HomeMy WebLinkAbout34-City Attorney ORIGINAL
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO - REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION
From: JAMES F. PENMAN Subject: Request from former Police Detective Gina Meyer
City Attorney For Payment of Lifetime Medical Expenses.
Dept: CITY ATTORNEY
Date: January 4, 2007 M/CC Meeting Date: January 8, 2007
Synopsis of Previous Council action: None.
Recommended Motion: Adopt either Motion A, B or C.
Motion A: Grant the request of former Police Detective Gina Meyer to pay 100% of her lifetime
medical expenses which will also maintain and strengthen the morale of the City's
police officers and other City employees; or
Motion B: Approve the payment of former Police Detective Gina Meyer's entire monthly
medical insurance premiums for a period not to exceed three years, without further
approval by the Mayor and Common Council, which will also strengthen and
maintain the morale of the City's police officers and other City employees; or
Motion C: That the request for assistant former Police Detective Gina Meyer be denied.
(CL
Signature
Contact person: Stephanie D. Easland Phone: 5355
Supporting data attached: Staff Report Ward:
FUNDING REQUIREMENTS: Amount:
Source:
Finance:
Council Notes:
Agenda Item No.
SDE/ed/RCA[MeyerGina.RCA.wpd] //9/0 -7
STAFF REPORT
Council Meeting Date: January 8, 2007
TO: Mayor and Common Council
FROM: James F. Penman, City Attorney
DATE: January 4, 2007
AGENDA ITEM: Request from Former Police Detective Gina Meyer for Payment
of Lifetime Medical Expenses
On or about October 12, 2006 and December 14, 2006, the City Attorney received
a verbal request from former Police Detective Gina Meyerthat the City assume the monthly
payments of her health insurance plan. According to Human Resources, Ms. Meyer's
monthly health insurance premium is $410.35 of which $80.80 is paid by the City and the
remaining $329.55 is paid by Ms. Meyer. Next year, the City's contribution will be $99.00;
however, based on past years, the total health insurance premium is expected to increase
in an unknown amount, with the current premium amount being a 9% increase over last
year's amount. Based on the current amounts, the approximate cost for Ms. Meyer's
health insurance benefits for the next three years is $14,772.60.
Subsequent to this verbal request, Ms. Meyer submitted a written request for
payment of 100% of her lifetime medical expenses which is attached as Exhibit 1 to the
Staff Report. Also attached as Exhibit 2 is a letter from Timothy Cloughesy, M.D.
submitted in support of Ms. Meyer's request for assistance with her health insurance costs.
Also attached to the Staff Report as Exhibit 3 is an authorization signed by Ms. Meyer
allowing the Mayor and Common Council to discuss her medical condition in open session
at the January 8, 2006 Council Meeting.
Any action taken by the Mayor and Common Council to assist a former police officer
with an exemplary record, such as Ms. Meyer in her unique and unusual circumstances,
would be based on the benefit of maintaining and strengthening the morale of the City's
police officers and other City employees.
The following motions have been prepared for consideration by the Mayor and
Common Council:
Motion A: Grant the request of former Police Detective Gina Meyer to pay 100%
of her lifetime medical expenses which will also maintain and
strengthen the morale of the City's police officers and other City
employees.
SDE/ed/StaffReports[MeyerGina.StaffReport.wpd] 1
Motion B: Approve the payment of former Police Detective Gina Meyer's entire
monthly medical insurance premiums for a period not to exceed three
years, without further approval by the Mayor and Common Council,
which will also strengthen and maintain the morale of the City's police
officers and other City employees.
Motion C: That the request for assistance by former Police Detective Gina
Meyer be denied.
Attachments
i
SDE/ed/StaffReports[MeyerGina.StaffReport.wpd] 2
EXHIBIT 1
December 29, 2006
To Mayor Patrick J Morris and City Council Members
Dear Mayor and City Council Members,
Refer: My Medical Benefits
I am imploring you to consider my request for 100% Lifetime Medical.
I am now requesting 100% lifetime medical. Medical expenses have continued for the
past six (6) years and are expected to continue as long as I can continue to fight the
cancer.
I retired in October, 2000 on an Industrial Retirement, with 16 years of service
My diagnosis as well as prognoses did not look good. As I was diagnosed with
Gliobiastoma Multiforme in stage 4 (malignant brain tumor), my life expectancy at the
time was less than three (3) months.
