HomeMy WebLinkAbout15-Building and Safety
Cl'tr;OF SAN BERNARDI~ - REQlI55T FOR CUUNCIL A~ IUN
From: Mark I. Sutton, Director
SUBJECT: Appeal Hearing - Board of Building
Commissioners Order to Vacate PI'emises,
Secure and Demo 1 ish at 765 N. "O~!:J;('('t-
^lbert Mamlouk ..-f/q"
~
Dept: llUILDING & SAFETY
Date: ,JUL Y 27. 19RR
Synopsis of Previous Council action:
NONE
Recommeno:led motion:
That the Board of Building Commissioners decision to have the premises at
765 NOrth "D" Street, vacated, secured and demolished within thirty (30) days;
and to incur all costs in the form of a lien on the property, be upheld and instruct
Staff to continue with the demolition and cleaning of said property.
Current Costs: $567.00.
NOTE: APPELLANT IS A TENANT.
?1~i~ ~.'IJl.f/IIJJ,.&-
Signature '- ./
Contact person: Oon Hp<; l"pr 1 P,lI
Supporting data attached: YES
Phone: ext./5071
War<:l:
FUNDING REQUIREMENTS:
Amount:
Sou rce:
F inanee:
Council Notes:
15-0262
Agenda Item No,
l1~
,
, .
CITYOF SAN BBRNARDINe- RBQUE~ FOR COUNCIL ACryN
STAFF REPORT
765 North "D" street
The Department of Building and Safety inspected this
building on october 8, 1987. The structure is an
unrein forced masonry building in a dilapidated and dangerous
condition. Some interior walls have been removed,
compromising the integrity of the structure.
The owner
our findings.
Engineer for a
..
was notified by mail on october 13, 1987 as to
The owner subsequently retained a Structural
structural analysis.
On November l3, 1987, the Engineer delivered a negative
report on the building, stating that it could not withstand
or resist minimum seismic forces, as outlined in the 1982
Uniform Building Code.
On March 15, 1988, the owner notified his tenants of the
city's intent to demolish the structure if it was not
rehabitable.
On July 1, 1988, the matter went before the Board of
Building commissioners. A resolution was made to vacate the
premises within three days*, secure the premises and demolish
within thirty (30) days.
An appeal was subsequently made by W.R. Holcomb, to the
Mayor and Common Council on behalf of Albert Mamlouk, a
tenant at 765 North "D" Street.
No permits have been obtained for possible retrofit.
The building has been posted as a dangerous building.
Staff recommends approval of the Board of Building
co~issioners action to abate the structure by demolition,
and lncur all current and future costs in the form of a lien on the property.
(*AII tenants, except Mr. Mamlouk, have vacated the
premises. )
75.0264
~ "F -'" J-"P"O
V ~,,,. :>c,,,,l "j
OEPAR ENT OF BUlLOlN AND SAFETY
PROJECT NO. 3114
RESOLUTION NO.
SAN BERNARDINO ItINICIPAL CODE, TITLE 15 EMERGENCY ABATEMENT
The undersigned respectfully submits the following statement of costs incurred by the
City of SIn Bernardino in abating the Pu.blic nuisance that existed on the property
located at: 751, 753, 763-771, North liD" Street
Owner: Earl Korchak
Address: 234 Mc Carty Dr., Beverley Hills, CA
Assessors No: 140-282-43.73.74
More particularly described as:
o
STATEMENT OF COSTS
'0
Lot 5 in Block 51 City Of San Bernardino. Book
7 of maps page 1 except north 200ft thereof,
ITEMIZATION
Building and Safety Dept's Costs:
Title Search S
Special Inspector' S
Inspector's Time 4 X $16/hr $
Secretary's Time 2 X $13 S
Cemp & Reti rement 25'1; S
Equipment 4 X 50t S
Certified Mail ing 4 X $2 S
Pictures 14 X $1 S
Administrative Costs 40'1; S
Hearing Time S
Newspaper Advertisement S
Additional Costs Attorney S
SUB TOTAL S
Costs From Previous Hearing_____S
$
$
TOTAL COSTS S 567.0C
Mark ~tton
. BUILDING & F TV DIRECTOR
W/O and/or EfA
Street Dept's Costs:
Labor
Administrative Costs
Building Pennit
Equi pment
Materi a 1
Dumping
s
s
S
S
S
S
TOTAL S
Demolition'Contract Preparation:
Contractors Costs:
Date: June 20. 1988
SBMe 15:28
By:
165.00
64.00
26.00
36.0.,
2,00
1l.00
14.00
162.00
50.00
40.0U
567.00
.
0,
o
o
REilORT :10 .l1lf2..-
C:TYOF SAN 3~NAADlNO
DE."AAT~ENT CF 3UIUINO ~D SAF..,-(
~CO Nar~ft 0 Street
SAN 3~NAADINO. CA. 924t8
UNIT INSPSCitON ~EP~RT
Th. 9ul1dlng ~nd S.~.t~ D...r~m.nt has In.p.c~.d ~h. d..cpll1.d
praper':~. The In.p.c':lon r.veat... tll~t tft. lte... ...rk.d do not conform
to tile p,.ovl.i.on. o~ tft. S.n I.,.n.rdlno /'luniclp.l Cod. CSI/'lCI.. It.....
..rked wltll an a.te,.l.k ..u.~ b. r..air... 0" CO,.,..c~.d .11:hln-La-da~..
