Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout07.G- Finance DOC ID: 2072 CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO—REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION Report/Information From: Jason Simpson M/CC Meeting Date: 10/15/2012 Prepared by: Jason Simpson, Dept: Finance Ward(s): All Subject: Presentation on Financial Management. Financial Impact: None. Motion: Receive and File Presentation regarding Financial Management from the City Manager and Finance Department. A Presentation will be provided regarding Financial Management from the City Manager and Finance Department. Supporting Documents: Financial Management San Bernardino (PDF) i J Updated: 10/11/2012 by Linda Sutherland Packet Pg. 52 T ' r 'J. hrf � buo O U N O O N m u N vi ro Lf1 m v _ � G O C: L v u O 4O a 7 i O D • � O V ro C6 LL N N 4 O LL ro U O H x,11 `�I U c- C6 °n N • - -� y- w � ro n J U cn N O o •-, 0 > °; V) • - �° - o U E v ``• O O u _ N •� U i N N n 4 vii S-- co uGJ :3 n =3 ° N (� o ca U Q O N �A E m v +� O O N .- (D U cn L7 Ln ca � : � AA ❖ . . a ~ 0 \ ® > » d / � / W / k / U') :3 � 2 V) k \ / \ / # = n = a u m / / / / e Ln .g n 7 \ \ / \ o � j k ° .\ 0 2 \ LL \ ./ \ o § \ = e_ 0$ 2 � / / \ k U c / — \ D m _ \ n 0 / . ° 0 L / \ \ % 3 % _ > u E \ o / " ) 2 / 2 = 0 I % > k \ o \ u § \ { m \ � \ 2 2 / \ / / \ > ƒ ° m Q y — 'e x m S \ ± % 5 3 .0 & 2 0 CL E o@ f . ° Jc LE x $ ._ e . . $ ® 2 G .A @ Q q $ / E \ U D q 2 Q) 2 6 0 / $ . U £ m U U w Q N > p p O O L — Q +' _ + (0 a) a L — O 0 > O > 6 co O w p aJ O L co X a a O +� � —C �, O O C L N -a 3 -r- 3 v (6 O �- a, -0 u Y in L1 _ O L a) L L 5 >. CL m v) E+' to N a1 f 6 t 0 " O_ `Ln aj H 0 � O O C co v Q O o a) Ln ° o o • U -a a t fo " U a1 0- 4� O ' a1 O (o +- o ti 4- + O i LO O _ " >- O LA > .^ O 4 + C N O > :3 (^o a) > Ov ti -4E L7 4- C O O U O v > m N Q c6 > u O i 4- -c U O m m a� v o ON E Q _ dJ > N L jE F V Q aJl a aU O 00 o -C C _0 a-+ U o 4-j m > Q v LL L _0 W Q N O N C: m N > N N N N U Q o v a) v N N N U + + O Q N m m M N C O O C O Q L. o O v V) CL 2 n N Q a� v 0 o = rn M m N � > > U OZS N ) 4' = tin O U fII 4 � CL L O Q1 � .E Q Q m te a + M U L U L I ._ E o D 4J 0 ^ t iJ � m ,N C6 N N t >, E `,2 v >, N o 0 — M Q- x Ln a) u N E u 4- N '— cB O N - � LL� i J CL O v O 0 • J O U d V a1 E U N N X s c U u X Ln L ^ , Ln Q LL >, ' O 4—J L U c v U 76 f 4— U_ 9 L c m O Q _ o 4-J O 06 � m 3 � w O • • O • a _ o w ` m (`IL/1 ` o ru V/ N m W O. O O V V C N C LL T V m � C m v ti V O Vf Q) x 4- 0 L v c� o_ X c C6 � . . U ^ 1 U N W 4- Ln o c LL. 4--J O E v L 4 b.0 0 v V) N u- 4� ao W Q > bD 4- U > 4J nA J a v o u N U _ `^ Q � L O U o c 4--J 4--J `L° w 4- S m O J a- O U cu > `> > U x F O Z L Q N Q) W O � O O tl) L Q1 10 -0 Y U } O LL U > L m U O J C6 O =3 J 111 Q c0 00 M � m v o, O o rn Of rn am o O ° c-i r-I -I N N Q C� O x u C6 •7 }' N •� �O ,V, ( a� x c N c� :3 LL ro u . o co U C6 Q V) O V) -1- i N v .N 4J � C- :3 p 0 06 � N o Q O O i v) p x x v N N N v 4-J 4-J c o a, � v � t Oo x ° v (1, (Z " 4 v +� O o a = i u V M +-j X _ ro 3 i 3F 7 f6 a O s � C O. � 3 � O � N W N o CL N d LL O ~ ~ L v O O H C LL ./ _y 06 N y C Ln N ^ f0 0 y F- N G1 C n ^, O W Q L ii z yi • • cu • _CL • • • • • LL :. J /� • • • C CU A • • r aj • • s cu m Q cu •CL c < CL U 4-, LL N l/'I �_ aJ O LL LL 0 > U 4- O — O N ra E ro U 1 a"' Q O O O + ' O > O O u "O � n O ' o - O j � +' L _ >• N o L U O v a) N O N — .— W QJ N }' O N t/) � O LL U = C J +J aJ N > aJ aJ vOi N O U O O > LL m Co Q vvi t1A aJ N LJ x ra a aJ a1 N > E N v N v vU N N > ru v o 3 a� v S� nA LL Q J LL d' LL 1-.' b A ate+ _ buo O Q V LL 4-J u- .