HomeMy WebLinkAboutGoal Setting Workshop Welcome to a meeting of the Mayor and City Council of the City of San Bernardino.
• The City of San Bernardino recognizes its obligation to provide equal access to those individuals with disabilities.
Please contact the City Clerk's Office(384-5002)two working days prior to the meeting for any requests for
reasonable accommodation to include interpreters.
• All documents for public review are on file with the City Clerk's Office located on the 2nd floor of City Hall, 300
North "D"Street, San Bernardino or may be accessed online by going to hitp:i,it u,r 01<iti c,r .
• Anyone who wishes to speak during public comment or on a particular item will be required to fill out a speaker
slip. Speaker slips should be turned in to staff seated on the north side of the Council Chamber.
• Public comments for items that are not on the agenda will be limited to three minutes.
• All who wish to speak, including Council members and staff, need to be recognized by the Mayor or Mayor Pro
Tempore before speaking.
• Please turn off or mute your cell phone while the meeting is in session.
NOTICE: Any member of the public may address this meeting of the Mayor and Common
Council and the Mayor and Common Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the
Redevelopment Agency on any item appearing on the agenda by approaching the microphone in
when the item about which the member desires to speak is called and by asking to be recognized.
Any member of the public desiring to speak to the Mayor and Common Council and the Mayor
and Common Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency
concerning any matter not on the agenda but which is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the
Mayor and Common Council and the Mayor and Common Council Acting as the Successor
Agency to the Redevelopment Agency, may address the body at the end of the meeting, during
the period reserved for public comments. Said total period for public comments shall not
exceed sixty (60) minutes, unless such time limit is extended by the Mayor and Common
Council and the Mayor and Common Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the
Redevelopment Agency. A three minute limitation shall apply to each member of the public,
unless such time limit is extended by the Mayor and Common Council and the Mayor and
Common Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency.
The Mayor and Common Council and the Mayor and Common Council Acting as the Successor
Agency to the Redevelopment Agency may refer any item raised by the public to staff, or to any
commission, board, bureau, or committee for appropriate action or have the item placed on the
next agenda of the Mayor and Common Council and the Mayor and Common Council Acting as
the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency. However, no other action shall be taken
nor discussion held by the Mayor and Common Council and the Mayor and Common Council
Acting as the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency on any item which does not
appear on the agenda unless the action is otherwise authorized in accordance with the provisions
of subdivision(b) of Section 54954.2 of the Government Code.
Public comments will not be received on any item on the agenda when a public hearing has been
conducted and closed.
���RNARD�ti
O
�� vt
O
D
OFFICE OF THE MAYOR
R. CAREY DAVIS
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA FY2014-2015
STATUS REPORTS
Table of Contents
Mission........................................................................................................................................................3
Values..........................................................................................................................................................3
Description..................................................................................................................................................4
Goals,Objectives, &Metrics.....................................................................................................................5
Measures, Data and Targets:....................................................................................................................9
FIRST100 DAY REPORT....................................................................................................................10
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
31
Mission
To provide quality and cost effective services to the people of San Bernardino. We will provide
excellence in leadership through the allocation of public resources to City programs that are
responsive to community priorities and maximize opportunities for economic,educational and
cultural viability.
The stated mission of the Office of the Mayor is to
➢ Restore fiscal sanity within City government;
➢ Increase the economic opportunities within the City,and
➢ Enhance the quality of life within the City
Values
Increase the economic opportunities and quality of life within the City of San Bernardino. To create
the hub of economic growth in the Inland Empire and to provide a wide range of housing,
recreation,cultural, education,and employment opportunities for all who come live and work here.
The key values needed to meet the objectives of the intergovernmental relations business plan
include:
➢ Integrity-Intergovernmental relations is about relationships and built upon a trust earned
through honest,truthful,and open policies and funding information.
