Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-Mayor's Office . CITe OF SAN BERNARDIO - REQUEO FOR COUNCIL AC1:))N From: T~elma Press, ~ia~so'REC'O -AD14tM.SOSiict: Flne Arts Commlsslon . t1ayor 0 s Office IS3S ;~AY 21 :}\ n 27 Approval of Master Plan for the Fine Arts - City of San Bernardino Dept: Date: May 14, 1986 Synopsis of Previous Council action: Ordinance #MC-309 - Dated October 10, 1983 Mayor & Council directed the Fine Arts Commission to develop a Master Plan for the Fine Arts in the City of San Bernardino. Recommended motion: Approve the Master Plan for the Fine Arts, City of San Bernardino, as submitted by the Fine Arts Commission. J-/~~ a/ ~. Signatu re Contact person: Thf>lma Prp'" Phone: <A<-~114 Supporting data attached: Yes Ward: FUNDING REQUIREMENTS: Amount: Sou rce: Finance: Cou nci I Notes: 75-0262 Agenda Item No. - ~ - - (. - '-' -, ~) J -'" The San Bernardino Fine Arts Commission has implemented its continued goals to mean that there is more to life than provision of municipal services and that one way a government can accomplish that goal is to create a climate that satis- fies, aesthetically, the senses of the people in the community. Cultural Arts not only add to the stature of the community, but also from an economic point of view, brings people here and keeps residents from leaving for their artistic pursuits and entertainment. The Cultural Arts in many cities, large and small, are the least developed municipal service. The National League of Cities and the U.S. Conference of Mayors, in 1974, passed resolutions and created task forces on the Arts, establishing the principle that cities recognize the Arts as an eventual service - and political recognition of the Arts to urban economic, social, health, stability development and rede- velopment should no longer be ignored. What is the City? The City is people. All kinds of people-- young and old, male and female, Black and White, Yellow and Brown. The City's people are its most valuable resource. That resource, fully developed, is an investment that will yield a rich return. The Arts have become focal points for community life. A new cultural constituency has emerged for the public official to be aware of and to serve. The Arts are an industry in themselves. They do not pollute; they employ people and generate taxes. Further, they involve a support structure that reaches out into the wider life of the economic community. The Fine Arts Committee members feel that unless a Master Plan for the Cultural Arts is considered for approval for the City of San Bernardino, a vital thread in the fabric which holds Cultural Arts together, due to the current programatic agenda of the administration, will fall short of meeting many of the major objectives in the future development as a livable city. ~~ - - - OJ j~:" . ^ ''-'1 " I C ORDINANCE NO. -, ~ MC-309 2 ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO ADDING CHAPTER 2.30 o THE SAN BERNARDINO MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A FINE ARTS 3 COMMISSION AND PROVIDING FOR APPOINTMENT OF MEMBERS AND DUTIES OF THE COMMISSION. 4 THE MAYOR AND COMMON COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO DO 5 ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: 6 SECTION 1. Chapter 2.30 is added to the San Bernardino 7 Municipal Code to read: 8 "Chapter 2.30 9 FINE ARTS COMMISSION 10 2.30.010 Members - Appointment. 11 The Fine Arts Commission of the City shall consist of eleven 12 voting members and one non-voting ex-officio member, all of whom 13 shall serve at the pleasure of the Mayor and Common Council. 14 Members of the Commission shall be appointed by the Mayor, subject 15 to the approval of the Common Council. Each Commission member 16 shall serve until a successor is appointed. Nomination and 17 appointment of a successor member at any time shall terminate the 18 appointment of any member without need for formal removal action. 19 Members shall be appointed on the basis of demonstrated knowledge 20 and experience in the arts and recognized dedication to cultural 21 affairs. All voting members shall be residents of the City of San 22 Bernardino. The ex-officio member shall be the president, or the 23 approved designee of the president, of the Inland Empire Cultural 24 Foundation ("CLASS"). 