� U .t V O s V a a c E m O ' — v a w co N E \ N U >, o Eto cn Q _ ro m w a--+ v \ cn V) \ 0 777 77 :! a) = i _ 2 \ L- L'- iJ � C) Q 4-- — p i �n _ O C- cn U Q Z V > > > 1 bLO c c ai m 06 u a • 1 1 � 1 • • • 1 a u x r x d J �+ H u F O p H m w ii io m 7 IA Q Q � U J Q 4-J 0 c a-J 4-J ro U V ' — N L.L ca Ln t E n 4 d1 O O =3 qA Lr Q U v V) � O O U o c Q N O O m Q O _0 Q f6 Q >. �' y Q 4- i > m 3 U O Q � Q j 0 :3 Q v 4� (L) o- > _ x V) x ° +' 4 LL 06 > o o }' r-4 > >. L +- M m L U 4--J v N Q. 0 Q O D � 0 0 Q Q �, •� CL d 4- Q cv 3 to ro I Q Y U O a, ° .2 L — U L L 4--J x 4- (/1 v 4J GJ cr- Q 4-M 0 X 4-0 E M 0 vii v) vii • 4-00 O cu N w •u +O+ S +O+ C rB y > N Q +M.+ O +�+ O > Q Q of LA Q v� e-I N M 44 LA t,D $ ) 7 c 0 / 7 § \ 0 \ 00 CC kcu< � < ® » ] @G e ` ` ƒ u ; / / / � ƒ � { � \ \ { $ / .0 � \ r : a E § 2 # ® ) \ \ / f E § . / ± \ / / / 3 f k E 0 ? - E ° E ` E ® f 0 » ) } CL � % ; & e ® & & - _ c e t _ < !_ % 5 / E % :3c >V7 « = 7 % < � a � > 2I = 22J ° w = e ® > gq i . , ° ± e _ ` k \ % \ , . . . . ) w 0 � > > U \ 3 0 t a } o . / CL w & , , , & ! ® / 7 xz « \ a );tk c ! � W) e $ ; ! 0- U. 3a \ � � § § a ( 2 \§ _ .B � 0 . : a A ■ - j« \ 2 rf } . �%\ � LL 0 ; % � , ;� 1 � � � � ! ) \ � ; ° ° � � { � / \) / • %° « ° (' _ � \ \""Cc _ ! - _ ® » � ! \ ■ ! (2 $ e ! co � 7 - -i LL ? . : - \ �� (t \ \ � ■ [ \ a co _ « \ ( § a) ■ CIA CO. ■ ( ( 2 : ak co U Q) O MO LL 06 4� (2) .0 . _ aA Wo C m d U pA 4 -+ m 4 ' O O •7 (1) — ? d J . � Ca 4' — \ LL 'U U N bA 0 m LL CL m m F- t (n C: F- 0 U- U f6 LL n V) +-J U N N W 0- (3.) -0 N to (� i — ro aJ _ (II N a/-�-+� �, ca N m N 4-1 N � O m E V) (u.� :3 V) _ N +� O_ +� -0 M W O U N ° o >- Q (3) m .2 i Jc: x O L Cl ro ca ao c _ N •� —°' .O U N = � O > E S v i O O i p 0- O V O 76 4� 4 f6 � p v 4 (1) ca _0 N N V) U /\ N O +-J N gvjp h!J }' v 'N m �0 +' O - U CO � O +-J } Ca i u N Q) m ii I ±-+ 4 , h 0 v Q u a _0 E I.L. Q m Ou L H 4- m � I -0 O >' 4J m N m C],0 _Q) m 4� v m v p cB 1 — U .2 E N O Q d n mQ � A cL Q N ^ L. 0 1 1Q •' _ L v 0 m �c v 0 Z �Ny • p i 7 0 H V a v 0 CO a u 0 +J o °Q p � _ O W Z W m � ual C3 c c c LU a m co W d' � ru (A cr- J m • LL L It N G ID p } o ,� v N N N .w O (A N o L Ci •- V m W � — :� •- x (1) a o 4-j - V Q o a� O L — Q •— N N4-j m cr r w a) N m Ln 00 CC U — U LL Q O O J ,�_ � Q Q Q :tf U Q 41 p aJ CAA . Q 41 LL J t1A m o N E 4m CO N 11 _ m N _ Q N Q (o bz Q- (3) c� L m a -i U A A A A A E >- L Q� O u c0 > a-+ LO L Ln vii W O E E y v v �_ O o u _ _ an a, � O a � > c� � N � N u \ Q) U Q O cv N u u v v — Q •V a co N ._ E u Q fa O p ao dJ p +- N O O O C Ql N N O cv , N V) N L N �� cB N 'Q F— w = a Qa o A A A 4-J txo ._ M .N c O a c a 0 Q V) N +� v DC >1 o 'o o - Q„ L O •� O L V1 L Ln Q v O " N ,� E CJ Q v Ln I L C L. = O w N m o ra u Ln Q _0 v -0 Q) O = no C ro 4— H u cz ra w v) U t = AAA � \ t M1• V) W Vl /� � T N• W 2 M1• -a r" �--' 1 N v U O 'O C c v N• v 0 LL Ln LA ° ° +, .- v CL in v v " a°n ° o N nA u 0 � v 1 ° o Q1 v Ln •— x i O +n 'Q '� O In �6 o p pip � Q 0° o ,to t/� u L +., a ° w n V O v Q Q c a s no U �- _ > ° ° .- u a v U:tj N i1 L > LL N c v > v v ° N v Y N N Q Q C 4- u D L- [6 'qp O O W u N vi V1 LL C: N N N > > N O N v u i 41 O O aJ h�0 1.. N ° v +, +, '+- .- v N o o, v L Q Q v 4- > v Ln I > > +, 4, ° > ° ° Q > - zt vu > L CL Ln I✓ E A A A A uA, AAAA u° o u U, Q u i y buo CD N J Al T' iL �/ f 2ii 11 00 d o a d v o O CT m o as .- ao 0 �- o m a r� OHO OO d O oo O O O� Oti O\ o O �Y- � O a O Q ° d �� �'1 O G°V O O �•O O �f S 0 a d O O a O � k"- 7 O O 60 «i �� ti 0 000 °° ° 0 P OCC INN m !11011, M mne ae Ji y.NN f o0YnNn m Yn+m Nam mr;o nmm0mn N Imp .MY Om; zoo mtmmmn n Mmtlr nn�mY mvm n.MYen M - ry N m Y. n- 0 N N M-MN N Mt. a NMN- N N O 0 0 0 000 0 ( OR I N8 8g��88�8 Rvo� 88 In �8 OR a 000 s#$88 R s8 as IN n 9Ji0 EIl�r�m v/it0� No,M 1mdN.nm t nN 06 f 6 6n Jim OmNNOOV m m amMmm0,0 PnMmm math N� Ommm W -n 1 mr NI mm mOPmmMa a p. aMa 0 Ym� W ONO M mn .mMA N N .aA a n .aN00N4 N N' nN•.m p nX n. P 0 CI 0 0 m M^Ml,mY n $ 000000000$o00goag $00 a aOOCDp00000 oo ^ 00D0om0000 c0 0000 00 0 0.0 nY 0 00 0 ON 0 0 00 mY W 00 m NN 0 n n PN N: 0 mM N M r N M n r a r v ° 00000 00000 0°000°Ic 00 0000. 