HomeMy WebLinkAbout51-Planning
CITY OF SAN BERreRDINO - REQUEST AR COUNCIL ACTION
I,m:
t:
Larry E. Reed, Director
Co " Subject:'
Appeal of BBC finding and
BBC Action of July, 6, 1990
By: Owner, William Bringman
Re: 555 W. victoria
Planning & Building Services
Date: July 23, 1990
Synopsis of Previous Council action:
NONE
Recommended motion:
e
That The Board of Building Co.-issioners' finding of July 6, 1990, that
the City incurred costs in the amount of $7,172.00, for the abatement
actions at 555 W. Victoria, and the BBC Order to incur the costs of the
abatement actions as a lien against the property and a personal
obligation of the owner(s) be upheld.
cc:
Shauna Edwins, City Administrator
John Martin, Senior Assistant City
~~
Signature
Ron Burdette
384-5205/384-5223
Phone:
Order, Demand Letter, 2
Exhibit A. Court Ward:
$7,172.00
Contact person:
Staff Report, BBC
Supporting da~ attach:fl: Stat~m~nt nf Cost
Complaint, -~gfl~g Fire Report,
FUNDING REclUIREMENTS: Amount:
001-181-41733
Source: IAcct. No.)
Board Ups & Demolitions
IAcct. DescriDtionl
Finance:
'"
f7~ - '/
eCil Notes:
75-0262
-/
...,
AQenda Item No._ -_
CITY OF SAN SER.RDINO - REQUEST .R COUNCIL ACTION
e
A. 12-20-89
B. 12-22-89
C. 12-25-89
eD.
12-29-89
E.
01-10-90
F. 07-06-90
STAFF REPORT
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & BUILDING SERVICES
CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION
555 W. VICTORIA
SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92410
REPORT/PROJECT NO. 90-3654
APN. 134-023-05
An inspection was made, the structure was found to be Open
& Vacant with trash and debris throughout property.
Notification process began with a Ten (10) Day Correction
Notice and Intent to Abate Nuisance being mailed.
The Fire Department responded to a fire at this property.
The structure suffered major fire damage. Based on the
extensive amount of fire damage stated on the incident
report which was routed to the Code Enforcement Division.
An on site inspection was ordered to determine the amount
of damage. The supervisor of the Building inspection
Division made the determination that the building suffered
over 50% fire damage.
The structure was still open with persons going in and
out, presenting an immediate health and safety hazard.
The structure was
summary abatement
pursuant to Section
abated by the lowest bidder
order and the owner was
15.28.150 of the S.B.M.C.
under the
notified
Board of Building Commissioners' ordered a lien against
the property for costs that have been incurred.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
The Current Zoning is R-S. (Residential Suburban)
The Staff Recommendation is to uphold the Order of the Board of Building
Commissioners to incur the costs in the amount of $7,172.00 as a lien on
the property and a personal obligation of the owner(s).
CE/555WVICTORIA
e
75.0264
e
e
e
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1
.....<D OJ' BUILJ)IJlCJ CODISSIOO'
ORD.. BO. 1419
aB1'oa'.F BO. 90~3654
2
3 OUD OF TB. BC)AllD..OF. BUILJ)ING CODISSIONERS OF THE CITY OF
SAN BDIIDDIJIO AtJTBOaIZING THE ABATEMENT OF A PUBLIC NUISANCE.
4
,
6
WHEREAS, pursuant to the San Bernardino Municipal Code, Title
15, Chapter 15.28, the Building Official has posted a buildinges)
located at 555 West Victoria
, San Bernardino, california,
7
8
9
10
and has notified persones) having an interest in the above prop-
erty that the buildinges) or premises constitute a public
nuisance:
11 WHEREAS, pursuant to San Bernardino Municipal Code, the build-
12 ing Official has served a "Notice of Hearing Before the Board of
13 Building Commissioners of the City of San Bernardino", relating to
14 abatement of said nuisance, to the persones) having an interest in
l'
16
the above property, and has prepared a declaration of mailing of
the notice, a copy of which is on file in these proceedings: and
17
WHEREAS, a hearing was held to receive and consider all
relevant evidence, objections or protests on .luly n
, 19 Jl.CL,
and examined the evidence offered by the parties relative to the
alleged public nuisance,
WHEREAS, the Board of Building Commissioners heard the test-
imony and examined the evidence offered by the parties relative to
the alleged public nuisance,
IIII
. IIII
IIII
-1-
e
e
e
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
:za
BO. 0., BUrLDrBCI' 0., COJOlrssro-..s.
