as a Deputy City Clerk. Therefore, the City would have the ongoing labor cost of an additional person,', and perhaps, as demand increases, the co~t of an additional clerk. ~~ City Clerk SC:dr elr.., ON rHI=Ml>>". . o o o o PREPARED FOR: CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO CENTRAL RECORDS MANAGEMENT PRESENTED BY: OAVID L. SWINGLE 3M FILE MANAGEMENT SALES REPRESENTATIVE . . o o o THE IMPACT OF A MICROGRAPHICS FILE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM The City Hall Space Study determined that the space occupied by filing equipment necessary to maintain the current paper-based filing system to be valued at $600,000 by replacement method of valuation. The rental value of the space (a very conservative method since there is no extra space available within the building at that price) indicates a value of $90,OGO per year. American Records Management Association (ARHA) studies have determined that 90% of the cost associated with maintaining a paper-based filing system is consumed by labor. Almost every study done comparing an automated system versus a paper-based system of file management shows that the cost of the repeated filing, retrieving, re-filing, and maintaining of paper files is far and away the major justification for investing in an automated file management system. RENTAL VALUE OF SPACE/YEAR LABOR COST (ARMA AVG.)/YEAR $90,000 $810,000 TOTAL COST $900,000/year The impact of a microfilm CAR system on the labor involved with a filing system is significant. Once the file is captured on film and its microfilm location entered into the computer any file requested can be attained in 1 minute or less. The documentation can not be lost or misfiled or removed by unauthorized persons. Duplicate rolls filed off-site provide complete security against any loss of files due to disaster. Hicrofilm'will recapture 95% of space dedicated to paper filing. Assuming 33% of current files are converted to microfilm; 95% of $30,000 = $90,000/yr $30,000/yr $28,500/yr. RENTAL VALUE 33% FILMED INITIAL SYSTEM COST (inc. tax) $59,330.32 $59,330.32 / $28,500 = less than 2 year payback for initial system costs based on space alone. The above analysis does not consider the tremendous savings in labor or the very significant value of insurance against lost documentation. Also not included is the value of the computer's ability to function as a general purpose p.c. for word processing, etc. for the department The supply and maintainance cost of the system is not expected to exceed $12,000 per year. . . o o o SYSTEM DESCRIPTION CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO - CENTRAL RECORDS MANAGEMENT CAMERA: 3M 664 High speed intelligent rotary camera. Microprocessor controls monitor filming of each document and coordinates all filming functions. Modular in design, this camera is ideal for high volume filming of a wide variety of files. Multiple reduction ratios and image format capabilities allows one camera to film one or both sides of anything from checks to documents up to 12" wide by any length. Automatic feed with variable speed will film up to 800 3" documents per minute. Fillll3 one or two rolls of microfilm for simultaneous dual roll filming. Film is automatically threaded. This state-of-the-art camera system will suit all of your needs today and will grow with them in the future. READER-PRINTER: 3M MFBllOO Multi-format bond reader-printer. Another highly versatile modular system from 3M. Will handle any micro format with inter-changeable microfilm transports. Zoom lenses allow user to work with film of many different reduction ratios without ever having to change lenses. Select portions of microfilm images may be blown up to larger than original size if desired. Again, the ability to grow with your needs makes this an excellant~hoice for this application. COMPUTER: Unisearch This computer and software provide a turn-key system for records indexing. This computer-assisted retrieval (CAR) system is easy to learn and use and can integrate the retrieval of all files whether in paper, on film, audio tape, or any other format. The system's cross-reference capabilities will become a valuable management tool. The computer itself is fully IBM compatible and may be used to run other IBM progralll3 such as wordprocessing or spreadsheets. The computer is a Sperry'p.c. with Sl2k ram and a 40 megabyte hard disk. All data is protected by a 60mb streaming tape backup system. . o o o SYSTEM PRICING 3M 684 Camera with automatic feed, workstation, 24X head, SOX