Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout44-Planning and Building CITYYOF SAN BERNQDINO - REQUEST Fo. COUNCIL ACTION From: Larry E. Reed, Director Dept: Planning and Building Services Date: March 11, 1991 Subject: Appeal of Planning Commission's Denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 Mayor and Common Council Meeting of April I, 1991, 2 :00 p.m. Synopsis of Previous Council action: On February 19, 1991, the Planning Commission, by a 5 to 1 vote, denied Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72. No previous Council actions. Recommended motion: That the hearing be closed; that the appeal be denied; and, that Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 be denied subject to the Findings of Fact contained in Exhibit "B." (Supports Planning Commission Action of Denial). OR That the hearing be closed; that the appeal be upheld; and, that Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 be approved subject to the Findings of Fact and Conditions of Approval contained in Exhibit "E." ~~ Signatu re Dlrector Contact person: Larry E. Reed Supporting data attached: Staff Report Phone: 384-5357 5 Ward: FUNDING REQUIREMENTS: Amount: N/A Source: Finance: Council Notes: 75-0262 Agenda Item No. J.f'f- CITY OF SAN BERN~DINO - REQUEST FcQ COUNCIL ACTION STAFF REPORT Subject: Appeal of planning commission's Denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 Mayor and Common Council Meeting of April 1, 1991 REOUEST The applicant, Mohammad Ali, is appealing the denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 by the planning commission. The applicant requests that the Mayor and Council reconsider the matter and approve Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72. BACKGROUND conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 is a request to establish a 2,500 square foot mini-market to include the off-site sale of beer and wine in an existing retail center located at the southeast corner of Kendall Drive and University Parkway (1689 Kendall Drive, suite A). This request was denied by the planning Commission on February 19, 1991 by a 5 to 1 vote. This proposal is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15301 (a), Class 1 exemption. The existing commercial retail center was approved by the Development Review Committee on December 29, 1988, under Review of Plans 86-143. In addition, Conditional Use Permit No. 90-22, a proposal to establish a mini-market which included the off-site sales of general liquor at the same location, was denied by the Planning commission on August 7, 1990. The previous applicant for Conditional Use Permit No. 90-22 had at least two negative encounters with law enforce- ment including convictions for sales to minors. According to staff, concerns about the previous applicant's history may have been the predominate reason for denial. The conclusions of the February 19, 1991 staff report (Exhibit "E") were: (1) that the crime statistics for the reporting district were below the city-wide average, but that there was a recent increase in residential burglary, vehicle burglary and auto theft in the area: (2) that the current applicant has had no history of negative encounters with law enforcement: (3) that the saturation level established by the ABC for off-site sales outlets for Census Tract 46 has been exceeded: and, (4) that, with appropriate Conditions of Approval, the proposal would be compatible with the surround- ing land uses. However, the Planning Commission felt because of the over-saturation and negative public testimony given at the hearing, including a letter of protest from California State University at San Bernardino, that an additional outlet was incompatible. 75-0264 j",\..".'y . . <' 0 Appeal of conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 Mayor and Common Council Meeting of April 1, 1991 Page 2 o OPTIONS AVAILABLE TO THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL The Mayor and Council may deny the tional Use Permit No. 90-72 or uphold Conditional Use Permit NO. 90-72. appeal and deny the appeal and Condi- approve RECOMMENDATION Staff's recommendation was for conditional approval, but the planning Commission denied the request by a 5 to 1 vote. prepared by: John Montgomery, AICP Principal Planner for Larry E. Reed, Director Planning and Building Services Exhibits: A - Letter of Appeal to the Mayor and Council B Statement of Official Planning commission Action C - Public Hearing Notice D - subsequent Letter of Protect Received Since February 19, 1991 Staff Report Preparation E - February 19, 1991, Planning commission Staff Report APPEALSRCUP9072 i!m1'.':'_'5.'Y"'.'-". - , . o () "-" MOHAMMAD All 17586 Mountain Court Riverside, CA 92503 (1/t./)68 J' - r;A6t5' roJ~rt6~uW~fTl LnJ MAR 0 4 1991 L!!J . February 28, 1991 CITY OF So',!\: 8ERNAliLJINQ' DEPARTMENT OF PlANN,NG & BUILDING ScRV!CES City Clerk City of San Barnadino 300 North D Street San Bernadino, CA HAND DELIVER Re: Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 To Whom It May Concern: Pursuant to Sections 2.64.030 and 2.64.040 of the San Bernadino Municipal Code, please find this letter as formal appeal for CUP No. 90-72 which was denied by the Planning Commission at the February 19, 1991 public hearing. Conditions and objectives of the San Bernadino General Plan and more specific- ally General Plan Policy 1.23.11 creating a "University Village Environment", have been met and accordingly, staff recommended approval for the approval of the Conditional Use Permit. The staff report prepared for the Planning Commission outlines the appropriate findings of fact which indicate that the Conditional Use Permit will not be detrimental to the health, safety and general welfare of the citizens of San Bernadino. I hereby request that Condtional Use Permit 90-72 be scheduled for public hearing before the City Council at the first availible hearing date. - Thank you in advance for your attention to this. Sincerely, ;t1v~"J a?' Mohammad A li cc: Denise Moonier EXHBIT "A" -. .. '__'~_~_"F" , . , . -0 ",:1 '-.-i city of San Bernardino STATEMENT OF OFFICIAL PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION PROJECT Number: conditional Use Permint No. 90-72 Applicant: Mohammad Ali owner: University square-San Bernardino Association Meeting Date: February 19, 1991 x Denied Based Upon the Attached Findings of Fact (Attachment B). VOTE Ayes: Nays: Abstain: Absent: Cole, Corona, Jordan, Lindseth, stone Sharp None Clemensen, Lopez I, hereby, certify that this statement of Official Action accurately reflects the final determination of the Planning commiS~.i= of :--.C~tY;f Z Bernardino. __ .> . ~ ~-(iJ. ~/ql S1gna e Date I Larrv E. Reed. Director of Plannina & Buildina services Name and Title cc: project Property owner project Applicant Building Division Engineering Division Case File PCAGENDA: PCACTION EXHIBIT "B" ~"",.,.;Ytffi'W"~'>:!I'.'=~=.....~ .., .,., , . . . {) ,. CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT AGENDA ITEM 6 SUMMARY HEARING DATE 2-19-91 WARD 5 , ~ /"'"'- r "" """l APPLICANT: Mohammad Al i u.I 17586 Mountain Court (I) CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-72 Riverside, CA 92503 C OWNER: University Square-S.B. Assoc. (.) 340 South Flower Street \. J'- Oranqe, CA 92668 ) r-- r "" 5 To establish a 2,500 square foot market to include the off-site sale of beer and wine in an existin9 retail center under the authority of Municipal ::l Code, Section 19.83.500. 0 u.I Located in a tenant space of a multi-tenant retail center on the south- II: - east corner of Kendall Drive and University Parkway at 1689 Kendall Drive, C Suite A. u.I II: C '--'" ;' EXISTING " GENERAL PLAN PROPFRlY I AND USE 20NING DI=SIGNATION Subject Multi-Tenant Retail CG-1 Commercial General North Apartments RM Residential Medium South Single-Family Residences RS Residential Suburban East Single-Family Residences RS Residential Suburban West Apartments RM Residential Medium \. ) ( GEOLOGIC I SEISMIC DYES ) FLOOD HAZARD 0 YES 0 ZONE A l( SEWERS: III YES ) HAZARD ZONE: 111 NO ZONE: II NO o ZONE B D NO ( HIGH FIRE DYES ) ''" AIRPORT NOISE! DYES....... I REDEVELOPMENT Il YES HAZARD ZONE: r1 NO CRASH ZONE: IXJ NO J \. PROJECT AREA: o NO ;'- 1'"0 NOT - ;' :""I "" -' o POTENTIAL SIGNIFICANT ~ [) APPROVAL ~ APPUCABLE EFFECTS WITH loIIT1GATlNG MEASURES - Z(I) NOE.I.R. !C [) CONDITIONS u.lCJ ""Cl 2Z [XI ~i'f;1m 15301 o E.I.R REQUIRED BUT NO ""Z 0 DENIAL Z- SIGNIFICANT EFFECTS Cu.I OCl Cl ass 1 WITH MTlGATlNG tn2 II:~ MEASURES :I 0 CONTINUANCE TO -"" > o NO SIGNIFICANT o SIGNIFICANT EFFECTS 0 ffi (.) EFFECTS SEE ATTACHED E.R.C. u.I I.. ) MINUTES II: \. ) \. ...- --- o PL.AN-1.G2 PAGE' OF , (.-10) O"fCl'....~ --- . . '0 ATTACHMENT B CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT CASE CUP NO. 90-72 FINDINGS OF FACT AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE ~-l~-~l PAGE ,. 1. The proposed market use is in conformance with the objectives of the City's General Plan, in that food markets with off-site beer and wine sales are permitted in the CG-1, Commercial General, land use designation subject to the approval of a Conditional Use Permit. 2. The proposed use will adversely affect the adjoining land uses and the growth and development of the area in which it is to be located due to the over concentration, in the vicinity of a residential area, of convienence stores with off-site sales of beer and wine available . 3. The size and shape of the site proposed for the use is adequate to allow the full development of the proposed use in a manner not detrimental to the particular area nor to the peace, health and general welfare in that the commercial development on the site was approved under Review of Plans No. 86-143. 4. The traffic generated by the proposed use will not impose an undue burden upon the streets and highways designed and improved to carry the traffic in the area, in that Review of Plans No. 86-143 was evaluated by the City Traffic Engineer who determined that the commercial center would not significantly impact existing patterns of circulation, and the Planning Division determined that the commercial development provides sufficient off-street parking to serve the proposed use. 5. Based on the above noted Findings, the granting of Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 will be detrimental to the peace, health and safety and general welfare of the citizens of the City of San Bernardino. ... ~=--=== .... PL.AN-l.08 PAGE 1 OF 1 (4-110) - - , ' o o OFFICIAL NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE'THE CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO MAYOR AND COMMON COUNCIL APPEAL OF The Denial of Conditional Use Pennit No. 90-72 THIS IS TO INFORM YOU THAT THE FOLLOWING ITEM HAS BEEN APPEALED TO THE MAYOR AND COMMON COUNCIL BY Applicant .... SUBJECT: WARD '* CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-72 5 PROPERTY Located on'the southwest corner of Kendall Drive and LOCATION: University Parkway at 1689 Kendall Drive, Suite A . PROPOSAL: To establish a 2,500 square foot mini-market which includes the off-site sale of beer and wine in an existing retail center r PUBLIC HEARING LOCATION: SAN BERNARDINO CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS 300 NORTH "0" Sl~ I SAN BERNARDINO, CA,92418 HEARING OATE AND TIME: Monday, April I, 1991, 2:00 p.m. A DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PltOPOSAL IS ON FlLE IN THE PLANIIIM 0EPA1mI1NT AT CITY HALL. IF YOU WOULD Lilli FUIITHIR INFORMATION ABOUT TIIS PROPOSAL PRIOR TO THE PUBLIC HEARING. Pl.lASE CONTACT THI PLANNING DEJllUlTMINT IN ~ON OR 1'1' '*lNING (714) 384-5057. THANK YOU. ,., .... ..,. EXHIBIT "C" - , ' -0 .:> Feb. 19, 1991 PLANNING COMMISSION DUE TO A PRIOR COMMITMENT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD WATCH ASSOCIATION, I CANNOT ATTEND THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING OF FEB 19, 1991 at 7:00 P.M. THIS LETTER IS TO REGISTER MINE AND THE NEIGHBORHOOD WATCH MEMBERS OF WHO I REPRESENT TO THE OPENING OF ANOTHER LIQUOR STORE ON KENDALL DR., CASE # CUP 90- 72 . THERE ARE ALREADY 3 BARS, 4 BEER & WINE STORES, 2 LIQUOR STORES, 2 MARKETS THAT HAVE A LIQUOR DEPT., AND A RESTAURANT THAT HAS A COCKTAIL LOUNGE WITHIN A ~ MILE RADIUS. WE ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT CAL STATE SELLS BEER ON THE CAMPUS. THERE HAS BEEN MANY