00 ° oaOVao Doc 0 Doc p°°° a R $°$p5p�r1 �8 $ $g $$$ 4 $ $ 8 $gr g$ $m$ °$ °p°p° $$R0 0 O6OaIMV . Nm n f. Ymf NO Inm 0mn�0 N /Y �N Ca W n N MN. Y m NJI. ' M M N m . m f� r0.MAMY a w w 0 0o C0000000060000 000°0 a 0vv000000 an C00000O00 Oo c ccocaO0 m J a 0O OnO0000000000 0000 00000000 0 00 000000000 0o a 0000000 0 a P. W Nm.ryo m,qO W O W no o so<o or Nt?0nq P a v° ®WrooRman o Y.m n.m m00 u O� <g N mmm Mim NNOK666 roam YYYONMOM Y K MNWaN,Nri® PW p OM.Nfflr a a MmNmmn.ommnY. nmWY NamoMmW n �n m0,aMMWm rvo m mmoaN-� m Zo OQ r mM.mMwnM mnM flavM ON .WOY n n .pa0 Meson 'M "mNY00m e ¢W MN�,m N�Nmmr v ¢a < c 2z c' mw w °O 00$00 voOO$voOVVOO 000OOaovOODO OOO Oo ooOV0OV00o 0c 6006600 0 CO p0 LL 1 OP p 0 w N 0Y W c NW Zm ry N' 0^ jo Nr Oa `N o 0000000000000OOD 000coo000OO000o 00 0000oao000 ooc 0 0000000 a `^ } Ow c o0 00000000 00 0O 0000 00 00 0000000°00 coc 0 OOOVOOO o = UOFW O7 gyp Nn, OIY N rgO�mM�mmm pO p°80 On m0 flOmO 00 00 00ry°OON000n mn- n YpnpOMfl N - aj N NIYVmmplmmh eN mM Im'IN'$ NN nn m AWN O. bPinnWrypf N � a 9m Y_ _ NN �o g O�U. 0 aDD$$�DaaR Q�°� . o s8°#8g8 g88a$ °°° c�8888 88 8 � m °g�8 <<Q m nNA 7�aSm MN Oe� rif p+ a88 mpmp mnmrm • nY�Yvimmmnm �n m mmry ¢ a s n[�n' 0 DNOm OMn p. $OM 00Y00YN N ±m tl�'m:Sfl nn n NNNBm 4 � .w0 N �N Y. 0 Y 0 Pn a N O m np 0 N - LL r ww N C } C y x Z xw7 ZZ Z Y F h >JyN �� Z ❑ O o Wtl 0 �OrC ZO wW}Z u Z J r 0 LL�7t 0yh�N�Z C2hZ Or O�NO U� Z WW NLL h 0 F t Wm J ff LL QN JZ Om1 NO U f Zh <u < C Z C {{{W....W A. 0 ( u > 0 = F �ry � J Z70sWj �x(tlUWWf JUNZ�OZU ZK W2QJWNWZy Ya ZJ Fm WW OY-�U ORO (NULLYKCj20WWU� WN fOh]FbF ¢ � W 4U u pmy� E ❑ W<am FGFOO�U �wLL?FW�nrc000�z�o yo wrS�7z_zSa ab W>❑J w M j LLYO} ZLLWNW _J< NJ<FUYZ�UWK❑'NZ W Y Nd QZN❑UZ p yZJLLU<? ��jCZJpON}2mJ(}] NQ KWUUaWUCV- WJWZ>UO a ( Z mNLL N O}mJLLW <U p3 NLL27aN- m W OJ(Z U JJ rSJ� JnF 0 FUE �(0 m <a LLO-( g�aa OW J}OLL AZ( c (O7(JLLp�W Ow <_ZvWNUWU rWr CUp�U. U ZCUZ} OY OZ �HI}Nw m W>WOa`�h<LLWWU'mw UWmO JW4 5k m'4m WN wa�O4p UH°m Am JaFhhYC �rNp7f w�a NUO¢W �wUOK�myCf3mJ0(0 IZ �WaO¢m7mF WM ZmWJWpO LL W`N_W'OmZK�+QGppLLW� <�nyW2]]F(WW 7}¢m h( HajWm]Om 0a W(WFjOW OA UU(QOU Na FN0WU4LL FN,m>_W0 j4 U N}6 OJ UJLLJKJ6a(� (< UJhJLL'y? ; } `< NO am, ON mY Am. LL m W W a 0 'N It m m A m Om Y W �NMYmmnmW mm WO•mmW ,' C 0 a 0�..'NN mflm m n� <N NOOPPYYYYYYf JIm mYt EOaammm0mm Oh NNmMMnn �9 0 _ nN U��.NNNNNNNNNNNN Nn . NNNNNNNNN Mm mmmmmmm C Y k yVy G nY 2 n4 zze xx x et zEEE zE EeEE x xzxzx err x x xxxx SSE S`• B BE SBSB BB EBBB E SSSBS t B S `0 S`0S `6 Y8 ffi ii i ii fiif =f 0iii i fif 9 ifi f i ffif Fp 600 .0 c CO Cabo c6 0000 c 06.06 boa 0 0 Coco � F° BEE hh E ES BhhE hh Bhhh h BBBBB BBB B E EEEE PPE tF c EE EEPP FP PPPP F PPPPP EFc F P FPPP E� boa oo p o0 vo•o 00 •p oo a o• o as boa o o .op0 6 �� YY� EY E 6E �YY� Y6 BY�� Y YY8 Y FYY � Y YTiYY A 0 FGF FF i GG iiiF FF GFFF G FFFFF FFF i i GGGG $ B E 777 77 7 77 7777 77 7777 ! 