➢ Collaboration-Advise and work together with partners to achieve the mission and goals
stated
Results Driven-Assist the City and partners with outcomes to achieve their objectives
and goals
➢ Accountable-Commitment to openness and responsible action to generate integrity
among our residents and governments
➢ Ethical- Ethical decision-making is required and a zero tolerance for untrustworthy
actions
➢ Inclusive-Work for the good of all
➢ Sustainable-The work product of today influences the benefit of the City tomorrow
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
41
Description
The Mayor shall be the Chief Executive Officer,and chief spokesperson, of the City of San
Bernardino. The Mayor shall vigilantly observe the official conduct of all public officers,and take
notice of the fidelity and exactitude,or the want thereof,with which they execute their duties and
obligations, especially in the collection,administration and disbursement of public funds and
property. The Mayor shall have the books and records of all public departments,pertaining to the
finances of the City.
EXecUtly
-4 Ilen r
r r
rrr
r ,
r , r r er
Manager •
r r r •
. r
Chi
Of • r
i r
r
f
i
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
51
Goals, Objectives, & Metrics
' f Resolve the 1. Continue forward 1. Continued
Bankruptcy progress of negotiations progress on
with creditors mediation as
determined by
2. Obtain an Approved Plan Judge Jury.
of Adjustment from Judge 2. TBD
Jury
3. Ongoing-
3. Maintain responsible maintain
spending within the Plan spending within a
of Adjustment balanced Budget.
Maintain a Create and maintain a Delivered a Balanced
Balanced balanced budget submittal for Budget Submittal for
Budget Council review and approval FY2014-2015
each of the four-years in office
Complete 1. Complete FY2011-2012 1. Council Approved
Audits Audit FY2011-2012
Audit
2. Complete by Fall
2. Complete FY2012-2013 2014
Audit
3. Complete by 1,t
3. Complete FY2013-2014 Qtr. 2015
Review our 1. Establish a Resident- 1. COMPLETED
City's based Charter Reform
Governing Committee 2. Final Public
Document Hearing August 7,
2. Provide initial 2014
recommendations for the
November 2014 Ballot
Establish City Establish a Reserve Fund Fund Established
Reserves Account for FY2015-2016 with positive balance
Budget for FY 2015-2016
Budget Cycle(Plan of
Adjustment
dependent)
Increase Increase the number of jobs Increase employment
employment within San Bernardino growth in San
opportunities Bernardino 6%for
FY2015
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
6 �
Increase City 1. Bring businesses to San 1. Increase Growth
Revenues Bernardino Metropolitan
through Product Growth
economic 2. Streamline Community to by 3.6%by 4th
growth (sales Development Process Quarter 2015
tax and within the City (Plan of
property tax) Adjustment
3. Create an Economic Dependent)
Development Strategy
2. Implement Staff
4. Stabilize property tax- recommendations
base by December
2014.
3. Recruit and Hire
Economic
Development
Czar by December
2014; Develop
and begin
implementation
of Economic
Development
Strategy by March
2015
4. See Improve
Housing Stock
Maintain City Create and Enact a workable Develop and
Revenues Business Retention Program implement strategy
by March 2015
Complete the Successfully negotiate forward 1. Establish
RDA-Wind progress with the Department negotiations
Down of Finance through a with DOF-
collaborative-based process COMPLETED
2. Establish
progress
through
negotiations to
allow for
Properties to
enter the ROPS
process- March
2015
3. Solve the Arden-
Guthrie, Regal,
and California
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAWS
71 Pit,� e
Theater Issues-
March 2015
Increase our Maintain leadership positions Show growth in
Regional within SBIA/IVDA,SanBAG, permitted activities
Leadership Omnitrans and other Regional at SBIA by end-of-
boards to benefit overall year
growth within San
Bernardino.
' Maintain our 1. Successfully negotiate 1. Complete
local Police and labor agreements with Memorandum
Fire San Bernardino City of Understand
Departments Police Officers' by end-of-year
Association 2014
2. Implement policies to 2. Research,
enhance efficiencies review and
within Fire and Police develop
Departments strategic
operations
plan for Police
and Fire
Departments
Increase
overall number
of Police
within San
Bernardino by
2015
Decrease 1. Reduce crime caused by 1. Implement
Crime within poor management of receivership and
our City Multi-family housing rating programs
stock by Fall 2014
2. Implement a anti- 2. Develop and
Marijuana Dispensary implement
enforcement program program by
December 2014.