25 2.30.020 Duties. 26 The Fine Arts Commission shall: 27 A. Make recommendations to the Mayor and Common Council for 28 the development and promotion of fine arts in San Bernardino. /......" ""'" .-..) '-' 1 B. Work with public and private cultural organizations to 2 promote the efficient utilization of community art resources and 3 to enlarge the opportunities for the diverse City population to 4 participate in and enjoy culturally rewarding experiences. 5 C. Develop a master plan for fine arts objectives and 6 development in San Bernardino. 7 D. Review the financial needs of fine arts organizations in 8 San Bernardino and recommend specific grants within the City 9 budget allocation for approval by the Mayor and Common Council to 10 achieve overall cultural objectives. 11 E. Accomplish specific projects related to fine arts as 12 determined by the Mayor and Common Council. 13 2.30.030 Chairman - Meetings - Absences. 14 The Fine Arts Commission shall be organized and shall 15 function pursuant to the provisions of Section 2.17.060 and 16 Section 2.17.070 of the San Bernardino Municipal Code. 17 2.30.040 Conflict of interest. 18 The Mayor and Common Council declare that the individuals 19 appointed to the Fine Arts Commission are intended to represent 20 and further the interests of all organizations and professions in 21 the fine arts and that such representation and furtherance serves 22 the public interest. Accordingly, the Mayor and Common Council 23 find that for the purposes of members of the Fine Arts Commission, 24 the organizations and professions in the fields of fine arts are 25 tantamount to and constitute the public generally within the 26 meaning of Section 87103 of the Government Code." 27 I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing ordinance was duly 28 adopted by the Mayor and Common Council of the City of San -2- I I - """ -. -...I meeting thereof, held on I Bernardino at an adjourned regular , 1983, by the following vote, 2 the lOth day of October 3 to wit: 4 AYES: Council Members Castaneda, Reilly, Hernandez, 5 Marks, Strickler 6 NAYS: None Council Members Quiel, Frazier 1 ABSEN'l': 8 9 .....4z?//,:::tfl/(2?";f,, Clty Clerk II':;;" day The foregoing ordinance is 10 11 of rtc! tm-?-V , 1983. 12 13 14 Approved as to form: I~~':;'~ City ttorney 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 21 28 -)- c - ~ ......\ '-' ) May 12, 1986 MASTER PLAN FOR THE FINE ARTS for THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO SECTION 1 THE ROLE OF FINE ARTS Throughout history, most nations have attempted to improve the quality of life through expressions of their values in various cultural forms such as drawings, paintings, carvings, sculpture, music, drama, dance, weaving, and the design of tools and implements. Those expressions which have contributed beauty and inspiration to individuals within each culture have been labeled the Fine Arts. Often various art forms are among the few remnants of past civilizations and cultures which demonstrate the inspirations and acomplishments to which those nations aspired. The Fine Arts are an integral part of the American culture. Since it is the role of each culture to educate its members in its traditions, values and aspirations, the City of San Bernardino has the responsibility to provide maximum opportunity for its citizens to participate fully in the arts. SECTION 2 THE NEED FOR A PROGRAM OF FINE ARTS IN THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO The population of the City of San Bernardino is comprised of various ethnic and socio-economic groups. Each group has c c -2- o ,) distinct values and traditions which can be shared through expressions in the arts and which will enhance and enrich the quality of life for the entire community. An on-going program in the arts will not only encourage this sharing of cultural values but will also act as a stimulant for the contined development and