77777 777 7 7 7y 77 0o a 0Y 6000 a • • e00 a oY • • e • Ye o 0 0000 W t� a{ae [a CS [e ec ea`r Cr (r[n [a CS y[� e to es to fa CS ar(a c [e n(n n.Le V �� ; P QOO�V 0.0O aMO�o N 0 0WFONpNOO(JCJ c MIt 0 (IN NF ^ 0 00 W 00 Ya it E OO,0NOOm8S°,° 1 " °8 01,m AN $ $ O8m SS$ N $ 8 .X $Q u S mmm8 8°°m°s°° °8.8 8s°s.x°°°82 88 ° °° s8 °8888 s m m88HM 2 moR 0N ^ YO W^^YI °n ♦ m VmMYaN N NNNO•lm$ 6 82-92.m R DOYry^^^8M •.Mm0^N o 7 Do 00 0000 000000100 00000 000000 0000 000 000000000 0 0000000 (Z� j,_ 00 m 0°Om GI0 d0i nN�° 0 m1100- /°o °m °m°NI°.Q°a °m°m°n m°r an ry°°°m°o°M q°1M a Y 4�° MN1 pm+MV� SS•YNIN Ng n ^ N R o f^ N. 0 N N M^aN M ♦ Nw^m 4 u ry a a S °°°888°° 8888°888 8888°886 8888°8 88 888888 Bd8 8 8888888 P Ni,O 0000 001 �pOpvm 0040M^YIY Y 0 0^0 0n m pIN �00 W Po al rlm fVO j his $�Nnn g�:m SO IMOMPFn � mnp6n� °n�i�88$� Yr Y h M P� M ♦ f m N 0 0 p n N [ a F1- J } WW y n O xNU 2 F m a WJ W h� p l0� 0 • m } 0 ] 0 0 a�0 F2f<0 Z mZFF� OF OWNO U` Z W NLL f 0 D $ J F �zLLN �ON�ZUDaNWLLN FU HO �Naw ] UN a I c N m J Z70�W- U�wW]�FZNZ�02U zC ZZ gWNaOy 6( ZW R 7mu� 0 <p0�aa yUumxm7ZOWJOf WF W�F hOWZm 0w J_U p W fi -dt0 <ON(V rwLLZ7 wFC0U7 UWO F- WV-<�JZZS< Z LL707 wfH tiLL �tV< �W-FmN 0 2� NO a WY4 04 wa2N VO E }}{9} 2 W w_J h ((�U z UWa <<}N}Z W U7-� m- Z M } h F �2JWw(aN (N aZ7a OmZ Y 2a�NNu Na N UO<Wue- uN�w2>u0 x a Z j� 77� �O FOa<U a^P N O aJW N Z aNf x W 4 V QQmt• �� h1 xqpw J-(0 aF 7 ''_amWO O< (ZN�NUNU aUm U u 2aUZY w° w J�a^ aN Wa aUf Om $ a a� Ya F�W00LL wU^r' 0 U 00 �wY aLL6 w0 �(7(m J N ]��u-( N°aa�wr .,WUOa�ma a mJ (0 2 w Omm7^E M mw] a0 ' w<NamOmZa OW w,a LLNaWLL7FF(WW7]1O-aa FFZ is Wm7Om7 0 W(JF JQQW 4 JUU((OVN<hN NUhI A:G>Z6 N4UN4UNf4 OS EJa7O(<O d m ZV��7LL]? t pp11 ^�NNNY N Y N IN6 N�•ppeeNmm N mN NmN O b„pm toll m N mN mN mp mN YNhmm Yi N �M1mnmr m 888888 88888888 8888 ' 8 888 888 888888888 8 8 D � NN0^ 0N hO0W0Np0 N000 N WaM 000 mm 00000N A A W ° 0N6 W 0 O N NO x0001 y N 0 4 WOO OMBOm 0004 0 0 0 °N 00 �0Na n °mmmmm0 MNM8 m Mom 4000 am0pC 0Omn N N 4 If Wl0 N0-0Nm 0, M N0s 0MW 0N0Y� 00MMA M M 0= NNN wNO om (466NrO* N NON M m 000 N0 0 1 QR m a 0 N N 000000 0000°000 O 0000 ' 0 000 000 00000°000 0 0 :t 88 0 00 O 00 O O O O 0 00 0 0 0 Dr yp@@ � pc0 'q 8 � Rappm,pN•8n 5,88,0 R,$8 088 N08,8888° 8 ry N 4° OOm wmdl nN ON0g9m aN0 � N� 0400 00 oN n 888 g mm°� �8S nmI ITBvN 6 S $+ NCR 0aN0r0NIt. 1 7Ma N 0 a0 Wmm INa 00MMMM m 0 �p NNNWNW ON MW06 0 N �W NWN Mom 0W0 . Ntl a a Q ry N M M 000000 00000000 0000 ' 0 000 000 000000000 0 0 c 000000 000 °0000 0000 0 000 000 00000000 0 0 c ID MMM 0 0 0 01 NN011 11 0040 0 aN 0040 N0N00000 - - C :o RivN� � R $ ` N �m �� IN) N '°`'R 88 00980080 d o n O V N N h tl a m tl M h h N A W N M W a N a d WOWWOa WWh000Nm MONO O 40x0 WMm m N N 0 0 M M M 0 10 y+ 0I t-mNtlN0 FtV MONNOi ON1O 0 0f6 M� V p NN N W . M h m N 01 0011 N m Q N O N M L O 000000 00000000 0000 ' 0 000 000 00000000 O O h o a Dm 8 MUM 8$88°28.8 9888 9 °28 888 $SM88888 < ' C :0 mOna00 �NNNN4N0 x000 NW0 mmm mN00000 A 6 w IC VN N It N .NN - roMWtmpma mmmoW � mog Wog emaa ,aoo N a .- Y N M mMNMM m W mn tlWON 50 NW N 040 N� 0 0 M m M A a L V 0 . NONoNd nCi 190 Yi N VI m(V �V6 R6 0011 mmm 0011 �N0 N C c Q 0 ' N N N m M 0 A N a L C N 0 N M m LL 8 888888 88888888 8 888888 888 888 888888888 8 8 7 LDN a OOOOM40 AppWmN N G, 0000x0 0NN '0Wa MMa0000, a a 0 0 C u M W OPB pn mm N1ppN m oya ym Nli qp 01: m m am" �MN a 0p 00 A 0 N /1 R 0 M 0Y1 tom Y aM0 O W O W m M O (Y'0N A A O WN M O N0 nM M h O 0 M I-1 wN10 N n°NOSa NN NNnN0) ®(V X10000 Ri9N .riry O C a 000000 00000000 0000,00 coo coo 00000 ' 00 ° 0 7D °o o x800 80008050 0 58 50 0 goo ooR 00$00 800 $ m v 0 h f N 0r r Oh W, 0a N IU LL ° o m �amn06d NmNWao 6 oimma6a6 Naiv qN(4 N°d�� 0110 RN a 0 M ♦ N�N fp00�°I p ON mNN� 0; A °l fpg N(p0 W N 0,P 0 �� W �WONN VI N N 010(V 01 m N Y1 MWm mM0 (V IO O M N f-NNOb� NMM00NIVq 0N�N.0m OYiW W,.0 NnV N �n0 ^1 7 0 N N N WC N N /m V ° R Y C V Q° C N m V j t ° D E�+ 7 0 N u D 7 d 0 fj ? O Y > w 0 0 x d Y c m LL' C X. x g $ m rc to d eG y x0 i � u •. " e ] w ° � fm � E9 0 R W m D c Y e x a gE u = EQ c m $ Aq m e [ fix $ E Y ° i 6 91 u d r w '0 9Axx0 gdZE x20 7 � E € u -° >, coop oysa ° � � yE d d �' NObN � — ° cEo $ _ m r � fx „ ° � E � 4 yyq6i U, a •„ so U. Ti R x x 9 0 C x - W D u E 7 N Y i x ¢ u 0 G 7 y ] S $ N N d Y m dTU RRA ° cF4xR$ ; t iedaupypy S 00 e 'x _ n° Y2x nE �$ ..9 Cl E0 ¢ A -: y°0 a a E F U F E R wy W ya 00 n yE ' 6 � uCt � , ° " F h K A 7 E 7 L 7 A 0 ° �a � W6y ] FO ] w- O Cuff W y N ¢ y 0 y Futu09 wfh W C m 0 co ui M N ry E L tD Ln rlj Ln ■■�■■ N cn W v � _ C13 ■■�.. rn ■�„■ � W � .