ORDU RO. 1419 1Ul1O.~ JIO'. ClO-3654
1
1
3 N~RB, 1'1' rs ORDERED BY THE BOARD OF BUnDING
COMlaSSIORERS 01' THE CITY 01' SAN BERNARDINO AS FOLLOW:
4
,
6
SECTION 1. Based upon the evidence submitted, it was found
and determined that the building(s) andlor premise. located at
7
8
9
555 W~st Victoria
, San Bernardino, California, constituted a
10
public nuisance for the reasons set forth in Exhibit "A", attached
hereto and incorporated herein by reference as though fully set
forth at length as the findings of fact of the Board.
SEC'l'ION 2. Based upon the evidence submitted, it was deter-
mined that the City of San Bernardino was required to initiate
abatement actions; that the City incurred costs in the SUIII of
$7 17' 00 to abate the above property, and that these costs to the
city to abate the above property shall be the personal obligation
of the owner(s) as well as a lien on the above property.
SEC'l'ION 3. The owner(s) is directed to keep the vacant
building(s) boarded and secure and to keep the premises free of
debris, trash, and graffiti. The owner(s) is directed to obtain
permits and to rehabilitate the building(s) ,in compliance with
city codes prior to any occupancy.
SEC'l'ION 4. Any person aggrieved by this order may, within
fifteen (15) days after .luly 10 1ClClO , app~al to the COllllllon
Council by filing with the City Clerk a written statement or the
11
12
13
14
l'
16
17
order appealed from the specific grounds of appeal and the relief I
I
t
or action sought from the COllllllon Council.
IIII
CE:102
-2-
e
e
e
IS
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2S
26
27
28
1
2
3
.ARD or BUJ:WIRG COJDU:SSI.U
om.. IIO.~ 01'0.'2 lIO.jO-~5if
4
I ~lI!1JY CERTIFY that the foreqoinq oreler wa. duly adopted
by the Boarel of Buildinq co_issioners of the City of San
s Bernarelino at a ~ meetinq thereof, held on the 6th
6 day of Julv , 19~, by the followinq vote, to wit:
7
COJDU:SSIonu: III
Chairman-Warren Miller ~
Dan Westwood .L
William Ponder
ABSTAIR
ABS211T
Dl
8
9
10
~
~
11
12
Jack Hunt
Benjamin Gonzales
.L
13
Manuel Flores
..L
14
Herbert Pollock
L
..L
Gene Pensiero
Gary Lord
~
IJtIYlD..r ~. JD.a.n {p j
CLERK, BOARD OF BUILDING COMMISSIONERS
The foreqoinq order
19~.
approved this -llUh day of Julv
,
,
IRMAN, BOAR
Approved as to form and leqal content:
IIII
IIII
CEIBBC
e
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
eARTMENT OP BUILDING AND OETY
300 North "0" Street
SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92418
EXHIBIT "A"
...-. -- ---'
An inspection we. _de of the below mentioned structureCs) and/or
premis_, .and sub.tandard conditions which shall include but not be
limiteel to the' fallowing, were observed.
- The ovn.rc.~ and all interesteel parties, as indicated on the Title
Report, were sent a certified _iling of these conditions.
l<. The reCOlIIDendation is to incur all current and future cost in tne fonn of a
lien on the property or a personal Obligation of the owner(s).
- All such substandard buildings or premises are hereby declared to be
public nuisanc_ and such nuisances shall be abatedoby the repair,
removal or demolition of such unsate buildings by the proper
proceelure. Permits are required prior to starting repair-or demo-
lition work.