integration of all members of the community. Since the cultural opportunities which exist within a community represent one of the most important magnets which attract people and business enterprises, a pervasive and rich program in the arts is necessary for the future development of a progressive city such as San Bernardino. SECTION 3 THE ROLE OF THE FINE ARTS COMMISSION In recognition of the need for a program of Fine Arts, the Mayor and Common Council of the City of San Bernardino estab- lished in October, 1983, the Fine Arts Commission for the City indicating that the Fine Arts Commission shall: A. Make recommendations to the Mayor and Common Council for the development and promotion of Fine Arts in San Bernardino. B. Work with public and private cultural organizations c c -3- ~ :J to promote the efficient utilization of community art resources and to enlarge the opportunities for the diverse City population to participate in and enjoy culturally rewarding experiences. C. Develop a master plan for Fine Arts objectives and development in San Bernardino. D. Review the financial needs of Fine Arts organiza- tions in San Bernardino and recommend specific grants within the city budget allocation for appro- val by the Mayor and Common Council to achieve overall Fine Arts objectives. E. Accomplish specific projects related to the Fine Arts as determined by the Mayor and Common Council. FINE ARTS COMMISSION PRIORITIES I The Commission is making a concerted effort to develop community awareness that the Fine Arts Commission is an agent of the City to enhance the quality of life through encouragement, support, and promotion of Fine Arts activities. To accomplish this function, the Commission has adopted the following priorities: " . c ,,-, '-' -4- ""' -..,) ) SECTION 4 PROMOTION OF THE FINE ARTS Promote the Fine Arts as a way of life through utilization of the media, city government and Chamber of Commerce brochures and publications in educational institutions to advertise and publicize community arts activities, thus reinforcing the concept that San Bernardino has an active cultural life and a rich cultural future. SECTION 5 COOPERATION AMONG FINE ARTS ORGANIZATIONS The Fine Arts Commission actively encourages art groups whose activities are duplicative to seek means of combining their efforts so as to improve the quality of their activity and develop broader audience participation among youth and adults. Working together to combine similar, less-productive groups into a cohesive, fruitful organization will benefit the artist, the organization, and the recipient audience. The goal is to develop an activity that will offer the highest fine arts experience for all. SECTION 6 PRIVATE SECTOR SUPPORT '- -5- .:) J c -- In recognition of the philosophical position that the quality of life and hence the social and economic well-being within a community are directly related to the variety and quality of cultural activities within that community, the private sector, including business and individuals, will be encourag- ed to contribute to support of the arts. Contributions may take the form of donations, endowments, bequests, and the establishment of foundations to provide funding for a variety of Fine Arts activities. The Fine Arts Commission will encourage and seek to provide the means whereby art groups can apply for and obtain funding support from sources within the private sector. SECTI.mL1 EXAMINE EXISTING AND PROJECTED FACILITY NEEDS Within the City of San Bernardino, there are several types of facilities available for use by cultural groups. They include auditoriums, the California Theatre of Performing Arts, galleries, and meeting places of varying sizes and accommodations. Schools, churches and a few business concerns provide some access to such spaces but often on a very limited basis depending upon that organiza- tion's needed usage. Some commercial facilities may be available upon payment of fees. The need exists for regularly available public facilities which provide spaces for lectures, films, music and dance recitals, dramatic , c "'-'''' '-- -6- , ..