■�■ LL m - cn ■■�■ 1.P1 ico _ C5 C5 - - - Ln - �✓ ro EZ Q V v • - U O 0 w � W � V V a) u') LL N b v U_ W U C6 LL 4-J O C '.F-i D v u E �. O N i N v x 76 o 4-J O + N v U u i Q O 76 E ++ a-+ O C: ry U — ro c6 = r J U N U N N J L.L E to fo OU m N U N U ( C N O � 1-.� U 5. N X N N `*N V) O O v O +ra Q +-, ' E O N E W O I— N O O . O N u&-. N CO iJ X X ( J U v) E CO E i w � c Q N =5 " N cn v O +� (B X O N > w c — N v V f6 4- Q) � v � +J L — 3 > C L N O (J L c j n QJ QJ > U QJ cn — • > L L Q1 b.A QJ !O > rG^ O '� -0 :3 U V (1) O -0 v 0 v> > +' nA > QJ 4-j QJ Cu L O 0 i 0 1 Q a + 0 u QJ a-•+ R L U Ln •� QJ N N Q1 QJ -0 O bo v Ln Ln QJ o o V , L- > c L O �' Q1 .v O O QJ _0 to o w U Qa) .� N X QJ c QJ D —O QJ u O Q L > CJ QJ L = Q! � QJ (6 (n L m Q) \ — QJ 'a C LA f0 QJ On Q (L6 C co C -61 +' o v o v • L (� 3 � + XQ v Q QJ f— Ln Ln D QJ `� N W in ui QJ O O L 2 O 4-J U i Q) U O > O buo i C6 > N N N Q (� C: -1 06 2 -*F Q O Q n V D O L UO t]A fB J O > N O O u I ._ U vi 2 — LL qA _0 c ^ 'O E C: — v � u o O — CL E O 0 I O N a + E N C: m U O �' Ln v pO bD u C w pv ii U - O a +� m �' C L L a-+ U O uz E m N — m c: E >, +1 c6 U O O }' U L `n bA U U (f) O cn O ■ ■ ■ U- �. U O A A A A Q O �Q LL CO Z U D u L O U ^ f0 U J o 0 O Q � U � Q �Ln E L N C: L O Ln v L L QJ V > to U L— cn U a� Y �_ }' 4J � 4J Q U N v > v H Uo V) U � LL C — Q. a_+ (0 Oj — Q - 1 (6 C: U C L c: N O v v o : C: L- u OLO CD U U =Al AAA A Rampant recycling fraud is draining California cash - latimes.com Pagel of 4 Entered to Rec. at MCC/CDC Mtg: /v ,5 by: latimes.com/news/local/la-me-can-fraud-20121007,0,&AWA"ov latimes.com ��Secretary City of San Bernardino Rampant recycling fraud is draining California cash Fraud rings bring cans and bottles from other states and illicitly 'redeem' deposits that were never paid. And some private recycling centers might claim bigger reimbursements than they deserve. By Jessica Garrison, Los Angeles Times October 7, 2012 Just over 8.5 billion recyclable cans were sold in California last year. The number redeemed for a nickel under California's recycling law: 8.3 billion. That's a return rate of nearly 100%. That kind of success isn't just impressive, it's unbelievable. But the recycling rate for certain plastic containers was even higher: 104%. California's generous recycling redemption program has led to rampant fraud. Crafty entrepreneurs are driving semi-trailers full of cans from Nevada or Arizona, which don't have deposit laws, across the border and transforming their cargo into truckfuls of nickels. In addition, recyclers inside the state are claiming redemptions for the same containers several times over, or for containers that never existed. The illicit trade is draining the state's $1.1-billion recycling fund. Government officials recently estimated the fraud at $40 million a year, and an industry expert said it could exceed $200 million. It's one reason the strapped fund paid out $100 million more in expenses last year than it took in from deposits and other sources. "The law says California has to make it easy to recycle ... so anyone with a devious mind, it's so easy, they can just go right in," said Los Angeles County Sheriffs Deputy Dave Chapman, who has investigated fraud rings in recent