HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-Development Services
..
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO-REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION
From:
Dept:
James G. Funk, Director
Development Services
ORiGINAL
Subject: Development Permit Type I No. 03-140
and a Determination of Public Convenience or
Necessity for an Alcoholic Beverage Control Type
21 license (off-sale general) for La Palma Foods
located at Ul31 North Waterman Avenue.
Ion
MCC Date: January 5, 2004
Date:
December 16, 2003
Synopsis of Previous Council Action:
None
Recommended Motion:
That the Mayor and Common Council approve Development Permit Type I No. 03-140 and determine that the
public convenience or necessity is served and direct the Development Services Department to send a letter to the
Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control for a Type 21 license (off-sale general) for La Palma Foods located at
1003 North Waterman Avenue.
~t.R.H4-~
James G. unk
Contact person: Aron Liang
Phone: 384-5057
Supporting data attached: Staff Report
Ward(s): 1
FUNDING REQUIREMENTS: Amount: N/A
Source: (Ace!. No.)
(Ace!. Description)
Finance:
Council Notes:
J /5/0'1
I I
Agenda Item No. 10
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO - REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION
STAFF REPORT
SUBJECT: Development Permit Type I No. 03-140 and a Determination of Public
Convenience or Necessity for an Alcoholic Beverage Type 21 license (off-sale
general) for La Palma Foods located at Ij)33 North Waterman Avenue.
1003
OWNER! APPLICANT
Harold W. Willis
La Palma Foods, LLC
1003 North Waterman Avenue
San Bernardino, CA 92418
(909) 884-7817
REQUEST
The applicant is requesting approval of Development Permit Type I No. 03-140 and a
determination of public convenience or necessity for an Alcoholic Beverage Control Type 21
license (off-sale general) for La Palma Foods located at 1~ North Waterman Avenue in the
CH, Commercial Heavy, land use district. /003
La Palma Foods grocery store is located in an existing commercial center conslstmg of
approximately 104,000 square feet and La Palma Foods occupies a 20,000 square foot building.
La Palma Foods currently has a Type 20 ABC license. The Type 20 license restricts the sales of
alcohol to beer and wine only. Like other supermarkets in the City (i.e. Albertsons and Stater
Bros), La Palma Foods is a bona fide grocery store that sells fresh produce, vegetables, fish,
meat and many other grocery goods. A Type 21 license would enhance La Palma Foods by
expanding their product lines. This expansion would also allow La Palma Foods an opportunity
to increase their overall sales productivity. The alcoholic beverage display and sales area will
account for no more than 10% (210 square feet) of the total floor area. The hours of operation
are from 7:00 am to 10:00 pm, seven days per week.
Based on Census Tract 0064.01, two off-sale liquor licenses are allowed in this area. Currently,
there is only I existing license in this tract. Although the tract is not located in an over
concentrated area, pursuant to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act, Section 23817.7 (3), the state
Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control notified the applicant a determination of Public
Convenience or Necessity from the City is required.
The Police Department indicated no opposition to the ABC application and recommended
approval provided that the applicant comply with the conditions included in the Planning Staff
Report.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
None. The applicant submitted an application and the applicable processing fee.
'.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Mayor and Common Council determine that the public convenience
or necessity is served and direct the Planning Division to send a letter to the Department of
Alcoholic Beverage Control for a Type 21 license for La Palma Foods located at 1003 North
Waterman Avenue.
ATTACHMENTS
A Location Map
B Site Plan & Floor Plan
C Conditions of Approval
D ABC Application
ATTACHMENT A
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO PROJECT: DPI NO. 03-140
PLANNING DIVISION
LOCATION MAP
LAND USE DISTRICTS HEARING DATE: 01/5/03
u
NORTH
j \ IC ~/'~ sC""'-
,. I
Z
11/
'"
c
"
r
,""." HOS'''f5 T
"
..
l
-
~
5
'~~
FTMt
lk
J(.u-r--
-~
...
w...:i~ ~ _ . _ __,~:::.:,~LLS (-LLG ~-r ..e:.