~ ~.J ~) presentations, and galleries for exhibit of paintings and sculpture. The public libraries, the convention center and the City Cultural Center are available for some activities but because of the nature of the accommodations, are not suitable for others such as music, dance, and dramatic presentations. A commitment to an early completion of the Sturges Project is greatly needed. It will make available much needed space for small recital, dance and dramatic events. It will also establish a central focus for Fine Arts activities within the City, providing necessary office space for recreation and Fine Arts groups, in addition to theatre and gallery space. Projected future needs include a larger facility or facili- ties to meet the need for activities that were outlined in the preliminary plans for the cultural complex for the Seccombe Lake Project, such as a crafts studio and a sculp- ture studio. SECTION 8 PROJECTED STAFFING NEEDS Essential in future planninq will be provision for a full- time staff, including a Fine Arts Director whose function will be to coordinate arts activities, serve as an informa- tion center, assist with publicity, spearhead fund-raising activities, provide expertise in grant-writing solicitation of funding from public and private sectors, and in general c c -7- ---- J ,) enhance public awareness and participation in cultural activities. SECTION ~ PROVIDING FINANCIAL SUPPORT FOR THE ARTS Research by the Ford Foundation and others indicates that historically and currently, symphonies, opera groups, dance companies, theatre companies, and art museums are rarely able to generate more than 40-50% of needed funding through their own funding activities alone. Therefore, the survival and effectiveness of such groups are dependent on government and/or private sector auxiliary support on a regular and ongoing basis. Governmental bodies should set the standard for support of cultural activities as part of their responsibility to provide for the social, educational, recreational, and enter- tainment needs of the individuals within the community. Therefore, an on-going system of support should be estab- lished and protected from the vagaries of annual budgeting. Projecting a long-term view, the Mayor and Common Council must establish a method of providing financial support for the arts which grows proportionately with the future growth of the city. A tax of 1/2 of 1% shall be assessed on all new housing developments and commercial construction. Funds c c -8- .-, ~~ , ~ generated shall be used wholly in support of arts groups, cultural facilities and staff, and city beautification projects. SECTION 10 THE IMPORTANCE OF THE ARTS IN A COMMUNITY "The Arts constitute one of America's great under- used and vital resources" (Quote from the Final Report, 67th American Assembly on THE ARTS AND PUBLIC POLICY IN THE UNITED STATES.) The need for avenues of self-expression and the natural crea- tivity inherent in the American people have resulted in an emergence of artists in our midst, many of whom have attained international recognition. To encourage development of such talent must be a prime goal of our educational and govern- mental agencies. Cities which are admired and recognized for their quality of life are renown for their cultural achieve- ments. Since San Bernardino aspires to become such a city, THE GOAL FOR THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO SHALL BE TO BECOME KNOWN FOR THE EXCELLENCE OF ITS CULTURAL AND ARTS ACHIEVEMENTS. c ,.- '- ~ \ ...,; RICHARD G. SIMON ~tnf:rdl ~ (11.11) rYrJ/I-I..!!I,f ,f7i!A:id~~ ~~~,~9i!.IIOI May 19, 1986 MS. THELMA PRESS Ci ty Hall 300 North "D" Street San Bernardino, CA 92418 Re: Fine Arts Commission Master Plan Dear Ms. Press: I have discussed with Barry Silver the potential revenues that would be received and the utlization for which they might be expended should the master plan be adopted as pro- posed, and alternatively should the .005 assessment be limited to commercial construction only. In 1985 residential construction in the City amounted to $63,950,000, and commercial construction amounted to $46,201,000. Without projecting any increases, this would generate $550,755 for all construction or $231,005 for commercial construction only. The Fine Arts Commission has not adopted a definitive budget for the funds. However, a general outline for expenditures might be as follows: 1) Annual maintenance of Sturgis Auditorium per estimates furnished $ 63,000. 