3. Increase targeted crime
programs 3. Implement Chief
of Police's
recommendation
by 1St Qtr.2015
Increase the 1. Improve the overall 1. Design and
quality of our Management of Rental implement new
City's Housing Housing Stock inspection
Stock policies
2. Stabilize Single-Family
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
81
Housing Values within 2. Maintain
San Bernardino property values
and increase
3. Encourage and enhance overall SFU
Master-Planned and pricing by 4%
Smart Growth and decrease
communities overall SFU-
Rental
percentage prior
to end of 2015
3. Revise and
enhance
Community
Development
Department
Enhance our Stabilize Park Maintenance Measurements to be
Parks and determined with
Recreation Explore revitalization of Parks Director
parkland
Protect Ensure continuation and Plan under
Preserve and enhancement of development-
Enhance our railroad/historical museum measurements to
Historical follow by September
Significance Explore cultural heritage 2014
museum opportunities
Improve City Program capital Program funding by
Services improvements for restricted December 2014.
funding within their intended Capital Projects to
uses (all Wards) begin early 2015
Conserve our Develop and initiate a water-
City's Natural conservation plan.
Resources
Explore renewable energy
development within San
Bernardino
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
91
Measures, Data and Targets:
Measures Office(s) Target Table_
Continued forward progress on ' Mayor,City Manager,Finance,
negotiations with Creditors City Attorney, Human
Resources
Obtain Approved Plan of Mayor,City Manager, Finance,
Adjustment City Attorney
Maintain Responsible Spending ' Mayor,City Manager
within Approved PoA
Create and Maintain a Balanced Mayor, City Manager,All OBJECTIVE MET FY2014-2015
Budget 1 Departments Budget Proposal-June 2014
Complete Audits Mayor,City Manager,City OBJECTIVE MET FY2011-2012
Treasurer, Finance Audit-June 2014
Department,Outside Auditors
FY2012-2013 - Fall 2014
FY2013-2014- December
2014
Establish Resident Charter Mayor OBJECTIVE MET-April 2014
Reform Committee
Provide Initial Mayor To be completed August 7,
Recommendations for the 2014
November 2014 Ballot
Increase the number of jobs in Mayor,City Manager, Measurement 1St Quarter 2015
San Bernardino Community Development
Streamline Community City Manager,Community To be completed December
Development Process Development 2014
Increase the number of Mayor,City Manager, 4.2% G M P growth by 3rd
businesses within the City Community Development Quarter 2015 to meet regional
growth projections
Create an Economic Mayor, City Manager, To be completed December
Development Strategy Community Development 2014
Stabilize Property Tax Base Mayor,City Manager, Measurement mid-year 2015
Community Development
Create and Enact a workable Mayor,City Manager, To be completed December
Business Retention Program Community Development, 2014
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
101
Police Department
Increase our Regional Mayor Measurement mid-year 2015
Leadership
Maintain our Police and Fire Mayor,City Manager, Human Ongoing measurements
Departments Resources, Police Chief, Fire
Chief,
Decrease Crime Mayor,City Manager, Police Crime-Free Multi-Family to be
Department, Community completed by Fall 2014
Development
Marijuana Dispensary
legislation by Fall 2014
Crime measurement monthly
Increase the Quality of our Mayor, City Manager, Police Inspection programs to be
Housing Stock Department,Community completed by Fall 2014
Development, Fire Department
Measurements to be taken
January 2015
Enhance our Parks and Mayor,City Manager, Parks and Ongoing Measurements
Recreation Recreation
Protect and Preserve our Mayor,Community Ongoing Measurements
Historical Significance Development, Parks and
Recreation
Improve our City Services Mayor,All Departments 1St Quarter 2015
Conserve our City's Natural Mayor,Water Department, Water Conservation
Resources Parks and Recreation
Renewable Energy Exploration
FIRST 100 DAY REPORT.
