HomeMy WebLinkAbout1988-460
10
14
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
,4
1
RESOLUTION NO.
88-460
2 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO AUTHORIZING THE
EXECUTION OF THE FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE TRANSFER AGREEMENT
3 BETWEEN PUBLIC TECHNOLOGY, INC., AND THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
COVERING THE TRANSFER OF THE FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE (FSLP)
4
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COMMON COUNCIL OF THE
5
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO AS FOLLOWS:
6
SECTION 1.
The Mayor of the City of San Bernardino is
7
hereby authorized and directed to execute, on behalf of said
8
City, a Fire Station Location Package Transfer Agreement with
9
Public Technology, Inc., relating to the transfer of the Fire
station Location Package (FSLP).
A copy of the Agreement is
11
attached hereto, marked Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by
12
this reference as fully as though set forth at length.
13
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing resolution was duly
adopted by the Mayor and Common Council of the City of San
15
Bernardino, at a
meeting held on the
5th da~l
regular
16
of
December
, 19~, by the following vote, to wit:
17
AYES:
Council Members Estrada, Reilly, Flores, Minor,
18
19
Pope-Ludlam, Miller
NAYS:
None
ABSENT:
Council Member Mau~sley
.- ~-~/
:A~ '-~ / "./:,~.'..( /
" ;. ~....'[ :.:.;::::::::-:f~:.~::~'::::
Ci t~{ Clerk
JFW:sS
November 23, 1988
1
RESO: AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF THE FIRE'STAT1oN
LOCATION PACKAGE TRANSFER AGREEMENT WITH PUBLIC TECHNOLOGY,
INC.
1
7 c:!-~
I
'~. _?A /
Evtyn ~ayor ~
City of San Bernardino
The foregoing resolution is hereby approved this
2
day of
December
3
4
5
6
Approved as to form
an~a~ content:
t ,?~
(J'ty Attorney
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
JFW:ss
November 23, 1988
2
AN AGREEMENT TO TRANSFER THE
FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE
TO THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO,
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Submitted to San Bernardino, California
~
PUBLIC TECHNOLOGY, INC.
1301 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20004
Dated: October 26, 1988
. ,
I. PROJECT ABSTRACT
This agreement describes a project to implement the Fire Station Location
Package (FSLP) -- a proven computer-based method for locating fire stations --
in the City of San Bernardino, State of California. This project will provide
the City with an effective method for developing an efficient configuration of
fire stations designed to minimize response time. It will help local policy
makers and fire department officials make better, more defensible decisions
about how many fire stations are needed and where to locate them within a
framework of locally developed objectives and constraints.
The project described in this agreement can be completed in approximately
eight to twelve months. City staff will own the FSLP system at the conclusion
of the project and will be able to apply the system for periodic updates as
local conditions change. In addition, the data base developed for this FSLP
project can be used for a variety of other community facility location
problems.
This agreement has been developed by Public Technology, Inc. (PTI), the
applied science and technology arm of the National League of Cities and the
International City Management Association. PTI has successfully transferred
computer-based planning and management tools, including FSLP, to over 150 u.S.
cities. Any questions regarding this proposal should be directed to:
Susan B Benton
Program Manager
Public Technology, Inc.
1301 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 626-2400
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
I. PROJECT ABSTRACT ----------------------------------------------
II. TRANSFER AGREEMENT -------------------------------------------- iii
III. OBJECTIVES OF THE WORK ---------------------------------------- 1
IV. RESULTS ------------------------------------------------------- 2
V. BENEFITS ------------------------------------------------------ 2
VI. PROJECT TASKS ------------------------------------------------- 3
VII. MANAGEMENT PLAN ----------------------------------------------- 5
VIII. WORK SCHEDULE ------------------------------------------------- 6
ATTACHMENT 1: FSLP PROJECT TASK-TIME CHART
ATTACHMENT 2: FSLP DOCUMENTATION TABLE OF CONTENTS
ATTACHMENT 3: RESUMES
ATTACHMENT 4: FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE AND
FIRE MASTER USERS LIST
i i
II. FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE TRANSFER AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this ___ day of , 1988 by and
between PUBLIC TECHNOLOGY, INC., 1301 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Washington,
D.C., hereinafter referred to as IIPTI,II and THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO, STATE OF
CALIFORNIA, hereinafter referred to as the IICity,1I covers the transfer of the
FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE, hereinafter referred to as the IIFSLP,II
distributed by PTI to the City.
The terms of the Agreement are as follows:
1. PTI agrees that it shall provide the Fire Station Location Package to
the Ci ty, i nc 1 ud i ng :
a. Those products and services described under Section VI, Project
Tasks, of this Agreement.
b. On-site and other technical assistance as described under Section
VIII, Work Schedule, of this Agreement.
2. The City agrees to complete those responsibilities described under
Section VII, Management Plan and to pay PTI the sum of $12,500 (Twelve Thousand
Five Hundred Dollars), said sum to be full and complete compensation for
services to be delivered by PTI to the City under this Agreement. The total sum
would be payable at the time the contract is executed.
3. The City agrees not to make the programs or any other part of FSLP
available to any other jurisdictions or organizations without prior written
approval from PTI.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto set their hands and seals and
to a dup1 icate thereof thi s _day of _ , 1988.
THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO,
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
PUBLIC TECHNOLOGY, INC.
BY /tf! ~l~L~
TITLE . L..-L. ---<-
BY
TITLE
i i i
, I
III. OBJECTIVES OF THE WORK
The objective of this proposal is to introduce a proven technology for fire
services evaluation and planning that will provide the City of San Bernardino
Fire Department with the means to make better, more defensible decisions about
the number, type, and location of fire stations that are needed to meet locally
derived response time objectives.