2) Grants to arts orginations- based on grant requests for the 1985-1986 fiscal year. These requests were considered worthy by the Commission, but were scaled down because of the limitation of available funds 125,000. IllI C RICHARD G. SIMON ~~~ c :) :) Ms. Thelma Press Re: Fine Arts Commission/Master Plan May 19, 1986 Page Two 3) Funds to be utilized for special projects. For example, we have received a request to fund a production of the traveling company of the San Francisco Opera. Other possibilities are the commission of a symphonic piece and a performance thereof in commemoration of Martin Luther King Day or Black History Week 25,000. 4) Establishmentor support of a dramatic reportory company- an art form lacking in the City 50,000. TOTAL $238,000. Additional funding can be utilized for beautification and/or visual arts, staffing needs as set forth in Section 8 of the Master Plan, and in the long run for major facilities acquisi- tions as outlined in Section 7 of the Master Plan. Very truly yours, ~--f /1- ~ RICHARD G. SIMON Fine Arts Commission Member c c ~ ,) CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA Mayor Joseph P. Riley, Jr. has intensified municipal funding for the arts. Charleston's allocation of 7.5% of its city budget to the arts is one of the highest amounts of any city in the country and is well above the average for other cities of Charleston's size. Mayor Riley believes that the arts are a positive catalyst to revitalization --both as an industry w~ich encourages and evidences the best of human nature and as the key to a livable city. Provided over 4,000 area jobs and inspired the involvement of thousands of volunteers. ALBUQUERQUE, NEW MEXICO In Fiscal Year 19B5, the city budget allocates over 5i percent to its arts and environmental programs. In addition, the city secured over $300,000 in private matching funds for support of such endeavors. CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA Under Mayor Harvey Ganntt's leadership, the city has used bond monies to finance arts facilities, such as the famous Spirit Square Performing Arts Center. The facility development of Spirit Square has been a product of true public/private partnership since its inception in 1975. Of the voter- approved $9.9 million bond referendum for the construction of Discovery Place and Spirit Square, $2.B went to the opening of the Spirit Square's Education building, which contains offices and spaces for community arts programs and classes. In 1979, a city bond referendum of $2.B million went to the opening of Spirit Square's Education building, which contains offices and spaces for community arts programs and classes. In 1979, a city bond referendum of $2.5 million was passed and $B50,OOO raised from private contributions completed andopened Performance Place and People Place in 19BO. c Page two c ,....... .....I J COLUMBUS, OHIO Mayor Dana G. Rinehart of Columbus, Ohio, perceives the arts as playing a central role in economic development. As Columbus' City Livability applica- tion emphasizes: "Columbus views its investment of money and services in the arts as an economic decision that will pay dividents of increased city health as corporations, in turn, view Columbus as a profitable place in which to invest." Columbus' city government annually earmarks 20 percent of hotel-motel revenues for the arts and stands among only a few cities to have devised a fixed, relatively substantial formula for distributing bed tax funds to the arts. City bonds have also been used to partially fund the Martin Luther King Performing Arts Center. In addition, one-half to one percent of the total construction budgets of various capital improvements projects is earmarked for artworks under the city's percent for art program. PITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA Mayor Richard S. Caliguiri has developed a variety of funding mechanisms to support the arts, ranging from bond issues and direct financial aid to public/private partnerships. His personal role as an arts advocate dates back to the 1960's when he was the city's Parks Oirector. Mayor Caliguiri can be credited for integrating the arts into Pittsburgh's Second Renaissance, with 3.3% of the city's general fund allocated to a wealth of arts activities; comprehensive planning and quality design for the built environment; and the city sponsorship of a national design competition for the new Liberty Center Hotel. SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH Mayor Ted Wilson's ten-year leadership in Salt Lake City emphasized strong City support for the arts and a commitment to bringing the arts to all segments of the population, including the elderly, persons with handicaps, and the underprivileged. - . . c Page 3 ,...... ......., ""'" .....J :) The City has provided financial support for the arts. In 1984, for example, Mayor Wilson called for an additional $55,000 in grant funds for major arts organizations, and the City Council approved it. In 1982, the Mayor and Council also approved a grant for $225,000 in seed money for Artspace, a unique artists' residential/studio project made possible by restoration of an historic, commercial building. 8ALTIMORE, MARYLAND Mayor William Donald Schaefer's pioneering efforts in support of the arts in Baltimore brought first place in the City Livability Award Program to Baltimore in 1981 and honorable mention in the competition in 1982 and 1983. Baltimore has a long history of arts support dating back to 1964, when the Percent for Art ordinance was adopted. Since then, over 200 works of art, valued at more than $2,5 million, have been acquired by the City. Under Mayor Schaefer's leadership, Baltimore ranks second highest in per capita spending for the arts by any city government in cities with a population over 350,000. Mayor Schaefer's personal involvement in founding the Mayor's Ball to Benefit the Arts, creating MACAC, the Cloisters Children's Museum, the ARTSCAPE festival and the School #3 Art Center are amont the many innovative projects being successfully demonstrated in Baltimore. BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA Mayor Richard Arrington, Jr. has demonstrated strong arts advocacy within his administration and with the City Council in earmarking $5 million of a $45 million bond issue in 1984, for an Arts and Science Center, in addition to funding for park improvements, the Birmingham Botanical Gardens and the City Zoo, Mayor Arrington led in the creation of a Museum Task Force to study the establishment of an arts district downtown and has also developed plans to allocate .5% of profits from Birmingham's new racetrack to the arts. The city's aid to the arts is more than 1.5% annually. - - -- :ili c. Page 4 c - ......; "', J CORPUS CHRISTI, TEXAS Mayor Luther Jones has increased the scope and diversity of municipal support budget for art. The City Council established a Permanent Trust Fund for acquisition of art works, and tripled its annual allocation from $25,000 in 1982 to $75,000 today. In addition, Mayor Jones and the City Council have used legislation to support the "beautification and cul- tural development of the city." Funds for art in public building construction projects and the allocation of a portion of the hotel-motel tax for art are ways in which Corpus Christi supports the arts. HONOLULU, HAWAII Mayor Frank Fasi, along with his staff at the City's Commission on Culture and the Arts, which is attached directly to the Mayor's Office, promotes the preservation of Honolulu's diverse artistic and cultural heritage. Honolulu recently strengthened the existing Percent of Art ordinance, requiring that not less than 1% of construction costs of city buildings be set aside for the acquisition of art works. LA MIRADA, CALIFORNIA Mayor Lou Piltz and the City Council of La Mirada, earmark 15% of the city's annual general fund budget