TOTAL COSTS INCURRED TO DATE: $ '7, I 7 Z fJ;:!!.
.
ADDRESS 1547 Fuchasia
CITY Ont~ri n CA 91762
PHONE NO.
OWNER
e DATE
ITEM
e
William Brinaman
555 W. Victoria
LOCATION
ASSESSOR'S NO. 134-023-05
TYPE/BLOG
SFR
VIOLATION Open/Vacant
OF INSPECTION
DATE PREPARED
6-22-90
NO. SUBSTANDARD HOUSING (Inadeeruat:.
S~CTrON 1001
Sanit:at:ion\-
UHC CM. 10
1. Lack at or improper water closet, lavatory, bathtub or
shower in dwelling.
2. Lack of or improper kitchen sink or drainboard in dwell-
ing.
3. Lack of hot and cold running water in dwelling.
4. Lack of adequate heating tacilities.
5. Lack of or improper operation of required ventilating
equipment.
6. Lack of minimum amounts of natural liqht and ventila-
tion.
7. Room and space dimensions less than required by code.
8. Lack of required electrical liqhting.
9. Dampness of habitable room.
10. Infestation ot insects, vermin or rodents.
11. General dilapidation or ilIIproper maintenance.
12. Lack ot ~onnection to requireel sewage disposal system.
13. Lack of _intenance of septic system.
14. Lack of adequate qarbaqe and rubbish storage and removal
facilities.
15. Inadequate housekeeping - trash, garbage, etc.
All Codes are adopted by and are a part ot the San
Bernardino Hunicipal Code (SBMC 15.04.020).
INSPEC'l'ION REPORT WAS GIVEN TO:
xx A property owner
B manaqer
C tenant
o by hand delivery
E reqular mail
xx F certitied mail
e
e
'l'HIS
on
e
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8..
9~
10.
11.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
1.
2.
3.
4.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
.111". ?,
~LrtU~ ~ n~~~u~ 'UO~J
OpenM- vacant.
Fire~maqed structure.
Broken doors and windows.
Illeqal addition (bootleq)
Inadequate weather protection (roof leaks, etc.)
Inadequate foundation.
Saqqinq floors.
Inadequate rat-proofinq.
..Chimney structure unsound.
Termi te damage.
Structural inteqrity questionable.
PLUMBING (OPCl
Water heater illeqally installed in bath or bedroom.
Water heater has no T , P valve or seismic tie downs.
Leakinq/broken/pluqqed sewer drains.
Laakinq and/or broken pip.s.
Cross connected plumbinq.
Yard sprinklers must have vacuumn breaks.
MECHANICAL fUMel
Illeqal qas heater or appliance.
Improperly vented water heater.
Inadequate or missinq gas shut off valve.
Combustibles stored too near heatinq appliances.
ELECTRICAL (NEe)
OVerfusinq - branch circuits not to exceed 15 amps for
liqhts and 20 amps tor receptacles.
Hissinq electrical covers or tixtures.
Inadequate outlets.
Electrical service entrance is inadequate.
Hazardous or illeqal wirinq.
GENERAL (SBMCl
Pools - staqnant water
inadequate qate
Not to be occupied until corrections are made.
Certificate ot Occupancy required.
Improper Occupancy.
Nuisance
Possible Fire Hazard.
Smoke Detectors Required.
Address required on all buildinqs and/or apartments.
Supplement:
^"""rv^. .'Iv. .;;v-...v.......,
o
inadequate tence
19 90
-
dill (j 1Co flUl~ .
INSPEC'l'OR SIGN~
tit
tit
tit
. 0
CITY OF
San Bernardino
DEPARTMENT 0' 'LANNINQ AND aUILDIHG a.RvIC.S
LARR Y E REED
OIRECTOR
July 9, 1990
William Bringham
1547 Fuchasia
Ontario, CA 91762
555 W. Victoria
San Bernardino, CA
APN# 134 023 05
PROJEe"r NO. 90-3654
Pursuant to action of the Board of Building Commissioners
taken on Julv 6 lqqn , a nuisance was found to exist at
555 W. Victoria ,San Bernardino, California.
Certain costs were incurred to abate the nuisance and are
listed in the attached statement of costs. These costs have
been approved by the Board of Building Commissioners' and
shall become a lien upon the property, if not paid.