This technology, entitled the Fire Station Location Package (FSLP), is a
computer-based planning and management tool. It will provide fire department
and local management personnel with a means to analyze the adequacy of existing
fire services and develop alternative plans resulting in a more efficient utili-
zation of resources and a more equitable distribution of services throughout the
community.
The FSLP supports improved evaluation and planning by comparing response
times resulting from specific fire station configurations with those established
as objectives by the local project team. These comparisons are done on a neigh-
borhood-by-neighborhood basis, for complete fire districts and for the community
as a whole.
Travel distances or travel times from each neighborhood to existing or pro-
posed fire station sites are determined by using a computer-readable version of
the community's street network. The network accurately traces the paths fire
trucks take in traveling to fires. It takes into account actual physical
barriers to travel, such as rivers, freeways, or railroad tracks. The network
also allows the local project team to analyze accurately the impact that changes
in the community's current transportation network, such as a new railroad over-
pass or an emergency traffic light control system, may have on fire service
delivery.
1
. .
IV. RESULTS
The primary results of the proposed work are:
1. The application of an operational, proven technology -- the Fire
Station Location Package (FSLP) -- in the City of San Bernardino.
2. The development of an equitable, efficient plan for the distribution
of fire stations that is responsive to various policy constraints
established by fire department and local administrative and elected
officials.
V. BENEFITS
The use of the FSLP has not only improved the delivery of fire services,
but has also often resulted in substantial savings in capital and operating
costs. For example, Gainesville, Florida changed its capital plan, saving
$500,000 in capital construction and $1,500,000 in operating costs over three
years. Oshawa, Ontario, Canada was able to save over $5 million by relocating
existing stations rather than building additional ones. Attachment 4 is a table
identifying more than 120 communities of all population ranges in North America
that have satisfactorily used the package.
Utilization of the FSLP will have significant benefits in terms of
improving the delivery of services through the development of a more efficient
configuration of fire stations while holding the line on costs. Benefits can be
realized in a number of ways:
2
o Improved data management and planning capability within the Fire Depart-
ment and enhanced opportunities for interdepartmental coordination.
o A mechanism for rapid and thorough analysis of the impacts of alterna-
tive fire station configurations and changes in the street system and
growth patterns in the community.
o Increased efficiency in the delivery of fire services through the
development of a fire station configuration that reduces response time
while equalizing fire protection coverage throughout the community.
o Decisions that can be defended before elected officials and community
groups because they are objective and based upon sound, comprehensible
procedures.
o Data bases that can be used for dispatching and determining move-up
policies, and developing property and fire hydrant management systems.
VI. PROJECT TASKS
This project will consist of the following tasks:
1. Establish Project
This task will primarily consist of an identification of needs and goals,
definition of study areas and project scope, and the assembly of a project team
consisting of management and technical personnel from affected agencies who will
be involved in project implementation. The City will have primary responsibil-
ity for the completion of this task in consultation with PTI. PTI will provide
on-site orientation for all technical team members on the FSLP and assistance to
the management team in establishing the project. PTr will also provide user
documentation on the FSLP project management and a sample task-time chart to
support this task (see Attachments 1 and 2).
3
. .
2. Provide Training and Data Collection Procedures
PTr will provide on-site training of local personnel in FSLP data collec-
tion requirements and procedures and will also provide all worksheets. PTI will
also provide on-going technical assistance during the data collection phase in
the form of telephone contacts, and written correspondence. Actual data
collection will be the responsibility of the City. To ensure efficient use of
local staff resources, PTr staff will instruct local personnel in organizing and
controlling data collection procedures.
3. Data Processing
PTr shall provide on-site training of local personnel in FSLP data pro-
cessing requirements and procedures, along with complete user documentation on
data processing, including error edits, sample job control, and output reports.
PTr shall provide a computer tape containing all the Fire Station Location
Package programs in source code form along with test data. The programs shall
become the property of the City of San Bernardino to be used in the future as
needed.
PTr will assist local data processing staff install the computer programs
and run them with test data. PTr will provide unlimited technical support over
the phone to support this task and on-site assistance if required.
If desired, PTI will provide all data entry and processing services to sup-
port the FSLP at an additional cost not included in the current contract. Data
editing and network calibration will be accomplished in conjunction with the
local staff. All policy inputs to guide data processing runs will be the
responsibility of the City.
Data editing and street network calibration, in which the computer gene-
rated response time estimates are validated, will be accomplished in conjunction
with local staff.
4
4. Analysis of Existing Fire Services and Development of Alternative Plans
PTI will demonstrate how to use the FSLP output to analyze strengths and
weaknesses of current fire protection services. This will involve an on-site
visit. PTI will train staff in procedures for developing alternative fire
station configurations within a framework of policy constraints and assist them
in analysis of proposed plans. Selection of a final recommended plan will be
the responsibility of local staff. PTI will provide response time objectives
used by other FSLP jurisdictions of similar size as a guide to staff along with
sample final reports and presentations.
5. Presentation of Final Results
If requested, PTI will provide on-site assistance to the project team in
presenting final project results to elected officials, citizen groups, and city
employees.
VII. MANAGEMENT PLAN
Responsibilities of the City of San Bernardino
This proposed work would involve a collaborative project between the City
of San Bernardino and Public Technology, Inc. As such, PTI would expect the
City to assume the following particular responsibilities:
1. The City would agree to appoint a single individual with the authority
to act as Project Leader for the FSLP project. The Project Leader
would be responsible for all project work performed by local staff
including data collection and analysis.