Otfte,. It.... mu.C II. r.p~ir.d 0" corr.c~.~ ~lCllln~d~q..
P~/'lITS, REGUIR~~YES____NO
Per...it. .re requir.d Co repal.. or C2r,..c1: ...n~ o~ tll. 1 C."'" F2r '"
con.ulC.tlon ,..garding till. r.po,.C. ~..l.tanc. ln .ecu,.in, ~ p.,...l~. or
.ch.dul1ng a ,..In.pec1:10n. pl.a.. c~ll the o'~lc. and .ch.dul. 9au,.
r.qu..t wlth tll' lnsp.cto.. who.. na.... ~pp.a"s on thl. ,..,o,.t.
OFFICE HOURS ARE 7: JO-4:JO /'lONDAY THROUOH FRIDAY
CITY
OWNER ~ o<-r I t::.~,J{' L!., ,,:... _ k:: DATE PREPARED Z - I - s:; ~
ADDRESS Z3~ rYIl I.<...,..i I i'r.TYPE 9LJ)O/VIOL.ATtON('''''''h1/~RA1 S-/r.L'#;"A..(,'6<.
., ,
,",?>"VU/" IJ;I!<.. 10ZtZADDRESS 7s1 7",~ 7~3, 771 AJ "V"S1-
~.' " ,
ASSESSOR'S NO. I"/-?-Z. ~?- ~3 7'1 7'1
,?,III& DATE OF INSPECTION_Ft {, I '3<6
PHONE NO. c.c. .
101 () CI S^-A11... t1'l"rl.;Cc....
S",;1{ 2.500
(-: 13) g?'L- /"(55
J-/L. C(()~67
VIOLATIONS
STRUCTURE-9UILDINO
1. Olle~.can1:J lIul1dln,tUFC11. 41/11. 41:2] Secu,.e all
lIul1 n9~ to FHA .tan4a,.d. to ,,..vont unavthO,.iz.d
.n~.nc.. S.cu,.e doo,.s an4 .indo.. .ith 'itt.d ,l~woOd
,ain1:." to ..1:ch hou.. tTi.. O,.n.lll. wlndo.. .u.t b.
lI1'oo,id.d .ith quick ,..1.... ..ch.ni.8. .h.,.o ..cu,.it~
.c,...n. .,.. In.1:al1.d on b.d,.008 .indo",.CUBe 1204i)'
2. Fi,.. da_g.d .tTuctu,..t.] .,eci'icall~
CSB"'C 1'.16.240] S.c...,.. CII. ".c....,.., po,...it. an" r.p.i,.
within thl,.t.,CJO] da.,. to lIuildin, cad.. 01' d.801i.lI.
J.
Ina".quat.
.q,uiplII."tCUHC
'i... .
'I. '1'01.
,,.at.cUo"
10. 1001n.
a,. 'i,.__~lgllting
UFC 10. JOl] P~avid. a.
1
.
o
.:. .
"
-
Q
7.
8.,
L['
...~ui...d
.q,ui"m.n~.
~., '::lQ ~"':l~'1'
~i~-'.;in,ul.nin, ..,.eem. o..c:>
4.
~
Inad.~uat. eli~sCUHC3.90t, to. tOOtm.UBC~~.~~O~.UFC
a"t. t2: "'ddi~ion.l ..ies ...., ~. 1'.~ui:"<1 t:l II. in
caMpu.nce ...it:\ builHn, C<I<lU.
,.
In.d.~uat. Found.eion-..9fin, ~loa'" in
CUHCtO. tOOtc. 4. J. k. l. UBC1. t04dHoun,Utl.:ln 0" ~i...s mu.e
lie p..ovide<l.
In.d.quat. "'aIls/v",,'" e.l .uppa,,':. t:.I...:l.l ~~. u ~ ...:rl
",hieh have b~"'e.k.n.d II, d.t."ia..atian o"/av...la.din,
CUHCIO. 1001c. d. II. J. 1. J mu.t b. ...p l.c.d a" st".n,tll.n.d.
In.d.qu.t.
CUHC'. '0:3.
.IIall II.ve
c.ilin, II.i,IIt In
UBC12.1207J 411 II..Dl:..o1.
7f1t.6in. c.ilin,..
"'Otil.\
..nd s...vic.
Inad.qu.t. ..aom dimen.ion. in
CUHC'. '0:::1.
U8Cl2. 1207J
9. Inad.qu.te ventilatian/l1,IIt in
CUHC'. '04. U8C12.120'] "'11 II.llit..1I1. ..a am. .h.ll II.ve an
a'9".,ae. ",1nda", ..... afl not 1... than 1/10tll tll. flloo"
.".. 0" to .q. fit. ...hicll.v." i. ,,,.ace.. and .n open.1I1.
",indo", ..... of' t/2 tile :0..1 ..... ...qui....enc. 8...II..ao.s
mu.c h.v... minimuoa of' ~ sq. fit. 0" II. p..avld.d ...1tll
..ech.nic.l vencil..tian.
10. I..p..ap... u.. of' unitCUHCI0. 10010] The u.. 01'
as llIu.t II. di.continued.
11. IT'ak.n doo... aT' ",indo",.CUFC11. 411/11. 412. USel. 104dJ See
nu.II... an. fiaT' co.....ction.
12..
.
Inadequate ...tp..aaflin,CUHCI0.1001kJ All
attic venc. aT' openin,. .ust be coveT'ed
...sll 'CT'.enln9.