duplex head. $26,442.00 3M MFB1100 reader-printer with workstation, cartridge transport, microfiche transport, Page Search retrieval, 20X-47X zoom lens. $13,927.00 Unisearch hardware and software. With workstation, 40 megabyte hard disk, 512k ram, 60 megabyte streaming tape back-up system, 5 back-up tapes, API reader-printer interface. $15,603.00 $55,972.00 . . . The 684 Intelligent, Rotary, Microfilm Camera. The 684 is a high-speed, highly automated document capture system, Using programmable microprocessor control. it coordi- nates all filming functions, with minimum operator interaction, , To use the system, an operator simply loads film, selects an oper- ating mode of preprogrammed instructions, and begins feeding documents, The camera does the rest. It monitors the filming of each document and displays its current status on an easy to read ' communication display, An automatic exposure control assures optimum image density for each document filmed, regardless of color, As fast as documents can be fed Into the camera, they are recorded as high resolution microfilm images, each identified with appro- priate image marking for precise Indexing and retrieval. The 684 system IS modular in design and can be con- figured to accommodate a host of file management applications, Add an automatic feeder for high-speed capture of uniform documents, Change reduction ratios or image ,'- -- o o o Receiving Tray: Documents are stacked after lilmlng lace down In collated sequence Workstation: Camera stand, with adlustable shelves, surrounds operator with workspace lor documents ready lor filming, ,. -~ l Automatic Feeder: Varoable speed, up to 800 3" documents per minute. Double leed detection prevenls over- lapping Images Film Loading: Camera i-Iccepts bolh16mm x 100' ilnd t6mm x 215'mlcrohlm on standard camera reels Automalicaliy adlusls lor fIlm thickness One or two rolls can be loaded for slmultHneous dual rolllmag,ng Films are automatically threaded and rewound Into light prool cassenes Index Control Codes: Bar Cucl{~~. Wrl~t)r 1l11t!(i (It, t II:; IUt ~r sheets or on lead document~ life elec .. IronIcally sensed by the camerd Indexln level IS InSlarllly reset ilccordlng 10 prograrTllnSlruCII()11S ,~""'. .~~.,........--ft"'I'l.' numbennq dl~Vln! wrlles Indexlnq Inlorm<-lllCJn on cinr:tlmenlS. u~lnq dry . mp,ict Ink let tcchnoloqy 0 ~ ~~~;~ '.. Keyboard and Display: J Command keyboard controls all camera funcllons, and sets UP operating parameters LoquKJ crystal display has UP to 300 addressable character positions, to communicate with operator In easily understood terms Document Feeding: Hand Feed Shelf po~tlons mixed documents as they are fed ,nto camera Automatic Feeder may be used for uni- form documents-at through-put rates of UP to 300 8~"documents per m,nute ..J - - o formats with our interchangeable lens units, Add our state-of-the.art Ink Jet printer and you can print up to 18 characters of Indexing informa- tion on each document before it's microfilmed - all under program controll There's even an RS.232 interface to communicate indexing information to a computer, No longer is it necessary to design your file management system around equipment limitations, Now a system can be configured and programmed to suit your needs today - and to grow with them in the future, Choose 3M. We offer the widest selection of products in the industry We stand behind our products with worldwide sales and service support, And we have the experience to design a system to match your needs In fact. weve been an industry leader for over 25 years, with a long tradition of product enhancement. rather than obsolescence, _ For more information, contact your local 3M File Management Sales Representative, c..... ....:.:-_-:;;;-;.; T....... ...... "'C"_.. -, . ~--_.. - "': ...-O~'.;:"i: ."': 0' ~~!:~=::~~~~_, .:. - Document Numbering: Up to 18 characters of IndeXing data can be wnnen on each document. or selected documents, as they enter the camera . . o o o 684 Microfilm Camera Reduction Ratios/Image Formats. III - . . ......... IIIIIIIII IIIIII 11_.. ....-- --- . . . . . . - - . 24X Simplex Front side of 40X Duo or Duplex Front side SOX Duplex Front and back of document across full film width 01 document across 1; film width document, side by side across full film width Three level image marking, available at all reductions, provides lor precise indexing and instant retrievaL Retrieval Codes. III Communicates search parameters - such as Roll Number, Date, Image Count - to retrieval eqUipment. SpeCifications Typical Machine Characteristics Camera Transport Speed: 1600/3200"/mlnute Reduction Ratios: 24X, 40X, sox Image Formats: Simplex, Duo, Duplex, Duo/Duplex Max. Document Width: 12"(9"at 40X) Electrical ReqUirements: liS v 20 Amp, 60 Hl 1&~7l)-'571.' 