2. The City would also agree to implement the FSLP system in accordance
with Tasks 1 - 5 above, and to devote or obtain whatever resources are
necessary to ensure a successful implementation, including staff time,
equipment, material, or other resources.
5
. .
Attached to this proposal are resumes of PTI staff who will be available to
work on the FSLP project.
VIII. WORK SCHEDULE
Table 1 illustrates a work schedule which will accommodate the full project
in four months. The schedule is an estimate and is subject to change depending
upon the number of people working on data collection. The work schedule
delineates the major tasks in the project and their sequence.
Total price of the project outlined in this agreement is $12,500 (Twelve
Thousand Five Hundred Dollars). This will include the provision of technical
support to local staff involved in project planning, data collection, data
processing, and the development of alternative fire service plans that respond
to policy constraints provided by City management.
Total on-site technical assistance shall not exceed two (2) days, including
travel. The on-site assistance shall be provided through no more than one (1)
site visits. Additional on-site assistance can be provided, if requested by the
City, at the salary cost of the staff professional requested per day plus travel
and expenses.
PTI shall provide unlimited technical assistance by telephone and letters
throughout the first year of the project.
6
. .
ATTACHMENT 1
FSLP PROJECT TASK-TIME CHART
...
IX:
<
:z:
(J
w
:e
r:
"-
~
en
<
~
~
(J
w
.,
0
g: en
z ~
w
0 w
;:: ~
< ~
(.)
0
....
z
2
~
<
t-
en
w
IX:
u:
o .
~
~
~
CI)
N W
~ IX:
0 Z
- 0
CI)
ClJ IX:
en W
ll:J A.
~
~ ..-
~ -- ____..00._
;$; -
~
N
C")
--;:::; --
C")
~__ 0_.00'
o
C")
Q')
N
OJ
N
,......
N
\.0
__N
l.{')
~--~ f-------...
~
~-_.-
C")
-~
N
--...'"
......
C\..
~
Q')
-,......
co
-
,. +-- - 1------
r-- --
,......
-
--.. i.O -'--0- ...
--.'::' ___ 0'"
L."l
-
-------
.--...........--_.
-_..~
....u . "--..._
-.--
0..-._-
..---
~
----- ---
-------
-- I-- -- __.
......-..
-.- '--- .
'-- -
-0__- t--- .__~~_~_
'-'- -..-----r----
--.- .---.---
.._~..
...f--'---.-- '--'--
._-~. - --. -......
-..---..- --'..
..--~-==~J=~---..---.
_n. _ --}--_ ..._1-__1---.
~. -..-_. -- ----- -'-
~
__~_o
C")
~
'"
......
......
--5 -_..._-- - -..--
.-
---'''-- ...
0'>
-en
~
en
<(
~
"'-1--_'
. ~--
,......
\.0
l.{')
'l:1'
t"":
C'..
.....
o
o
VI
-
It; "0
o C
(.!) rti
~+'''O
~ en ~~;~
o C ClJll:J.cN
S- or- ~ QJ U ll:J
COll:J~ -J:
QJtO +' ~
"~a. U~VI~VI
~ ~ ct: .~ QJ U IU +' C
~;~:g~ f'~j~~
~ +' ll:J c.. .~ So. U
c.. >, V) c.. VI QJ ~ c.... .....
QJr-+' ~
~;:; ~ ~'u"f~ ~ ~.;;;
.....c..........CQJOll:Jll:JVI
a:: QJ't~ ~~ 5:~ ~ ~
c:tk 0 ~ c:t < c:t U U U
~-
~ "roc..> ci LLJu..
,...;
_. -.-._~.._..-..-
.. --- L--- _..... --...-
-- t--.....
...__ ___ - u.. _0_'_
,.. --- -'- '--' -..
_"0 .._ _____.
.--
------.-
--T'--~-~
-~--I.'I_ _u.._
I
! .. ---
..----
1--1-'
~---
>, ~~
U
I "0 ll:J ct:ll:J +'
VI 0 C S- a4-' C
"0 "0 ~ IU I I ::3 ~tO+, ~
~ s- VI ~ U
ll:J ll:J "0 QJ+' ~ U LLJ U C
N N c: "'QJW 00 ct: z: QJ Cl
ll:J ll:JVI ll:J ..... QJ ~ VI'" ....
:I: :I:QJ Vl.c 0- +'0- s- LLJQJQJ VI
c: 0\ VlQJ QJQJ 0 ~ 0 ~VI
- -0 C c~... z: +' ~ ~co ~ct:
~ ION ~ OS-V) Vl 0
..... :::;..r:: .r- 0 +' VI COO+' ~~
+' VI VI "'3..r:: QJ..r:: "O/tl.....
.c ..... VI .....QJ ll:J +' ~ .-::: ~ ~~ ~ ~ QJQJ
C..... X~ ...+3..... z~
ct:~..... .....- LLJ ..... Vlc3 "'3 UOU/tltO ~
.0 Vl ..... Vl QJ ~ ~ B3
~>, >,10 ~r- "'0- A.';; ~ .c ~ o. 0\
ct: ~ VI ~+' ::3 c.. QJ U OE Itl C
c~~ ..... VI ..... It: a r- 0- ~ Cc:t~ VI ~C~
+' LLJ +' .~ -- ';;'; QJ::3..... c..s.. .o.r- QJ
t-C4J') C C+' -tOtO ..... a.c:::: 0 ..... to +'
UQJttl QJ"O QJC ..... us.. > ~ > >,0 C C s.. _+J+,
LLJ _ "Oc "OQJ ..... 0 to ~~ &~~~~~ Itl.o to
--'..... U ..... ttl ~.1 -t.J L.I... L.I... c.. uOn.
--' .....
a . U ci ~t!i81<i~
U co W UO
N M
.,. .