months. Under the state's 25-year-old recycling law, California charges consumers a deposit on most beverage containers sold within its borders. Anyone who brings empty containers back to one of about 2,300 privately run recycling centers can collect 5 cents for most cans and bottles and 10 cents for larger containers. Only products sold in California are eligible. But a can is a can — and many recycling http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-can-fraud-20121007,0,3535567,p... 10/7/2012 Rampant recycling fraud is draining California cash - latimes.com Page 2 of 4 centers in California aren't that interested in where they come from. Hence the influx from out of state. Last summer, the state Department of Food and Agriculture counted all vehicles driving into the state with used beverage containers through 16 border stations. The three-month tally was 3,500, including 505 rental trucks filled to capacity with cans. Officials with the state Department of Justice said they have filed approximately 10 criminal cases this year against fraud rings bringing in cans from outside California. Investigators looking into one case sometimes stumble across another. In the spring of 2010, special agents Jose Soto and Joe Somanek, part of the Justice Department's recycling fraud unit, were driving east on Interstate 8 to tie up some details in a case in Arizona. Around 5 a.m, they were drinking coffee and making plans for the day when a white Ford pickup and trailer sped past them, heading west. Suspecting the truck might be carrying cans, the agents flipped a U-turn and followed it more than 150 miles to San Diego, where it pulled into Ace Recycling. The driver and his passenger unloaded 21 large bags full of cans, were paid by the owner and headed back to Yuma. The suspects made the same journey at least three more times over the next few weeks. Officials said that fraud ring brought in at least $189,000 worth of cans before they were caught. Ultimately, the owner of Ace Recycling, Michael Barshak, and several others pleaded guilty to grand theft and unlawful recycling. Eleven states have container redemption programs, and experts believe some level of fraud exists in each. "Seinfeld" fans will recognize the scheme: Two characters once conspired to drive a mail truck full of empty bottles from New York, where they could be redeemed for 5 cents each, to Michigan, where they could fetch 10. The problem is particularly challenging—and costly— in California. This is the only state in the region besides Oregon with a deposit program, making it a magnet for recycling fraud. And it is the only state besides Hawaii to directly administer the program through private recycling centers. Other states have beverage distributors or sellers collect the deposits and pay the redemption costs, so they— and not the state —are responsible for the money. But grocery stores and markets opposed that approach in California, which opted to have private recycling centers take in the material. The state reimburses the centers for what they spend on redemption costs, based on their account of what they take in by weight. http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-can-fraud-20121007,0,3535 567,p... 10/7/2012 Rampant recycling fraud is draining California cash - latimes.com Page 3 of 4 The centers, which make their money by selling the material for scrap value and sometimes by collecting additional fees from the state, have a financial incentive to maximize the amount of material they take in, not to look for fraud. State officials say recycling centers in California are required to take reasonable precautions: They are