1126110PI Dimensions: 39"Hx26"Wx32"D Work Area: Floor space required, approx 7' x 7' Accessories Autofeeder: Vanable Speed, double document detection Sequential Numbering Device: High Speed Ink jet pnnler. keybOard controlled With 18 characters, fixed or variable Thermal Output: 6000 Btu/hour Weight: 180 Ibs. (w/o accessones) Check Endorser: Continuous pnnt With 6 digit dale Work Station: Adjustable height. adlustable shelves storage compartmenls casters ' \ I lU,l} In IJ~A .......11", 'itA OM'.t:[ Pld"~" f IUn .lIu1 f'rl.,Jllnq }1',11~1l1'. File Management Systems/3M 3M Cenler St Paul MN 55144 3UI . o o () READER-PRINTER WITH CARTRIDGE/ANSI TRANSPORT c c I c \~ ........:..~._.~ '....T~a:I'.Il.,iiIl~ ;..... .... " ,""" , -- If you ve been looking for an economical plain paper micrographic reader-pnnter that allows format versatility, 3M now has It. the Multi-Format Bond Reader-Pnnter, MFB 1100 This extremely versatile machine accepts all microfilm formats THE 210 CAT HANDLES CARTRIDGES The 210 Cartndge/ANSI Transport accepts 16mm film, 2,5 mil to 57 mil In thickness in 3M cartndges, ANSI rolls and ANSI carriers and Ektamate' carners, The handler IS self-threading for ease of ~ ..~ T"'~Y~-; '~":""~.t~~'~~,.~..t:u...~~ . ,.... ;'" I-,;'~"'~l"i~~-l""l'~ operation and transports film at 10 feet per second In both directions An electronic odometer keeps track of your Image localion to help you retneve your document quickly, PICK YOUR SPEED AdvanCing and rewinding can be accom- plished with either vanable-speed motonzed or manual controls, Page Search and online computer Interface kits may also be added, Page Search offers 18 modes of retneval, from simple single-level blip film, to 3-level blip film . o o ---0- READER-PRINTER WITH FICHE ATTACHMENT The fiche handler accepts fiche, lackets aperture cards and also available IS a 4" x 12" dual fiche carrier A wide range 01 easy-to-change lenses IS available, ranging from t4x to 47x, The Image can be rotated a full 360 degrees with Prism Image Rotalton, allOWing you to read documents right side up, no matter how they've been microfilmed A pUSh-button seleclton of printing modes lets you make prints from conventional negative microfilm, or, with a low-cost oplton, from POSitive microfilm, on 81,," x 11" plain paper Our front-loading paper cassette holds 250 sheets for easy operator access, THE FIRST PRINT IN 12 SECONDS ' Addlltonal copies are delivered at the rate of t1 per minute, Up to nine copies of a single image may be selected. A standby sWitch is Included so the machine is immediately ready for viewing and printing and, when put in the standby mode, conserves on lamp life, . i ~ ! o READER-PRINTER OTH 110 ROLL FO TRANSPORT ATTACH M E:)" - The 110 RFT (Roll Film Transport) allows for bofh 16mm and 35mm open spool films, A "quick gr.ip" take-up spool provides easy film threading, All handlers can easily be Interchanged by the operator without tools, On the cartndge/ANSI and rpll transports advancing and rewinding can be" accomplished with either variable-speed motorized or manual controls, The microfilm also comes to an auto. matic halt when rewinding IS complete, FRONT LOADING PAPER CASSETTE PROTECTION FOR YOUR FILM As the film passes through the 111m gate, it opens and closes automatically, minimizing actual contact with the film, An optional mOdular work station is available lor the new MFB 1100, For all your microfilm format needs, look at our plain paper reader-printer thaI's as easy to use as It is versalile the MFB 1100 from 3M QUICK GRIP TAKE UP SPOOL n' . THE ZOOM lENS SYSTEOOR THE MFBOO READER-PRINTER o r " () ~ (") o 10"11... HiMI -.. 123456768 .........- - ..\ o An optional zoom lens kit is available for all MFB 1100's The zoom lens keeps your Image in constant focus, so your image always stays sharp while you change reduction ratios, No more refocusing or lens changing, Documents can be reduced or enlarged With one easy-to-operate control, THE ZOOM LENS SYSTEM INCREASES RETRIEVAL PRODUCTIVITY More prints can be made per hour With the zoom lens system, It works with all microfilm o formats, Computer printouts and legal sized docu- ments can be reduced to lener size, Hard-to-read documents can be enlarged, All with no time lost changing lenses Toner consumption will also decrease since the zoom will give you the exact reduction or enlargement ratio you want. The zoom system features true one-to-one blow back and is available in the following reduction ratios 6,5x-14x, 14x-32x, 20x-4h o o OPTIONAL ZOOM LENS SYSTEM .. .......