;
I
2
CI)
N W
It- a:
0 z
N 0
CI)
ell a:
0\ w
co a..
c...
1.0
-!:l
""
...r:;:)
;s;
~ .----
N
M
.......
M
0
M
en
N
co
N
CI)
~
~
~
'0
~
en
<
I-
,.....
I-N
1.0
-~_.
l.(")
C"-.J
~
N
M
~_..
N
N
~
R:
en
.......
.-- --.-
co
-~ 0-----.
r-.
1-=.....-
1.0
.......
t!)
.......
c:::-
-~~.
M
~
-;:
~
en
._--_..I---~.
c:c "-___
r--
~
U":
..;:
f":
C\.
--
C
C
+.) en
c:: en
-g ~ ~G
co ~ .~l ;: ~
en VI en '-
~~.:e ~~
co ..- c:: lO
NU+.) O:X:
co c:: ~
~:X:U;>~ ~~
>NN'- IX
-O::J en
~1.L..c:u .c:Q)
U en en>
~ ~;:: ~ f;:: ~
co >,.0 >, elI.o U
O..-/O..-+.)/OQ)
/0 +.) co +.) +.) '1"")
~~~~~~g
-
I.L.
~< a:. u
~
..__ ..- 1----
C::I
::J ~ Q)
IX COOl
~,-:i~
Oell ell
-+.)~>
~::JC::O
-~ItlU
OE
ZOVlQ)
Ou.c:c::
u +.).....
Q) 0'; r-
WI::C::elI
::.:: f! :G
-lCIJ+)C:O
WIIlVl
~~ >,'0
co ~
c::..... Vl
:x:.....,CIJ
VlItlI::IIl
-"ClJIII
-l.o"OCIJ
!CO....... ~
Vl . .
W co
l.(")
-=1=_
.
Itl I
E ~
VlQ) IIIU
~~ ~&";O~
-ct r- c::c...
~ c..."O.....
c( Q) c:: u.. "0
o N ~ Itl c::
Z >, ell It! CIJ
Wr- "OVI VI
~~ C::VlO
oct ~~~~.
U Oor-Itl
W "0 '- ell
IX ~ U c... VI r-
Itl ell c:: CL.
o lX"O-
Z:~ c::.....-
c(~Vlt~~t~
VlCIJG./CIJ::J"OOO
_>>r-UC:OU
~~:;:; ~g ~& /0
-l
ct
Z .
c(ct cou
I.D
!
--L.-,-- ~---
I
;;c J
-/00"
z>.....u
~e~~~
~+.)~~
~~~Wc;>
ct Ec:C:
Ir- CIJ Itl.....
z: Ir- r- r- ~
o ::J ~CL. Vl
-ILL- E
~I::-~~
~!-.-c::+.)o
z: Itl.... ..... r-
~~ ~s ~
WOCO;:EW
~I
~l< ccu
,..:
, .
ATTACHMENT 2
FSLP DOCUMENTATION TABLE OF CONTENTS
CONTENTS
PART I - PROJECT LEADER'S GUIDE
Section 1: PROJECT EXECUTION
1.1.1
1.1.2
1.1.3
Study Package Documentation ..................................
Identify Practical Uses of Package ...........................
Consult Key Departments ......................................
1-1
1-3
1-3
1-5
1-6
1-8
1-11
CONTENTS
....... ... ... ... ...... ............ ...... .... ........ ... ..........
1.0
INTRODUCTION ........................................................
1.0.1 Assemble Proj ect Team ........................................
1.1
DETERMINE PROJECT APPLICABILITY .....................................
1.2 DETERMINE PROJECT FEASIBILITY ....................................... 1-13
1.2.1 Prepare Project Workp1an ..................................... 1-13
1.3 BEGIN PROJECT OPERATIONS .................................... ~ · · · · · .. 1-14
1.3.1 Obtain Decision on Implementation ............................ 1-19
1.3.2 Implement proj ect Workplan ................................... 1-19
Section 2: DATA COLLECTION GUIDELINES
CONTENTS
................ ....... ......... .......... ....... ... ... .... ......
2-1
2 . 0 SET UP FOR WORK ..................................................... 2 - 3
2.0.1 Process Location Constraints ................................. 2-3
2.0.2 Set Bounds on Data Collection ................................ 2-3
2.1 IDENTIFY DEMAND FOR FIRE PROTECTION ................................. 2-5
2.1.1 Define Extent of Study Area ..................................2-5
2.1.2 Establish Property Analysis Guidelines ....................... 2-6
2.1.3 Establish Guidelines for FDZ/Focal Point Configurations...... 2-13
2.1.4 Distribute FDZ/Focal Point Worksheets ........................ 2-17
2.1.5 Group FDZ's AccordL~g to Their Strategic Importance .......... 2-18
i
2.2 IDENTIFY SOURCES OF FIRE STATION SUPPLy............................. 2-18
2.2.1 Process Station Site Proposals .............................. 2-18
2.2.2 Distribute Station Site Worksheets ........................... 2-20
2.3 GUIDE PREPARATION OF STREET NETWORK ................................. 2-20
2.3.1 Establish Network Guidelines ................................. 2-21
2.3.2 Distribute Link Worksheets ................................... 2-23
Section 3: DATA PROCESSING GUIDELINES
CONTENTS
............ ...... ................ .... ...........................
3-1
3.0 SET l1P FOR WORK ..................................................... 3-3
3.0.1 Begin Computer Operations .................................... 3-3
3.1.1
3.1.2
Set Up PATH Run Sequence .....................................
Adjust Network Policy Assumptions ............................