Restore Fiscal Sanity
Working with the City Manager and other department leaders,a balanced Final Hearing
budget for the FY2014-2015 was delivered for the Mayor's and Council's June 30, 2014
approval.The budget included the beginnings of repayments to the City's
creditors ($10.6M for the Fiscal Year). This budget utilized a"zero-based"
budgeting technique for all departments (with exception of Police and Fire),to
review all spending within City Hall.
The bankruptcy proceedings continue and forward progress is being made to Ongoing
allow the City to emerge from the Bankruptcy. A tentative agreement has been
reached with CalPERS and progress with other creditors has been made. L
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
11 �
The FY2011-2012 Audit has been delivered for Mayor's and Council's approval, FY2011-2012
which will have an impact on bankruptcy negotiations;the verification of COMPLETED
restricted funds for use within their intended purpose; the San Bernardino
Employment and Training Agency(SBETA);the wind-down of the FY2012-2013
Redevelopment Agency(RDA); and for better programming of City services. Fall 2014
The FY2012-2013 Audit continues with a deadline of fall, 2014 for Deadline
consideration by the Mayor and Council.
A Charter Reform Committee was established which reviewed the City's Final Public
governing document.As a result of these meetings,charter reform priorities Hearing
were proposed for the November ballot as well as a request for ongoing review Scheduled for
of the Charter to bring about better governance. August 7, 2014
Community Development, Public Works, Parks&Recreation,the City Manager Implementation
and Mayor's Offices have been charged with developing workable business to be effective
plans to increase City services in a cost-effective manner. Each business plan upon passage of
shall contain measurable goals (metrics) and be implemented in FY2014-2015. the FY2014-2015
Once adopted,they will be posted for resident's review with updates toward Budget
meeting stated goals.
Create Economic Opportunities
Development of the City's first Economic Development Strategy since 2005 is Fall 2014
currently underway. A key part of this strategy is the hiring of an"Economic
Development Czar'who will have overall responsibility for implementation
and growing the economy,reporting directly to the City Manager(as an
Assistant City Manager).
Mayor Davis called upon executives of the largest employers and revenue Established and
producers in the City to form the Business Roundtable of San Bernardino.This Ongoing
ongoing advisory group is designed to make key recommendations for
business development and retention,beginning in the downtown core.They
are already providing recommendations concerning the City's gateways
The wind-down of the Redevelopment Agency has made significant progress in j Ongoing
modifying its working relationship with the California Department of Finance.
Negotiated solutions have already netted results, resolving nearly$12M of a
perceived$15M debt obligation of the former RDA(a savings of repayment
obligations).
The City Manager,the Mayor,and Council Member Rikke Van Johnson have September 2014
partnered with the schools (high school and college),the faith-based
community,SBETA and the local businesses to find and create jobs within the
City.Originally focused on youth summer jobs,this initiative has been
expanded to serve as a job referral service for residents within the City
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
12 1 P ,t
In the first 100 days,the Administration has met with several businesses Ongoing
interested in locating in San Bernardino. The companies that see the
advantages of doing business in the City are from industries such as green
energy development, renewable electricity producers,aircraft maintenance, RV
production and light industrial manufacturers-representing nearly 2,000 jobs.
In the first 100 days,the City has also met with nearly 20 land-use developers
and two major financial institutions who are interested in bringing their
projects to San Bernardino.
In particular,we have welcomed new and expanded businesses to San COMPLETED
Bernardino such as the Innovage Facility(healthcare) and SunOpta (light
manufacturing),which together will eventually create nearly 600 jobs.
Improve QualiLE of Life:
The housing stock needs improvement. To that end,the Administration has Established and
implemented the following with the goal of stabilizing/improving the City's Ongoing
housing stock:
• We have formed the Housing Advisory Group (consisting of trade
associations,major housing developers,and multi-family housing
managers) to review the City's ordinances,inspection requirements,
and current processes in order to develop metric-based best practices
that will improve the housing stock.
• The Community Development Department is currently under internal
review(through new Director Mark Persico) to streamline practices
and work with the Business Roundtable/Housing Advisory Group to
meet mutual goals.