PROBLEMS IN THIS AREA OF WILD PARTIES AT THE FRATERNITY HOUSES, llUMEROUS PROBLEMS OF "BEER RUNS", ON THE EXISTING STORES & THE SELLING OF CIGARETTS TO MINORS. KENDALL ELEMENTRY SCHOOL WHICH IS LOCATED AT 4951 N. STATE ST. WILL BE GREATLY AFFECTED BY THE EXCESS IN TRAFFIC AND THE UNDESIRABLE ELEMENT THAT FREQUENTS LIQUOR STORES. WE OF NEIGHBORHOOD WATCH URGE YOU TO CO-OPORATE WITH US IN OUR EFFORTS TO KEEP OUR NEIGHBORHOOD A SAFE PLACE FOR US AND OUR CHILDREN TO LIVE AND GROW IN. WE STRONGLY REQUEST A DENIAL OF CUP 90-72. ANY OTHER ACTION WILL ONLY COMPLICATE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS THAT ARE PRESENT. THAJK YOU, ~' p: ~t.a4-'"7"V "'~ SUSAN JOHNS N o AREA DIRECTOR, NEIGHBORHOOD WATCH EXHIBIT "0" . ' " -0 -0 February 12, 1991 PLANNING AND BUILDING DEPARTMENT City of San Bernardino 300 N. D Street San Bernardino, CA 92418 SUBJECT: February 19, 7:00PM Council Chamber Hearing Conditional Use Permit #90-72 S.E. Corner of Kendall and University Pkwy, S. Bdno As a 18 year resident of Kendall Drive and a graduate of CSUSB, I would like to formally voice my opinion in opposition to the granting of conditional use permit #90-72. My reasons are as follows: * A community truly committed against drugs (as we profess through our Community Against Drugs program with Ms. Jeri Simpson) will recognize that another establishment that sells alcohol, a gateway drug, near CSUSB is not needed nor should be endorsed by the city. * San Bernardino already has too many liquor stores in the north end of the city. * The corner of Kendall and university is a very danger- ous intersection. Many accidents have occurred there over the years due to that fact that the speed limit is too high. A liquor store will only attract more intoxicated persons to an already dangerous location, resulting in more fatalities. It is also my understanding that the person applying for this permit paid an individual in the neighborhood to collect sign- atures at 50 cents per signature. Is this legal? Even if this were legal, it appears to me to be very unethical. Please show that San Bernardino takes seriously its commitment to raising a generation of drug-free youth by not allowing yet another gateway drug to be sold on the corner near our finest institution. Sincerely, .-/m J ;2 I' .-..L I / ( tt- Lira i c t Q-ti t ,;J::L 'LA. Margar~ Bleckert ' 3287 Genevieve St. San Bernardino, CA 92405 . . .. o o Margaret Smith 1635 Kendall Drive San Bernardino, CA 92407 February 13, 1991 Planning and Building Services Department San Bernardino City Hall 300 North 'D' Street San Bernardino, CA 92418 To Whom It May Concern: Hearing scheduled February 19, 1991 for Conditional Use Permit No. 90-721 Parcel located at the southeast corner of Kendall Drive and University Parkway I am against the selling of alcoholic beverage in the building at the above-mentioned location. We do not need to encourage our Cal State University students to buy and drink alcoholic beverages. An establishment so close to the University could cause some people to purchase alcohol before classes because of stress and tension. A convenience store in this location would cause traffic to increase causing a greater hazard in an already dangerous, highly traveled intersection. There are three convenience stores in a one mile radius of Kendall and UniversitYl we don't need another one. Convenience stores lower the value of the area because of the possible burglary and robbery that could and do occur, and because of the unsightly parking lots that develop. There will always be inconsiderate people who won't find a trash can to dispose of food and wrappers. Couldn't someone come up with a more desireable establishment than a market that insists it must sell alcoholic beverages? Sincerely, ~ 7?t~ ; 5jl~ -h,~# Margaret Smith Jim Smith . . r """Ill CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT AGENDA ITEM 6 SUMMARY HEARING DATE 2-19-91 WARD 5 ~ ,...., / APPLICANT: -... Mohammad A11 W 17586 Mountain Court rn CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-72 Riverside, CA 92503 c( OWNER: University Square-S.B. Assoc. (,) 340 South Flower Street '--" \. Orange, CA 92668 r--. / """ 5 To establish a 2,500 square foot market to include the off-site sale of beer and wine in an existing retail center under the authority of Municipal ~ Code, Section 19.83.500. g Located in a tenant space of a multi-tenant retail center on the south- a: - east corner of Kendall Drive and University Parkway at 1689 Kendall Drive, c( Suite A. W a: c( ~ I EXISTING GENERAL PLAN """ PROPERTY LAND USE ZONING DESIGNATION Subject Multi-Tenant Retail CG-1 Commercial General North Apartments RM Residential Medium Sou th Single-Family Residences RS Residential Suburban East Single-Family Residences RS Residential Suburban West Apartments RM Residential Medium \. .) / GEOLOGIC I SEISMIC DYES , f FLOOD HAZARD 0 YES 0 ZONE A 1( ) l SEWERS: IXl YES HAZARD ZONE: 111 NO .) \ ZONE: IXl NO 0 ZONEB o NO HIGH FIRE o YES AIRPORT NOISE! o YES " REDEVELOPMENT []I YES ) HAZARD ZONE: QI NO CRASH ZONE: I PROJECT AREA: \. \.. !Xl NO o NO - - / ...., ...., -' o NOT o POTENTIAL SIGNIFICANT Z [) APPROVAL c( APPLICABLE EFFECTS WITH 0 MITIGATING MEASURES - I- !C [) zrn NO E.I.R. CONDITIONS WCl u.Q ::EZ ij) ~E'f~bn 15301 o E.I.R. REQUIRED BUT NO u.Z 0 DENIAL Z- SIGNIFICANT EFFECTS C(W OQ Class 1 WITH MITIGATING lnl a:Ji MEASURES 0 CONTINUANCE TO -II. > o NO SIGNIFICANT o SIGNIFICANT EFFECTS 0 ffi (,) EFFECTS SEE ATTACHED E.R.C. W MINUTES a: to.. "--.,.) \.. ..J - ... o u PLAN-I.02 PAGE 1 OF t (4-90) (;ITYO#_~ C!ffflW.~IEM1CU FXHIBIT "E" . . " o o OBSERVATIONS CASE AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE CUP NO. 90-72 6 2-19-91 2 CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT ,. REOUEST The applicant requests approval of a Conditional Use Permit under the authority of Code Section 19.83.500, to establish a 2,500 square foot mini-market to include the off-site sale of beer and wine in an existing mult-tenant commercial retail center in the CG-1, Commercial General, General Plan land use district. SITE LOCATION The pr~posed mini-market will occupy a space ~n an existing 16,179 square foot the southeast corner of Kendall Drive further described as 1689 Kendall Drive, 2,500 square foot tenant retail center located at and University Parkway, suite A. MUNICIPAL CODE AND GENERAL PLAN CONFORMANCE The proposed project is consistent with the Municipal Code and is in conformity with the General Plan as shown in Attachment "A". CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL OUALITY ACT STATUS The proposal is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to section 15301 (a), Class 1 exemption. BACKGROUND The commerical retail center was approved by the Development Review Committee on December 29, 1988, under Review of Plans 86- 143. Conformance of the proposal with respect to site plan design, elevations, setbacks, lot coverage, circulation, landscaping and parking was reviewed in the Review of Plans process. In addition, a proposal to establish a mini-market including the off-site sales of general liquor was proposed for the same site, 1689 Kendall Drive, Suite "A" and was denied at the August 7, 1990 Planning Commission meeting. In this earlier proposal, case file Conditional Use Permit 90-22, the applicant had at least two negative encounters with law enforcement including convictions for sales to minors. According to staff, concerns about the previous applicant's history may have been the predominate reason for denial . ~ an 01 ..... IIMANlN) --- PLAH-UI PAGE 1 OF 1 (..00) .' o o ... CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT CASE CUP NO, 90-72 6 2-19-91 3 OBSERVATIONS AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE ... ... ANALYSIS PROPOSED USE The intent of the Commercial General land use designation is to provide goods and services which include general retail, restaurants and convenience stores. The proposed use of a market with off-sale of beer and wine is consistent with the intent of the General Plan and is permitted with approval of a Conditional Use Permit. COMPATIBILITY WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD The commerical center is located in what is essentially a residential environment punctuated by the campus of California State University, San Bernardino. Characteristics of the State College district include established single family neigborhoods and multi-family units as well as recently planned , single family suburban developments. Directly north of the intersection of Kendall Drive and university Parkway is undeveloped property designated in the General Plan as CG-3. Future land development will be required to demonstrate a University Village environment, and according to General Plan Policy 1.23.11 "will allow for nighttime use of university-related commercial uses, provided that they do not adversely impact adjacent residential uses". Because the proposed site residential and commercial with the surrounding land General Plan provides for the State College area and is in the vicinity of both existing land use designations, it is compatable use. This policy guideline from the the compatability between residents in nighttime commercial uses. MUlti-family apartments abut the commercial center parking lot on the west and are located north of the center across Kendall Drive. Single family homes, the nearest being 1699 Sheridan Road, approximately 75 feet from the proposal, lie easterly of the site as well as to the south. The nearest school, Kendall Elementary, is located approximately 650 feet from the proposed site. California State University is approximately one quarter of a mile to the north of the site. ... cmCl''''~ --- PLAN-U8 PAGE 1 OF 1 (...go) 0 0 CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING CASE CUP NO. 90-72 AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT AGENDA ITEM 6 OBSERVATIONS HEARING DATE 2-19-91 PAGE 4 ~ .... ~ CRIME """'l The site of the proposed market is located within census tract 46, and a crime reporting district which is 41% below the average crime statistics for the entire City. According to the San Bernardino Police News Release dated December 28, 1990, during the seven week period from November 4 to December 25, 1990 vehicle burglaries rose 116 % from the same period one year ago. CONCENTRATION OF ALCOHOL ESTABLISHMENTS The nearest on-site sale of alcohol, as reported by investigator Detective Diaz, is the Jersey Pizza at 985 Kendall Drive located one and 6/10 mile from the proposed site. The nearest off-site sales is the 7-11 market at 1395 Kendall Drive approximately 9/10s of mile away. Other off-site locations are in excess of one mile from the proposed location. The concentration of existing outlets for off-site sales, 13 and two pending, exceeds the saturation level of nine, as determined by the Police Department. In contrast, the number of existing on-site sales, six and one pending, ranks below the current saturation point, eleven. Because the determined number which is set for saturation levels is lower for the off-site alcohol sales, and because more off-site locations are generally proposed, these concentrations occur more readily. COMMENTS RECEIVED Area Residents The applicant hired Rosalie Hurtado, who is an employee of a business located in the same retail center to circulate a petition in support of the proposed business, throughout the residential community. The petition also states that the undersigned have no objection to a market which would include the sale of alcoholic beverages in the above mentioned center. The applicant has submitted to staff the petition with 291 signature~ .Although it is not possible to verify the accuracy of information provided, several residents who had signed the petition were contacted by Detective Diaz of the Police Department to verify their position and signature. On January 16, 1991 The Police Department contacted Mrs. Lee at 1699 Sheridan Road, who is opposed to the proposed business. Mrs. Lee advised Detective Diaz of her concerns that the retail center maintain the lighting in the parking area to a sufficient level so as to discourage loitering . ~ .... CIT'f' 01 ..... .