not allowed, for instance, to buy more than 500 pounds of aluminum or 2,500 pounds of glass from any one person in any given day. But fraud rings find ways around the law—hiring people to return the cans in small bundles at numerous centers, for example. Investigating such cases is time consuming and expensive: It's not illegal per se to drive cans across the border, so officers must follow the cans into the state, stake out the locations where the cans are broken down into smaller loads, and then follow the smaller loads to recycling centers. To help identify people bringing cans into California, Gov. Jerry Brown signed a law last month that will require those importing more than 25 pounds of aluminum or plastic or 250 pounds of glass to declare at the border what their purpose is and the source and destination of the material. Importers aren't the only problem. Recycling centers themselves may actively engage in fraud by seeking reimbursement for more than they are entitled to. A recent court case alleges that employees at one of the state's largest trash companies did just that. In a lawsuit and whistle-blower complaint, Brian McVeigh, a former supervisor at Recology in San Francisco, said workers made more than $1 million in fraudulent claims a year. One part of the alleged scheme, he said, was pretending that cans it had picked up from commercial and residential customers had actually been turned in to its recycling center; the state often provides bigger reimbursements when materials are acquired that way. McVeigh claims he was fired when he tried to get the company to investigate. A judge dismissed the wrongful-termination suit, and McVeigh has appealed. His state whistle-blower suit is ongoing. Recology spokesman Adam Alberti denied McVeigh's allegations and said he was terminated for cause before he ever raised whistle-blower complaints. CalRecycle—the state's Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, which does administrative reviews, not criminal investigations—looked into the matter and found "multiple violations" of state recycling laws, according to a letter it wrote to Recology in 2010. Among them: that Recology failed to keep adequate records, failed to properly inspect loads of recycled materials and did not always follow a requirement to take down the names of people it claimed had brought in large quantities of recyclable material. CalRecycle itself has come under scrutiny. A 2010 report from the California state http://www.latimes.com/news/locaVla-me-can-fraud-20121007,0,3535567,p... 10/7/2012 Rampant recycling fraud is draining California cash - latimes.com Yage 4 of 4 auditor found that the agency did not ensure fraud tips were followed up on. From 2005 to 2010, the report found, CalRecycle logged 295 calls to its fraud tip line. Only 17 of those resulted in an investigation; officials could not say what happened with the other 278. The state review also found that the agency did not always follow up on audits of beverage distributors that were supposed to be paying deposits into the state's recycling fund. In 2010, the agency had a backlog of reports from beverage distributors and manufacturers so severe, it was owed $10 million, a CalRecycle spokesman said. Since then, the backlog has been reduced and it is owed an estimated $3 million. John Halligan, CalRecycle's head of recycling enforcement, said his agency now analyzes data from recycling centers' claims in order to detect fraud. This year, CalRecycle has removed 19 recycling centers from the program and launched reviews of 256 others. Some centers complain that they too are victims of fraud, and that the state should