The City Attorney's office is working on a new program that will force
bad actors through the justice system,to meet best industry
management practices and maintain properties
The City welcomed a new Police Chief and an Interim Fire Chief. Police Chief Completed
Jarrod Burguan has developed new and innovative solutions for consideration
concerning police service and reorganization of the Department that will result
in more sworn officers on the streets. Interim Fire Chief Paul Drasil has
returned to the City and employed his deep commitment to finding workable
solutions that maintain the Fire Department's continued excellent service
Police Chief Burguan and the City Attorney's office are working on a new To Legislative
strategy to deal with illegal marijuana dispensaries in the City.Their efforts Review
will be released shortly for the Council's consideration Committee
July 2014
The Administration has partnered with Mayor Pro Tem Virginia Marquez,to Policy Legislation
LEGISLATIVE AGENDA OFFICE OF MAYOR R. CAREY DAVIS
131
bring the east-valley's first comprehensive homelessness intervention action Passed
plan to San Bernardino.This plan re-focuses on the efforts toward prevention,
service access,permanent housing,and service provision based upon the Implementation
community's needs to reduce the overall number of unsheltered on the streets Phases
thereby reducing panhandling and vagrancy crimes (key to economic
retention/development).
This plan utilizes existing federal and state funding sources outside of the
General Fund. The program will have measurable goals announced within the
next 120 days and require a report to the Mayor and Council within its first
year
The Administration has requested development of a city-wide communications To be completed
plan to bring transparency to the government and allow residents to easily Fall 2014
understand what is going on inside City Hall.
In the first 60 days,the Administration called upon faith-based organizations to Ongoing
assist the police department to stem the gang-violence within the City. Many
organizations answered this charge,working to engage the community directly
The Fine Arts Commission has been restored under the leadership of City Clerk Established and
Gigi Hanna. Her goal is to increase the awareness and enjoyment of various arts Ongoing
within the City.
As a side project,the Mayor's office (through the Chief of Staff) has launched Ongoing
efforts to protect and preserve the City's rich history.Working with the
Historical Society,the University and outside agencies,an effort is being made
to protect historical documents and preserving historical cemeteries
A SUGGESTED VISIONING PROCESS
Allen J. Parker
City Manager
7/18/2014
Introduction
While the City of San Bernardino is a legally defined physical area, politically
divided into seven Districts; it is also a collection of diverse communities and
neighborhoods in constant change. As a result, it is difficult to get one's hands
around the concept of a vision for the City.
For example, the Downtown once served as the Central Business District (CBD)
for the City. Today, it is a governmental and judicial center with hardly any retail
offerings. Residents have changed their shopping patterns over the years as
neighborhood and strip commercials centers have replaced the CBD. Newer
regional centers —Victoria Gardens, Citrus Plaza — have also replaced the CBD
as the source for major department stores.
Therefore, any visioning process should take into account the City's diverse
communities and neighborhoods. In so doing, we should work toward the modern
concept of"urban villages: activity centers that provide pleasant living, shopping
and working environments; strong pedestrian accessibility; adequate, well
located open spaces; an alternative, well connected street system; and a balance
or retail, office, residential and public spaces."
Acceptable, practical, economic development should underscore the process as
well as providing adequately funded, essential municipal services.
Step One: Providing Municipal Services
As many of you might recall, I benchmarked the City against the City of Moreno
Valley — similar populations, diversity, square miles, etc. Our General Fund
Budget is approximately $124M; theirs is $80M. Some of the difference is
because they contract for police and fire, but not all. More recently, I performed
the following comparison.
San Bernardino is made up of seven districts of approximately 30,000 people. If
each district were viewed as a separate city with its own city manager, police
chief, public works director, parks & recreation director, etc., one would assume
our average costs per district would be less than the average of the seven cities I
selected at random if for no other reason than economies of scale; i.e., one city
manager vs. seven, one police chief vs. seven. However, that is not the case.
1
The average annual General Fund Budget of the seven cities is $13.54M. The
average of the seven districts of San Bernardino is $17.7M, a difference of
approximately $4M.
