HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-1541
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
RESOLUTION NO. 2018-154
RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN
BERNARDINO, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING THE ANNUAL CPI INCREASE TO THE
MAXIMUM PERMITTED SERVICE RATE SCHEDULE FOR SOLID WASTE AND
RELATED SERVICES
WHEREAS, Proposition 218 was adopted on November 6, 1996, adding Article XIIID,
Section 6 to the California Constitution; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Council approved a ten (10) year exclusive franchise
agreement ("Agreement") with Burrtec Waste Industries, Inc. ("Burrtec") on January 19, 2016 by
Resolution No. 2016-10; and
WHEREAS, under the Agreement, Burrtec had been providing the Services at the rates
set by the Mayor and City Council in 2008; and
WHEREAS, the costs associated with the Services had increased dramatically over the
last nine (9) years and exceeds the revenue collected by fees and charges; and
WHEREAS, under the Agreement, the Mayor and City Council set the Maximum
Permitted Service Rates for the Services; and
WHEREAS, on March 21, 2018, the Mayor and City Council declared the result of the
Proposition 218 Protest Hearing and Approved a 5 -Year Maximum Permitted Rate Schedule for
Integrated Solid Waste Collection, Processing, Disposal, and Related Services; and,
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Council finds it necessary that rates be sufficient to
cover the costs incurred by Burrtec in providing the Services to protect the health, safety, and
welfare of the residents and businesses of the City of San Bernardino; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Council also finds it necessary, to protect the residents
and businesses of the City of San Bernardino from unreasonable rates, to ensure that the
Maximum Permitted Service Rates do not exceed the limits imposed by the California
Constitution and state law; and
WHEREAS, the intention of this Resolution is to increase, for the period of July 1, 2018
through June 30, 2019, the Maximum Permitted Services Rates by the lesser of either the
Consumer Price Index, as required by Section 1.19 of the Agreement, or five percent (5%),
whichever is lower; and
1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. Incorporation. The foregoing recitals set forth above are true and correct
and are a substantive part of this Resolution.
SECTION 2. Findings. The Mayor and City Council finds and determines as follows:
(A) Revenues derived from the proposed adjustments to the Maximum Permitted
Service Rates do not exceed the funds required to provide the Services. (Cal.
Const., art. XIIID, § 6(b)(1)).
(B) Revenues derived from the proposed adjustments to the Maximum Permitted
Service Rates are not used for any other purpose other than to provide the
Services. (Cal. Const., art. XIIID, § 6(b)(2)).
(C) The amount of the proposed adjustments to the Maximum Permitted Service
Rates imposed upon any parcel or person does not exceed the proportional
cost of providing the Services to that parcel. (Cal. Const., art. XIIID, §
6(b)(3)).
(D) The Services are actually used by, or immediately available to, the owner of
the parcels subject to the proposed adjustments to the Maximum Permitted
Service Rates. (Cal. Const., art. XIIID, § 6(b)(4)).
(E) The proposed adjustments to the Maximum Permitted Service Rates are not
imposed for general governmental services such as police, fire, ambulance, or
libraries, where the service is available to the public in substantially the same
manner as it is to property owners. (Cal. Const., art. XIIID, § 6(b)(5)).
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(F) The Mayor and City Council conducted a duly noticed public hearing on
March 21, 2018, at which time the public had the opportunity to provide
testimony regarding the proposed increases and the Mayor and City Council
considered the testimony prior to adopting the proposed adjustments to the
Maximum Permitted Service Rates which includes this CPI Increase.
SECTION 3. California Environmental Quality Act. The adoption of this Resolution
is exempt from the Requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA")
pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21090(b)(8) and Section 15273 of the State CEQA
Guidelines codified at 14 CCR Section 15273 because the Resolution pertains to the adoption of
rates necessary to maintain services within the City's existing service area.
SECTION 4. Approval of the Annual Adjustment to Maximum Permitted Service
Rates. The Mayor and City Council do hereby approve and adopt the proposed adjustments to
the Maximum Permitted Service Rates as described in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and
incorporated herein as though set forth in full.