for arts and cultural activities. This is one of the highest levels of municipal support for the arts in the country and is especially hoteworthy in view of La Mirada's relatively small size. MOBILE, ALABAMA Mayor Lambert C. Mins and the Commissioners of Mobile, Alabama have intensi- fied their efforts to bring the arts to all segments of the community. Mobile earmarks 7.75% of its annual budget for the arts and restoration. High-level municipal support uses funding mechanisms ranging from bond issues and matching grants to both direct and indirect contributions. -. - c Page 5 I"'"'" '-' :) J NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA Mayor Ernest N. Moria1 has demonstrated his strong commitment to the arts through dramatically increased city support as well as through comprehensive planning for the arts. From 1980 to 1984, the city's support for the arts increased 126%, while the city budget itself increased only 39%. RICHMOND, CALIFORNIA Mayor Thomas J. Corcoran and the City Council attach great importance to the city's support for the arts. Mayor Corcoran believes that strengthening the arts is a significant factor in altering the harsh perception of this community while providing a focus for community spirit and pride. ROSWELL, NEW MEXICO Mayor Peter R. York has led general fund for the arts. and Art Center, the Roswell Theatre. his city in earmarking approximately 2% of the Municipal funding benefits the Roswell Museum Symphony Orchestra and the Roswell Little SAVANNAH, GEORGIA The commitment of Mayor John P. Rousakis is exemplified by the earmarking of $2.13 per capita to the arts in the city's budget. Under the Mayor's leadership, direct city support of the arts has grown from $76,000 in 1978 to $300,000 in 1985. SCOTTSDALE, ARIZONA Mayor Herbert R. Drinkwater has increased his city's level of support for the arts to $10.92 per capita each year, among the highest in the country. The Mayor and City Council authorized a $10.4 million redevelopment program that transofrmed a deteriorating downtown area into the Scottsdale Center for the Arts, with two theatres, an art gallery and space for outdoor _ _.. ".. _ _..L-"- _ ..1_ "I _ "1_ 'I "II c Page 6 c ~ , ,) TULSA, OKLAHOMA Under the leadership of Mayor Terry Young and the City Commission, Tulsa, Oklahoma, has continued to provide significant financial support for the Tulsa Performing Arts Center and the city-owned Gilcrease Museum, despite difficult economic times. The city earmarks approximately 2.1% of its annual fund for the arts. Municipal funding includes $1 million this year for the Performing Arts Center and $850,000 of the Gilcrease's total $1.3 million budget. WASHINGTON, D.C. Mayor Marion Barry, Jr.'s support for the arts has resulted in a creative arts strategy. Mayor Barry's Geographic Development Program brings the arts to previously unserved or under-served areas of the city by giving grants to libraries, churches, community centers and other nontraditional "arts Presenters", and also provides training in fundraising, marketing, financial management and other topics of interest to emerging arts organizations. - . c c ~ ~ Culture Pays (4 to 1); Don't $Irangle II Iy MAmN L'MAL CULTURAL ACTIVITIES .nd the .u1t.......1a1ed iDdUltr)' ..., f... 0lIl, two tblrds ",...&1. The 0&..... ODO tbird eom.. in Ne. York Cit, .... Iq bUli_- VerJ Iq busi_ from _bu-' JI'ODtI aDd sllMalioDs rr- oit, .nd .tste. Their total.....oditureo.... woll over 13 biIIioo. ,_. TIle S- publle fIpno _ ..ttiDl_ sllMalio... v.lu. of the nonprofit iDltitulioDs aIoae ia over S5 billion. AD It ia _ 10 stGp llIillldq '" our eultural iDltitulioDs .nd together the, emplOJ more tban 50.000 _Ie. That .....nda ..._related indUltrioo u friapo. u -.tiOlll. The,.re looeold. thoop.aolet'.u,that5O,OOO_ledependf...tbelr .... part '" UIa _, "'"'" oit,. IiviDg on the "eulture" iDdUItr)'-oa thaatre and... .... OR Owerty'........biaMt iDdUItr)' ia lourismlonIJ the gar. ballet .nd opera, OR m_uma aDd fIIma, on librarloe aDd _ _Dt iDdUItr)' ia 1arprI. VisiUn apeDt $1.1 biIIioD here wt .nd OOtsni... gerde.. .nd more. ~. aDd. .. part '" tW ....1 Ie New y...kera u w.ge&. Thia ia big bUli_ bal II Ia unllb &OJ _ b...i III WIlr did aD ..... ..... _ here aDd spend all that Some parte.re relativelJ profitallIe; _1lreaI< eVOD'~. -'WIlr"'_h '( ... _aDd_vlduala.