-...0 CEJfrIIW.""IJfI'IN01IIMClU PLAN-I.OII PAGE 1 OF 1 (4-10) o o . . OBSERVATIONS CASE AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE CUP NO. 90-72 6 2-19-91 5 CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT The Police contacted Paul Plesnicher, 1649 Sheridan Road, who advised the investigator that currently he is not opposed to the sales of beer and wine. Mr. Plesnicher previously submitted a written letter of protest to ABC concerning CUP 90-22. At the time, his objection to the proposed business was the sale of general liquor rather than the sales of beer and wine. CUP 90-22, which was proposed to establish a market including the off-site sales of general liquor, was denied last year. Comments indicated and wine. from area residents ,included in the Police Report, that they were not opposed to the off-site sale of beer Council On December 10, 1990, staff received comments from Councilman Minor opposing the establishment of a market which includes the off-site sales of alcohol. He did not distinguish between the sale of general liquor and beer and wine only. California State University, San Bernardino Comments from the California State University, approval of conditional Use Permit 90-72, were from the police Department. Staff contacted the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) to confirm that the University operates a food establishment which includes the on-site sales of beer and wine. The University has a Type 41 License from ABC for the on-site campus sales of beer and wine. which opposes the received by staff Police Department The Police Department does not support the proposed business primarily due to the increased change in rate, between 1989 to 1990, during the 7 week period from November 4 to December 25, 1990. Development Review Committee The Development the meeting on site plan, the hearing. Review Committee (DRC) reviewed the proposal at January 18, 1990. Based upon their review of the proposal was cleared onto Planning Commission for ... .II CllYCI'lIIIN~ CENTl'W.--'O..... PLAN-LDB PAGE 1 OF , (..sID) , . 0 0 ..... CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING CASE CUP NO. 90-72 AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT AGENDA ITEM 6 OBSERVATIONS HEARING DATE 2-19-91 PAGE 6 .. APPLICANT HISTORY On January 17, 1991, the Police Department contacted ABC regarding the applicant Mohammad Ali. The applicant currently holds an ABC license for the M & M Liquor and Market, 10541 Indiana street, Riverside, and is part owner of the market. ABC advised the Police investigator that there were no special conditions, violations or adverse letters from law enforcement agencies in the business' file. CONCLUSION The proposed establishment of a market including the off-site sales of beer and wine is a permitted use subject to the approval of a Conditional Use Permit. The design of the commercial center conforms with the San Bernardino Municipal Code with respect to site plan, elevations, setbacks, lot coverage, landscaping and parking and was reviewed by the Development Review Committee. The crime statistics for reporting district880jSC402 are below city wide average. Whereas Conditional Use Permit 90-22 requested approval for sales of general liquor, the current applicant requests a permit for the sales of beer and wine. Further, the current applicant has had no history of negative encounters with the Police. Staff holds that, if the attached Conditions of Approval (Attachments C and D) are adopted, and if the proposed business would be operated between the hours of 7 a.m. and 10:00 p.m., the proposed market which includes the off-site sales of beer and wine would be compatible with the surrounding commercial and residential land use . RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72, based on the attached Findings of Fact (Attachment B) and subject to the Attached Conditions of Approval (Attachment C). ~;frw' Larry ~. Reed Dir;9Tor ~f Planning ~nd ~~.v>1 .s: /}1a7'MV1 benise S. Moon1er Assistant Planner Building Services .. aN 01'..... III!NW'll:.C) --- PLAN-I.D8 PAGE 1 OF 1 (4-00) .' ." o .0 OBSERVATIONS CASE AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE CUP NO. 90-72 6 2-19-91 7 CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT -.. ~ Attachments: A _ Municipal Code and General Plan Conformance B - Findings of Fact C - Conditions of Approval D - standard Conditions E - police Department Investigation F - Site Plan, Floor Plan and Elevation G - Location Map '" ... . .-",' 't.Oft PAr.!:. ~,- ~~l~ . . o ATTACHMENT A o r """'Ill OBSERVATIONS AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE CUP NO. 90-72 6 2-19-91 8 -oil CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT CASE ... r ..., HUNICIP~L CODR AND GENERAL PLAN CONFORMAN~E Cateaot"y Pl"o~osal Municipal General Code Pl~n Permitted Use Market with off-site sale of liquor Permitted N/A subject to a conditional use permit Height Setbacks Front 18.5 feet 2 stories 2 stories or 30 feet or 30 feet Side-Street 10 feet 10 feet 5 feet N/A 5 feet N/A Abutting Residential 5 feet 5 feet N/A parking 19\ 11 70\ 70\ 11 N/A Lot Coverage * 2,520 square feet at 1 parking space/250 square feet 2,520/250 . 10.08 or 11 parking spaces ... ....,j c:m'OISIW~ --- Pl.AN-8.DB PAGE 1 OF 1 (4-SlO) ATTACHMENT B . . CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT FINDINGS OF FACT CASE AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE CUP NO. 90-72 6 2-19-91 9 FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The proposed market use is in conformance with the objectives of the City's General Plan, in that food markets with off-site beer and wine sales are permitted in the CG-1, Commercial General, land use designation subject to the approval of a Conditional Use Permit. 2. The proposed use will not adversely affect the adjoining land uses and the growth and development of the area in which it is to be located. Conditions of approval will mitigate potential negative impacts to the surroundng residential properties. 3. The size and shape of the site proposed for the use is adequate to allow the full development of the proposed use in a manner not detrimental to the particular area nor to the peace, health and general welfare in that the commercial development on the site was approved under Review of Plans No. 86-143. 4. The traffic generated by the proposed use will not impose an undue burden upon the streets and highways designed and improved to carry the traffic in the area, in that Review of Plans No. 86-143 was evaluated by the city Traffic Engineer who determined that the commercial center would not significantly impact existing patterns of circulation, and the Planning Division determined that the commercial development provides sufficient off-street parking to serve the proposed use. 5. Bases on the above noted Findings, and under the mitigating conditions imposed, the granting of Conditional Use Permit No. 90-72 will not be detrimental to the peace, health and safety and general welfare of the citizens of the City of San Bernardino. ~ ~~I~~ Pl.AN-8.06 PAGE' OF 1 (4-10) . 0 0 . ,.. ..... CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING CASE CUP NO. 90-72 AND BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT AGENDA ITEM 6 CONDITIONS HEARING DATE 2-19-91 PAGE 10 ~ .... 1. Convex mirrors shall be located within sight of the clerk's counter to provide adequate visibility to all aisles. 2. Business hours shall not extend beyond the following time intervals: 7 a.m. through 10 p.m. seven days a week. 3. Sales of single cans of beer or wine cooler containers shall not be sold . 4. Wine shall not be sold in containers smaller than 750 mI. or with an alcoholic content greater than 15 %. 5. Cups or individual servings of ice shall not be sold except for soft drink dispensers. 6. posting of signs prohibiting littering and loitering shall be required and enforced by management. 7. No alcoholic beverages shall be consumed on the exterior of the property adjacent to the licensed premises or under control of the licensee. 8. Exterior lighting will be sufficiently and properly maintained to illuminate all areas of the exterior of the building and property for easy detection of suspicious and criminal activities. 9. No game machines, video or otherwise on licensed premises. 10.No public telephone booth shall be located on the premises. ~~ Pl.AH-I.CIII PAGE 1 OF 1 (4-CID) - .' CITY OF SAf QeRNARDINO PLANr-CJ3 DEPARTMENT . 'CASE CUP NO. 90-72 . CONDITIONS , . 11. \. AGENDA ITEM 6 HEARING DATE 2-19-91 PAGi " Alcoholic B8veraae conditional Use Permit After 12 months of operation of the business, the license own.r, shall submit to the city two sets of mailing label. of property owners and their address and/or t.nant. addres.es of property within 500 feet of the exterior boundaries of the business property owned by the licen.ee. A map illustrating the 500 foot radius boundary and all parc.ls within that boundary shall also be submitted. This information shall be obtain.d from the lat.st San Bernardino County equaliz.d a.....m.nt roll and map.. After r.c.ipt of the mailing labels and map, the city will .end an evaluation questionnaire to those neighboring property owners and r.sidents, councilmember. and polic.. Thi. .valuation questionnaire will ask question. about the operation impact. of the bu.ine.., the effectiveness of current condition. of approval and any proposed change. to the condition. of approval. If any .ubstantiated and .ub.tantial negative evaluations are received or at the City'S discretion, a public hearing with the Planning cOllllllis.ion .hall be held. Upon notice by the city, fifty percent of the latest Conditional Use Permi~ application fe. .hall b. paid by the applicant for the preparation of the .valuation report to the Planning COllllllission. After the public hearing the Planning cOllllllission may modify any existing conditions of approval, add new conditions of approval or revoke the Conditional U.e . Permit. These revised conditions or revocations shall be permanent and subject to appeal to the Mayor and COIIIIIIon council within 15 days after imposition. - ,. The above process of evaluation of the business operation impacts may be required in any subsequent years of op.ration as d.t.rmin.d by the city. . . - - ERNARDINO PLAN(()3 DEPARTMENT CASE CUP NO. 90-72 . CONDITIONS "' (' CITY OF SA~ AGENDA ITEM 6 HEARING DATE ?-.1.~:-..ll-- PAGE ,? ""'\' op.ration quideline. that the lic.nsee should follow in the sellinq of alcoholic b.veraqes are: _ Not permittinq drinkinq in the parkinq lots. _ Not allowinq drunks on the premises. _ Discouraqinq loiterinq on the premises and conqreqation of qroup. of people. _ Not .ellinq to minor. or someone under the influence. _ Maintaininq a clean .tore and parkinq lot, includinq immediate tra.h pick-up and qraffiti removal, and maintaininq the land.caped area.. _ Limitinq sales of individual or .mall Ulount. of beveraqes that could be consumed immediately on or near the store premises. 12. Arcade qame machine. .hall not be located on the premi.... 13. outdoor public telephone. .hall not be allowed. 14. Alcoholic bev.raqe .hall not be allowed to b. con.umed on the premi.e. (in.ide or out.id.) of the proj.ct prop.rty under own.r.hip of the lic.n.... 15. There .hall b. .uffici.nt, maintain.d .xt.rior liqhtinq to id.ntify any per.on or their activiti.. by the polic. of any property und.r own.r.hip of the lic.n.... 16. Two docum.nt.d Alcoholic Bev.raqe control violations for sal.s to minor. or to .om.on. und.r the influ.nce shall result in the immediate r.vocation of a store'. conditional U.e Permit. 17. Th. out. ide ar.a .hall be k.pt cl.an by imm.diate trash pick-uP and/or .w..pinq, all qraffiti shall be removed within-.e~n day. of occurr.nce and the dev.loped areas shall be properly maintain.d. 18. The above conditional U.e Permit conditions of approval shall be po.t.d inside the store at a prominent public location. r CITY OF SAI. ERNARDINO PLANI~(b DEPARTMENT CASE CUP NO. 90-72 . CONDIT.IONS ..... AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE 6 2-19-9C 1, .....' 