An appeal may be made within fifteen (15) days of the date of
the decision of the Board of Building Commissioners to the
Common Council. If no appeal is taken, the costs incurred
shall become a lien upon the real property unless paid to the
City Clerk within fifteen (15) days of the date of this
notice.
Larry E. Reed, Director
Planning & Building Services
by: .1l-. f{j . !rIe.,.:4,-i... 1
Code Compliance Offi~er
Approval: Jlh'vi ,i. [unt~t., .
Code Compliance supe~
cc: city Attorney
City Clerk .
Finance Department
300 NORTH O' STREET. SAN BERNARDINO.
C"'L.IFORNIA 92418-0001 (11.)3.....71/1..'
e
e
e
. -- --- ----------
Depar~.nt~ planninq an4 Bui14inq
~. Bnforc...nt Division
s~ .c.s
Statement of Costs
. .
The undersiqned respectfully submits the followinq statement
of costs incurred by the. City of san . Bernardino in abatinq
the public nuisance that existed on the property located at:
Property Address:
555 W. Victoria
owner:
William Bringman
1547 Fuchasia - Ontario, CA 91762
Mailinq Address:
Parcel Number:
Project Number:
Leqal Description:
134 023 05
90-3654
Block 44, Lot 3 and 8, PM 45/77 MB 7/11
ITEMIZATION
Department of Planninq and Buildinq Services costs:
Title Research
Notice of Pendancy Processinq Fee
City Clerk Administrative Costs.
Contractor's Costs
Administrative Costs
Public Service Department Costs
$
$
$
$
$
$
Total costs____$
25.00
125.00
22.00
5,000.00
2,000.00
7,172.00
40%
Previous costs incurred:
Date
Date
Amount $
Amount -$
Total Du. $ 7,172.00
Date: 7-9-90
By: ~_-'~O~~
C'ode Comp iance Of cer
Approved
.
OfFICE OF THE STATE fiRE MARSHAL
FIRE INCIDENT REPORT 0
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
S?lI'''CI'O];'~'~\~GI
FIRE DEPARTMENT
'"
'0
'0
co..
IOE....TIllllr.IIt'..L us..,
.
OWN[ "~I:
"COitUS
MANAGEIt NAME
,toDltUI
.
SP/APT NO.
AL.A"'"
SQultCE
'0'
ADDRESS
ZIP
z
CITY
ZIP
Fez /51
,
CITY
ZIP
Tl:l.EPMDH[ N .
.
A. INFORMATION (PAGE 17)
B. PROPERTY CLASSIFICATION (PAGE Ill)
COOlE .1'P[ 0' 'NClOEN.
I I 1 t/ JI.[) J )II c"
CODE P"OPEATy Cl.AS$IF'C"-'Dtrt (CDuPl.EXl
2
CODe PltOP[Il'TY CL....sS.'.'...T IO~ IIND' VI DYAL!
, L
(
D. EXTENT OF DAMAGE (PAGE 4S1
EXTENT OF DAMAGE _ FIAE
,
CODE EXTENT OF DAMAGE - WATt"
,
3
...A N A\IE"IuES h40KE SP"EAD
.
H. PROTECTION FACILITIES (PAGE 81)
,
CODE SPIIlINIlLE'U - TYPE
I
CODE SP'U"'Jl:LElt' - E"ECTlVEHUS
I
CODE STANDPIPES _ TYPE
I
CODE STANOPIPU.. (f'F'[CTIYI:NUS
I
CODE POltUII.! UTlNGUISHEIU _ TYPE
I
CODE POltTA'1t..E UTINGUISoHIU!S - E"ECTlvINESS
I
3
.