3-6
3-6
3-7
3-21
3-22
3-25
3-29
3.1
CALIBRATE STREET NETWORK ............... 1 . . . . · · . . · · · . · · . . . · · · . · . . · · . .
3.2
~'lALYZE STATION SITE OPTIONS ........................................
3.2.1 Beg in LOCATION Run Sequence ..................................
3.2.2 Review LOCATION Baseline Results .............................
3.2.3 Finish LOCATION Run Sequence .................................
Section 4: PROJECT REVIEW
CONTENTS ................................................................. 4-1
4.0 DEVELOP INFORMATION BASE ............................................ 4-2
4.0.1 P-.s semble Background Data ..................................... 4-2
4.1 PRESENT PROJECT FINDINGS ............................................ 4-3
4.1.1 Prepare Station Site Options Comparison ...................... 4-4
4.1.2 Estimate Benefits of Implementation ..........................4-4
ii
PART II - PROJECT OPERATIONS GUIDE
Section 5: GETTING READY
CONTENTS
.................................................................
5-1
5.0 INTRODUCTION..... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . .. 5-2
5.0.1 Study Package Document at ion .................................... 5-2
5.1 BEGIN PROJECT OPERATIONS ............................................. 5-2
5.1.1 Meet with Project Team .......................................... 5-4
5.1.2 Study the Response Time Concept .............................. 5-4
5.1.3 Study Basic Uses of the Technology........................... 5-8
Section 6: DATA COLLECTION
CONTENTS
6-1
6. 0 SET UP FOR WORK ..................................................... 6-2
6.0.1 Acquire Maps of Community ..................................... 6-2
6.0.2 Begin Analysis of Street Network ............................. 6-2
6.1 IDENTIFY DEMAND FOR FIRE PROTECTION ................................. 6-5
6.1.1 Create Fire Hazard Analysis Districts ........................ 6-5
6.1.2 Establish Property Analysis Guidelines ....................... 6-8
6.1.3 Develop FDZ/Focal Point Configurations ....................... 6-8
6.1.4 Fill Out FDZ/Focal Point Worksheet ........................... 6-17
6.1.5 Group Fire Demand Zones According to Their Strategic
Importance .................................................... 6-24
6.2 IDENTIFY SOURCES OF FIRE STATION SUPPLy............................. 6-25
6.2.1 Identify Station Sites ........................................ 6-25
6.2.2 Fill Out Station Site Worksheet .............................. 6-28
6.3 PREPARE STREET TRk~SPORTATION NETWORK .............................. 6-31
6.3.1 Draw In Basic Transportation Network ......................... 6-31
6.3.2 Fill Out Link Characteristics Worksheets ..................... 6-37
iii
Section 7:
DATA PROCESS ING
7.0.1
7.0.2
Acquire Computer Programs ....................................
7-1
7-3
7-3
7-5
7-5
7-9
7-10
7-14
7-20
7-20
7-26
CONTENTS
7.0
SET 'UP FOR WORK. .....................................................
Run Test Data
7.1
R'UN mE P AIR PROGRAM ................................................
7.1.1 Execute Program Adjustments ..................................
7.1.2 Prepare Input to PATH Program ................................
7.1.3 Eliminate Errors From Output Displays ........................
7.2
R'UN THE LOCATION PROG~ ............................................
7.2.1 Process Policy Input to LOCATION Program .....................
7 . 2.2 Examine Ol1tput Displays ......................................
Section 8:
RUN COLLATING
cor;TENTS ................................................................. 8-1
8.0 CAT.!\LOG CO~UTER OUTPUT ............................................. 8-2
8.0.1 File PATH Output Displays ....................................8-2
8.0.2 File LOCATION Ol1tput Displays ................................ 8-3
8 . 1 REPORT Rtm RESULTS .................................................. 8-4
8.1.1 Prepare PATH Run Report (Optional) ........................... 8-4
8.1.2 Prepare LOCATION Run Abstract ................................ 8-5
APPENDIX A.
APPENDIX B.
APPENDIX C
APPENDIX D
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
A-I
REFERENCE LIST ............. ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. B-1
SAMPLE JOB CONTROL INFO&~TION .............................. C-l
SAMPLE COMPUTER OUTPUT DISPLAYS ............................. D-l
iv
ATTACHMENT 3
RESUMES
RES U M E
SUSAN B BENTON
EXPERIENCE
Member Set'vices Officet', Public Technology, Inc. ,
Washington, D.C.
1 gaS - Pt'esent
Responsible for' integt'ating the var'iety of set'vices and
activities provided to over' 155 PTI city and county
membet's. Directs PTI I S national seminar' and wOt'kshop
seri es whi ch pt'ovi des techni cal and management tt'ai ni ng
to over' 500 local government officials annually.
WOt'kshops developed for such at'eas as i nfot'mati on mastet'
planning, privatization, ct'eative pat'tnet'ships in the
publ ic sectot', and str'ategic planning. Initiated a
na ti ona 1 pr'ogram for' ass is ti ng key 1 oca 1 gover'nment
offici a1 s i ntr'oduce and manage change wi thi n thei r'
jUt'isdiction and developed wOt'kshops for building change
agent sl< ill s. Respons i b 1 e for 1 i nk i ng COt'pot'ate
t'esources to the needs of local govet'nment in such
technical areas as information planning, public safety
communication systems and geogt'aphic information
systems.
Pt'ogt'am Manager, Public Technology, Inc.
Respons i b 1 e for dit'ecti ng PTI IS fi re set'vi ce pr'ogt'am
which offers the most widely-used computed based
pl anni ng tool s for' local govet'nment fi t'e set'vices.