19. possible a44itional con4itions of approval, base4 upon a negative evaluation process outline4 above, inclu4e but are not lillite4 to the following con4itions.of approval: ~~c~ ;~::; dons of A.llllroval Aleoh v condi~ional u.. p.rmit A. Arca4e game lIachines shall not be 10cate4 on the premises. B. out400r public telephones shall not be allowe4. c. signs saying "No loitering", "No littering" an4 "No public 4rinking" shall be poste4 in the front, rear or si4es Cas appropriate) of the establishments. store employees shall be require4 to a4vise anyone loitering to leave. D. Alcohol beverages shall not be consume4 on the premises Cinsi4e or project property un4er ownership of allowe4 to be outsi4e) of the the licensee. E. There shall be sufficient maintaine4 exterior lighting to i4entify any person or their activities by the Police of any property un4er ownership of the licensee. ., F. Sales of single beer or wine cooler containers shall not be peraitte4. Beer must be so14 only in six-packs aM wine coolers in four-packs. G. cups aM corkscrews or in4ivi4ual servings of ice shall not be so14, except soft 4rink 4ispensers. B. wine sball not be so14 in containers 750 1M. or with an alcoholic content 15'. smaller than greater than I. Business hours for sale of alcoholic beverages shall be restricte4 from opening earlier than 7:00 a.lI. or closing later than 9:00 p.lI. J. Only one sign a4vertising "liquor" shall be F CITY OF SA.CBERNARDINO PLAN~aG DEPARTMENT CASE CUP NO. 90-72 . CONDITIONS AGENDA ITEM 6 HEARING DATE 2-19-91 PAGilll allowed. Neon beer or wine window siqns visible from the outside shall not be permitted. K. Refrigerated beer or wine shall not be sold. L. Alcoholic beverage sales shall not constitute more than 30' of the markets shelf space. M. Alcoholic beverage sales shall not constitute more than 30' of the gro.s sale., and quarterly receipt records shall be made available for City inspection. N. All alcohol sales shall be by clerks 21 years of age or older. O. TWo documented Alcoholic Beverage Control violations for sale. to minors or to someone under the influence shall result in the immediate revocation of a store'. Conditional Use Permit. P. The outside area .hall be kept clean by immediate trash pick-Up and/or sweeping, all graffiti shall be removed within seven days of occurrence, and the landscaped areas shall be properly maintained. Q. On-site security patrol' guard coverage shall be provided during business hours. R. On-site electronic surveillence shall be required during business hours. s. The display area for the sale of alcohol beverage shall be limited to the rear one-third of the store. T. The ~ove Conditional Use Permit conditions of approval shall be posted inside the store at a prominent public location. /ke - ATTACHMENT 0 .' CONDITIONS CASE AGENDA ITEM HEARING DATE PAGE CUP NO. 90-72 CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING AND BUILDING SERVICES OEPARTMENT fi 2-19-91 15 r' -0 S'l'AlmARD ~NDr'l'iONS 1. Minor lIClditications to the plan shall be subject to approval by the Director ot Planninq. An increas. ot IIlOre than 10 p.rcent ot the square tootaqe or a siqnitieant c:hanq. in the approved concept shall b. subject to (Planninq commission and Development Review Committee) review and approval. Construction shall b. in substantial contormance with the Plans approved by the Development Review Co_i ttee, Planninq C~ission or Director ot Planninq. The developer is to submit a complete ..ster landscape and irriqation plan (4 copies) . tor the entire development to the Enqineerinq Department with the required te. tor approval, the landscape plans will be torwarded to the Parks, Recreation, and community Servic.. and the Planninq Department tor review and approval. (Note: the issuance ot a buildinq p.rmit, by the Department of Buildinq and Satety ot the City ot San Bernardino,. does B21: waive th... requirements/conditions.) No qradinq permits will be issued prior to approval ot landscape plans. 'l'h. desiqn shall include, but not b. limited to the tollowinq: Stre.t trees .hall be planted on 30 foot cent.r spacinq unl..s oth.rwis. indicated by the Depart:lllent ot Paru, Recreation, and C~ity Service.. Th. Parks DepaZ1:aent shall deteJ:mine the varieties and locations prior to plantinq. All tree. shall be 24" box specimens. Tre.. are to be inspected by a Park Division repre.entativ. arior to plantinq. Planters shall be enclosed with concrete eurbinq. ~ ....- ~ ~... t 0# 1 ...., t- o .. . . " r """l CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING CASE CliP NO. 90-72 AND BUILDING SERVICES OEPARTMENT AGENDA ITEM Ii CONDITIONS HEARING DATE ?_1Q_ql PAGE ,,; . ,... . The se~Cb trom the north _ , south _ , east _ , west _ property line shall be ber.lleet at a ~.vimum 3:1 slope and shall be plantecl with a tall tescue eype turtq:as.. A L&nclscape butter zone shall be installeet bet-.,een ta~ilitie. anet street. The lanetscape anet irriqation plans shall comply with the -Proceclure anet Poli~ tor I.&nclscape and Irriqation- (availal:lle troa the Parlcs Departaent). Subject to the conetit10ns ot the Department ot Parks and "~reation (atta=ecl). ftees, shrubs and qround~over of a type anet quality qenerally ~nsistent or ~oapatible with that ch&racterizinq sinqle- faaily hoaes sball be provietecl in the front yarci anet that portion of th siete yarcls whi= are visible fro. the street. All lanc1scapecl area. aust be provietecl with an auto_tic irriqation .y.t_ adequate to insure their viability. The lands-::ape ancl irriqation plans shall be approvacl by the Parks aDd Re~eation Depart:lllent. 2. At all times the busine.. will be operatecl in a lI&IUler ,.,b.i= doe. not proetu~e obnoxious noi_, vibration, octor, etust, ..,a, qlare, or other nui.an~e. 3 A .iqn p~:rUl tor the aulti-tenant c:oaaercial/inetustrial ~ter shall be approvecl by the Pl&JUlinq Departaent prior to ~~ of Certificate ot o~cupanc:y. III the event that tJUa approval i. leqally ch&llenqecl, the City will prolQltly notify the app1i~t ot any ~laia or action and will c:oopente tully iD the c1eteIUIe of the _t-::er. 0IIC8 notitiecl, tb.e appli~t aqree. to c1efencl, inct_ify, anc1 boleS ba%1Ile.. the City, its otti~ers, aqenu and _ployee. trOll any ~laia, action, or proceectiDq aqainat the City ot San Bernarclino. The appli~ant further aqre_ to reimburse the City ot any ~o.U &lid attorneys' te_ vb.1= the City _y be ~irecl by a ~oart to pay a. a r~t ot suc:h action. but saab parti~ipat1oD shall not relieve app1i~t ot tUs ob11qation uncler tJUs ~oncl1t1on. :;;.&- ........ '.. 1 06 , ,.. . . - o o - DRC/ERC DATE CAS E Co" P ?c- ?~ CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO STANDARD REQUIREMENTS POLICE DEPT 4. SECURITY V 5. / 6. ./' 7. v v 8. __ 9. ~/ 10. V 11. r/ FOR COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENTS LIGHTING: Li<<htinl levels on the exterior of the building are to pro- vide a minimum of one foot candle of minimum maintained il- lumination, evenly distributed, on the ground level fro. dusk until the termination of business each operating day. All exterior doors to buildings shall be equipped with an illumination device capable of providing a minimum of one foot candle of maintained illuminated at ground level durinl hours of darkness. Aisles, passageways, and recesses related to and within the project complex shall be illuminated with an intensity of~at least .25 foot candles at the Iround level durin. the hours of darkness. Open parkinl lots and carports shall be provided with a minimum maintained one foot candle of li,ht evenly distrib- uted on the parkinl surface durinl the hours of darkness. All exterior li,htinl devices are to be inaccessible to co..on reach or climbinl and shall be protected by weather and vandalism resistant covers. All exterior li,htinl shall be projected so as to not cast lilht onto adjoining prop- erties. Interior nicht li,htin, shall be maintained in those areas that are visible from the street (,round floor only). There shall be a minimum of 20 foot candles of illumination per square foot of surface area adjacent to ,as pumps. Parkin, lot poles will be shake proof so that lilhts cannot be daaa,ed by shakin, the pole. Lilht fixtures shall be positioned in such a manner so that "stray" li,ht does not affect adjoinin, property owners. Interior nilht li,htin, shall be maintained in those areas that are visible from the street (,round floor only). 12. ~ DOORS, LOCltS, AND WINDOWS: Swinlinl exterior ,lass doors, wood or metal doors with Ilass panels, solid wood or metal doors shall be constructed or protected as follows: Al Wood doors shall be of solid core construction with a _.:_.:_.._ ......:-.\,___... _~ 1 ':I/Att . . - -Q -0- DRC/ERC DATE CASE POL:J:CE DEPT C:J:TY OF SAN BERNARD:J:NO STANDARD REQU:J:REHENTS 13. ./ 14. v' Bl Hollow metal doors shall be constructed a minimum equivalent to sixteen U.S. ,auge steel and have suf- ficient reinforceaent to .aintain the desi,ned thick- ness of the door when any locking device is installed such as reinforceaent being able to restrict collapsing of the door around the lockin, device. Cl The above doors shall contain a 190 de,ree view anile door viewer. Except when double cylinder deadbolts are utilized, any Ilass utilized within 40" of any door lockin, mechanisa shall consist of laainated class, teapered ,lass, wired ,lass or plastics. All swin,in, exterior woo~ and steel doors shall be equipped as follows: Al A sinlle or double door shall be equipped with a double or single deadbolt. The bolt shall have a ainiaua pro- jection of 1" and be constructed so as to repel cuttinl tool attack. No double cylinder deadbolt locks shall be installed on the front door. Bl The deadbolt shall have an eabedaent of at least 1" into the strike receiving the projected bolt. The cylinder shall have a cylinder guard, a ainimua of five pin tuablers, and shall be connect.d to the inn.r por- tion of the lock by connecting scr.ws of at least 1/4" in diaa.t.r. Th. reco...ndation does not apply when panic hardware is r.quir.d or an equivalent device is approv.d by the Building Code. Cl The strike plate shall be a miniaua of 3" in height and shall be secured to the jaab with a minimua of four 2-1/2" scr.ws. Double doors shall be .quipp.d as follows: Al The active l.af of double doors shall be equipp.d with aetal flush bolts having a ainiaua .ab.daent of 5/8" into the head and threshold of the door fr.... Double doors shall have an astragal constructed of steel, a ainimua of .125" thick, whicb will cov.r the op.nin, between the doors. This astra,al shall be a ainimum of 2" wide and extended a miniaua of 1" beyond the ed,e of the door to which it is attached. The astra.al shall b. attached to the outside of the active door by means of weldin, or with nonr.aovable bolts spaced apart on not more than 10" centers. . . o o STANDARD REQUXREHENTS DRC/ERC DATE CASE POLXCE DEPT CXTY OF SAN BERNARDXNO -/ All exterior hinted doors are to open/swing outward. 15. 16. v Hintes for out-swinCing doors shall be equipped with non- removeable hinge pins or a mechanical inner lock to preclude removal of the door from the exterior by removin, the hin,e pins. 17. v Windows Al All moveable windows shall be equipped with a locking device and shall be constructed in a fa.hion to re strict them from being lifted out of their tracks when in the closed po.ition. BI All moveable window. shall al.o be equipped with an auxiliary locking device which prevents the window from bein, .lid open 1either vertically or horizon- ! tally) open while in the clo.ed po.ition. Oarage type door.: (rolling overhead, .olid overhead, swinging, .liding, or accordion .tyle) Al The above de.cribed door. shall conform to the follow- ing .tandards: 1. Wood doors shall have panels a .inimu. of 5/16" in thickness with the locking hardware being at- tached to the support fra.ing. 2. Alu.inu. doors .hall be a .ini.u. thickness of .0215" and rivet to,ether a .ini.u. of IS" on cen- ter .long the outside .e.... There .hall be a full width horizont.l be.. att.ched to the main door .tructure which .h.ll .eet the pilot or pede.tri.n acce.. door fr..ing within 3" of the .trike are. of the pilot or pede.trian acce.s door.' 3. Fiberglas. door. .hall have p.nel. a .inimu. den- .ity of 6 ounce. per square foot fro. the bot to. of the door to a hei.ht of 7' and p.nels in re.idential .tructures sh.ll have a density of not less than 5 ounces per squ.re foot. B) Where sliding or accordion doors .re utilized, they .h.ll be equipped with guide tracks which shall be de- signed so th.t the door c.nnot be re.oved fro. the tr.ck when in the clo.ed and locked po.ition. C) Doors that exceed 16' in width shall have 2 lock receiving points; or, if the door does not exceed 19', o o DRC/ERC DATE CASE CXTY OF S~N BERNARDXNO STANDARD REQUXREMENTS POLICE DEPT 18. ~ a single bolt may be used if placed in the center of the door with the locking point located either in the tloor or in the door traae header. 