I'ound.tion and
wi tll 1/4 inch
lIuildin,.
1:::1. I11e,.1 .dditlon/.ub.t.nd...d .cces.oT"
CUSC:::J.301. UHC:::J.~Ol] A4ditian of'
Must conflo"" to cod.s 0" b. d..oli.II.d.
(!!)
1'.
.T'Ok.n/oai..in, ..c."io" .idin,/.tucco on ~x--r;.r /;..,.-
CUHCI0. 1001b. c. d. II. J. UBC17.1707J mu.t be ...p.il'.d 0"
T'.p 1.c.4.
Inadequate
dOo" ac
it clo...
pT'ap."l".
doo"CUSC:3:::J.3:::J()4. UFC12. 12. t04] In.call n.",
0" ...pai.. ..i.tin, daa" ta 1n.u".
p..op...l" 0" if' a lock i. p.....nt: that 1t lock.
2
4'
Jb
o
lb.
CIl 1",n.., 'trQ:ur. uQundCUBC:. t04d, 2.20:1,0
UHCtO. 1001e:.~. h. 1. J. k. 1. ] R...av. elltmn.., ta ..aa" Una.
caD a1: t~i' paine: and ,.al ,.l...ooa a.. ...p.l.. ,true:ur
.11., ta e:a~',
<
"
MtALTH-~~Nr~~i~~N
17.
Poal II., 'llagn.n: ",.t...
tnad.q.u.U ~a1:' CSal'lCl~. 48.
s..1"'1lI1ng paa 1 .c~ 24. 100. HIoS
ar ...plac. .ceo..dlng to cad.,.
tn.d.q.uat. '.nc.
Stat. c~d. T1tl.t7CAC
Cod.77741 Oraln. ...pal..,
lS.D.b..t,/Junk/lnad.q.uat. ....b.g. sta...g.CH..ltll .nd
Sanll:aUon A.gulac:i.~n' nth :J ell.p.2 3:3. 02:l.~. 024.
SB~a.21.0:30.9.21.04O. 9.21.0~O. 9.21.0.0. 9.24.020.
S. 24. 0::10 9.24.040.13. 24. O~O] R...ov. d.b..i.1 Junk .nd
,..avid. ,uitaol. e~nta1n...s ",itll ltds '0.. ..ubbi.II and
,...o.g ..
19. Unlle.n..d/lnop....ttv. v.lltel. V.... ....t.
Ltc. CSB"CS.:J::I.Ol0kl A.llIav. a.. sta... 1n a
lIulldln..
20. Ins.cts-v.rmin-anlm.l d..applngsCSB~b. 04.1,,0. .. OS. 080.
UHCl0. 1001b. d. Il. 11 Ad.q.u.t. ....su...s "'Ult II. t.t.n ta
.It..inat. tllis conditlon ln
21. Unsanit.r" d..ainba...dCUHCb. .01.10. loo1e. d. J. 1.
UBC2'.2~l.kJ A.s..l or ...,l.e.-d..alnllaa..d lI.cts,l,sll.
22. Un..nlta.." '100..cov...ing-"10a..in, ln
i. . II..lt" h.z...dCUBC1.104d. UHCl0. 1001... J. 1]. A.cav...
a.. ......1 ,..o,.rl".
:z::J. Dw.lllng lacks hot ",.t...CUHC~. 'OS. 10. 1001.. d. III Hot
_t... 0' not l..s tll.n 120 d.g....s F. ..u.t b. ,..avid...
to ...q.ui...d ,lumbing 'iztu...s.
24.
"'t...
lI.d..oa..
R.loc.t.
.......1 t.
II..t... 111.,.11"
CUf'tC2.. 20:2.
_t... "..t...
1nst.al led 1n: lI.tlI..oa..
~. '04-'05. UHC7. 701e. UlC2.. 20:3J
to. suitable location und...
2:S. "'t.,. h....,. t....o, ...1" v.nt.d CU1'1C2.. 202. ~. ~04. ~. ~08.
uaC2. 200. UHC7.701c] V.nts sllaU .at.nd 12 incll.. .lIov,
tb. ,oint al ..it '..a. tll. ..aal. All v,nt ,i,.s to II.
..cu...d.
26. Rooi' l..king ln tll. ..... abav.
eUllel.l04". 2.20:3. UHCb.601. 10. 1001b. c. d. h. 1. J. k. tl
R..ai.. ..aaf.
'" c:"CT1UC,toL
27.
Ov,..lu.ingCUSC1.l04d.
10.' 100111. d. .. i. J. t. 1.
UHC2.. 202. 4.401. 7.70111. ". "01.
NEC2.. 202...t. '90. bJ Fu..d .lect..ical
::I
-
WJI
lJ
o
b~an~~ Ci~~~it~"all~'
'1.1..' not ~o ,":..d l'
~.~.ptacll~
ilT'Dded
a.o. I>o~
wi:~ non-tamolrl'l~'~
light'/20 amp,:Q
2e. I1is.ln, .1'~~T'icial ~Qv...,/'h:u.... in -..
CUlC~. 104<1. UHC2.202n, 7,701:'. '1, ~Olo
10. lOOn. d. I. i. J' c. l. NEC2. 202a~':. ~O. ~l ~11 ou,:llu Ind
s.ltc~.' mu.~ hay. p~~p'~ CQv.... and all .1'C~T'lCll!