In 2009, Rutgers School of Public Affairs published a "Literature Review and
Analysis Related to Optimal Municipal Size and Efficiency". The executive
summary concluded:
"The most important point is the differentiation by the type of service. The
literature even suggests that the details of tasks within a service type are critical.
For example, small communities deliver police services more efficiently for
routine patrol tasks, but large municipalities perform better in traffic light
maintenance and special investigations. Over 80 percent of municipal services
are of a routine and labor-intensive nature. Allocative efficiencies
(management of resources) are more important than scale efficiencies in
these routine service situations."
Again, "Larger municipalities will deliver specialized and capital-intensive
services more efficiently. Smaller municipalities deliver labor-intensive
services more efficiently."
Accordingly, I would suggest that those services routinely provided directly to the
citizenry be done so on a decentralized basis, and that each district be provided
a budget allocation to pay for those services, i.e., policing, parks and recreation,
code enforcement, building inspection, landscape and hardscape maintenance,
street repair, etc. Stakeholders of each district — residents, businesses, churches,
non-profits —would participate in a process to recommend how best to spend
that district's allocation.
I would also suggest that a process be created to allow for each district's
stakeholders to determine priorities and their funding from the district's allocation.
In addition, funds would be allocated for services that need to be centralized —
Mayor & Council, City Attorney and Clerk, City Manager, Finance, Human
Resources, Civil Service, etc. — or provided on a regional, city-wide basis such as
fire.
The above-described decentralization process should result in the following:
• Based on the attached 7-city comparison, meaningful General Fund savings.
• Be part of the Plan of Adjustment to help bring the City out of bankruptcy.
• Give us the ability to deconstruct our service delivery and find better and
more cost effective ways to deliver services...reengineer.
• Create a process in which neighborhood associations and district residents
and businesses can become involved in the budget deliberations and
allocation of resources.
• Help us understand what matters to our customers - citizens and businesses -
and what they will want five years from now.
2
Step Two: Develop a Plan
Direct the City Manager to work with staff and develop a plan to decentralize the
providing of services into the seven districts and to return to the Common Council
within 90 days with the recommended plan.
DISTRICT/CITIES COMPARISON
ANNUAL MEDIAN BELOW
CITY POPULATION GF BUDGET HSE INCOME POV%
Bell 35,280 $13.5M $36,654 29%
Adelanto 31,239 $12.9M $41,113 32%
Banning 30,310 $13AM $38,919 19%
Santa Paula 29,963 $11.6M $54,168 17%
Ridgecrest 28,235 $12.8M $60,885 12%
Norco 27,393 $15.1 M $82,075 10%
Imperial Beach 26,845 $15.5M $46,975 19%
7-City Average 29,985 $13.54M
San Bernardino 213,295 $123.8M $39,097 31%
District Average 30,471 $177M
3
Revenue Revenues
Enhancements
Real Property Transfer $3.2 Million
Tax 50%+ 1 Voter Approval
Reduce UUT%(7.75 to $4.5 Million
7.5) and/or broaden the 50%+ 1 Voter Approval
base and charge UUT on
refuse, sewer, water
of a percent increase $7 Million
in sales tax 50%+ 1 Voter Approval
Increase Transient $400,000
Lodging Tax Rate 50%+ 1 Voter Approval
Establish Warehouse $300,000
tax 50%+ 1 Voter Approval
Establish Quarry Tax $200,000
50%+ 1 Voter Approval
Establish 911 Fee $4 Million
50%+ 1 Voter Approval
A fee charged to all cellular and land line phones to
recover costs associated with 911 operation
Library Parcel Tax $2 Million
2/3 Voter Approval
Parks Parcel Tax $5 Million
2/3 Voter Approval
Establish Citywide $6-7 Million
Assessment District 50%+ 1 Voter Approval
Would pay for street lighting, street sweeping,
graffiti removal, tree trimming
Increase Business Fire $300,000
Inspection Fee Update Master Fee Resolution
Entered Into Rec. at MCC/CDC Mtg; 7 g
by;
Agenda Ite N
by. �,
City lervCpC Secretary
City of San Bernardino