- ~.....',.,... ..-.. . . PAPER FILES Keepin~ track of paper files in an open .shelf system or file cabinets can present a lo~istics challen~e for even the most efficient records manager. Often, valuable search time is wasted on files that have been checked out, misfiled or misplaced. UNISEARCH can tell you the cabinet, drawer, and folder of any random paper document. If the document is not in the file UNISEARCH can be used like a librarian to track its location, identifying when and to whom the document was released, t .;i:~::'. , UN/SEARCH MAJG , Maintaining' and managing re('ords or matf'r- ials ('an h(' complicatt'd. Most husinpssps t()da~" maintain several tYPtlS of filing systl'ms in order to satisfy their total information nel'ds_ A computerized system is a.simple, proven means of creatin~ a sin~le index to all your filin~ systems_ UNlSEARCH is a computer- assisted retrieval (CARl system desi~ned to integrate the retrieval of all your files, includin~ micro- film, diskettes, roll film. tapes, paper, and other stora~e methods all in one index, UNlSEARCH offers easy to learn opera- tions with concise menus and the ability to customize your in A CAR system is the heart of a complete records management system. UNlSEARCH lets you file and retrieve information fast. while reducing rour records and matl'rial management eosts, It can virtually eliminatl' the costly, time-consuming problems associ- ated with lost documents, incomplete index- ing, and inefficient cross-referencing. · ...-- ''''''''''~"""",,,,' ..~ -'-:::>>'~-"'" -'\"~''4;'~\ ,. . r~~ r'~:!~7:': 'I,?t";l'::;;;...~~:t~!~,..:...,.,,~~~~..,y.' Microfiche is oneofthe most popular mediums for storaJ<e of important business documents. With UNISEARCH. your microfiche filescan expand in size and complexity without sacrificinJ< file management. When you need to see a document stored on fiche, UNl- SEARCH Quickly pinpoints its exact row and column and will tell you which fiche to place in the reader/printer. MICROFILM Microfilm offers the most economical means of recordin~ and retainin~ business documents and records. With UNISEARCH, you can prepare indexes which allow random source document filmin~. UNISEARCH adapts to almost any micro~raphic indexin~ format or film blippin~ technique. It is desiJ<ned to interface directly with automatic reader/ printers. . . . o C') f) o "" (', o POWER FILES o Power file storaKe devices combined with UNISEARCH provide automatic access to record or part locations. UNISEARCH instantly shows availability of requested records or indicates where the records have been sent. UNISEARCH provides a checkout function. a wait list, and status reports on the records and parts stored in the system, An optional bar code reader allows entry of information about file folders or materials without usinK the keyboard_ Data is entered by usinK a bar code wand. UNISEARCH is directly connected to the power file and causes the device to rotate to the proper shelf and to indicate the position of the item selected, . I) ::; o o t9 Flexible file size with an unlimited number of records. Each record can consist of up to 12 fields totalinK to 300 characters, File size is limited by disk space only. t9 Variable formats. Only UNISEARCH lets you track microfiche, roll film. diskettes, tapes, paper, materials, and other types all in a sinKle index. t9 Office Systems, UNISEARCH is not just a records manager, It offers a complete range of office technoloKies as well. The system can serve your business as a word processor, a financial planner, an accounting tool or as a data communications terminal. 19 Consultation. Experts are available to help you select the proper equipment and software for your particular needs. You will be provided the ongoing support necessary to ensure continued cost savinKs and increased productivity as your business demands Krow and chanKe, , . Ol.k Orl... Communlcltlonl TIp' Orl... BI' Codl W.nd. Microfilm R..ders Controllers Ol.k Selnn.rs Printers CRT OCR Copyright 'Cl 1984 Com SQuared Systems. Inc -- - --- o o o UNISEARCH@ . Spony Sync - IBM Sync . ASYNC - 16 1M .105 MM . 9 Track IBM/ANSI . Strum.r 110 FIX c2S COM SQUARED SYSTEMS, INC. - 2520 PILOT KNOB RO . MENDOTA HEIGHTS, MN . 55120 TEL (612) 452-9522 FAX (BI2) 452-3607