~ bit of help~ _.... free.nd daD'l upoet Iomsk. _, 80 New y..., A _ _ .. 'fioIlere .lIonred that f... 48'lb the oitJ eontributea about" bIIIIoa. ,_113lI million loeftn tIleeuJtanl.l&l. ., _tIle.......r.ctor. TIIe,eameto the Iateat bouIpt ...tal. ia deIIan aed ......... 10 ...., ..... New Yen ~ ...., ....... te P Ie tile thaatar. to the inatitutiona.....g.A_...i&_teaon!J.___ PIlII.... . letlle Ie tile_aDd .........., gar. of 1.. of tbe oil,'. aanual budpt, U1a1 eoDtriIJa_ 10 aIl1I ... 10 .... .. . .. tW _ ... ..... Ia 0IlIJ 8ve other underverJ"_.-' Yetf....V8rJcIGIIIJ'tbedtJ... ........ ill tile wwId. a.. tile ._... tile pUeriea. on eulture, it pta ...... .11eut r- ~ aDd _ _ ..........,.. _ . '.. -.It aed baDet, aDd ,OU .... inclireellJ. .......................YenCitJ. Yoaaloeredu.. There .... p__ Io..t 10 tile ...... tllia.. ml11Ion'" tile........ ~... New Y....... contribution to its owa ...1tanI1IIe. n- wbo p_ ... ........ .lJ I ,,"... eutseontrulda,__taa_ - w.IlantIe...i11 . o.e_-a_ b," 'lIIon_aboDt50DOWreotau- the park. _ntial oitJ ~ 10 adturaI.etivlliee. ... --' u..Ia e... .. _ dloInrubera, ...... 15 The eontrut 10 faIIe. What __ wbeo,oo eat tile eIt.J'a. ~...... ...................1IwiIIt Ia them? How eootribulioDlo.m_m....li1nrJor.baIIet'II.lbejob... _......... Ifu...... _10 eat, If tile Phi1har- librarian.... va1uaWo tban "...0. .... job? Ia an -... .... 1M te..... _ ..1lII_ .. tour. If lhere ia no w...kmu..umgaard...ttarolfl.........._wOO....jobln heIal?... Ya_to........ ......taa.Olllere. Ita priv.te industr)'? Ia . jobIeae _0 ... ...... 1- UkeIJ Ie 8lI1tIoraI aettollr 10 tile ...... IIIttartar fuIlioIIllbio. ta1ked- need welfare ..rvlees than .0' ot..... uDOmplo,ed? .-, , I "V . ...t....tIle _ iD. TIIe,.bop here Nor ia lhe job 1_ Hmiled lo"euItuaI" _ere If tile.. 8ret, ....,.................. tile ... 01 ,lie ".tcwe" to tureilldUltr)' iaeripplecl. Youaioo.....__out"'wenln ........._ tbe hotel indUltr)' aDd ill _unata. ........ ... ..... .,.. .... _. . . .........-....a inetIletiaaa aDd ing IIrma; air_ aDd man,. _ -. ., ,__ ..... ..... tto. Tile ., ....... abou&S211 Last .anuaer, llIe New Y'" - .... ".,ed 1Io... .... fa' fu ..... . ...... .... I ~ 1..,. The _ SbeepMeedowiDCeatre1PuL........O'........... --..... - I ...,................. 1I&r),.ddnpto thouaand eame out, ai_ half............. TIle I8IorIir hGI ~ ___. ..Ie.... $1117 .nd bUlIare. .IoDO would have ....... ..Ie...... tInaoe tile .......--~bu"--Io.~tODO- ................. . ..;., _~i ...... - - ,......."".,...1 U"'..........latllec:ity.about Opeoo_-..........OOO ...... ~,: ......'. .......__.... .,.. .._tu-' Or tske the niPt8.800 _ Beyul1 SIDe..... "T..... ..........-Job...... J . ..' TIIoNloaloeta1k of Corinth" .t the MeUopolltaa Open. Tile, ..-...... ....................... I. .......-...tbrinp .late.; 3? ..me fr_ Teuo .IODO. AU in all. tile, ..-& aed.........aedt."M II.............. _aDdjoba. $184,000 in New Y..... _fa. _nrants,...._ _.. s.. Oattllii ...... ~............ puIftIeIaaa. And department ._ Tllet'. __ &lIa tile <it, ~ te ,," . . .- .................. us ... Uatenere. keeping the _ra .....g f... . w.....~. ra, ..pt.. .... .... U. New Yenere ...... jalIe .... .t PerhapstbebeetllluotrationoltllebnpooctoltheenllllraJiII- .*l!Il.1'nIa\ Mw. Yenere..............-Idled bJ the duatr)' on New Y'" CII", ~ heeM Ia-.....C4IIlIr '. 1# IV" I , .. .......... _.tllo. ill "'" world-. -. ..ltur.1 ..nter. The area........ LI..&a c.rw.... '11 '~-:r. . _..-eltJ. chaapd from. deeeJi8l........IaoolI.... I ... _ ....J-....... ........... JnItnral La.t year that area prod...... _ NO IIiIIIoa ta -.I..... .=:_... ..... aIIIoet ..., ..... Mrviee ia ts...-maa'_w...tb-.lle.......aed......--. . ~\. ..~ .. ~._;.. _ ~.ll7lt Is "OJ be produ.... tm\a, wWIODt ...... c:-Mr. ... ................ _II. . -. . I _-{..... : '; 4..Ii:.~. ~...-, ~ ". Reprmted by permIssion of New York News. Ine Copyright 1976