The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About43-Development Services CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO Development Services Department - Planning Division Interoffice Memorandum FROM: Mayor and Common Council ~ Terri Rahhal, Deputy Director/City Plarmer TO: SUBJECT: Item 43- 9/2/08 MCC Agenda: Manta Management Appeal No. 08-02 Appeal of Planning Commission Denial of a CUP for a Type 48 ABC license for 100 West Hospitality Lane DATE: August 29, 2008 COPIES: James Penman, City Attorney; Rachel Clark, City Clerk; Fred Wilson, City Manager; Valerie C. Ross, Development Services Director The subject appeal by Manta Management is a request to reverse the action of the Planning Commission to deny a Conditional Use Permit for a Type 48 - On-Sale,General Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) license at 100 W. Hospitality Lane. The appellant has also requested that the Mayor and Council reconsider the June 16, 2008 determination that the Public Convenience or Necessity (PCN) would not be served by issuance of a Type 48 ABC license at the subject site. This item has been continued from August 4, 2008, at the request of the appellant. To identify conditions of over-concentration that require a PCN determination from the City, the State ABC Department evaluates the concentration of ABC licenses within the Census Tract where the site of a license application is located. Therefore, all previous discussion of the subject ABC license request by Manta Management has focused on Census Tract 060, the location of 100 West Hospitality Lane. As previously reported, there is one existing Type 48 ABC license in Census Tract 060: The Lark, located at 917 Inland Center Drive. This site has been permitted as a cocktail lounge for over 30 years, long before the PCN determination requirement came into effect in 1995. At the August 4, 2008 hearing, the appellant requested a continuance for staff to investigate and report on all PCN determination requests for Type 48 ABC licenses in the City of San Bernardino. There has been only one previous request for a Type 48 ABC license that required a PCN determination. The Mayor and Council granted a PCN determination for a Type 48 ABC license for the Gents Organization at 1462 E. Art Townsend Drive on October 7,1996. 9/~/org "it 4 3 Item 43: 9/2/08 Manta Management Appeal 08-02 Page 2 There are 18 existing Type 48 ABC licenses in the City of San Bernardino. All except the Gents Organization's license were granted before ABC required a PCN determination. The original issue date noted in the ABC list refers to issuance of the current license only. Staff has added notes to indicate previous licenses or Conditional Use Permits issued to permit Type 48 licenses prior to the 1995 PCN determination requirement. In addition to the search for previous PCN determinations, staff also researched requests for Type 48 ABC licenses that did not require PCN determinations due to an ABC license concentration within the limits accepted by ABC. There was only one such request. On December 3, 2001, the Mayor and Council denied CUP No. 01-14, a request by Fanatics Restaurant to convert to a night club and upgrade a Type 41 ABC license to a Type 48 ABC license. The site of the request was 1689 W. Kendall Drive, Ste. H. Staff can also provide an update on the status of the stated intent of Manta Management to obtain a Type 47 ABC license for on,site sales of beer, wine and distilled spirits at a bona fide restaurant. On August 22,2008, Troy Neptune inquired about the City's role in the application process for a Type 47 ABC license. Staff informed Mr. Neptune ofthe input of City staff in the license application review process of the State Department of ABC, and that the existing Conditional Use Permit No. 93-21 for 100 W. Hospitality Lane would be modified to approve the proposed restaurant operations and to include the conditions of approval issued by the State on a Type 47 ABC license. Mr. Neptune indicated that Manta Management awaited the outcome of the current request for reconsideration of the PCN determination and approval of CUP No. 08-03, and that if these requests are denied, Manta Management may apply for a Type 47 ABC license. Attachment: 8/29/08 Type 48 ABC License Query on www.abc.ca.gov Page I of4 ~\'!) c'~~ C. \ \f 01,:, .1 ,~"~"'n.. ....