'iltu~.' mu,e ~. ilT'OIl.~l~ instal1.d Ind socu~ld tQ t~e
buILd In,.,
2". Inadoq,uaU ouUlts in
HECsoc.2101 Each habita.L. ~OO. lIIust havo 2 CQnvilnc.
outl.t, o~ 1 outlot and 1 light Iiltu~o. lIaU~ooms mvst
havo 1 ligllt "lleu"o and OFI pl,vg.
:10. El.c':,:"ical '.rvi~. is inad.q,vat. ,.~ .lisHn, IGoId!
"T'vod CNEC,.~2~Ol Ani. s'T'''1c. doslgnod to ,vppl~ ~
.inimvm a' 60 a.p.,.. 3 ..,1T" s.~"l~. 'aT' VII to' C'iva]
ttuo III1~. b,.an~h ~1~cv1':. ~apa~lt...
31. H.laT'dovs/Ul.,al IIIiT'ing in
CUBC1.I04d. 2.20:3. UHC2.202. 4.401. 7.70n. ,. '01.
10. lOOn. d.., i. J. k. 1. NEC2. 20:Za,.t<90. 61 I1ust bo T'.pl.c.".
lIT'op'T'l~ "'lIal~." a,. T'.1II0V." to .Ll.inat. hala,.d..
~C~ANIC~L-WEATtNQ
:I~ Ill.gal gas h.at'T'C,l .nd/oT' gas a,pli.nc., in
C~C2.20:Z. ,. 'o~'oe. UHC7.70Ic. UBC2.:Z0:3] All vnv.nt."
aT' ap.n I>la.. ga' .'1I1ianc.s lIIvst b. disconn.ct.d and
T'.mOV'd IT'a. 1I~..i'.s and the ga' lIi,.S ca".d in ·
_nn.T' that 1I~.".nts r.cann.ction 01> th..so a"1I1 ianc.s.
:1:3. Inadoq,vaU h.al:CUHC7.701al An allllT'Ov.d h.aUng ,,,,to,,,
shall b. inst.llod callaOl. a' 1I,.0,,1ding 70 d.g,..., F
tllT'o' ,..t aOov, 'looT' in all haOlt.ol. T'OO.S.
.....
:14. Ina"o,vatalldsstng ,as .hvto" .alotll "al".
COft".cUon~at CUlIC1.104". 2. 20:3.
~1104d. '.,02l.,ooCc-23. UPC12. 1213.J An a"T'ovod ,hvt
off/val".1 cannlc~ian shall 01 ins.al1.d in.n
adJ.c.nt/accos'iOlo location 10,. .11 .as 'iT'.d
a,,!J.ancu.
3~. Co.bustiOl., aT" ,toT'.d too n.aT' h.ating ao,lianc.. in
CU/'lC8. a06.a2. 7. 703 7041
Ro.av, ~a..vstl01.s. Chock .anu'ac':vT"~' spoci'ication,.
PLUMII tHe
:J4. Lo..king/b~okon/lllv91.d ....T' dT'aln' in
CUBCI.I04d. 2.202.' 4.401. ,. '0'. 10. lOOn.". J. k. 1. All
liltv,... and a,,11anc.. mv,t b. lIT'o"T'l" con"oc,:.d to
".,,. lin., and ..intain'd in a ...nitaT''' conditIon.
4
"
. "
J L
o
:37.
",
:38.
o 0
~..king-~..~..d pip.~-.issing plumaing 'lr~u...~ ln
CUBC~. 104d, 2.202. 4,401. ,. '0'. 10. 1001d. J. k. 1. ]
wat.r pi,.s Ind 'lrtu...s must b. ,.... 0' l...s
lIIaincain.d in I s...vic'11I1. Ind sanita.." c::Indition.
o
-'11
.nd
E"op.rativ.~i~sing p...~sur. t.IIIP.rlcu... ...li., valv.
'or hoe ",au" s'lseeIllCUBCL 104d. 2.20:3. UHC2.202. 4,401.
10. 1001d.,. 1. UPC~O. 1007, 1:3. 1:30'-1:306:R.pl,cl valv..
:39. C..o~s conn.cted ,lulllaing 'irtur.Cs] in
CUPC1.l02.&110. 6.608. 10. 100::lh] w.t.r inl.u must b. a
lIIinilllu. 0' 11nch IIIOv. tll. ..im 0' tll. v.~s.l s.rvic.d.
Inl.ts ln ",ate.. clos.t Ctoillt] tanks Must b. .~uipp.d
IIIitll aop..ov.d ANTI-3IPHCN d,vic.s IIIitll 1 inch c1..rlnc.
allov. tll. ov.r410", tull..
:39....
Vard sp..lnkl...~ .u~t II. 'r.. of e..oss conn.ctions
.pp..ov.d v'CUUIll b....k...Cs] in,t,ll.d It l.,st sia
inell.~ laov. ,urrounding ground. ~nd h.ads s."vie.d.
...i tll
C61
I:ENERA~
9
()
NOT TO BE OCCUPIED CUBC2.20::J. :3.:307. '.'01-'031 DIII.11in,
shall not b. occupi.d until violation, not.d abov.' have
b..n co"r.eted ,nd approved b'l a Bui1din, In,p.ctor 'rolll
th. Cit'l 0' San B."na..dino Build in, and Sa,.t"
D.pa..tm.nt.
A Certificat. 0' Oecup.ne'l ...i11 b. r.,uir'd to r.oeeup"
propert"CUBC2.20::J. :3.:307, ,. '01-'031.