0) Overhead doors shall be equipped with slide bolts which shall be capable of utilizing padlocks with a minimum 9/32" shackle. 1. Slide bolt as.emblies shall have a trame a minimum ot .120" in thickne.s, a bolt diaaeter a minimum ot 1/2", and protrude at leaat 1 1/2" into the re- ceiving guide. A bolt diameter ot 3/8" may be used in a residential building. 2. Slide bolt aa.embliea ahall be attached to the door with bolt..which are nonremovable from the- exterior. Rivets shall not be uaed to attach such aa.embliea. E) Padlocka used with exterior mounted slide bolta shall have a hardened ateel shackle a minimum of 9/32" in diameter with heel and toe lockin, and a minimum 5 pin tumbler operation. The key ahall be nonremovable when in an unlocked operation. F) Doora utilizing a cylindeT lock ahall have a minimum of five pin tumbler operation with the bolt or locking bar extending into the receiving guide a minimum ot 1". Common walla shall be aa sound proof aa poaaible. All roof openin.a giving acceaa to the building shall be secured with either iron bara, metal gatea, stamped metal or ahall be alarmed and meet with the approval of the police department. ADDRESS NUMBERS V 19. 20. v/ 21. ~ Roof top addresa numbera shall be provided. They shall be a minimum of 3' in length and 2' in width and of contrasting color to the background. Numbera shall be placed parallel to the atreet addreaa aa aasigned. The project shall diaplay atreet addreaa numbers placed in a prominent poaition aa near the atreet aa practical. Numbera shall be a minimua of 6" in hei,ht and of a contrasting color to the back,round. All individual unita shall be clearly identified by numbers, letters, or a combination thereof. Theae numbers and . . 0- 0- DRC/ERC DATE CASE CXTY OF SAN BERNARDXNO STANDARD REQUXREMENTS POLXCE DEPT letters shall be a minimum of 6" in height and of a contras- ting color to the background. All numbering of units shall be in a sequential, logical order, ACCBSS CONTROLS: 22. V An access control override device shall be provided for use by police department personnel to ,ain i..ediate access. Perimeter fencinl or cross fencing shall be installed to prevent criainal aovement or activity. The exterior business walla shall be posted with Hunicipa~ Code Section 9.52.070 relative to trespassinl, The placeaent of outside public telephones shall be re- stricted to an area immediately adjacent to the front of the store, RETAIL/CONVENIBNCB STORES 23. ~ 24. v 25. ./ 26. / 27. / Lockable cold beverage (beerl cases shall be locked at 2:00 a.a. No alcoholic beverages shall be displayed or stored in the front 2/3 ot the custoaer area. Ice aachines shall not be installed in tront ot store win- dows. The interior cashier/sales counter shall be located so it is visible troa the building exterior. 'Fl... flser U'.. i~t'i.. t):a- l""ullt.er ahall bit .1.va...A . _;n~_tl. of 6" above the rIal.. vf LIlli: by_lB... Windows and counter/cash register area will not contain dis- plays/advertiseaents that block the visibility ot the cashier troa the outside ot the store. A photo-electric beaa across the entry door shall be installed to audibly notity or ring when custoaers enter the store. Utilization of outside intercoa speakers is prohibited. .' 0- 0- DRC/ERC DATE CASE POLICE DEPT CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO STANDARD REQUIREMENTS 28. ALARM SYSTEMS ,/ If the units are alaraed or wired for an alara systea, the buyer is to be notified to contact the Police Department for an alara perait. 29. OTHER REQUIREMENTS / The placement of machinery (compre.sor equipment) shall be away froa residential areas to abate the intensity of noise. APPLICATION I'OLICS COlIC.'" ATTACHMENT E roa ~NDITIONAL USI PIRMITS roa~COHOL IEVlaAGI LICENSES .' , . .' LOCATION. 1689 Kendall Dr.. #A (M & M Market) Conditional U.. Permit No. Qn_7") Reporting District RD880/SC402 1')R/D Average -41% Part I Crimes Persons 8 83 Property 75 Part 11 Arrest. 15 Alcohol Related 3 = 20% Past 90 days: 5/1/90 to 8/31/90 Alcohol related 25% Cencus Tract 46 On Sale E-6/A-11 1 pending General Vicinity Off Sale E-13/A-9 2 p.ending Distance To Nearestl Distance School J.C. Carmack School 4865 State St. Cal State SB Church College Dale Baptist Church 4747 State St. Approx. 650' 3/10 mi. Approx. 650' Park Lionel Hudson Park 5/10 mi. Park & ~lind5or ABC On Sale Licensed Premises .1ersey Pizza 985 Kendall ~D/E ABC Off Sale Licensed Premises 7-11 1395 Kendall Dr. Distance of Parking Lot to Residence 1679 Kendall Dr. 1671 Kendall Dr. Distance of Building to Residence 1679 Kendall Dr. 1671 Kendall Dr. 1-6/10 mi. 9/10 mi. 9' 451 9' 9 ' INVESTIGATION: On 12/26/90. I received the investigation for a Conditional Use Permit (CUP #90-72) which had been submitted by Mohammad Ali and Mohd Rammaha for M & M Market. 1689 Kendall Drive. HA. SB. The nature of this project will be an approximate 2.500 square foot market in an existing retail center. which is located on the southeast corner of Kendall Drive and University Parkway. The proposed business will sell grocery items. produce. beverages and will include the off site sale of beer and wine. . . o D CUP #90-72 Page 2 The business will have one full time and one parttime employee in addition to both applicants, who will operate the business. The proposed business hours are 0600 to 2200 hours, seven days a week. The applicants will apply for the Type 20, off-sale beer/wine ABC license pending the approval of this Conditional Use Permit. I received information from Denise Moonier, the assigned planner, that Conditional Use Permit #90-22, had previously been investigated for this same location for a Type 21, off sale general ABC license on 5/14/90. Conditional Use Permit #90-22, was subsequently denied by the Planning Commission on 8/7/90, citing the applicant's (Wifki Mustafa) past negative encounters with law enforcement, two violations and con- victions for sales to minors and one sales of narcotic paraphernalia violation. On 12/28/90, I spoke to ABC Investigator Jack Clark, who advised me that Mustafa's Type 21, ABC license had not been issued and was still pending. He said that Mustafa had applied to have the license trans- ferred from 1689 Kendall Drive, #A to another location in San Bernardino County which he had not been able to secure. Mr. Clark advised me that Mustafa was given 90 days to transfer his Type 21 license from that location and the deadline was 1/17/91, however, that deadline could possibly be extended. depending on the circumstances. He advised me that Mustafa would not be able to transfer that license to any other person and would have to transfer the license to another suitable location or have the license revoked. Mr. Clark advised me that the current applicants, Mohammad Ali and Mohd Rammaha had not yet made an application for an ABC license with ABC. He advised me that the applicants would have little difficulty in obtaining a Type 20 on sale beer/wine license for that location and that it was within policy for the applicants to apply for their Conditional Use Permit and await its approval prior to applying for their ABC license. On 1/17/91. I contacted ABC regarding applicant Mohammad Ali who currently holds a ABC license for the M & M Liquor and Market, 10541 Indiana Street, Riverside, which he is the part owner of. I was advised that there were no special conditions, violations or adverse letters from law enforcement agencies in the business' file. On 1/15/91. at approximately 1100 hours. I conducted an interview with both applicants. Mohammad Ali and Mohd Rammaha. at the SBPD regarding their application for a Conditional Use Permit. During the interview Mr. Ali advised me that he had hired Rosalie Hurtado, who is an employee of a business located in the same retail center to circulate a petition in support of the proposed business. throughout the surrounding area. Mr. Ali advised me that he had received the completed petition with signatures and would provide me with a copy of it. During this investigation I reviewed the previous Conditional Use Permit, #90-22 investigation which had been completed for the same location o o CUP #90-72 Page 3 and while doing so located a letter of opposition submitted by the President of California State University, San Bernardino, Anthony H. Evans. I later contacted Mr. Evans' office in order to determine if the University was still opposed to the proposed business. I was referred to the Vice President of University relations, Dr. Judith Rymer, who advised me that the University was still opposed to the business and that she would submit another letter of opposition stating their basis for opposition. On 1/16/91, I received a copy of the letter which had been signed by University President Anthony H. Evans and which was consistent with the previous letter of opposition submitted by him. See attached copy. On 1/17/91, applicant Mohammad Ali provided me with a copy of the petition which had been circulated in support of his business. I re- viewed the 15 pages which Mr. Ali provided me with and found that their were 295 names with 291 signatures on the petition. I contacted several of the subjects listed on the petition and verified their position and signature. COMMENTS FROM AREA RESIDENTS: On 1/16/91, I contacted several residents who live in the immediate vicinity of this site. I spoke with Caroline Sadergaski. 1663 Kendall Drive, who advised me that she had no opposition to the proposed business and does not believe that the business would increase any problems in the area. She feels that the business would be beneficial to the area and provide easier access to a market for the area residents. I spoke with Clara Smalley, 1657 Kendall Drive. who advised me that she is not opposed to the proposed business and does not believe that the business would cause any problems to the immediate area. She was originally opposed to a liquor store. however. believes that a grocery store would be beneficial to the area and said that she does not have any problem with the business selling beer or wine. I spoke to Susan Lee. 1699 Sheridan Road, who advised me that she is opposed to the proposed business because of the off site beer and wine sales. She believes that the business would possibly cause further problems in the area such as loitering, littering, drinking in public, public intoxication and loud noise disturbances. Mrs. Lee said that she is currently experiencing problems from the customers in the parking lot of the retail center which is located directly across the street from her residence. which include narcotic activity in the parking lot, drinking. urinating in public and high speed traffic through the area. She believes that the business will aggravate the problems which already exist in the area and will increase the amount of vehicular and pedes- trian traffic. She advised that she is not opposed to the market, only to the sales of alcoholic beverages from that location. Mrs. Lee advised that the current problems are caused by subjects who gather in the parking lot of the retail center near the proposed business site and advised me of the need for the retail center to maintain the lighting and take other steps to prevent the problems from occurring. o o CUP #90-72 Page 4 I spoke to Paul Plesnicher, 1649 Sheridan Road, who advised me that he had previously submitted a written letter of protest to ABC regarding the previously proposed business (CUP #90-22) which was regarding the sale of "hard liquor". He said he is not as opposed to the beer and wine sales of the currently proposed business, however, stated that the area is already experiencing numerous problems, such as drunk in public, narcotic activity, littering and loitering. He said that the business would possibly contribute to the already existing problems, unless it is properly controlled and managed by the business' owner. I spoke to Catherine Rideout, 1676 Sheridan Road, who advised me that she has no opposition to the proposed business and does not believe that it will create any additional problems to the area. I attempted to contact the residents of 1679, 1671 and 1667 Kendall Drive, with