.
.
J. MISCELLANEOUS (PAGE lOll)
'''IEFIGMU"
NO. '''JUIIED litO. OF OUT..,
CIYILI"""
HO. IHJU"EO HO. A' 0(ATH5
s,~ FO"~ GO : su"~lfTto 'all: tACH OUTH
2 ICH(C<< 1I0x I' YES) 0
S~N 'Oll:~ GO.50 17 731
,
11'1111. "AT~D ]
, 00
o~,e
SOURCE OF HfAT CAUSING IGNITION
2
C 0<
t
I
'Oll:~ OF HtAT CAUSING IGNITION
,
ACT OR 0"'l15510N CAu51NG IGNITION
.
,
11'
,
u'
.
I.
CODE PlI:lVATE '!"IGAOf - TYPE
I
CODE PIIIVATE IIltl"AI)I _ [FF[CTlVEHtSS
I
COOE SPECIAL "AlARD Ptll:OTEC"ION _ TYPE
I
COOt SPECIAL "AlAtll:O P~OTECTlON _ EFFECTIVENESS
I
COOt 51GHAL OR WAtll:HIHG SYSTE~
I TYPE I CODE I UFtCTIVEHUS
CODE SIGNAL WAtll:NIN'i SYSTE'" - ...(AH' OF ACTIVATION
I
CODE SIGNAL'WA""I"G SYSTE... - TYPE DETECTORS
I
CODE WATCH.4AH I CODE I OTHElI: FACILITIES
I U'I.:CTIVENUS rf'FfCTIV[NUS
2
,
.
.
,
,
.
''10. .'H....""~...~I....>.J...,w .... .........,.........."
1. Joint ReiOPonse !n
2. ~~utu.1 Aid In
3. Mutual Aid Out
<-
L.
IT RADIO NO..
SPATCHEO
3. ARRIVAL.
4.10.8.ncl10.19
5. TOTAL. TIME
6. PUMP TIME
7. RESPONSE TIME
M. EQUIPMENT
1. HOW EXTINGUISHED
5. HOSE USED
6. NO. L.INES
7. FEET
8. L.ADDERS USED NO.
::
2. TANKD
3.DRAFTD _. HVDRANTJ!!
3"
I
~.o c
9. TOTAL FEET
O. SPECIAL. EQUIPMENT
N. PERSONNEL RESPONDING
.2."2
3.
2.
4.
I MAKE
P. INSURANCE INFORMATION
I MODEL
I VEAR
I L.tCENSE NO.
I STATE
PROPERTY
CONTENTS
TOTAL
AGENT
L.OSS
ADDRESS
Q. REMARKS
r--
c
ACTION
OFFICER
IN CHARGE
FIRE 1.06.' IRe.. ....1
:;,",-. '...".-.....,...
Ctl'I_I'lI..r.........~...tl
e
e
TEI..EO..E'7T'
.OUATII.-'Y
AnOP:.EY OR PARTY W1THOUT ATTORNEY (N_AND ADDRESS);
wi.lliam A. Bringr-~n ~ l~)1'ilb 2.(,9.
and Edward L. Kay
1547 Fuchasia 'FI'[:" -j ,
Ontario;. CA 91762 ,.
NIY FOR (N MI): ,....__.
InMfI na.... 01 coun. jUd,c,a' d'atricl or Drane" coun. "any. aM IlCIII oIIIca aM atr"'addr.":""'_'~J ., " ". P "",iI?
Court .- ~'1 "~2 4 1991J
By
AN6F.liii;;~,.
OUH; D'S'~~~~" W'IfJ..'.-' GNI'";>. CUi/"
. '"'cr. ". ' Fo
... :4 . .l4(
" ,l::."
r-~, ~lD;
"-.."