SECTION 5. Effective Dates. This Resolution shall be in full force and effect upon its
adoption. The annual adjustment increasing the Maximum Permitted Service Rates as reflected
in the attached schedule Exhibit "A," incorporated herein by this reference as though set forth in
full, shall be effective July 1, 2018.
SECTION 6. Bost Fee. The Host Fee required to be paid by Burrtec Waste Industries,
Inc. pursuant to Section 3.4.4 of the Agreement shall also increase as reflected in the attached
schedule Exhibit `B," incorporated herein by this reference as though set forth in full, shall be
effective July 1, 2018.
3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN
BERNARDINO, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING THE ANNUAL CPI INCREASE TO THE
MAXIMUM PERMITTED SERVICE RATE SCHEDULE FOR SOLID WASTE AND
RELATED SERVICES
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing Resolution was duly adopted by the Mayor and
City Council of the City of San Bernardino at a Joint Regular Meeting thereof, held on the 200'
day of June 2018, by the following vote, to wit:
Council Members:
AYES
MARQUEZ
BARRIOS
VALDIVIA
SHORETT
NICKEL
!�
RICHARD
X
MULVIHILL x
NAYS ABSTAIN ABSENT
I --�" /2� -x4t-a-
Georgeann Wanna, CMC, Citv Clerk
The foregoing Resolution is hereby approved this 201h day of June 2018.
R. Carey Davi Mayor
City of San B mardino
Approved as to form:
Gary D. Saenz, City Attorney
By:
4
:
x��xx
ae;eaeae�e�e
�ea�a�aeae�
��xxae�
ae�eaeae
o
�-
y
N N
m M
M
M
fl1 co
m N
U1
n
M
W
Ill lD
W W
rl
N
.'I
N N
N N
O V
N N
M
Ot
N O
a m
M
N
m to
m
O
n
m m
h
1l1 t0
N
l0
� f91
T l/1
ll1
T lIl
T
fn 111
Ol l/1
m
f(1
V
v v
�1
Y
C
d
LL
c
_
cl
i
c w
6 �
u v
m
mo+oln.-I
I/1
'nO1
W
mlo.-lul
M
N N
to tO
N
O
W
Q
lnammm
V1 01
1/l to
M
W mlo
M TI:t
W
O
a+
M
W
oLANo•+
O
3`
tC O
N
ti to
00
r� fV
C O
pp
lG
m 1l1
r, rl
01
O, m
w
n
.ti u1
OG
N
N
O 01
w C
W r%
G V
N N
N
N Of
N
N N
N N
O
(D co
Wm
l0
W
N M
m
O
W f�
m
N
f+
N M
O
V1 l0
N
N M
I!1
f�
N
N m
1l1
W
N N
M
N G
O
N
m m
1, 01
N
C
rl
rl
W
N
N
n
i/1
h h
h
h 4/�
h Vf
to
1/f
to
h h
N to
h
h h
h
V} iM1
Vf
NNNN
Vk
a/�
,h^�
,h�
C
000 W
W
000
000 000
000
000
a00, a00.
W
NW
000
000
000.
N fV
!V
N N
N
N N
N N
N
N
N N
N N
eV
N N
fV
N N
N
N
N N
fV N
N
Ol
N
u
e
a
u
r
u1
3' iQ
N W
rl Ol
I/1
M
to co
N 1/1
Y1
V
N co
N Ol
Ill to
M N
co
l/l
N
W
m O
M N
N
N R
l`
N
M M
N (O
N
O
Gl N
rI M
O
lIl
V1
O
tD Of
lI1 N
W 01
ON Y1
W
to
r n
Ill
('/1
n
Lm 00
O.