~..h~-::.....-'_~.._ "":~ :..~'~_\'f~"" i ~'-i c. ~,_ ,,7'.i:l ~~b i"('vL:i'l..'~"';l~ (.:;<J 1~ California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control For the city of SAN BERNARDINO- (By license type 48) Report as of 8/29/2008 License r~tus I License Orig. Iss. Expir Primary Owner Business Name Mailing tj Number Type Date Date and Premises Address Code Addr. 1) 321648 ACT 48 12/27/1996 11/30/2008 GENTS GENTS 3610 ORGANIZATION COMMUNITY 1462 E ART CENTER TOWNSEND DR ORGANIZATION SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92408 Census Tract: 0077, 2) ~962Q3 ACT 48 12/31/2002 5/31/2009 CAPPADONA TARTAN THE 3610 CAROLC n Il DS' Yl15I'b~ 1602 E HIGHLAND AVE SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92404 Census Tract: 0062,02 3) 440727 ACT 48 7/24/2006 6/30/2009 VAN SANT SPORTS PAGE 3610 BRIAN !I317~s c'/'?J<g9 RAYMOND 1225 E L YNWOOD DR SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92404 Census Tract: 0062,02 4) 447307 ACT 48 12t7/2006 11/30/2008 CRAIG FRANK LCS 3610 LEE GREENBRIAR '}m~~ 1259 E 4//?/'?/t L YNWOOD DR SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92404-2752 Census Tract: 0062,02 f5ll393~lt2 IACT I~ 2/3/2003 1/31/2009 I SAMFORD II SOUTH SIDE 11376 E BLAINE 113610 I f9Q<:;70 3/23/'67 htto:llwww.abc.ca.gov/datport/AHCityRep.asp 8/29/2008 Page 2 of 4 CELESTE MARIE SALON CC & E ST 495 E RIVERSIDE, RED LANDS CA 92507 BLVD SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92408 Census Tract: 0073,01 6) 4Q2128 ACT 48 3/26/2008 2128/2009 ONE 11 LARK THE 3610 toCc II/S- ~/2P /9>/ YOUMACK INVESTMENTS INC 917 INLAND CENTER DR SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92408-1809 Census Tract: 0060. 7) 427369 ACT 48 8/2412005 7/31/2008 KILPATRICK FLASHBACKS PO BOX 8236 3610 'iOOil LEIGH JANE RED LANDS, 123NEST CA 92375 5/<J/~O SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92401 Census Tract: 0057, 8) M42~9 ACT 48 11/2/2006 10/31/2008 KT BUSINESS RED FOX THE 11708 3610 ENTERPRISES PARKMEAD 21/ WZ- INC ST 2./18/'a 3142 NEST SANTA FE SAN SPRINGS, CA BERNARDINO, 90670-3654 CA 92405 Census Tract: 0046,02 9) ~5j 130 ACT 48 10/1/1990 10/31/2008 FELIX BENJAMIN 3610 149 N MOUNT VERNON AVE SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92410 Census Tract: 0049. - 10) 361108 ACT 48 2/3/2000 1/31/2009 PEREZ SAUL EL FARALLON 2138 N 3610 G'6"~'2.. DIAZ EASlWOOD IAnkrt. 12/3//93 1227 N SIERRA SANTA ANA, WY CA 92705- SAN 7007 BERNARDINO, http://www.abc.ca.gov/datportlAHCityRep.asp 8/29/2008 Page 3 of4 UUUULU CA 92405 UU Census Tract: 0055, 11) 4Q9J29 ACT 48 5/4/2004 4/30/2009 HARRISON MUSIC ROOM 3610 RONNIE LYNN '1'-/b<;'l/ 4./Q/9( 4360 N SIERRA W'( SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92407-3823 Census Tract: 0045,02 12) 350965 ACT 48 3/7/2007 3/31/2009 INLAND PACIFIC CARLOS 3610 INVESTMENTS OBRIENS C,Up LLC 440 W COURT ~ ST SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92401 Census Tract: 0057, 13) 270951 ACT 48 4/16/1992 1/31/2009 CALDERA CLUB TRINIDAD 3610 ROBERTO K 1562-1/2 W FIFTH ST SAN BERNARDINO, CA92411 Census Tract: 0043, 14) 71796 ACT 48 3/6/1979 6/30/2009 HASSETT MARQUIS 3610 DENNIS M LOUNGE THE 1036W HIGHLAND AVE SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92405 Census Tract: 0046,02 15) 301269 ACT 48 12/13/1994 11/30/2008 RENDON CHAVELAS BAR 10325 MILLS 3610 ALFREDO A AVE 1180W MONTCLAIR, HIGHLAND AVE CA 91763 SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92405 Census Tract: 0046.02 f16i1144954g II ACT II 48 112/2212007 114/30/2009 II LOPEZ JESUS II LA CONSENTIDA II 113600 I ,-,2.b70 7/C.("'} 2... http://www.abc.ca.gov/datport/ AHCityRep.asp 8/29/2008 Page 4 of 4 1950W NIGHT CLUB HIGHLAND AVE SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92407-6504 Census Tract: 0041, 17) 436109 ACT 48 4/20/2006 3/31/2009 HEDRICK ELGIN & FAGAN 3610 ').1'2;2.'1/ GREGORY 2/ l'?,I'ifl ROLLAND 336W HIGHLAND AVE SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92405 Census Tract: 0053, 18) 373971 ACT 48 3/9/2001 2/28/2009 CO EN ALlFONSA LULUS HIDEOUT 3610 ~3<bOI 1958 W RIAL TO 6(2-"Il'n AVE SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92410 Census Tract: 0049. -- - End of Report _ u For a defin~ion of codes, view our glossary, httn.//www.ahc.ca.lwv/datnort/AHCitvRen.asn 8/29/2008