not lump them in with the rings that illegally import containers. But Halligan said spotting fraud should not be that difficult for the centers. The vast majority of people turning in cans bring in less than 10 pounds at a time. "When someone comes in two times a week with 480 pounds, you should know" that something is not right, he said. less ica.garrison;jzlatimes.com Copyright © 2012, Los Angeles Times http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-can-fraud-20121007,0,3 53 5567,p... 10/7/2012 Enter Into Rec. at IVICCICDC Mi. Agenda Rem No; --7c/' �.L �' ) BAR STOOL ECONOMICS by: ,' Ot}y Clert CDC Sclet�c{rnetnnary Suppose that every day, ten men go out for a bUY 2h��'rjII1To`rN ten comes to $100. If they paid their bill the way we pay our taxes, it would go something like this: The first four men (the poorest) would pay nothing. The fifth would pay $1.00 The sixth would pay $3.00 The seventh would pay $7.00 The eighth would pay $12.00 The ninth would pay $18.00 The tenth man (the richest) would pay $59.00 So that's what they decided to do. The men drank in the bar every day and seemed quite happy with arrangement, until one day, the owner threw them a curve. "Since you are all such good customers, he said, I'm going to reduce the cost of your daily beer by $20.00. Drinks for the ten men now cost just $80.00" The group still wanted to pay their bill the way we pay our taxes so the first four men were unaffected. They would still drink for free. But what about the other six men —the paying customers? How could they divide the $20 windfall so that everyone would get their"fair share?" They realized that $20.00 divided by six is $3.33. But if they subtracted that from everybody's share, then the fifth man and the sixth man would each end up being paid to drink his beer. So, the bar owner suggested that it would be fair to reduce each man's bill by roughly the same amount, and he proceeded to work out the amounts each should pay! And so: The fifth man like the first four, now paid nothing ( 100% savings). The sixth now paid $2 instead of$3 (33% savings). The seventh now pay $5 instead of$7 (28% savings). The eighth now paid $9 instead of $12 (25% savings). The ninth now paid $14 instead of $18 (22% savings). The tenth now paid $49 instead of$59 (16% savings). Each of the six was better off than before! And the first four continued to drink for free. But once outside the restaurant, the men began to compare their savings. "I only got a dollar out of the $20" declared the sixth man. He pointed to the tenth man, "but he got $10!" "Yeah, that's right, shouted the seventh man. "why should he get $10 back when I got only two? The wealthy get all the breaks!" "Wait a minute," yelled the first four men in union. " We didn't get anything at all. The system exploits the poor!" The nine men surrounded the tenth and beat him up. The next night the tenth man didn't show up for drinks, so the nine sat down and had beers without him. But when it came time to pay the bill, they discovered something important. They didn't have enough money between all of them for even half of the bill! And that, boys and girls, journalists and college professors, is how our tax system works. The people who pay the highest taxes get the most benefit from a tax reduction. Tax them too much, attack them for being wealthy, and they just may not show up anymore. In fact, they might start drinking overseas where the atmosphere is somewhat friendlier. For those who understand, no explanation is needed. For those who do not understand, no explanation is possible! David R. Kamerschen, PH. D Professor of Economics, University of Georgia