negative results. I also attempted to contact the residents of 1684, 1676, 1670 and 1664 Sheridan Road with negative results. AREA COMMANDER COMMENTS: On 12/28/90, a notification form regarding the proposed business was sent to Area Commander Lt. J. Devlin. I later received a response from Lt. Devlin's Administrative Sergeant, Sgt. Guerrero advising that he was opposed to the proposed business because the neighborhood surrounding the proposed business has recently experienced a radical increase in residential burglary, vehicle burglary and auto theft which is documented in a press release dated 12/28/90. He advised that it is a known fact that substance abuse, such as the consumption of beer and wine greatly contributes criminal behavior and feels that the addition of retail alcohol beverage outlet at the proposed location would undoubtedly en- hance the current crime problems and pose an added problem to the police department's ability to provide a safe environment for the citizens in the immediate neighborhood and that the proposed business would potentially increase the police department's calls for service in that area. POLICE DEPARTMENT RECOMMENDATIONS: If this Conditional Use Permit is approved it could be reasonably ex- pected that an increase in activity, such as juveniles buying or attempting to buy alcoholic beverages, littering, loitering, drinking in public, public intoxication and drinking and driving could very possibly be expected. It should be noted that Rule 61.4, Proximity to Residences, could also apply and an ABC license may be denied by ABC, per those rules. If this Conditional Use Permit is approved the following conditions would be recommended by the police department and if implemented would possibly alleviate or lessen the aforementioned expected police problems. ~ o o CUP #90-72 Page 5 1. Must comply with all City building. fire. zoning and health regulations. 2. No single cans and/or bottles of beer or wine coolers to be sold. 3. No sales of wine. in less than 750ml containers. 4. No wine shall be sold with an alcohol content greater than 15% by volume. 5. No sales of ice in less than 7 lb bags. 6. posting of signs prohibiting littering and loitering and management enforcing this. 7. No alcoholic beverages shall be consumed on the property under the control of the licensee. 8. Exterior lighting will be sufficiently and properly maintained to illuminate all areas of the exterior of the building and property for easy detection of suspicious and criminal activities. 9. No public telephone booths shall be located on the business' designated premises. On 1/15/91 at approximately 1100 hours. I. Det. Diaz explained these conditions to applicants. Mohammad Ali and Mohd Rammaha. who advised me that they understood the conditions and would have no problem in complying with the conditions and implementing these conditions in the operation of the business. Respectfully submitted. ~- . ' , . o o BUSINESS CONDITIONS M & M MARKET 1689 Kendall Drive. #A. SB 1. Must comply with all City building. fire. zoning and health regulations. 2. No single cans and/or bottles of beer or wine coolers to be sold. 3. No sales of wine. in less than 750ml containers. 4. No wine shall be sold with an alcohol content greater than 15% by volume. 5. No sales of ice in less than 7 lb bags. 6. posting of signs prohibiting littering and loitering and management enforcing this. 7. No alcoholic beverages shall be consumed on the property under the control of the licensee. 8. Exterior lighting will be sufficiently and properly maintained to illuminate all areas of the exterior of the building and property for easy detection of suspicious and criminal activities. 9. No public telephone booths shall be located on the business' designated premises. ....._~^ IU.JEC~. Ale LICENSE APPLICA~ION , -.. "".~. ",'" ' . , . ~~--_. .: ::r 6.m Z.' VlCI IftAf.. DUE. Il-zr-7tl . . to. "~.J:' DU'L171i 0 We received a notice on the listed Alcoholic leverage license arid request your input, prior to approving or protesting the application. Plea.e return this form to the Vice Detail with your comments no later than --1-Z'~1 . If we receive no response from you by that date, it will be considered that you do not have any interest in this matter. ADDRESSaJW'CIl.1AJtlAlL rJL. ~f1 APPLICANT a mCW1l;!J?JlltJ /la. /J1/Y1tJ M/Im/41#l 'J'YPE OF LICENSEI IJlflL,j~ YOUR COMMENTSI Li/~1/JiZ "1,11'/ IMJ7L[g &L fl Ll:fM,K J/UL dr /)ff./ Jt/YJI[ Lf}rA-rr()1l! JiJI-'1t7 DUvrU OAf tf-7-'jO IJr 1l~6 /i#1.11 PIt.. N~/bllB02~() So.(!li2/J"III.{Jt""" 1111. PkPoSEn 8l(SIIvl!(f JI.M Rt!Ct<./rLy btlce.~(c,) A 14rM, CAf.. Irv,RCAJ'E: If'! ll.if.O~' g~~ I ucJ././lf..l P,ull.l.LAR.XAJVi)A,.~ fl.fePT;AJ DoC......ft-tfU ,,..,. nn 1j.'1'/l4'tafVj P/l..fU /2.cLf4sE ()(!,.ft/) I t-1,R-fO. irIS /I. /tIVtJWN f1Ilcr "('?Mr 5t.tOr'ftllwU 4J1~C€.1 .SoI.OI <4S' e' t W.,J C,flf4.rl Lo""' T1Z<8l.f.11S" 11> C:lZ"...,...4l l1e-ifAv,dll.. AOPI't"/'()'/ (oF ~ (Lf;'1lfIl( /l.l-(oU.,d (IHlrLer ,4.r / ~q 1t-tf,..d)4U 11I'4 4'1141.<> I.IrJOf!)uSrtPLy LflMlJtf. 1lIf LU.{Ul.~r <./2-''''11. P~(I~i-;" /f1JtJ Po~ IAN AODe/J P{lCe.L~ TO f}/i. (Jo4'€. urf)/1-7'tof.F:N'Jf ~1L.rry TO PIl4.....ot ~ ~4F-i. p..,t4.JloAl....Ew'l folZ. (I/'t t,rt2.6lf .11 ~ \....""'I:.O,.q..'Q /V~~I3()flf4cOP. f/I"t. SJJPV WC'IolL,t) ,.wr LH Af.>(.( 't"O SfJW\<.1l. flft .jlII.fA. w.flI. -(lit jAOPI-r'Or.J4<. n...rU)Ev , IJ'':' JIr f'Jf.,.A/ f3 "'-1OIt ,Pt,.A) """.N ,t 13~s,,'''€.Sf. " . . ,W. ~" p ,y~, -- o San Bernardino POlice Department P.O. Box 1559, San Bernardino, CA 92401 News Release RELEASE IMMEDIATE DATE 12-28-90 DANIEL A. ROBBINS CHIEF OF POLICE REPORT NO: N I, Approved By: For Mo~ Informal ion Call: (7141 384-5720 Sherrie Guc::-rero Media Information Dp.presentative The San Bernardino police Department-is warning .residents in the northwest section of San Bernardino of an increase in vehicle and residential burglaries during the 7-week period from November 4 to December 25, 1990. When compared to this same time period in 1989, it has been found that vehicle burglaries rose 116% and residential burglaries rose .about 1%. The affected area is bordered by Kendall Drive on the north, Inter- state-215 on the south, Little Mountain Drive on the east, and Palm Avenue on the west. Thieves are smashing out the side windows of vehicles to gain access to valuables inside. These thefts are most often occurring between 1:00 a.m. to 5:00.a.m. and 9:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. To 9ain entry into homes, suspects are primarily entering the living areas through attached garages. These crimes are occurring between 7:00 a.m. to noon and 4:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. The Crime Prevention Office of the San Bernardino Police Department wishes to remind residents that by using a few crime prevention techniques, these thefts can be prevented. Homes--including garages--should be locked and secured, even if you will only be gone a few minutes. Vehicles should be parked in well-lighted areas and all valuables should be removed from the interior of the vehicle. -MORE- ern .. - .--... CI.__....__. ;r21 002 ~~'~~~_~NCREASE o D Be sure that all vehicle doors and windows are locked, and never leave the pink slip in your vehicle. If you do not normally drive your vehicle between 1:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m., it is a good idea to enroll your vehicle in the San Bernardino police Depart- ment's C.A.T. (Combat Auto Theft) program. By enrolling in the program, the registered owner signs a waiver giving police the right to stop his or her vehicle during.the hours of 1:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. But the most important step residents can take to safeguard their neighborhOods is to become involved in a Neighborhood watch program, which teaches neighbors how to protect their property, look out for one another, and report suspicious activity to the police. For more information on Neighborhood Watch or the C.A.T. Program, or if you have any other questions, please call your local community Service Office (see map below) or the Crime Prevention Office at 384-5715. &. '312w...... 3IH77Il &.,...w."" ....7.. ..~.. O.,292W.--.. ...."- D""w.__er. 3Io106716 I. 202SL HgNonlltG ....712 ,. 202SL II;NaNltG ....712 I t$}= C...- JOUr .... CoIIIIII..", ...... 0IlIcI for InfonnallO. on C'- ,...._... ..........,.... W......... JOUr.." lor... C.A. T.__ ....... .-1-..... - ..........-.....-............ - ~IK;-...C'- =-... V,Ic:.....' ..._" '.'0.. ,..-,.!..-_::: . C..... . '_" :"__ - - <P-\ '-..,,1 '. Lette~ to Detective Dias Jaalluy 16. 1991 Paae 2 I u~ae the Saa Beraardiao Police Depart.eat CO .ake a coace.t~at.d effort to p~eveut tbe off-eice a.le of liquor in the propo.ad facility. 8heerely. ~~~ huUeat ;, - , .' ~ to o OAI.IPOIINIA .TAT. UNIV....ITY .AN ..IINA..DINO Tit' CaU(o"do SlI" U.f.....lly OFFICE OPTIIE PIlEIIDENT 7141880.6002 Juuuy 16. 1991 Detecti.e Joba Dia. I.. II~aa~di.o City 'olicI Departmeat 466 W.lt 4th Itr.ec San I.~na~dino. CA 92401 D.ar Det.ctive Di..: It i. .y underlt.adinl that. conditio.al UI. p.rmit for a %.'00 Iquare foot facility o. the louthera cor.er of Ke.d.ll Drive a.d Uaiv.r.ity 'arkw.y b.. beea .ppli.d for. Th. p.r- mit would iDclude off-.ite liquor ..1.., On beh.lf of C.lifornia Itate Uaiverlit,. S.. ler.ardlDo. I wi.h to IKpr... .tro.1 oppo.itioa to thl propo.al to ..11 liquor ia thac facility. At . time wh.. alcohol u.e ..d abu.c i. iner...lnl amonl t......r. ..d youal .dult., we b.li.v. that aothinl .hould be do., to e.coura,. or f.cilie.t. the .al. of alcohol to th... Iroup.. Our .tudent populatioa aad the iucr.a.iD' Dumb,r of youal t,'Da,er. ia the relidenti.l ar.a. uear the ca.puI ar. at particular rilt. I mi,ht point out that iD receat year. tbe uaiver.ity ba. tatea .tep. to reltrict tb. .al. aa. u.e at alcohol oa the ca.pu., aa. further re.trictioa. will be i.plemeat.d iD the fall. Ia additioa to provid!a. ea., aceeee to alcohol by vulaerable .roup., the propo.ed facility aleo ha. the poteatiat to .ttract . hi.her th.. Dor..t rat. of cri.. iD the fora of robberie. a.d .hoDtia,., thu. .aki., the eat ire retail eeater le.. lafa for .tu.e.tl aad aeilhborhoo' patroal, Pi.ally. we ha.e beea cDncerDed for .ometlme about the leriou. traffic coaditioa. aa. tbe frequeat acci'eat. at the Ke.'all Drlve/Uaiver.ity '.rkway iater.ectioa. Addta. liquor ..1e. on that eoraer would have the poteatial to eKacerbate the .ltu.tioa. 6600 Univeraity Park".,., Son Bernardino. CA 82407.2317 , . . ' o o WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, N~:GilBORS OF U~IVE~SI:! SQUARE SIIOPPIrIG CENTER, !lAVE :;r) OBJECTIOII TO HAVI::G A MARKET WHICH WOUL~ INCLUDE THE SALE CF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE ~ENTIONED SaJPPING CESTER. INFACT, A ~ARKET ~~~ZR:, ~OULD BE ~~F~ CO::V~:;:EnT FOR US, WOULD REDUe: DRIVING AND "OULD SAVE TIVE. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT F~P THAT USE BE G~~~:ED. 'L.f\ \ {\I ~ ~~~ \l..bO \<...Jl.1\ "'-... ~l ~i;!;dJ +J:~~~'~ .:;"-- , , C' '/1~"1;Ct )/71(://] 1t6c ^~,'/t: II ~ 19 .., ',"/L'--:/ / t. . I. I . ,l-J. rL7 ,/, /Lr; , A. . II. t t<,....., II ,r I - . 0. n I j (". u '. -;pi- r. (1 .' ~~""" c. 1/ c, ( f\i, orIn II ~ _/ ~ W 'v~0h I t.t (J j;_l' I 1(.Jt1ft J~ J I~'I kf' l "!I ~.f11 lId",! K( "d.IJ ,I H So I -.-./ -' ~ ,'I - '- '",,; 'I ':'l" i" I '.. "".II..~....I ~.-, .. r.......... _ \\..A...J./l-f. . " 'I '" . ..J. ..IlU'\...lL.-Y' . / I :' 'J"J('-'- ! f"'\ i ,. \' . 'I .... I " ~ Address Phone Si~nature ~ 4'l.'1,~ ~ ,. ~. ;?;-;~~~.~ /"./ " 1_//: r--' *'.J :JL;J 7c,;Z -/- ,,~: ~.... 4~~ _ ...,.,~"&# t b~l--~ 1 (j j ("7"''':' ." i:- " ." - I-- - .... , JiD '01./32.. 'Z " i-,,' , --- "'"J/' /v~r' /\U'Jfr.'// ;./.: ;;>,.. , "he, , .,\ ~(" \ ~ G-c (~.\t\~ II "# 'f Y- /, (,.{ ~J Iv )< I~//// #- .3'S 1 . 'I J' ' '" 'I ~ -. I (7\A"v\\. '.C'fio<:..1<J' j.'''''I ,(.>., ,,'IL '"-jU I -~" ~)J ~U -2,:rf->>'-3:- ~ - . ? p~Jf'U) ,,;; j) .. J2-l ~ ~~.SC/~'O~ ~gz. "~ A" Itd:,' :'...:._~/r-/ I ...,. r",.... ' ' I, l . j.t " .f( 1\1 >t"1 /l 1." ,', I: \ I ,v 1.1:" c't0 iI" I,lL) 1'1' t l(v.t~ r 11 \. -f" ,. , II Irv L .I. , ..., 2..,'-' -. .,1 -Ip.... -, ... - - - ,/ ..,. ~ ' "'~, - '-~ .. .) ,-" ~ .;..<...- . ~~'f/-'?'f'/7e& /1;4 ~"7~t~{ ~?)l'-f:.l~L- _~.cl ;~ ~ '-.3~);:fo ~ l~ ~ 7-/S0'i~ ,'/- "I~ . 