San Bernardino Municipal
Central Division
351 North Arrowhead Avenue
San Bernardino, CA 92415-0220
LAIN TIFF:
WILLIAM A. BRINGMAN
EDWARD L. ,KAY
IECEIVIE IDJ
and
DE NDANT:
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
RISK f/.ANAGEMENT
.. ,.., ~L:-
_1"- ,t, =" v'
. ~
(!J DOES 1 TO 1 0
COMPLAINT -Pep.onallnlury, Property Damage, Wrongful Death
28120 0 MOTOR VEHICLE 28130 iJ OTHER /Sp<<:ify}:
Ci ProPertY Oamalle 0 Wrongful Oaath
o Pe,aonallnJury LJ Othe, Damell" /.".cify}:
N
1. Thia pleading. including a:lacnmenll and exhibill. consiats 01 the following number 01 pallea: ',' f nil r
CASE HUMH":
134897
2. a. Each plainliff named above il a competent adult
o Eacept plalnt,ff (nama):
o a corporation qualllled to do businesl in Californ,a
o an unincorporated enl.ty (describe):
o a public anllty (de,cflbe):
o a minor 0 an adull
o lor wnom a guard'an 0' conaarvalo, ollhe eatale 0' a guardian ad litem haa bHn appointed
o othe, (.pecify):
o olher (apecify):
o Except plalnlill (name):
o a corporation qualilled to do buline.. in Calito,nla
Dan unincorporatad antity (deacribe):
CJ a public entity (deacflbe):
Oa mino, 0 an adull
o lor whom a guardian or conservator 01 the eatate or a guardian ad litem has been appointed
o other (apec/fy):
o other (apacify):
b. 0 Plaintiff (name):
'I dOIng busin... under Ihellcl,'lous nama 01 Is;:;ecify):
and nas complied with the fictllious buslnas~ name laws.
c. 0 Inlormalion aboul additional plaintiffs who are not com patent adults is "'own in Complalnt-
Anacnment 2c. (Continued)
AC'S C_
310011021
,..~....
--..-
._-,..."
_"""'1
_.....2
COMPLAINT -p..._lln!urY. Propet1J 0.....,
Wrongful Death
U,'"O','.JO'
e
e
e
SHOAT TITLE:
BRINGMAN VS. SAN BERNARDINO
CASE NUMaER:
\~4- 2.,~l
COMPLAINT -Peraonallnlury, PropertY Damage, Wrongful Death
Page two
3. a. Each dafendanl named aDove is a nalural parson
lJU Escept delanclanl (name):
City of San Bernardino
o a Dulina.. organizalion, form unknown
o a corporalion
o an unlncorporaled antlly (dascflDe):
o Escept defendanl (name):
~ a Dusinns organizalion. form unknown
o a corporation
o an unincorporated entily (d8lcriDe):
liD a puDIIC entity (dISCflDe): C it Y 01
San Bernardino organized and
o other (specity): operated under Cal-
ifornia Law
o a public enllly (descflbe):
o olher (specity):
o Escept delendant (name):
o Escapt delendant (name):
o a businesa organization. form unknown
o a corporalion
o an unincorporated entity (descnDe):
D a bUSlne.. organization, form unknown
o a corporation
Dan uftlncorporated anllty (descrlDe):
o a public enlily (descrlDe):
o a public entlly (descrlDe):
o other (speclty):
o olher (specify):
b. The true names and capacll'es 01 delendanls sued as Does are unk~own to pla,nli"
c. 0 Inlormation about addlllonal delenelants WhO are nol nalural persons IS conlained in Complalllt-
Attachment 3c.
a. 0 Defendants whO ara 10lnad pursuant 10 COde 01 Clvol Procedure section 382 are (names):
4. [iJ Plaintl" is reQulrad 10 comply wllh a ClaIms slalule. and
a. lJU plalnti" has complied wllh applicable claims S1alules. or
b. 0 plainti" is excused from complYIng oecause (specity):
5. This COU" is the proOlr cou" oecause
[iJ alleast one detendant now resides in its JurisdictIonal area.
o the principal place 01 business 01 a corporation or unlncorporaled association is :n liS jurosdicllonal area.
o injury 10 person or damage 10 personal propeny occurrad III Its Jurosdlct,onal area.
o other (specity):
6. 0 The following paragraphS 01 thIS complaint are alleged on 'nformation and belief (Specity paragraph numDers):
(Continued)
Pq. two
.'-.';
SHOR'r TITI.E: ..