42. I.prop.r occupane"CUHC10. 10010. UBC~20::J. ::1.:307. '.'01-
,oa1 Occupanc" is not Illo",.d in this buildin, or
portion th.r.o', "au .Utt vae.t. th. ......
4:3.
Nuts,nc.CUBC1.104d. UHC4.4011
This it ,n att...ctiv. hazard
d.1:.ri...nt,l to hu_ns. It lIlust
r.pair.d. e~.an.d up. or ....ov.d
.hleh _" provo to b.
b. provid.d ,rot.ctlon.
i_.di.l:.l".
44. Fir. haz.rd in or on
CUBC1. 104d. ~ 20:3. UHC2.202. 4.401. 8.801. 9.901.
10. 1001c. d. J. k. 1. UFC2.201. ::I. lOll R..ov. ".. building.
".vic.. appar.tus. .,uip..nl:. cOlllauttib 1. ..s-t. or
v.,..atlon ",hiell can c.u,. 0.. lug..nt the spr.ad and
int.nsit" 0' Ii... 0" .rp10tion.
@
Fault" lIIal:.ria1s 0'
CUBCt.1044. 2.20::1.
0' con~tuction mutt
Building Cod.. and
sa', ",ndition.
construction in
UHCl0. 1001e. d. J. k. 1.) All ..at.rial,
II. .110....d or .ppov.d II" the Unilorm
.d.,uat.l" .aintain.d in good .nd
,
.
,',
-6
:.~ ."
(B
TIlis
u
~
4h.
In.adequ.ce .1l.ai.O"."Ce a~ .0 ()
CUBC1. L04d. 2.20::J. UHC2.202. 4.4()1.
10.10011:1. c. d. e. ~. g. ft. i. J. _. t. Ill. n. a. ~1. 1044. 2.202.
upe~0.2. NEC2.20:z..0.1. .0.4. .0... NFC2.201. 3. lOll
Re,.i~ .a"d/a~ ~~,l.e. ~uildin, a~ ,a~~.a" tfte~.a'.
47. S.a_e detec~o~Csl l'equt~edCUBe12. 1210.. UFe APP9ID.l-
'-.1 rns~.11 tma~e d.cee~a~~ .s ~equt~ed.
48. Add~." ~.qul~'d an ..tt buildi"" ."d/a~ .,t,CUFC10.208.
Sal'lC12. ::J2. 0:30]. A"l" ..dd~u, l,,'a~tlI.Uan, an bul.1d1"g.
'0.
, Ille..l eon't~ue~l.a" ..II tell ~e,ui~"
ins,ec~ta"sCUBe::J.::J01-30'1.
SUPP~ENT I. ~~JI/ <.~1 0./ ?/a",c: -C,l'"
;9_ Tr-.:,) of..:.. -t
7... (Jf't,.,,~.- ta V~A-~L_"'"
,e~tlItt. ."d
S/r-IIL.111f'o.....,(
in~eetta" ~e,o~~ ..as ,ive" ta:
~ A ,~a,e~t" a,,"e~.
8 _".,e~.
e ',".I,,'.
D b" ..."d d,ltve~".
#f E ~.,ul.~ _1.1.
XXX F ee,.tHied _1.1. 6/20/88
..3
lqll,
a"J'"'- 6
&12", t ;,JM rAJ<-/
tns,.eta,. Sl,".t~
6
-
-
-
Ll!
~
o
o
o
o
W, R, HOLc~~"If!, . Et'l):..M3Mltl. Off.
ATTORNEY AR!jJ;.';;.' ~ 2- 31
sos A":~:::E::7 ~N'-q'!G -5 ,,~~ -s ~
SAN BERNARDINO, CALIf.Jl::SRN'I..io'92401
(7'....' eag-I041
August 5, 1988
fif
Mayor Evelyn Wilcox
Common Council
City of San Bernardino
300 North "D" Street
San Bernardino, CA 92418
Attention: Shauna Clark
City Clerk
Dear Mrs. Clark:
I hereby respectfully request that a companion matter relating
to the appeal of Albert Mamlouk be placed on the Council
agenda of August IS, 1988.
The companion matter relates to Mr. Mamlouk transferring his
off-sale beer and wine license to the abutting property,
without a protest from the City Police Department.
It is Mr. Mamlouk's desire to build a new building for his
business on a vacant lot that abuts his current business
at 771 "D" Street. I have been advised by Chief Burnett
that the Police Department will protest the moving of the
license next door. If such a protest is filed with the
Alcoholic Beverage Control, no transfer can be accomplished
without a formal hearing before the Alcoholic Beverage Control
Board.
There is a large backlog of hearings before the State Board,
and I am told that it would be at least a year before this
matter can be heard. This being the case, Mr. Mamlouk has no
alternative but to stay in the pre~ent building and retrofit
it to meet the City Codes.
The rationale for the Chief's position in this matter, I am
told, is the fact that the area is a high crime area. I am
advised, however, that since this license was issued to Mr.
Mamlouk, crime has in fact decreased in this reporting district.
.
o
-
~
o
o
o
-2-
Mayor Evelyn Wilcox
Common Concil
Attn: Shauna Clark
City Clerk
August 5, 1988
In any event, in the interest of fairness, Mr. Mamlouk
should be permitted to move a license previously approved,
to an adjoining location without the filing of an arbi-
trary protest by the Police Department.
Mr. Mamlouk has invested blood, sweat and tears in this
small family-owned business and is entirely dependent upon
it for his livelihood. Without a beer license, the business
would be in serious financial jeopardy.