111.1 , /Y;J/P - WI.l..l!..L '~',i( 7 -9 7 t: fI . .' --.. . . ~(,7 -?711 . ~(1-0& );)- 6'b '7 - 7/6/;7 / --= ~ ,",,~.; '. I. ,- o , /~ , . . ". ", ,. .,.., / ,,, "r _h__ o -""-. WE, 'l:HE UIlDERSIG:;ED, :;;;:rr;I:ilOR:l 0: U::IV::'.;I':"; S~:';.\!<: SHOPPING CE:;':'ER, hAVE 1;0 ObJECTIU:1 Ti.I ii,;V:::G A ~ARKET WH1Cll WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOi!0!..:C BEVnAGE I II TilE ABOVE I.IENTIOIlED SHOPP DG C:: ::TS::. r:;FACT, A ~ARKET THERE, WOULD BE VEHY ~J::~:::I~::T FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND WOULD JAV:: TI~E. 'J./\\ ....\ WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRAK'l:ED. Phone Sip:nat'-'re ~ A/66~ ~f 4, Ji . ':. ..1...)"""..%1'1 /I/tl /c('7."!',1..xi.'~ ;)/ ' I-- I (...,.w1' j/'./..... - 1"'.//"1':;: / / '/Ir -I~ .1-:fJZ;'l It60 k1><oJ, /I p", /1,., '(" f /1.(,. .. It.feu )(':r-f1'c>-P/ a" ~./~x{ (/~i1k' If: ~ " v.. 1111. :jet' L),' ; ,\ ',' ,". _/ ',':" ~, i' "',,','\ \ L ,". I !.~ \....,1 h.':.!;I.... ti!, . '-d'r~ 'J""';""a'//' ~,~'O jOt /,1,.'/' "I #SJ i ' .. , ;....o"'~) 1('~I~ l{~~{'!(;n~IJ// /), .:f:l-'r..? .... .' \. \~ l'\....I .d lId.d.~(i .(1,(1\ \.. i t 1 -j,11 1 ( \ ,1 . llllc'.'c Ui/l KU((/a!/ ,fl.\. it 7L' ,~//;/~'; t?I/IIY" /t.t-c JJjll~ItJrj L),'.;J 7( ....., ~. ._1 J/ J r. .)--- I I P .u~)11 .-b"-.<dIV.~../v....of..Arr.- IGIt? t' ('-~)V ti. r-nL '-.1-,('/3:;'" fl. .. r r. . 1 L I ~; I' i '/~.~J ;l.-f I (...J171'1l L n~1.\\J\. ")' U ' ' j/ i ,. :r1< .l.,.>k1>_'h.i......l, t~ Jl'(;C r.~/1/7t-i;1 I" ) J 'L.'i_.~~!t' <.Y' !10~ Jk.t'L' k3}"r/tf.,tI Dt..:1f (.0 I - , ~ :.~) "i\~;/~" ~~~yf~~_lbi,() ~e,~ ~~lj,~~. ..,-".._,_~\~__P"'-= /(( 0 r ~t-8C\1 (p' 1'.0 7 Ii- . ~{ 7. j '). -I Z 714 1" J(-,) -.:< 1 (<; f/..'.; ti;":; r ~ .- ,.... 1/^ I' ~ -" . " .. '-7.;.1/ - /-;" n/. . ~ .-/- - R" ~- , f" ..; Lf III J ' - ,,' .,~ ' " ." "\ ?r7-')-('~.h 'Fi.; d~;1;lt , Rxo- sl r R ?.p,~,~ ~.. '/~i. T:'(", ~",Jt . ."u { 0'7- 'S' 7":2. <---:- I -<:... l t> . ./ ~. - ~-:;--:> /"7. L. (~'<' - _-:.~))_.... r -:-. ,)j.I....: \JIILI ; -':1 I Yr. \).,(... \ \ \{L \;h: ~l '-':d-; ~i~t - ,- I {<~(, V ~::-o7/""ll ~ 'JX'l-!-lq{.t ~~I- ~ ~(.)-{Al'~ ) k/~riY':: r 1ft I. /- . ' I /" ~ . /?') )' J.../; !JW 1..t1/~. ~7 -/3'1!)) )J. 't. I~ ?S81 . (r;:fttl SEt) 3~(( '8~')-Llr,;.:~ ~ /~ 1-4{ ;'1 G."."-- . i ~ o o ---' WE, 7HE U&DERSICNED, N~IC"nOR3 U~ U~IV:P5I!~ S~~AR: SHOPPING CENTER, bAV~ ~O OBJECTI03 TO HAVInG A MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIOUED SHOPPI~G CEeTER. INFACT, A MARKET THSRE, WOULD BE VERY COCVENIEllT FOR US, WOULD RE~UCE DRIVING AND wcu~: ~AVE 7I~E, ~_ ~91 ~E URSE ~~~T A ?2R~::T FOR THAT USE L~ ,.;~A::?ED. \..... I ) (' , ame ~ 11 Adcir,ess ;y.' t ,....lit ,';' ~. 11'1/.,/, I I'Fc' ".~,'/ --/r/ -' /", " _ ) . /'1 v I '~~') 1 1)'1-',:' .,',.. . ((/.,) No,A. :.'( ," I -;ti ;-'/ : 7:i'~:~/ j' J."" I ~ >~' ..Jl' 'J C .-7 ~ : ~;~';" /c{r. 1u,,'I""':U /((7 ,<<, g)-iI., ?,,? :, " V~,(./;.--..... Ii c 't.'. .It.; "jn II 4: /7 ? ,:7::,'7 - (: ',: '(.. : " ~~';.-r:'--. 1'/( id.) .h1?t'In- (/11/(/ y::j' 7 -L~-j {'I (/,..~/~ .'J k, (.' k',:,,/)/~// ,*/K/ ~)'1-,L)I-~)l~~ /" . , , 1 /1r-t:?U /('''f'ldaU 11/t'5 ~'7-/7'i(-/ . ~;\' ;: '('y /([1, r",,.1fkll it I(,~; i1,7 1'1<11..\ '-fA [1UC1/'l /MO ^~'J1rII'1// tf 1[, 9 ~...t - 'ill 2~_ /jJp",,'f#~~~_/C: 6{1 Af.",.-Ih /1 .:fJ lit' ff'ltlf.. V6 II' :;IM]J f 1/d:. k~ II h () 1r'h1f1/J /1 HI (j- mt'(r./u - G- ~.~M. l';oj' $(,0 ~dcd' -'\j u ~0G-l~(;<i t"'" ;1L~a<..._.-4r. Jl,(s-C ~,_LU -:\t \ ''\1... ~~''1- ~61"1 "., t. ~6-D.~ . --kc - j{N(' ~~l?~~.qr;I~ ::..1k.f:L') 1LE,Aj~LL ~ -4/f:7 -- '~-<rJ )Jt,_Jh /~. '-0 cf? it,v!(" /J.. rJ I,L g&t)-~(,:;)cj .J:.. ' ~ \.'-a.'",-~' 1.J^(~,.\(~..A.n()~ b??\\l,\ Vb- i.,ll:l.X ". ...1., OJ. .(....".0.....",'" 1/../..0 Rf'v-.--i~ti n( ." 177 ~,'1f 7-'11.;)) , .. . ~....'-t-.\..t>--'c":'I:~~ '\(1';,> 'l....-.r1~\. r::,,...t:' ,: . <OBI-~/'-:J~ '\. c H (""0' ~ ";--' -] r7 o o . WE, THE UNDERSICNED, N:ICODORS U~ UGIV:~SI~~ S~~An: SHOPPINC CENTER, bAVE UO OBJECTIO~ TO HAVIUC A MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERACE IN THE ABOVE MENTIONED SHOPPI~C CEeTER. INFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VERY COKVE9IEDT FOR US, WOULD R~DUCE DRIVINC A~J WOULD :AVE ~I~E. ~E URGE ~~~T ~ ?:R~!? FOR T~AT C5E __ :~~~N7~~. Phone ~ -rerr'l l AIlA.y rAM'-=:.. S ~ -5;:;;;- 5 ':5Iv.{[) A IJ- ~ ~~('A> lIT':r:~: t (l 71l c.- f 0-..,. _P C-fJ I ( )/1 ') ~Z;- _ )-'-r"J..... J . '- Jr::.) -t.- t::,. '\ rv-\...... - ,- . / I / P. /A '" ~ ' c"," " Address J G b D W. ~ ,N'1.J.) r- /~~'i' W. [AJ;IJJ6blt. s., J.kl( \.JltJ~~bR ST' ~ lC ;"t\~Or C,,-T- J btJS W f,.>ocx> Ii!. C;,T ~l>1.\ ~~P\l \ ()O~ L/-10t./ !.-,4/18ucW;JD.e. t/ ~ 17 LAir F JV/J'i/n Da. 1-f3l>5 LA KtuJOOd df.. ync,- l.JfJ€t-J()ptJ DI< '1917 /VI ~k-/fU R..J II' 1~ 1?1~ /JP' cX604~ &~Q~' r1. 77 ,1.(1:/ ~t1' ,J I;>-f. .'~A e ,/)44t7"r.:7N 1590- E ~5"r: ""-Jr>- , I 1 .' , I \...,~ , h~.1 \('G ~'" t:, ":? ''f {. ''''-' --I' .- -- ..' ,,' ..' -, ~~~~:~ ~ 'SG'7- S'6? v~~ i~1 1~71 ~~~ s~. 05"6-.3;6~,~; ~7- ro 7 '"I I.. ~ ""h~"(~ . . , ~g..,. 1'1'- b ~O'I't.. If <:{( 7 'b 7b~ ~~, x:>~"3 ~'l~I()L.. 987-0370 1/,/7 -- (..U)-r-!6~C r ~" 113,,;... I 'I ~1?,1_L 5-7 ~ Jli!IJ? 7 p! C{f{) - 01~ '- /' , c , - , / ~ ". ~.d"'-"" " -,-- - \' ..- ._- o o WE, THE U~D:RSICIED, NEIGHnORS U, U~IV:R3I~~ S~~AR: , SHOPPInG CENTER, bAVE NO OBJECTION TO HAVInG A MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIOnED SHOPPIIG CEU~ER. I InFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD EE VERY conVENIENT FOR US, ~~ULD REJU2E DRIVING An~ wou:~ ,-AVE TI~E. WE URC:: -:i':1~T A FE;..;.l!'! FOR THAT USE i::": ;;.:;,i;7:~:l. ("")07<=> m7 1/;1:0 Av~ .:iJL/LtJ&qfY?("J? :)(')(..0 {I//AtI// /.71/(: ~t /~.-:: ..(r",c/,{/..v~ . ~6tL-'L _ /r2:?~ t:b/kr;e ~ .k:7/t:J ~aSe ZefJg;6 '13 3 ~/;9/M Ijl/E' _)i~~ A - ,,~ 1J6t' to~~ 9'(.tt 311 ~~\.-4\ '!:.\ "'\Ol-\~\\~ ~f\\\\1> \~~ Do( '* :).\4 8~). -10"\0 Ar.\? ,,~~ \').n) ~~ \) \' ~ ao\ g8~- CoBS- IAt:,~ %\1>!)\~\)E ~~~ ~,),~ &8'l-~'\84 ;' !\i\. c-;._)'?:~ h~.t.\\\r'\\\\.iX\ur"~\,~ <Rn-mL '- -y,1^~ (7,/~/ /#~t? gtf'7~0/:5:2 {,IA ~(,) /6-M' ~/ j'(O~' ffl,. / 1/'1 Z}~ j~ lfrfi/it-o- . l;arne --- .J to. \/ fJU;;C7 , ~~010-:<: J ~.Ji~ (l e jy([fjr-I ~:(\ A.ldr..sS Phone gfc.-;) V1 (. Si;:r,&:ure 17(r V [L) JJu'cP/IV 176.3 ..5ht"';cI ''''-1 J-/ qCt(j OOt. nltX idJ e. J J-jO Lf~ndA// :Df? ;J7T //llV l 5t:J7S (< , \ \ \ \\. I' $3~C'm 88/J-/6t1~ I ~._~?~~ ~ J .. .1';". .. . . o D ~-- I . - --.. - . WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, NZIGHBORS ~F UNIVERSITY S~UARE SHOPPING CENTER, hAVE 10 OBJECTION TO HAVInG A . MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC . , BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIONED SHOPPING CENTER. INFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VERY CONVENIEnT FOR Us, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND WOULD SAVE TI~E. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRANTED. Name Address ~~~""; -\1:\",5 Col \eq,<>.1* I ~ 3 '_ _\ ___ J~;.5 Cc>\~r' ;ff1j~ _\&!~ \3'<.I\~.woS Iq~S" .uJ. L"I\e~e p..;e Jla,.v:l ~~"( ~AT1~ Sl'+~ AS A~oUF." ~il4'.N\ ....\;Wd.... ( \ Lft#t.? 5f1AA /71.r 1,) r/J/1"-1e ~VE~/"l) %.. ,..j)_C1 II ., 'i '" ~,~~ Phone ~~7-;21 ~4 ~:r-~I'fo9 $;87-5')..83 .~ I q.'l..'3 ;-:; /,,~S-- -- ~ 0"'.... J7uJL- ' I( If ,~~~~)., " ~~-f; . .r C'lv ~.&mflf. lCJC;ZS ~fJ ~T1'C)l{J :.~ .~. _ A..~~ 13J,!5' (' -~... .~~ ~\C"v ., - , ,. ~ ~ g80-tl;;2lf.:I.. lV~ aroD -G4~ ~ -~ ')/'tIjt"" " t~l. ~ ,I't' WE, THE ulm_QIGNED, IIEIGllilORS ll~ U!nv:::.Oy S~.~AR:': . SHOPPING CENTER, hAVE NO OBJECTION TO HAVING A MARKET ~HICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE A30VE MENTIONED SHOPPING CENTER. INFACT, A MARKET ?HERE, WOULD BE VERY COMVENIE~T FOR US, WOULD REJUCE JRIVING AND WOULD SAVE TIME. WE URGE THAT A F~RMI~ FOR THAT USE EE GRANTED. ( :j , /!, . t,.e, E-.-..... . '- / t.. ,'n U/ It' Pa t{ iu.. ( . v .. \ '1/1--<.02::. ;c<:::-/.~\'; C.1>t~ -=:/~'l m~ 1.-1, c~r.. , (n.0.. ".n .I'~ ,\ "., '.. ~ ,~C\.i L1u., .:), \,,~ \ _ . -J;-:;y. y. f-f C';'I~3J'.- ./ -:)Ji~,;,r / (-tt P-;;I . 1"1/ Kr; P-01' ---. Address Phone (.,!~, 'I . I , (ell p.f !-:(,~ .ILl'( f .J, . /..., I,/~(" ':I: (~. .- ':{. \c.i'-X:; t"~(.' \~-,/li{(' :.w-~1.C ;; . 1 /0.. 'J ~-l,.l Jd'.. ~,l"., . J'H:J L0i.l'd.~ /-dI/< :tt be.> (.., "/2"_1 W71;;17/ .:-~/4 M '; t ( ill- it ~ v c. //4 Sf: " cn, '\ (c,\ \.. yo:' l-let' I \ ~ d~~"(~ //J:fP ;.4 'B''i:7' 'j (fe, /) C lie <..( '< 1 ' td"! 7'> I <I~<t} . U-u J J---' v' C- ~ , 1(':'\('" (..(.l,.f, ,-, ~ '"l 1(\ J )- '''~~:;\~:g'~} \\0 '"/! ' u- .'( I ft. , c.... ( " " I I I ( ,;;%:1;:;;~,-::.a ~\ I I /~'f )$Cc.. II qc:r E> ;~;~~~li~~o ~ . o o -'.... ". . '."~'\' " ~....;o ,H'.": . .. ....u J\. . . . <Iii- .-.1 ' tIE. TH~ UHDEIlSIOICED. ;.IZIOUDORS l)!' UlllV::!\aI~l~~I~ _ SIlOPPl NO CEl/TER, itA VE tiO OBJECTIOIl TO HAVIIId:A:: " ., ..... ' .,,'"' MARK~T WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIONED SHOPPIIlG CENTER. ! IUFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VERY COCVEIlIEUT FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVIl/G AND WOULD SAVE TIME. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRAIl~ED. . ,L.~ .1 ., Address 50/3> v~~ ~ V yqfo lJ~ ~ .J. ' . , I y.:n-r1111 ~<(31) i/~ /lu-l' ~ ~. 0 'i,I..-:.::;:F- ;!! ~ 7t" '! (fec c -J , _,6 ' :j /{ljj./Jt.PJu.~1U< RdflJrI. ~.,\,.. ~d. .A...~ .-:tl.-- I b ::l1..4A QM~ (1.-- ~" ,.~ /f,n SflelCltJl1A/ lp J.5&9 <.hp,;rltJ n 1?d ~ ~",.(ll\., ~'-" . I 5 'Fe, " ~ft-' .o~~ I ,,'" st..,,;.! A~ ~. ' /61:1. S/,q;J".. {(./ ...lJA. '2. L :,.0 ~ ,LIt.-. ~ d 1~-:31, ~.?,J.{~' lJ.l" 1f2('~l!te. ~ --/~'l , , P\ 1901.~ C-C I 1=-1We-"", Sl .~ .' .' I ll=..rfL . . ~ It~~,v....:FI51J ~~~ ~ .r. ~~ -1...1(, SI~A"7"7D'" -<J.A" ;; 57 E l>'"t 4 Phone 'b''ii''I1I ~:l I" 15 ,sllr;z /IM M Ko ~ -\, g'(O i~ ~ 8~;;.8bt8 ~ o ., Qr~ -- ; '~J:S4 ,g." _~. ,I. f.~.c .: 'VII' ~81."'JI)IJlSIC.J:DI IIZICUDORS Ill" unVtRSI'!'1" S~:JAR: ' " iA 'l" . ..' ~ , . l' .., ..... . 1 ' ...;It, . ..\1 . , ,., " .~.. . 1 ~.. . . .'<'~ ' SJIOPPIlIO CEIITER. bAY! EO OBJECTIOll TO HAVIno A ,\ i~ ~'t:.., ~' ,. . ,. ., o MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THI SALE OF ALCOHOLIC \.~ '. .,i' .. ,~,_. BEVERAOE IN THE ABOVE MENTIOllED SHOPPIfIO CENTER. t ,. IRFACT. A MARKET THERE. WOULD BE VERY CONVENIEnT FOR us. WOULD REDUCE DRIVINO AND WOULD SAVE TIME. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRANTED. ~', . ~ ~_:~. . Phone ~.~~f~allle Address i~1 ;!N.JfA$1J. 193b (nt./&.f $I hI '~d:~~~' //I~I"J ~ 8 ^I..~,.f ..Jc!:S7 t a'fo~" If.3o c.."Ll.~ ~ #..!"r ~. JI!;;i> DI/jr A-k. "-~ L5?r>("nlJ~P kll~ c#-'5~ fll tJ C.DJI~ rllIl 1#- 9~ ~f9-,S sun!C~7 LI ~lJd Sr;,I"f (,._t... Jj, ,..,~--< k'J . J1iliU JI. [WAIf>41 'a.~~...,,!Q~ _lqC)\.\. gf~ st. Gte.~,,\ L~\).l~ l'\o-~ ~ :Ai- ,#;L1~ IJl~:h Sta'e ~(JtH. - ft7-/7'f2- '1"'?7"C,$IJ/ S- ~o - If 3 ( ~- 3"S-->') ~7-t:kS~ ~_.{;flU ~ffi -(o4~ ~~ r-C(7"/ t> ...? -:s're, ~7 '3:- ,~n2 if (, C q- f 7- ,-t-5'~ p~ 987 - 2~<J' ~.t~ ~ If 0 ;:loY 6 '/l-il;U:'!J.'IJ ~ ,c< ~ '<)61,cf1{oJ. <6~O - 10Ct g, ctCbc -\O~~ KltO - l ~t ~ /. K;;;;;;';::\:.," .~~ I WE, THE UllDEQG::ED, :ii::IGiiilOR:J 0: U:::VBF,Qy S:l,UARE SHOPPING CENTER, hAVE SO OBJECTI09 70 HAVI~G A MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SA~E OF ALCOHOLIC EEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIOGEO SHOPP1~G CENTER. :~FACT, A MAPKET THERE, WOULD SE VE3Y C09VE~IE~T FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND w:~LD SAVE ~!ME. WE URGE THAT A ?ERM:: FOR THAT USE =E GRANTED. 5 ' '.): (ca;;-::;t= ?~p~f WtJ5~. cay-. ~ ff~~// --p,.-- -)37-773 C. ~ 51S t'j.-- '1 b wL l"z/fIIJJ1 ~r7 70(..1 . ~ ~ ~ . - ~ (l/JJP~ ff?~r' /~".. ~~ g: _/.~ .J~ -r-:-: <6~Q _L4 "I,:) ~'\) ~ ~ Addr~sS _ J9~ ('nllo~p -J-~ "\ '" ,C{;:l5" cd I~"" ~:t:t-.:::lt'_n · 7 -..J *7-11 1'1 Z, S c()I/~<l ~-L -ti:..:ZJn - P!lone Signature ,&~i-lU'f .. u e87-9'~'7 " ""<:;- C((-:;- 0 3l/ cf ~~~;~:..j;. -- . " o o WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, NZIGliBORS 0' U~IVZnSITY S~~AR: SHOPPING CENTER, bAVE ~C OBJECTION TO HAVING A MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERACE IN THE ABOVE MENTIONED SHOPPINC CENTER. INFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VERY CONVE3IE~T FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND WOULD SAVE TI~E. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRANTED. jf7- 9037 ...fj1'''3 f6 g '5171(- ~-5d'-l(, 1(1 - 'f1"'1...~ 9f$"7 - rnj..7 b_' L./k~. Y"'n - ts"r./., <Jf7,$17~ -~~\ Name Address ~Aij;i mn!if7f j57JL .sIU/dll/AJ ~B..lli..!