Pt'OV; des mnanagement and technical assi stance and
tt'ai ni ng fOt, the Fit'e Stati on Locati on Pacl<age, and the
FIRE MASTER system. Specializes in intt'oducing a
Ct'oss-depar'tmental, team appt'oach to develop ct'eative
solutions fat' public safety issues. Pt'ovides assistance
in the at'eas of schedul i ng, management tt'ai ni ng, and
pet'sonnel/administr'ative policy t'eview and development.
1982-1985
Business Managet', Public Technology, Inc.
Responsible for administration and coot'dination of man-
agement and pl anni ng projects for the Depa t'tment of
Urban Systems and Pt'oducts. Assisted local govet'nment
officials with the implementation of computet'-based man-
agement systems.' Responsible fOt, the at'eas of financial
and budget management and systems mar'keti ng.
1980 - 1982
Comptt'oll et' - Cat'; bbeana Counc; 1, Wash; ngton, D.C.
Supet'vised domestic and over'seas offices of
; nter'nati onal economi c development ot'gan; zati on.
Managed feder'a1 and non-federal gr'ants in the at'eas of
agt'ibusiness and technology tr'ansfer.
Graduate Assistant, Ot'ganizationa1 Behaviot' and
Development. The Amet'ican Univer'sity, Washington, D.C.
1978
.
Responsi bl e for the t'eseat'ch and or'gani zati on of a book
on human resour'ce development. Developed annotated
bibl iography on pub1 ic uti1 ity t'egu1 ation for t'egul ator'y
text.
EDUCATION
MBA
Amet'ican Univer'sity, Washington, D.C. 1979
BA Indiana Univer'sity of Pennsylvania (Sociology/
Psychology) 1973
HONORS AND ACTIVITIES Gt'aduate Fellowship, Amet'ican University, Washington,
D.C.
Publications
Member, D.C. Ur'ban Management Association.
"Analyzing Firefighter' Scheduling Policies and Options.1I
Management I nfotma ti on Set'v; ce Repor't, I ntet'nati ona1
City Management Association, Washington, D.C., December
1985.
IIA Computet'ized Appt'oach to Fi r'e Station Location."
Management Infor'mation Set'vice Repot't, Intet'nationa1
City Management Association, Washington, D.C., July
1987.
ATTACHMENT 4
FSLP and FIRE MASTER MASTER USERS LIST
..
:E:
l.&J
l-
V')
>-
V')
0:::
l.&J
l-
V')
<
:E:
l.&J r--.
0::: co
- ~
LL. .-
Z
00 L.
z- QJ
<~~
l.&J-IQJ
c.!:'~+oJ
< 0.. 0.
~o QJ
uo..V')
<
0.. >- ~
CO en
Z ::l
o V') 0
-O:::L.
I- l.&J ~
<V')I-
U~
o
-I
Z
o
-
I-
<
l-
V')
~l
-
LL.
-
I-
0..
Z
-
-Ie
I5lI
o
:E:
-Ie
<
U
I-
~
< ><
VI.. 0 _ -I :1- < ~ ~ z.
o U 3:" O"U U U <I:
8 -I.....z VlNU 0 VlU
.. - '0 I- ~ ~; < QJ'C ; ~'u ..
g ;~tA'~~~ :~3 ~~~ ~
In ~~~ g,~c5'c-l~oo~'~
L. u..... 0. +oJ 3 QJ +oJ c::
~ :c-g ~;::: ~~-;O ~ ~ ~ ~.;
o U - :E: :E: :E: Z 0.. V') V') V') V') V') 3:
-Ie
I5lI
ZZ
<<
Uu
o -Ie ~
o I5lI 0....
q ~<~~ ...~.~
o :I:>< Uu >,L. L. >-
o 01-.. .. +JIOIO Z<
In ~ .. "~';.c.~~;;U ~~~ ..U~
~~..... U U.-Z OOU L. ..
o ';IO~U~~&. ...:~ .... ..~~.;
o +oJ.- 0 VI coco IO~.- 0 10 10 U VI O+J
o c:: QJ 3: 10 QJ L. 0 ~ :J; 3 QJ QJ "'? .....
o ~~ .~2'g'~~'t~~~.g-5c::'5
In +oJ.- +oJ 10 0 0..... QJ 0 ~ +J +J ::l 0 10.....
N <ULL.~-I-I:E:ZZOOOO'O:::V')3:
Z ~~
~ ~ ~~
< U 0 < Z C::c::
~ > U>< ~U 0 ~ ~~
o LL. 0" I- ..... QJ QJ
o >, ..... VI .. ~ L. < .. ~ ~
0..>, +oJ -Ie; g' :E: >,~ 10 ~ >0 <I: U~
~ ~ ~ ~~~'L:4::5 < ;~~~cl~~ .. s ;'~< >:E~ 5 ~.?~5< e11-< i
N 5 ~ U 0 I- 0 .. ~'L: ..:I: U ~ 08 c:: ,; .. .. ~ :;; ~ ~ U -I ~ ~ ~ ~ -Ie .. ~ U ~ .. ~ ~:i U U -;0
I U c::u....QJ ~+JO ..0.L. 0.- L. QJ 0 ZO "-+oJ V')V') SI QJ L. QJ 10 10 .. .. ..V')
"0 +oJC::+oJOUL. QJIOO+oJ+J.-QJ.-o:::.... 1O::l" >>~QJ~C::C::~" "'OC:: I
g ~.~ ~ ,; ~ E t: -g VI 8. ; -;0 0::: ~ ~ ~.; ~::: QJ ; ; t cO ~ .; ~ ~ .; .; Z Z .:;; ~ ~ ~ < ~ ~ ~ ; E ;
o ~ QJ c:: L. C 0..- L. ::l c:: 0 ~ ~ c:: c::..... VI ~ >.- VI VI 0 3 '0 ..... VI..... c:: c:: .. .. L. 0.. CO 10 c:: 10 10 I+- ~ +J
o ~ ~:= ~ ~ !6 ~ ~ E- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :0:; i" ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ..... .~ g g ~ . ~ c:: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~
o .- c:: L. ::l QJ L. ~ 0 0 10 10.- L. L. 3 ::l ::l..... c::..... 10 10 QJ VI 10 QJ 0 10 ~ QJ QJ QJ..... +J 10 10 10 10 0. 0. +J +oJ .....