We therefore respectfully request that this Honorable Body
formally instruct the San Bernardino Police Department to
refrain from filing a protest with the Alcoholic Beverage
Control Board for the transfer of Mr. Mamlouk's license to
the adjoining property.
WRH:ht
.
o
o
o
o
LAW OFFICES OF
EARL I. KORCHAK RECEI'.":' '" : "'i1
A PROFESSION""L. CORPORATION
'88 AUG -4 A 7 :30
CENTURY CITY NORTH BUIL.DING
10100 SANTA MONICA BOULEVARD, 25TH FLOOR
LOS ANGf:LII!:S. CALlF"OFlNIA 90087
TEL.EI"HONE (213) 2??sege . {Slel 764-6203
July 29, 1988
CITY CLERK
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
300 Nbrth "0" St.
San Bernardinb, Calif. 92418
RE: APPEAL FROM RESOLUTION # 1221
REPORT # 3114
751 - 771 North "0" St.
Dear Sir;
This is an appeal to the COMMON COUNCIL from the
above order from the COMMISSIONERS of the City of San Bernandino.
We are in the process of making a conclusive determination
regarding the economic feasibility of retrofiting the building
at the address set forth above , which is involved in the above
report and resolution.
We respectfully request an additional 45 days to allow
us time to make this decision.Please grant this request and
notify us accordingly.
Thank you For your cooperation in this most difficult
of circumstances.
Very
EARL I. KORCHAK
EIK/da
...... ~....
()
,
o
o
CI
:'i\l~'-\< .., ....
. '). _,"I;';,
- ~~Y':-'
.: - ~ .~; .;-. -~,;;..\
. ~-/- .--<
t ~Ot:-::-S:Al'tBERNARDINO
\~\, -'":.:-"'"
.",.. ~ ,.............- ,::-"
"'~'-"""-'J-/
'-..'. .' '.,......-
.,....,{~j '......>~~/
':.J':'t';:l~ ~:' -~ ./'~
October 13, 1987
'OJ
300 NORTH "0" STREET, SAN BERNARDINO, CALIFORNIA 9241B
.~
Re: 751, 753, 763 & 771 N. D Street
San Bernardino, CA '
Structural hazard to commercial building
Assessors No: 0140 282 43, 73 & 74
Report/Project No. 3114
Earl Korchak
234 McCarty Drive
Beverly Hills, CA 90212
On October 8, 1987 an inspection was made of your properties at 771-775
North D Street by the Department of Building and Safety, City of San
Berna rd i no.
Upon inspection it was determined that the building appears to be in a
severe state of deterioration and may be hazardous to your tenants.
Because the building is constructed of unreinforced masonry and is an
aged structure, the cement bonding is deteriorating causing bricks to
fallout of the building. Also, some original walls of the structure
have been removed by a previous tenant to the rear of 765 N. D Street,
which may have an effect on the strength of the existing walls.
Please be advised that you must sumbit, within 30 days on receipt of
this letter, structural analysis by a qualified engineer or architect
to ensure the safety of your tenants before any vacancy can be reoccupied.
James Richar~Acting Director
Building and Safety Department
~~ d/Zt~~htl^--
by: Alex Va1enzue1~-----~~
Code Compliance Officer
Phone: 714/384 5272
Hours: 7:30-8:30 a.m. or 3:30-4:30 p.m.
cc: Charles Racoosin
c:;..'.f'le5
f2t....C 0& 5; VI
~6-lf'g13
/r/6" ~- tlt~ /'?'J1j
~PR'OE 'N -.-~-!_---
,~#r~~~==
~ '1
r
Ie
.
fTA
o 0
FRAN~ TRACADAS &: ASSOCIATES, INC.
o
-, SIrucbnI EIl_~L'lIo CIvI EIl__L'lIo LaI PInIq Ie Da9l
,
Nov_ber 13. 1987
EARL I. ICORCHAJc: ..
10100 Santa Monica Blvd.. 25th Ploor
Los Angeles. CA. 90067
".
!tE: Structure. 765 Horth "D" Street
Ci ty of San Bernardino
Dear Mr. ICorchaJc:
Ptu-suant to your request and authorization we examined the
above-referenced building to evaluate its structural features
to adequately resist minimum forces which may be imposed by
normal use or seismic occurrence.
This examination considered only the structural ellllents
of the building and their ability to withstand these forces.
No consideration was given to the aesthetics of the structure.
The minimum forces referred to were determined in accordance
With standard engineering practice' using the 1982 Uniform
Building Code as a guideline.
This review and evaluation wes of a non-destructive nature and
consisted of visual eX8lllination of the inside and outside of the
structure. FOllOwing is a brief resume of our review and findings:
The existing bUilding is a single story Commercial
bUilding of approximately 9.800 square feet (see
a~tached sketch). In general. the lOad-bearing and shear-
resisting walls are of a non-reinforced brick masonry.
The exterior and interior of SOllIe of these WlIlls have
been plastered over to present a more pleasing appearance
but this has not added anything structurally to the
building.
The roof construction consists of bow-string trusses
approximately 16' o.c. along the Southerly POrtion
of the building wi th no ceiling in the rear area
(easterly 97' ~. These trusses bear on unreinforced
brick masonry col~,s and have steel pipe supports
approximately at their center. Roof rafters span between
the trusses with roof sheathing running parallel with
the trusses. This sheathing consists of 1" x 6" + boards.