/_l:rJ~.twJ~ .J ~ /3 5Yv/;d flt,Y1 'D,..,. LEScMALI I (;1.'2, <;~(,r\t1a.. ((d' L1Lj'2..D N.0~~ ~ IO~1 "i'l~ D N -V;f--U' ITV -:;J'::/4)C ~ ~420 (II V}lf~ifY?/~~l \" ...., \. I ~..,.. ~ ,J#IDc.(~ (;['11~ 1.{4,,-() A;, u"t6;rty ~ I.P+- /of 1 Lf'-t PI , / ,,# ~ ~#:'1 .~~-,.A ,.,~.. ~ A...e."""'/7'7 \~~b ~ 1rl1fLJ!> rr&'J ~~, .J.~ .i9~ Cn ~~e'8" 80c ~ 1::t2- 14p. <!d~c.. ~be,. 1f ~. !UJ ,+;1'(1, ._ ~C(Jt~ I if! ~~~ :::::;;r , N.~ri\~n!l~ Phone ~ ~fJO-/5'7P ~ 88'7- "IY~ g-r-o -3d" I W'O-~1-~ ~-(cr"J 3la..- M,"'/~I' <?9.1J t~ ,~(57d2. ~-~5 J"aO-(A1/n' -~ .... " - i " .. . Utt"" .~. ~ l o o WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, NZIGliDORS U, U~IV:RSI~Y S~~AR: -'- t snOPPING CENTER, bAVE ~O OBJECTIOU TO HAVI~G A MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIOnED SHOPPInG CEnTER. INFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VERY COCVE~IEDT FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND WOULD SAVE TI~E. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRANTED. L..ct\ \ ~ J Phone 34151/J 1_ r;.,oVJ 7A c. .fJ. ~ J4Lj~.J At ~ M~ C-~ ~ l/, Address YJ-o A. L V v. ql~',' , '\ 9y1~t>A). I/tUl'TtI ~r[ )~~t',~~~, C(Cf'VJ Ii #PMJy'! ~IIGI.. ~:z.o \1. ,1~u,d*'OD{ I c(r06,.!. (/~'1{)r/-/ M!. ~/O\lY' l.j I..j].() fJ 7) ~A~ l/J(?~ /1.1, V)l1Z~/"7'r /()(I J-f H 1. (J ~0fl6if...1 f(J 13 4'1Zo JJ. ~s.=-t? ~ /~75"'" tA II II .. -Jf./t>':l C{ - 'iJ6r;5ft/J ~-~~ ~- 6~/3 _ ~;?4,q Rq '3 ~o - '7I1Cf, If " .f1lM- ~41, I!.:.J .tJ. , m-l--z..oG'1 ~ 'il~eh - OX'lID ~ . " o o A.It, SOP1XlO"1 be" 71'>,( 4- . AGte ~7 - i'fl=> . , ~~O'?:Z1:, '1 ,I ~ iD-??.r,7 ( " ~O '~<6c? :tt:>oifl ((t7-tJ/7r ~)c; ~ )~7 2.~ -::41 ~^ 7~ ~iO mLt 7fJf..~ '1q()-7J/~T .d Uli.. ~D .K'3QL- ~ , ,i 1:- ----w.. ",-:::,,,,m. .."".", 0' ommm-,,:m, SHOPPING CENTER, hAVE KO OBJECTIOn TO HAVING A MARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIONED SHOPPING CENTER. INFACT. A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VERY CONVENIENT FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND WOULD SAVE TI~E. I ~ $ -q J WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRANTED. . Name Address Phone .i!7~" 7/)9" ])iA1W:r. fkiVJdAtk't. .!if23N. (lum/v;dGf AtJ/.,s.J?,. . ,,_ J / ~ JI J f , ~IJI~'( j) frl'BK.AAAtlrz_ ~fye.L:t/-.o~d,' 'lKSOrr u(,y,h~,j?o/ ~-.f-'. 58. -P/ff? IS 'B LAc_N. woLF .:2.ot5'jv. (J1JUtl7D6 ~~~ f'Pr:l~ ~s Co {(eqt' A-ue. '':H'S C..I/~~ .,tu]e \." b " <;:({)1#-Lf4 "~oU<. GGO-o50<'" Jj>?, '7lJ7if ..' ::~'~ ~~: I y,""1 M~ :t=:t,~ ~~~ '~~IIP~;' '5u:.'# SiY'P$-SV dO(".~ Go (Ie~r- ~ ~~); 7~S- " W~~ ~~ :' ,Av. ~-~ R~,,> ~ j(..~ . ---- --- 887-911-4- ~ ffl ... tu1 _ gto - /4f2 2-11:: > ~/I''''':I " :J.6 ~< f. "';"c... 'f f' <...t::Jrct:: cl!~> (, , \ \' 1\ \' \ {. II uw~ (\,ol~l &:~~ ~CL~* IA. <.....J.."..__-:+~~ , ' o o WE, THE UNDERSIG~ED. UZIGUDORS U, U~IV:~3I:Y S~~AR: SHOPPING CENTER, hAVE 10 OBJECTION TO HAVIIG A MARKET WHICH WOU~~ INCLUDE THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN THE ABOVE MENTIONED SHOPPIUG CEUTER, INFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VERY CO:VEUIEUT FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND WOULD SAVE TI~E. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE BE GRANTED. Address Phone "'/ /~ . ,,'-It, ;'V."- . / .' .,. ". J.. v . ~' fYlerr I (LIrv 9,:~ -=- \ .&~" f)5OrJt I [) m~SHac::I~ ~.. U7S7/t. 9v7. ~7f1 ~ - Sip:nature .A )::;;/i/c.. No"vt. . ~7- )~)- ~~ jJO- ~'r' ri7 ~ 287-">.).3 ~ .:t <irf7-3/b ~ ~~ -- -- -- 7:A It~(- " .. ..- ....-- - -- -- ~L~ - ~ ~ .., '. UE THE t:'I!lO-~'I=-!l ""'-'-"~"P"'" ,,"-"-O~'" sr...,,,.,. .,. , . _ ......,~_ t .._.'J.....v ~ _-. ......... ...l. ,.\..o.'L.\_ GIIO?PIIlG CE::T::R, hAVE 1;0 0SJ:::CT~:J:: :~ ::;.:IIl:G II MARKET WH:CH W:JULD INCLUDE THE SALE 0: ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE IN T9! ABOVE N!~T!OIlED EHOPF!~G CE9TER. IllFACT, A MARKET THERE, WOULD BE VE?Y CO~VE3IEllT FOR US, ~CULD REDUCE DRIVING AND WOUL~ SAVE TIME. WE URGE THAT A PERMIT FOR THAT USE 3E :RAllTED. '\"C\\ ,V \ Address ~ - 7JiJ7- ,:/-'6"0 L ( <S"'&I- I " r.7. gg7 -/7I.(-L ff6 -;-65 fr ,f r '7' - .? ,( 7'~1').' 880- 04/?/ ~ /I II ~;;;~ ().t~ t:y ~'/7-71 M. J I fH..nJ'It.I~ I r- o - ~ : -- i , ' o ,rrUiHjIi ljIi IU,'j , -~ 1~'"'I,lI..I''' ~ p"Jn~'! jU~ -" ~mqUI; '1';1 ,. !~. . Ii.:' 'Iii" I. I I I ; I' '. ,r.: I' ~ I " . " , I! I I i'i!i'i IIiIIj i!Ili Ii !!i'!Jjli ~!i~~.'l -R==:' , H. -mI, ~:e! JI~'~I i1j ,~,U 'H' i i ! 'I .jJ' I!::J 'Hi .I L mil III ",.' · n! ~:er! h" h,e Ii ,'I~ ill : ,'t== P. I" :1 " . , :"1 ':1 _It. I ..-- r.fi: " il~ I~n: I: ~ h i II 'ill'l!"" i,'" , ,., "'Ill !~!~ n "Grr1~ - I !I,i!!," ~ n . ,41---= . ~ ' 0; Clil I , I 'G"'P . I . . 'II ,I,i1'! I " 1 ~ !~!'l'll i:llL ~.~ ~ -~i! mli Ii '~ ~ ij~ ~ !I J.E&L, ~::'~~iIHI! IiI ~ 0 III " ~1' I ;J '; ". . . ." · I C I 1(IHil~' iP fill ilii E III .'. I I. I r ' , . " ~ =<- ~.. - o I -I: ! I i i , 0' , , ' ~ , - . '\::) :! I.. ~. ~ ! , " . ,-- '-t-~ i I; !.e ill f:: :\ , ' \st' \ /. A' // /,-'.ii,.___ ~.. .......:.--' / !e I ~ II- o @r - RIuh. Prtce AIdL'Acta -.-.- ------- \ ", - aT ;{; - ;-.;- , ' o o I I , I " I ~~ ! !, 1* , ~ I iii I ' I q, l il I , I i I ,- f" I Il- I I i I.. ~ -111"~1 '''''' al,'.'{',"I' 'I ~ I ", ." , , I' jllllj II '~I ,I ; . , . ! I i ~I e: ~ ...,.... ii~ ~I~~ R.~ iilli~)III;ln.~I' . .' I I;..J 'fI III I .!. I~ il' , 11,1 , '1I,!!Ii! !II, : _....IIi::! ~H~:hID I! !:If: ,,1,1 nip',,::, _ -.. "".,= II I I I. , II; iLl' ..J! !!IIII'!~ II! ' ..~ 'I' =- .. II IIzt I =!;I; II ~ !!! ~. I ':if I III ,.,..APrlceALctI'UcII -.-.- ------ -I) ~,A'1' >1}- /,;- " REST RooM }D' OFFICE . . FI6IJ({ DRAlfJ \\ "" ~ 3~" , WAlk-IN COOLER ~ ~ .J { ~ , . i' V1 ~ Lu :t:. (j1 Itl I I I ! 1 i I 1 I 70' i yOlAIITAt"fII PR'tN\<S I FRoNi COIAN'"TER. . I CIISH1ER :.. -~._-- Floc? R ENTE 'f\1Jcc. nRf\l.W k-- 35"'. j . . . o ATTACHMENT G o LOCATION CASE CUP NO. 90-72 HEARING DATE 2-19-91 AGENDA ITEM # CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PLANNING DEPARTMENT 6 0' 0' 0; N: 'griP l!): -I ~~ C...~.,OIt.I. ITAT! UNIVUIITY ~ . , o PETITION o WE THE UNDERSIGNED STRONGLY OPPOSE THE ISSUING OF ANY KIND OF LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1689 KENDALL OR. OR ANY SURROUNDING AREA IN THIS VtCINITY. WE FEEL THAT SUCH A LICENSE WILL ONLY INCREASE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS WE ARE NOW EXPERIENCING WITH TRAFFIC HAllARDS TO OUR CHILDREN AND INCREASE THE CRIME RATE IN OUR AREA. NAME ADDRESS o 6 c2bd~ >t4D~~ 'J2!fDl :Irq< ') .,/:J!i/ - .SB 9~.j/7 ~~:J, .-;~ /~3S- j(~/Jk7fl A. 5,/3 ~~LfD7 7~C.~ SZ.Jb h(/az~ AVe- 5./5. 9.2 YO} ~~\.~~~Cl~ J \c\=lql\.'), ~~~~S)~S\-.'~ <iQ<\-Ol- .....9Alom ~0- rov+ rPoJu~ct.. 4d-.-l..{oTf . / I ,1. ify Ci PETITION o WE THE UNDERSIGNED STRONGLY OPPOSE THE ISSUING OF ANY KIND OF LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1689 KENDALL DR. OR ANY SURROUNDING AREA IN THIS VICINtTY. WE FEEL THAT SUCH A LICENSE WILL ONLY INCREASE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS WE ARE NOW EXPERIENCING WITH TRAFFIC HAZZARDS TO OUR CHILDREN AND INCREASE THE CRIME RATE IN OUR AREA. ~~ src:V~ ;;5A.AJl:lAI-fL- \ q ~ '-\ rl.. 4~17 \( 9 ~OA-\ \ c\ e. J.. A kr:; uJon 1) iJ/l. ZIP CODE S~DD 9d-.407 51111{ "BpND C1p-vo1 cr/)1fb7 9'2.<-/67 NAME ADDRESS ., C.I Ir 'r 'r 971 ~ ~~ ..IVlO 9~()7 S, "', t:tqtJ/ /~S'o ,..;," PETITION o o WE THE UNDERSIGNED STRONGLY OPPOSE THE ISSUING OF ANY KIND OF LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1689 KENDALL DR. OR ANY SURROUNDING AREA IN THIS VICINITY. WE FEEL THAT SUCH A LICENSE WILL ONLY INCREASE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS WE ARE NOW EXPERIENCING WITH TRAFFIC HAZZARDS TO OUR CHILDREN AND INCREASE THE CRIME RATE IN OUR AREA. ,;: NAME ~ ~ ~ . ADDRESS ZIP CODE 1& Y ~ .. ['j3r ,-('j(J~/iI ,:w,)~. f~l '" ..*. )ATE NAME QDRESS -~~,,(T\~,^- 6tCf.~~l(, C,(fl , TIJ ~...._ !f 07] kJ.~ ~, k...l 3) I , )~ '--f? l ; fJ V 5.' .Jijjt, SJvr-c/~ ,/. ~/i13 5~( 4.<0. c, /6/(;.. ~~;Jo.r.l<d, /fry "3 b ~I~..b...} lftJ/ Ih~i J?JJnt/Ja.-v !?e. ~ . rr {ftiRI()A . . :> '10 COl~ tf- t'(fl3JS2P--B9.1!j ~ ~~ Cf"l\\~'1-Q~ (3 jO ~ ~ -#179- lfl30 C~-e.~\~ I'D.? eolley? /tH #fS:; &'67-/10 ~ /7 J{J f'?o//q'MJ) /Jt!l) flH{!J1 (~~Qtl~ (/ e:1/D.I!J9- ~ ~""" (!"J!AI l'fY7 i'A>"'tO ~'K{;O"""i -t~ ~~. ff~~~nril1 V1;?{) &\lp5e~-#=' &)1t7"tJ: -~-- " PHONO SIGNATURE <rl t'f -D0"1-"1 '-IVtA >'>-n- '1v1f( ~"7. 6tf J{> h. -mo-. ~~ .-,0f!? ~'11~"7 j'f7~ f'?P 'KJrJ- 'if?9 0 ~{4 -- r --- ~ COUNCvLMAN TOM MINOR, WARD 5, WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, NEIGHBORS OF UNIVERSITY SQUARE SEOP?ING CENTER, URGE YOU TO SUP?ORT A CONVENIENCE ~~RKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF BEER AND WINE IN THE ABOVE REFERENCED SHOPPING CENTER. A ~~RKET IN THIS LOCATION WOULD BE VERY CON~ENIENT FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND PROVIDE A NECESSARY SERVICE. WE SUPPORT THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THIS RETAIL CENTER. \ NA.'l:E Q01l.ESS . PRON9 t;~~~t:r\~~hWt "'\ \1 a t N). :3 h eR.-l~f.~'Q ') W'O ~ erg t !~9l )7Ib~bAJl./C;)1 / C70 5 It "i7'r{o" ~ r~ t1 (ck ..,j r:!.J '(' II )90 6 I ~ ~ J9M ('~S<J )E:{) l'i "'1 (Jel!ey> 1(; 'f:- ~'~~ 11,,) &eI..~, k..'f- ,I. j ,.l. "10 "'" ". '(;8 4'-'1NlMowlJlflhl l'?lJ.:> C.:>l-L1UJ.. /36 rn/fQ~V~, l'l~d ClJe(f 114 _kf~ aLjAlA~ 1'J8() ~.J/"I' /17_ SIGNATURE ho-IO$?. No 8E6 .. 5'~~ ~ ~~-o W/~ $:;.& i-/" 7~O mt~130 m,. 'fit! .2f{tJ (g-7'7 ~ <;> 9 cJ - ..:;>q,:R ~(/P4"-".t<'/~~ ' 1-/ COUNCILMAN TOM MINOR, WARD 5, WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, NEIGHBORS OF UNIVERSITY SQUARE SHOPPING CENTER, URGE YOU TO SUPPORT A CONVENIENCE ~~RKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF BEER AND WINE IN THE ABOVE REFERENCED SHOPPING CENTER. A ~~RKET IN THIS LOCATION WOULD BE VERY CONVENIENT FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND PROVIDE A NECESSARY SERVICE. WE SUPPORT THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THIS RETAIL CENTER. k ~ NAL'IE QDRESS PHONP i~_ff73 /NSIfV" I C{ !, 0 tel II2I{C I.N t 11ft ( ~D~'~~';~~~'~-HI~~ ~ COUNCILMAN TOM MINOR, WARD 5, WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, NEIGHBORS OF UNIVERSITY SQUARE SHOPPING CENTER, URGE YOU TO SUPPORT A CONVENIENCE ~ARKET WHICH WOULD INCLUDE THE SALE OF BEER AND WINE IN THE ABOVE~ REFERENCED SHOPPING CENTER. A MARKET IN THIS LOCATION WOULD BE_~~ VERY CONVENIENT FOR US, WOULD REDUCE DRIVING AND PROVIDE A NECESSARY' ct} SERVICE. WE SUPPORT THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THIS RETAIL CENTER. .fJ~ o o PETITION WE THE UNDERSIGNED STRONGLY OPPOSE THE ISSUING OF ANY KIND Of LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1689 KENDALL DR. OR ANY SURROUNDING AREA IN THIS VICINITY. WE FEEL THAT SUCH A LICENSE WILL ONLY INCREASE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS WE ARE NOW EXPERIENCING WITH TRAFFIC HAlZARDS TO OUR CHILDREN AND INCREASE THE CRIME RATE IN OUR AREA. " NAME 1?~'I\t41 S;!/~R J\i\U 0~ A ~~ J ADDRESS 7'93"'< 1/tIRf//y J4.v.(. sB. ~ l0, ~lUl &,y-il.-r.,.,1 ZIP CODE 9:< Yr17 Q,{wrt ."' o o PETITION WE THE UNDERSIGNED STRONGLY OPPOSE THE ISSUING OF ANY KIND OF LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1689 KENDALL DR. OR ANY SURROUNDING AREA IN THIS VICINITY. WE FEEL THAT SUCH A LICENSE WILL ONLY INCREASE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS WE ARE NOW EXPERIENCING WITH TRAFFIC HAllARDS TO OUR CHILDREN AND INCREASE THE CRIME RATE IN OUR AREA. . AI;lDRESS 9/t?,t::f~:;;~=:: z:;) . . o o PETITION WE THE UNDERSIGNED STRONGLY OPPOSE THE ISSUING OF ANY KIND OF LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1689 KENDALL DR. OR ANY SURROUNDING AREA IN THIS VICINITY. WE FEEL THAT SUCH A LICENSE WILL ONLY INCREASE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS WE ARE NOW EXPERIENCING WITH TRAFFIC HAZZARDS TO OUR CHILDREN AND INCREASE THE CRIME RATE IN OUR AREA. NAME ADDRESS ZIP CODE r9'i'+~ Lv. Co)J-t2~ t2..z I ~" ~~ 1'd-'fo7 (../ 9. MclJI/" U 5' '12.. '101 ~5' .J.M'*le..- 1-/L/.J5 La .y5~/ u? z...~'I'r t.J ~~. 4.-r 1J7 ',2~O? " z-Yo 7 - . . .0 . o PETITION o WE THE UNDERSIGNED STRONGLY OPPOSE THE ISSUING OF ANY kIND OF LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1689 KENDALL DR. OR ANY SURROUNDING AREA IN THIS VICINITY. WE FEEL THAT SUCH A LICENSE WILL ONLY INCREASE THE EXISTING PROBLEMS WE ARE NOW EXPERIENCING WITH TRAFFIC HAZZARDS TO OUR CHILDREN AND INCREASE THE CRIME RATE IN OUR AREA. NAME ADDRESS ..