M
V
lG N
N M
C
1, 01
N
M V
ll1
C7f
Oi N
I� Co
e'I
^1
N M
a
Ill l0
N
N m
Q Ln
O1
tb
N
H
M Ifl
N m
W 11
C I!1
W
W
M V1
N N
W
M
O N
Ill l0
W
O
01
r1
1� O
M m
a N
n cn
O1
O
W
p.j
N
O
N
n
hhh
hhh
hh
h
hhh
hhh
hhh
hh
h
Nh
h
h
hili
h h
h
In
VI Ol
O
N O1
IA
N Ol
O N
Ch
df O
Of N
mLq
O1
Vl 1p
ei
W a
m
M
N O
ei I�
M
v
NN
01
N 1p
n
N
O NE N
Ol N
O O
to
n
a
N
W I!1
N C
O
co
N
N
V t!1
m
1p
a M
C l
to
N O
w IA
H
N m
N 10
.a'i
N
O
N
Ill
l0
rl
N m
IWfl
m
W
uNi
N N
n
M
amD O
7 l0
Ln
V
m Vl
INlmo
m
N Mlip
P W
O
H
rl
o
�-1
N
hhhhh
h
hMf
hhh
hhh
hhh
NNNN
hh
NNNNNN
ry
N M
V
LL'9 (O
N M
In
W
to
N
C
C
0)
7
u
N
N N
N N
N
M
M M
M M
M
'7 O
V
V V
v
(Y
(o w
(O O
w
Q
M lO
n
W m
O
'+ NHt�
i,WW
.moi N
N N
N
N N
N
N N
N
N
01 O
N m
." i N
M M
MN
M
ae
�e
gggg
;p
777777
y
O
0 0
0 0
O
0
O O
0 0
0 0
O O
0 0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
0
N
N 4n
N N
4n
M N
N 4!1
Y1
4n
N N
Vl 4A
Ori
C
x 2E
� N
V
L n
4n H
H %D
N
m H
m Q
4n H
m
H m
Q 4n
H
3 p
14 4D
CII fV
r/
N 00
M N
0
rl O
Q
41100
H m
4h
N N
N .-1
0
C
�D o0
N m
o m
N 40
4D o
H m
4n m
Q 4n
d m
n m
4D
H
O N
m Q
m d
4n n
m
m
d�
m
4
N`
n
Y4
4A N
V/ V!
V!
to to
N 4-1-1
-
V}
in V-VS{AN
x
x
x
7 7
7 7
x 7
7
7 7
7 x
7
b
C DO
00 ap
00000000
a0 00
00
QO aD
00 00
a0 a0
0
W
0 0
DD DO
0 0
W 00
0
W
N
p
N N
N N
4V
N (V
eV N
N N
N
N N
1V fV
fV
0
y
G
u
C
a
u
L
Q H
m O
n Q
m
4q
b lD
m 4D
m M
4q O
N n
n N
4D
(n
w m
4D OD
m N
W n
n
N
y n
Y m
n co
V1 n
m m
m H
m
N
w O
m m
R n
M m
N w
H
N m
C
m In
n N
m
4D
RR
N m
d l0
00
'i m
Q 1!1
n m
rl
m a
N n
m
00
0
n
�/+
NN
VS hh
V?H
Vf NNN
N{nN
Vl v1
Vf
m
R
d H
H O
411 M
H Y1
m
d
N
N
Q Q
n O
N n
m a0
N
4n
Q
� n
Q N
O m
n
W
MO
00
1!f N
H
n m
H d
m N
n
M H
d N
lV
.+
N w
ry m
0
4D
0
10
4n m
H ry
m 4D
d N
O d
n m
N
H
m m
ry d
40 O
d
N
N N
Vf VY
V}
VF 1A
i/F N
V/ N
V}
to to
Tj
y
N M
Q 4n
40
N
m R
4n 10
N M
Q 4[)
O
R
C
C
u
V
N
N N
N N
N
m M
m m
M C7
Q
Q Q
d Q
Q
ID
004
4�l
mmmmm
vvvvcv
�e�eaeaeae
d v
m m
c
LL
cl
x° 22
N
u
r
3 4 +nmoo
p
y
R
N
N
N
.-�Nmm
tD �D