This roof sYStem is not tied to the shear-resisting walls
in accordance with good seismic-resistant construction
practice.
463 N, Siena Way, . San Bematdtno, CaJlfomJa 92410 . (714) 884-1115
o
,
.
~
'-
o
o
o
P&le 2: Mr. E: Korchak
765 North "D" Street
City of San Bernardino
In short. this buildina. a non-reinforced brick
masonry structure. is not "tied" together and
in its present condition is not structurally
adequate to resist minimum seismic forces as outlined
in the 1982 Unifo1'lll Buildina Code. '"
~ It is possible to strengthen those portions of the
----;7 buildina which do not aeet the minima code re-
quirements. but in our opinion it II&Y not be
economically feasible.
The fol10wing is a summary of what will have to be done to meet the
minimUm Code requirements:
1) ReJIlove and replace all "straight" roof sheathing
and some of the toof frlllllina members (roof sheathing
that runs parallel with the end walls);
2) Strengthen the existing roof bow-string trusses;
3) Anchor all structural walls to the roof framing;
4) Strenghten all structural (exterior) walls;
5) Strengthen existing brick masonry columns.
Enclosed are a number of colored photographs which were taken on
the site. (A print of the site plan indicates the area from
which these photos were taken.) A brief explanation and observation
is made on the back of some of these photos.
Respectfully submitted.
~ 1/ f..
Report No. ~
~
arles P. u am, C.E.
Plan Check Engineer
Building & Safety Department
City of San Bernardino
FRANK 'ffiACADAS & ASS~IATES.
~- ~.--~
Fra Ti-ac a. E.
INC.
)
xc: Chuck Racoosin,
GEORGE SCHNARRE REALTY'
Enclosures: Site Plan
21 Photographs
"
o
o
o
o
3QO NORTH .0. STREET. SAN BERNARDINO. CALIFORNIA 9241B
February 17, 1988
Re: 751-771 N. D Street
San Bernardino, CA
Structural hazard to commercial building
Assessors No: 140 282 43, 73,
Report/Project No. 3114
Earl Korchak
234 McCarty Drive
Beverly Hills, CA 90212
Recently we received a request for a Certificate of Occupancy inspection for
another automotive business in the vacant portion of the building.
It is the decision of this department not to issue any further clearances for
your building. Furthermore, we are asking that you vacate your other tenants
until you can supply them with a safe environment to conduct their businesses.
On October 13, 1987, I wrote to you that the building is constructed of
unreinforced masonry and the cement bonding has deteriorated causing bricks to
fallout of the building. Also, I mentioned to you that a previous tenant
to the rear of 765 N. D Street removed existing walls from the interior and
exterior of the building without permits or inspections.
Please be advised that you contact this office within 10 days on receipt of
this letter with your intentions to vacate your tenants, retrofit your
'structure or demolish your structure or further action will be taken.
Mark I. Sutton, Director /"
BUildi~;7d Safety 3eparrent JO--.-
~y'y,.z,../ V'J~)
by: Alex Valenzuela
Code Compliance Officer
Phone: 714/384 5272
Hours: 7:30-8:30 a.m. or 3:30-4:30 p.m.
enc1
.. ~
~~1GRESS
j
1
JI
.0
o
o
o
I.....w OI"I"ICES 0""
EARL I. KORCHAK
. 1II.o"ES'IONAt.. eOIlt~""'''ON
CENTURY CITY NORTH SUIL.ClINQ
10100 SANTA MONICA .OULEVARO. 251'N ":.oOOR
1..0. ANOELES. C:ALI"OIllNIA 80087
TEL.EfI'HONE 12131 277..... . ta,al 784-8203
March 15, 1988
Albert Mamlouk
c/o: 7/10 Food Store
767 North D Street
San Bernardino, California 92401
Dear Mr. Manlouk:
EZ1closed you will find a copy of a letter that I have received
iran the City of San Bernardino, Building and Safety Dep....u.-it.
As is clear iran this letter, the Building and Safety Dep.... .......ut
Director feels that the building is unsafe for occupancy in its present
ca1ditial. .
loI1en I received the first notice iran them, I en~ the
services of an engineer to inspect the property and prepare his report as
to lIilether it is eccn:mi.ca1ly feasible to repair the building or lotIether
it should be dem:>1ished. The opinim of the engineer in additial to the
opi.ni.m of the Building and Safety engineer is that it is not eC(l'V'ftTi,."lly
feasible to repair the building and that it U1.ISt be dem:>1ished.
I have been advised that the tenants U1.ISt be vacated iran the
premises by May 15, 1988 or else the City will obtain an Order of
DellDlitial at that time.
As you can ;mI'lg5T1e, it is a disaster to me, as owner of the pr<J!lE!rty:
However, I have no alternative but to cmply with the Order of the CitY of .
San Bernardino.
tbler the cirCl.mltances, it is to the best interest of you and your
custaDers to vacate your premises as socn as possible.
EIK:ps
-
.
o
o
o
.~
E. · S ·
nglneerlng ervlces
Z.lohn Szekely, P.E.
C_u1taDl
August 3, 1988
Earl I. Korchak
IOlOP Santa Monica Blvd., 25th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90067
RE: Structure 8 765 North "D" Street
City of San Bernardino
Dear Mr. Korchak:
I have been retained by Mr. Charles Racoosin of George H. Schnarre
Real Estate to provide Design Calculations and Drawings for the
rehabilitation of the above referenced building. Calculations and
Drawing will conform to the provisions of the San Bernardino Municipal
Code in accordance with standard engineering practice using the 1985
Uniform Building Code. Calculations and Drawings to be completed
20 days from today.