. BRINGMAN VS. SAN~RNARDINO
o
CASE NUMSEIl
\ ~ 4- 8~"1
-7.
COMPLAINT _Plrsonallnlury, Property Damage, Wrongful Death (Continued)
,... .,,,..
D Th. d.magl. claimad lor wronglul dealh and lhe relation.hips 01 plaintitl to the d.c....d are
D list.d in Complaint-Att.chm.n. 7 D as lollows:
8. Plaintitl has sutl.rad
D wag. lOll
D ho.p,tal and medical I.p.n..s
UO property damage
UO othlr damag. (SpICIly):
Attorney fees
Loss of value of personal property
[iJ lOll 01 use 01 property
o g.neral damage
D loss 01 larning capacity
9. R.Ii., sought in thIS complaInt IS withIn the JUrlSdlCllon ollhls court.
, O. PI.AINTlFF PRA VS'
For judgment tor costs of SUIt; for such relief as IS lair. lust. and eQultaole. and for
CKI comp.nsatory damag.S
D (Superior Court) accordIng 10 prool.
e
[] (Municipal and JU,UCI Court) in the amounl of $ 1 0 . (10 C... _ ._ .__
D other (specl/Y):
". Th. lollowing causes ot actIon are aUach.d and the Slallments allov. apply to each: (Eac" complaint mUlt "ave
onl or mora causl' 0/ acr.on allach.d.)
D Motor Vehicle
Cil Gen.ral N'gligence
D Int.ntional Tort
o ProductS I.iabihly
o Premise. I.iability
D Oth.r (SP'C/ly):
U,'"O,.,.20,
COMPLAINT - Plrsonallnlury, Propert, Damage,
Wronglul Death (Continued)
v~~ ~i6aintiff
\' / i,;:.."'1:.:....,...:.:::) ~-
Edward L. Kav. Plaintiff d
Pate eft,..
William A. Brinqman
e
. Edward L. ~ay
flype or DIll" ".m..
!We ..'.11111.......
celt "I. 11
I SHORT TITLE:
I BRINGHAN
e
e
e
..~..J CAS\~M~R ~~ -,
.' . -,
VS.
.-
SAN BERNARDINO
FIRST
Pap four
CAUSE OF ACTION-Genl!,."IJE!I~lif~ence
(numw)
ATTACHMENT TO CiUCompla'Ml =~Cross.Com".,"
(Use I sl"lrl/e cluse 01 ec/ion lorm lor elch cause 01 aC/lon.)
GN-l. Plaint,tf(nlme): WILLIAM A. BRINGMAN and EDWARD L. KAY
allegestnald.f.ndant(nlm.): CITY OF SAt-; BERNARDINO
[iJDoes
to 1 n
wal In. legll (prox,mate) caUII ot damages to plaintiff. By tne tollowing actio' omllllonl to act. dafandant
negligently cauled lne damaga to pla,nt,ff
on (oa/e): January 12 through 15, 1990
al("lace): 5"5 West Victoria, San Bernardino, CA
(oesc",,/ion 01 re..ons lor liabIlIty):
At such date and place Defendants and Does 1 ~hrough 10
did so negligently, carelessly and needlessly demolished
certain building structures commonly known as 555 West
Victoria, San Bernardino, California without the exercise
of reasonable care and in violation of applicable Munici-
pal Code Sections for the City of San Bernardino, including
but not limited to Section 15:28.140(c). Defendants knew
or should have known that such action would result in dam-
ages to Plaintiffs.
Fo,m "OO'ow", Dy Ihe
JloIchcaa' COUncil 01 C.li'ornl'
E"ecll'.. Janua,y I. 19112
': ..."0.......
r.AII~F OF Ar.TION-l'lene'al Neoliaenee
'-cP.,'5 ~2'