nm ni
Q ry
cA 1-
O O
�0 1D
m �+i
o ry
Mvi
lD m
o 0
�e�e�x�
m.a
N
Q
m
.+mN�n
V
N
Q
a a
�o co
o o
N .-1
�Dn
Q a
a v
�n m
in
D1 1
o 0
�e��exx
o+0000
a0
e
n
mo
N
N
O O
vi vi
m m
Q,
.-I m
m m
O O
ui ui
n
n
m .ti
aa vt
x�x�x
00000
0
vi
in
oo
m
m
0 0
vi ui
n Q
nmmm
ao R
Q to
0 0
ui vi
o0 o
0o of
xaeae�e�e
00000
O
ui
1D
o�onQrn
Q
O O
ui vi
Ln w
'D H
p N
O O
vi vi
oo Q
C to
Q oo
o o
O O
o
O
o o
O O
o o
O O
O
G
C
W W
o0 c0
oD
o0 00
00 W
W
C
00 W
O O
W W
O
00
O
00 00
O O
DO DD
O
OD
O
DD 00
O
DD a0
•+i
N fV
N N
N
N IV
fV fV
fV
fV N
N N
N
N N
N N
N
N N
N N
d
C
a
u
r
oo
inW
o
U1
oo.nw
n M
O Q
m
O\
mmoo
N m
Q N
v+wo+nm
O
Vf N
N n
m
a0
�o T
m
Ln
a%
N
n m
M of
m
10 N
to O
N
m n
N v
O
O N
o1 N
o'
Q N1
of
.ti
o0 e -I
N Q
N n
Ln lD
M
r
n
N
H V!
in N
to
aA an
N of
N
V1 an
N v'
of
of N
of {/�
N
of of
v1 an
V
V
InlD
0 0
r- LID .
0 W
Q
Q
N 10
0 0
n to
0 oo
w
'ARO
m rl
M
to
ui
oo
Q
N w
ai ui
.-r tD
Q oo
N
n
O o0
0 1D
Q m
n tV
fV n
O m
N Vj
N co
0
N n
0 m
fV Ln
m w
tD
N
o N
N N
Q 1!1
N N
n
N
w n
M Q
m co
Vl lD
w
Q
m .
n 0
O Q
H of
M
Q V1
."I
N Q
N w
{4 11
N N
y r
N m
V to
r
N m
Q N
r
N m
Q o
A
K
C
d
t
7
u
N
N N
N N
m
m m
m m
Q
Q Q
Q Q
w
tD O
tD to
w
n
umi
u1pi uni
v00i uO1i
lo
lo
n n
n n
n
n n
n n
- 911*9
o
0 0
0 oo
> .q
IR
0 0
CROoCRC��
O o
��oocqoqcq
0 0
0
N
fV fV
N N
N
N N
N N
N N
V
C
a
y01
G
u
L
a
•3 n
N O
00 ID
m
u
ao
M ID
R
O
n
m ao
.ti .ti
d o
N m
-
m
L
w
N Q•
m m
41 M
o n
N
n
Ol N
In e+
N
vi m
D1 O
o n
w ID
I,
N n
lD 1-
n O
m
'•+
V• i.
m V•
o m
w P
'D
00
a m.
N
cn
w n
o �n
O .•i
f0
00 N
N a0
D 00
m m
N N
N N
of
N Vf
N V!
H
y
N m
V• Y7
ID
C
M1
4
NNNLf
Ln
1A
V!
N Vf
VS aR
1AN
ul
O 00
00 ID
00
m H
T T
N T
m
0 O1
lD
O
I, N
n N
O
O
N O
D1 koti
M N
m 1l1
OVhf
I�
N
a, n
Get N
H
H
O
N
m V'
iD w
C
V
of
of
V1
N
N N
N N
N N
.y
a -I N
N N
rl
w
f, 00
. O
.-I
00
00 00
00 O\
Ol
Ol D1
D1 D1
Ol Ol
�e�ex�e�ae
> .q
0 0
0 0
0
0 N
N N
N N
fV
O)
A
V
C
a
u
L
•3 n
N O
00 ID
m
1,
ao
M ID
R
O
n
m ao
.ti .ti
d o
N m
-
m
pW
N
T
5A
V! Vf
Vf V!