I have examined the portion of building currently occupied. It is
my professional evaluation that its structural features adequately
resist minimum forces which may be imposed by normal use or seismic
occurrence.
'Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please do not
hesitate to call me.
Sincerely,
Z. John Szekely P.E.
'-r~
.
, 620 E. Valley Boulevard, SUite B . Colton, California 92324
Business (714) 824-9535 . Home (714) 982-3784
,
~,..
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
l}
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
'28
.
Ii
I
o
o
o
1221
,
;~.. '":. ~-::i;OL~JI::::()N NCI.
<>,'.:PO?T 'le. 3114
RE~OLUl'I'JN '.J::' --':-~i!t; ~OA?:~ Q[,' ~)lJII.L'IN~; COr-1HI~S IONE:~3 OF l:~~
...,......'\.1
\......:...
OF :;AN 8~RNA?DIlJ() A,IJTtiORI?IIW 'I'HE ABATBI1~NT OF A ?1.lBU:;
~U~SANGE.
~-lHERt.A8, p11rs'.Jant to ~an ~et'nardino ~!1Jni.cipal f:ode, 7itIe
15, Chepter 1~.2~, the Building Official has post~d ~ huildin~(s:
or premises located at 751, 753, 763, 771, North "D" St.
!I San ~ernardino, (;aliforn"ta, ,.'ith a "Noti~e to At:ate Nuisan~e",
:: p.nt:! has ;'\otiZ-=-?(~ tLe oet':.,on or persons hav:.ng an interest i:t SB'!.":l
Ii
IDroperty that the said buildin~(s) or premises constitute a
~PUbliC nuisance, and has prepared a de~laration of pORting and
;1
~mallin, of the noti~e, a copy of which is on file in these
, . ,
prOC~~(1.1na.s; an'..l
\'IH.~j75A;~, pur'Junnt to S'1id San Bernar1ino Nunicioal Co,1e, the
]3uU,iin'O!: Official has served a "Notice of '~earing Before the
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
i
, Board of Building Commissioners of the City of Can Bernardino",
i
I rel~tin? t~ abateme~t of said nuisance, to the person or persons
:havlng an Interest In said property, and has prepared a
;
ideclaration of mailing of the notice, a copy of which is on file
I in these proceedings; ann
!
;1 1>1!{l!:?EAS, a hearinv, was he 1:1 to receive and consinp.t' aE
!
,
~r~levant evidence, nbjp.ctinns or protPsts on July 1st
'I
;; 19 88 and
II \'hlEREAS, the Board of Rui Id info; Commiss ioners heard the
~testlmony and examined the evidence offered by the parties
':relati'1P to su~h aile~ed Dublic nuisance,
~JOW, TrrE~E?QR~, BE I~ ~~~OI,V~D g~ ~~~ ~OAan OF 3UILUT:~G
,0'"
o
o
o
1 COMMISSIONERS OF THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO AS FOLLOWS:
2 SECTION 1. Based upon the evidence submitted, it is found
3 and determined that the building(s) or premises located at
4 751,753, 763, 771 N. "D" St. , San Bernardino, California,
5 constitute a public nuisance for the reasons set forth in Exhibit
6 "A", attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference as
7 though fully set forth at length as the findings of fact of the
8 Board.
9 SECTION 2. The owner(s) is hereby directed to commence the
10 abatement of the public nuisance by obtaining the necessary
11 demolition and/or building permits within ten (10) days after the
12 date of posting of a copy of this Resolution in a conspicuous
13 place on said building(s) or premises. The abatement must be
14 completed within thirty (30) days thereafter.
15 SECTION 3. In the event the public nuisance is not abated
16 within the prescribed period of time, the building(s) or premises
17 shall be razed, demolished, removed, repaired or rehabilitated by
18 the City of San Bernardino, or by a person or persons authorized
19 by the Building Official, and the expense thereof made a lien on
20 the lot or parcel of land upon which the public nuisance is
......
21 located.
22 SECTION 4. Any person aggrieved by this order may, within
23 fifteen (15) days after Jul y 22 , 1988 , appeal to the
24 Common Council by filing with the City Clerk a written statement
25 of the order appealed from, the specific grounds of appeal and
26 the relief or action sought from the Common Council.
27 I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing resolution was duly
28 adopted by the Board of Building Commissioners at a
<
2
o
II
I
I
1
regular
o
o
\
,
o
1st
meeting thereof, held on. the
, 19...!l. by the following vote, to wit:
2 day of
3
4
~;
OJ
I
6'
i
8
!J
"
10 day
1]
12
I
,
131
July
~'I- /~!~ .
/#~~ //1 / -(V~
Cl.e-r'k; - Board ot BUL ing Commissioners
The foregoing resolution is hereby approved this 1st
AYES:
NAYS:
ABSENT:
of
Commissioners Miller, Heil, Lord, Westwood, Ponder,
Hunt, Gonzales, Flores and Pollock
None
July
, 1988.
g/J '4 t(~
Chairfuan,~~ ~ng ommissioners
14
App ov'!!d as to
fo~m .~~.
"--.../
161 Attorr:ey,
d Attorney
181
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
261
,
I
2-'
I'
"jl
2si!
. I
3