~ <<<<COCOUUUOOc.!:'c.!:'~c.!:':I::I:~~-I:E::E:ZOo..o..o..O:::O:::O:::O:::O:::O:::V')V')V')V')V')V')V')V')V')3:
~s~
~
s z:
~ ~ 5
ll!SI <U V') u< ..
o 0 0 < u.. ~ < "U QJ >-
g 5 U-I :E: 0.. L. U 8. ..'L: 8Z
>< LL.z.. ..<;~ ~ < ..VI 10 10 ..~
o 1-" I- 0 VI.. U QJ V') c:: > QJ::l -I L. U >,..... L. :E: -Ie ....J.. VI
o >< '0 :E: < :E: < c:: QJ U ~ 0 >< ..... 0 - < 10 +oJ .0 10 "'? < _ L. c:: ..
~ I- .. ..... U e5 3: ......- .. c:: ....... I- > U U 0.. < .. 8 ..... 0.0 . z: U QJ..... c::
..;.~~..'; ..;:::;:-B~~~~ ..c::~.: ..~US~ UVI~~.. ..C;;t:~E
o ~ +J 't; g' ~..... ; t 8 ~ 'i ~ g :E: ~ ~ .~ > ~.~ ;.; < .. 0 -g 'S co <1 ;.g 10 .~ 0.. ~
o Q) g'L...... IO~ c:: QJ Q) c:: 0.Q) L.~ IO+J~O" L..- L. 0'- O-lIO+J+oJ QJ g'E QJ.....
o .-..... QJ.- .0 ::l QJ L. +oJ c:: QJ QJ L. QJ U.- c:: +J 10 L. 10 0 C::.CI. 3 +oJ.- C::.- ~ +J +J E
-'-~'-L..-enQJL.-QJ'033C::~::lL.~+JQJc::.-IOQ)~C::C::::lQJ.-::lVl_.-
~ ~~~~~8~~~~~~~3~i~~~5~~~~~0:::~~~~~~~~3
-Ie
z:
<
U
z:
<
U
Z
<
U
.
0..
:E:
0:::
LL.
-I 10 U
18 I ~ ~ 8 6 :I: -I ~ ~ ~ 5 < < -I co
0.., ~ '5 -Ie 85 .. ..=:E: < 0- ..;::~ ..';UULL.L."
o I + < >< 10 >< ll!SI c:: VI" 3....< >, < +J +J .. .. .. QJ +
In ~;U ~ I- ~ I- ~ ~ .; E.~ ;; i ~ -Ie ....J ..a i ~ 3: ~ .~ < .....: 5 ~ (ij ~ ~ ~ ~
en" .. .. 0.....u.-L.OU:I:LL.3 0.-.. U3:L..-OEIOL..-o
.. 10 10 .. c:: 10 c:: .. 0 QJ......- ::l +J 0 QJ" +J..... 10" QJ .....:Ii: QJ I+- U ..... U ..
o E L...... L. 3 c:: 0 c:: 3..... L. O~ VI" ....... L. QJ >..... QJ 10 .. Q):I: .- 10 > c:: c::
g ~ ~ ~ ~ E E .~ S ~ t ~ U Q) ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ B :; ~ ~ g' ~ 8 0 ~ ~ U 0::: ~ ~ ~ s:
10 U U c:: >, >, c:: c:: en..... Q) ..-:;n E c:: 2' c:: c:: ~ 0. >, 10 c:: VI ~ U U c:: c:: c:: +oJ .-
In 01 c:: L. 10 10 10 QJ QJ c:: 10 L. +J 10 10 cD QJ 10 0 QJ.... 10.- L. 10 10 QJ 0 0 10 10 10..... ......
N <<<COCOOOOl.&JLL.LL.LL.~:I::I:~-I-I:Ii::E:zooo..o..O:::O:::O:::V')V')V')I-3:3:
QJ
Q):;n
~IO
+oJ ~
U
a3~
I
1015 <~
I~ QJ ~ ~
l~ -g 5 ~ I-
10 I- c:: Q)
c:: L.:Ii: .. .... ~
I~ ~ .. ~ ~ ~~
j+oJ ~ ~ '; .. V') ~
I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~
I~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
.- +J
IOC::
U QJ
E
>,QJ
.- en
VI 10
::l c::
010
-r- :E
>
QJ QJ
L.u
0.L.
::l
L.O
QJVI
+.JQ)
VI 0:::
10
L. VI :Ii: QJ
QJVlo.. L.
+.J QJ -I QJ.....
VI L.V') L.LL.
10 ~ LL. .....
:Ii: 0 LL.
L. 0
QJ 0.. L.
L. U..
..... c::..... Q)
LL.-:E:+J
o
S-le + Z
, .
FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE TRANSFER AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this ________day of
___________________, 1988, by and between PUBLIC TECHNOLOGY,
INC., 1301 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C.,
hereinafter referred to as "PTI", and THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO,
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, hereinafter referred to as the "City",
covers the transfer of the FIRE STATION LOCATION PACKAGE,
hereinafter referred to as the "FSLP", distributed by PTI to the
City.