1A
O
O O
00
nb
.-I N
u1 w
1�
p
n
00 N
N a0
D 00
m m
N N
N N
of
N Vf
N V!
H
y
N m
V• Y7
ID
C
Lj
4
Ln
T
N T
N
ID
lD ID
ID w
ID
aeae
0O
�e****
onoo
0
xx
00
**ggx
Om
m
are
moo
ae x
xae
x�ex
aeaeae
ae
�,
o
b0 o
n W
o0 aD
N
N W
n N
N n
n n
00
O m
00 n
oo
o0o
n a0
Mom
f.
W n
aNm
W m
o0 00
o
00 O
O
W
N O
N N
N N
N
N fV
IV 1-414
N
N N
N
N N
N
N N
eV
N N
N N
N N
N O
u
C
u
u
n
m m
m
M ry
fo •+
O
m
m
Lono
fn
oo a
N N
m
m M
m n
.y
m
.+
a ao
fn
M
v
M .+
h
tq
rl to
oo of
n
m v
m .+
ao 00
M y
fn
N b
fn
H C
N eV
W
00 00
n CA
O rl
b 00
N
n n
ID
00 I~
M
m
Ont N
n
M ti
m �"�
C
u
L
U
z
z
h
N
N VT
UT h
V}
to of
N iA
an an
VY us
of
N N
N
N N
to
to IM
N of
v' N
of
N
N W
n ul
N fl1
N N
M M
n
00
n m
OD H
M O
m m
m M
.ti .1
M m
O b
N
N M
N M
C�}} .ti
V M
W Q
u1 0
O e�
M 0
n M
n 0
m
fD
n LO
M o0
n
lO
m
f+1 m
H 00
00
N
n tD
�D In
00 O
m 00
O
10 fl1
Ln
00 C
m
co
M
n
M
40 10
N N
M
M
M
N M
m N
h M
N
[On
N
u
u
O
z
O
z
VT
N V/
VT N
Vt
VT N
h H
VT Vf
VF VT
N
N to
V?
N N
H
N N
N UT
N N
VT
9
g
J
L
T
o
T
o
=
n
E
41
41
o=
o
.N.d
W ry
U
cG'
°
.-
H
C
Q
9 r.
Q.
C
a.
a y N
E
$$ mLL
�
iVme2
�
W
c
�
0
I
0-6
W
d
n
u
CL
o
W N
N
N O
O
W
C LL
N
LL
E
U C
Q
m
m
E
m
o
t m
ami m}
N
c
G
c
.tCO N
C
V
c
m
N
a
m
m m C
' WW
f9 C
m co
c E
:—�.%
m E
d
2
c
nY
F
F
N
a
n
N
n
>0
nnn°
L m
U
oa�i.
w
U
'°
t T !0
C
of
m 0
J
N
U V .-.
W al
N U
0 V
N E
W
E
W
E
W
W
K d
J
m
c
w d y
m y
2.
W c
o c
n c
o
Ti
y
m e
Y
e6 }
Y
Y
Y o
Y .-.
u d>
Y
°6
Y
u
Y Y
u u
T
y
c W
J=
H d' E
° CO
C W
e
.4. W y
W
a
fn
V
fD O. L
iz a
a
N f+f
a
1 a
3 9�
a
H li
o
Y0 r(
if
E E
W
C
N e
C
V
E
O
V wV �i
N
L
iC
Lo
i(
A
A
ar
ol c o
Z' W
o
L 0
n lL
U
W W ...
W d
01 W
F H
00 0
W
0] U O
0
D U�
0)
0-'
W
W
TC
W �.
TC
W
YC
W
r[ Y(
W W
m
O N n
F- J
W W
J.5
V
O
M 1O
O OO
O
N
H N
NM Nb