Being a single mother of two very small children (ages 2 & 3 '/2) I felt and urgency to
make decisions. The damage to my brain from the cancer, surgery, radiation, and
chemotherapy did not allow me, nor was I capable of making decisions especially long
term, should I be lucky enough to beat the odds that were against me.
Please note that I was an officer whom was assigned to work the Cajon Pass/Duffy Train
wreck and served search warrants on Narcotic Labs and such.
Refer to my work history attached to this letter.
Thank you,
_ L
Gina Feola Meyer
EXHIBIT 1
Work History for Gina Feola Meyer
City of San Bernardino Police Department
1984- 1989 Patrol Officer
1989 - 1991 Patrol Officer with the Community Response Unit (CRU)
While working CRU I was assigned to work the Cajon
Pass/Duffy train wreck along with 4 fellow officers,
Whom also were diagnosed with cancer and have since
died.
1991 - 1996 Undercover Narcotics Unit
Buying and selling narcotics, serving search warrants
Including residential, commercial and labs.
1996- 1997 Promoted to Corporal /Detective
1997 — 2000 Detective Bureau
1 .
EXHIBIT 2
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA,LOS ANGELES UCLA
?LEG EIVED
"Y A T_UR IN E
BERKELEY-DAVIS-IRVINE-LOS ANGELES-RIVERSIDE-SAN DIE O!.S CI �j �� SANTA BARBARA-SANTA CRUZ
ttt-
9'J s �a
uc�r.
TIMOTHY CLOUGHESY,M.D. UCLA SCHOOL OF MEDICINE
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR of NEUROLOGY REED NEUROLOGICAL RESEARCH CENTER
DIRECTOR,NEURO-ONCOLOGY PROGRAM 710 WESTWOOD PLAZA,Suite 1-230
LOS ANGELES,CA 90095
December 22, 2006
Re: Gina Meyer
UCLA#244-12-26
To: Mayor Patrick J. Morris and City Council Members
Gina Meyer is a patient under my care in the UCLA Neuro-Oncology Program with a gtioblastoma multiforme
(malignant brain tumor). Ms. Meyer is currently status post treatment with surgery, radiation therapy, and multiple
chemotherapies. Due to Ms. Meyer's condition she suffers from chronic neurologic deficits that are not expected to
change over time and she will require lifelong medical care for this condition. Ms. Meyer has limited power to the
right upper and lower extremities. Ms. Meyer also has right foot drop which requires her to use an ankle-foot-orthotic
device as well as a four point cane for safety. Ms. Meyer's gait demonstrates right sided hemiplegia and
circumduction on the right leg, as well as increased tone and spasticity on the right side. Although Ms. Meyer has
continued to demonstrate evidence of stable disease since 2001, her condition is guarded and the prognosis for
glioblastoma is poor.
If you should need any additional information regarding this case please contact my office at (310) 825-5321.
Sincerely,
It.
Timothy F. Cloughesy, M.D., Associate Professor
UCLA Department of Neurology, Neuro-Oncology Program
Received: Jan 4 2001 05:00pm
, JAN-04-2007 04 =48 PM BRIAN FITCH 91093729817 P. 01
rQA,
EXHIBIT 3
AUTHORIZATION TO RELEASE MEPICA.L RECORDS
I C � MEYER, hereby authorize the release of medical information as
follows:
1 Entity who mny disclose Mform,ation: City of San.Hemardvno.
2. Medical information to be disclosed: Letter dated December 22, 2006
to Mayor Patrick J. Moms and City Council.Members fion�,Timothy V.
Clougshesy, MAD., Associate Professor, UCLA )Department Of
Neurology, Neuro-Oncology Program, my letter dated December 29,
2006 to the Mayor and City Council, and zy furthar inform t
requested by the Mayor and Common Council in consideration of�tio my
request to the City of San 13mardino for payment y life
inaedical expenses.
3.
Persons or entity who are to receive information: Mayor and Common
Council of the City of Sao. Bernardino at the open session of the
January 8, ?.007 Council Meeting.
4, Purpose of information received: To support my request to the Mayor.
and Comm on Council to approve payment of my medical expenses fir
the duration of my life.
This authorization expires on: February 8, 2007.
I have been advised of my right to receive'a copy of this authorization,.
DATED '
ilia Meyer
uU11 AUVI JU,jl�jjj rul(Ij if
SDFi/rA�'v�eyer.MotR�loaeo,>Vuthonx�tion)
i
I
i