The terms of the Agreement are as follows:
SECTION I.
A. PTI agrees that it shall provide the Fire Station
Location Package to the City, including:
1. Those products and services
described under Section II, Project
Tasks, of this Agreement.
2. On-site and other technical
assistance as described under
Section IV, Additional Services, of
this Agreement.
B. The City agrees to complete those responsibilities
described under Section III, Management Plan and to pay
PTI the sum of $12,500 (Twelve Thousand Five Hundred
Dollars), said sum to be full and complete compensation
for services to be delivered by PTI to the City under
this Agreement. Ninety percent (90%) of the total
purchase price will be payable at the time the contract
is executed. The remaining ten percent (10%) will be
held by the City to be paid over to PTI at the time the
project is complete, as determined by City's project
leader.
C. The City agrees not to make the programs or any other
part of FSLP available to any other jurisdictions or
organizations without prior written approval from PTI.
/ / /
/ / /
/ / /
1
SECTION II
Incorporated herein by reference are all representations
and covenants of PTI contained in that document entitled "An
Agreement to Transfer the Fire Station Location Package to the
City of San Bernardino, State of California, bearing date of
October 26, 1988.
PROJECT TASKS
This project will consist of the following tasks to be
performed by PTI:
A. Establish Project
This task consists of:
1: An identification of needs and
goals;
2: Definition of study areas and
project scope; and,
3: The assembly of a project team
consisting of management and
technical personnel from affected
agencies of the City who will be
involved in project implementation.
PTI will provide on-site orientation for all technical team
members on the FSLP.
PTI will provide on-site assistance to the management team
in establishing the project. Total on-site assistance will be
provided as set forth in Section IV of the work agreement.
PTI will provide user documentation on the FSLP project
management. PTI will prepare a task-time chart to support this
task. Said task-time chart will be in the form set forth in
attachments 1 and 2 of this Agreement.
B. Provide Training and Data Collection Procedures
1. PTI will provide on-site training of local personnel
in FSLP data collection requirements and procedures
and will also provide all worksheets.
2. PTI will provide on-going technical assistance during
the data collection phase in the form of telephone
contacts, and written correspondence.
JFW:ss
November 23, 1988
2
3. Actual data collection will be the responsibility of
the City.
4. PTI staff will provide on-site instruction to local
personnel in organizing and controlling data collection
procedures.
C. Data Processing
1. PTI shall provide on-site training of local personnel
in FSLP data processing requirements and procedures.
2. PTI will provide complete user documentation on data
processing, including, but not limited to, error edits,
sample job control, and output reports.
3. PTI shall provide a computer tape containing all the
Fire Station Location Package programs in source code
form along with test data. The programs shall become
the property of the City of San Bernardino to be used
in the future as needed.
4. PTI will assist local data processing staff in
installing the computer programs and running them with
test data. PTI will provide unlimited technical
support over the phone to support this task and two
days of on-site assistance if required by the City, at
no additional cost.
A. All data entry and processing services to
support the FSLP;
B. Data editing and network calibration to
be accomplished in conjunction with the local
staff.
C. Data editing and street network
calibration, in which the computer generated
response time estimates are validated, to be
accomplished in conjunction with local staff.
7. Policy inputs to guide data processing runs will be the
responsibility of the City.
8. Data editing and network calibration to be accomplished
in conjunction with the City staff.
/ / /
JFW:ss
November 23, 1988
3
9. If specifically requested by City, PTI will provide
total data entry and processing services to support the
FSLP, but this is not included in the price of this
Agreement.
D. Analysis of Existing Fire Services and Development of
Alternative Plans
1. PTI will demonstrate how to use the FSLP output to
analyze strengths and weaknesses of current fire
protection services. This will involve an on-site
visit.
2. PTI will train staff in procedures for developing
alternative fire station configurations within a
framework of policy constraints and assist them in
analysis of proposed plans.
3. PTI will provide response time objectives used by other
FSLP jurisdictions of similar size as a guide to staff
along with sample final reports and presentations.
4. Selection of a final recommended plan will be the
responsibility of City staff.
E. Presentation of Final Results
As part of the price of this contract, PTI will provide on-
site assistance to the project team in presenting final project
results to elected officials, citizen groups, and City employees,
including attendance at one meeting.
III. MANAGEMENT PLAN
Responsibilities of the City of San Bernardino
City hereby assumes the following particular
responsibilities:
A. The City will appoint a single individual with he
authority to act as Project Leader for the FSLP
project. The Project Leader will be responsible for
the timely performance of project work to be performed
by local staff, including data collection and analysis.
All work is to be performed in conformance with
requirements established by PTI for proper
implementation of the program.
JFW:ss
November 23, 1988
4
B. City will implement the FSLP system in accordance with
Project Tasks Section of this Agreement.
C. City will devote or obtain such resources as are
necessary to complete the implementation in conformance
with the Task Chart. Such requirements shall be
provided by PTI to the Project Leader in writing, prior
to the commencement of any task requiring City staff
participation.
IV ADDITIONAL SERVICE
A. Total on-site technical assistance shall not exceed two
(2) days. The on-site assistance shall be provided
through no more than one (1) site visit, except as
otherwise required by this Agreement.
B. PTI shall provide unlimited technical assistance by
telephone and letters throughout the first year of the
project.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto set their hands and
seals and to a duplicate thereof this _____________day of
, 1988.
THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
PUBLIC TECHNOLOGY, INC.
BY:
BY:
Mayor of the City of
San Bernardino
Title:
ATTEST:
City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND
LE..~1t-L CONTEN. T:
~J.~
~ City Attorney
JFW:ss
November 23, 1988
5