1(1' "t., J--;:: ; <I' ., I 'X "...., ,-
.., ",~ _~~, Ht "of., \,. ",\, .-:-:,;1
..--.."...\~. '~..,_...._ .wl ...~---:!,\_II ........"'\.-1 ""'-, . '':1\:' ..
~ -~ r ~:--'.'=I ':'j--':.--' "l~" .0;- . ...... . \_-- ,,:~:s " .
I ," --~--=;, -\"-:\'i~'''''' ~\,h"__,"-,!,:""-,-,--,,,,,,,"',r;" 1
~~ ~':f - \\\\ ~ ~I" :iO\~\~'~\j ~\\~~-:-;'~I;~~~~\:\~tl;.'lr':,--
t, ;,. r.. . I'. j .' \\\0:.1:: O"'Ol OllOd
""',, -....... . _. " ' ~\. \'\, (".. _ V
I ,,..,rrrr----__j__ --__'_,;,_,'..,'.. . \. -I,.. \ \ . \l ":"~(
I Vi III I. _n " I' ,\ t\,'\-\-\'~---' ----.\.\.\ II ....:..
" III _ "/',-rl i~'J . , \ \ \ '" .." \ \ ,':
....\\\. \\. I
'1 :'
,~,:" I
.....1
,
III
::::>
, +tt,t 'Z'
~.J' ~
I'or _.__...~_______~=. >
:", -I """"'," I';.~ <.(
~ ~ '
", 1_ ~-:to
~oo f'I~3
1..\ 0 \\;~I" ,
;: ~~. . . 'I \ \ U 'f. :::1I'J ~
.", J' -(. :~ ...'"
./ .---...----~-... "l"1 'lJJ.
iI. ,- .. ~.~---.,.-------..,...- ,.,/..'. "', '}-
. . l' "'1' 't
-. ..'.::...1 I I.J ..'. :'~J.. <(
,:------_--::::1._______ .+ \5:'~ .'~:=' '.3:
~.... ~ - ----I-----..<<...~.. . " '.
" \\\\J ,;:.'\J'~.,"
.....:...-........~~" _ .....c..:' ;;~~....;;.. to. :~;
:: 1..;'''''.,:>>,;" ~"'~~"'T\,;,e..""-"~_
:~, 0.<( ....,,': ': . ~~:3 r.i~IT@I~1 !;~.~.~I :~~'
.-_ _......_- J" . ' ~. l. :'\.. . ....r ~., 1
. , 5r1~-I:rmi';"I' 'J7"r.r.n'I-;-;';r.-1rr I :~~~ ;\:: rt~i
I I H'I:iOl'~'I'II"\:i I: OI'II):,I',s:~:a_i.II~.n ~ + I ::: <';', ::..; tJ ,
.: :. !j~I/)O.'.: . kc :':~ .L; .... "
.-' __ -. 1:1::J:t'litfIJV;,:'~;I:b+u""J'I_I.:lj;';:I: :t:'I'~E.: I I ~ .;' \l:::
~.. j ______ . ~. 1[.....~:..:..:.'..;:.I,;;...~.!I.~.~!;{.,.!.:'..:....~l"'I.~. ..... Ji ...... l~11 t. II'.. I ,'. J
'I '~------ ~ -: .' . -,,-_: ~,;' '.""''"'r: '~,.~:'.:.~=---.. .\ ' .
;\:'I.~t-.,.-.___~ ~ '~I/ . -;1".10:; ...u ~.:I VIf!J ~..U'JII..... ':.:. l:.[.....--D]..,.t... J
......'\ '_ ___ .." '11'''11':.1'' , _. ~Io. . ., .-:. -;...-
?.....::"._ =---. ','. '\ ..:....'..::... n.j~ ',1::":
..'\.: ~ '-'- - '
O'loo\:. "'. ....._..:;;::-' ,,::; . '-.::---> I .,~. ,=:I' \:fl\! J.
. -..- ... ,--.- - ...,-,.--.,. ...-. '-" ;;:)~"
tot ",..._"at ----:.:..-=:.:.:~'r.r.:::..--... -f." 11'\' ~~ "'.r
.~,,",,,....... "I- .. - -I.~ \_._..; _
:.,lIJO.l.::'uvJ.,m<,INn'NI :10 -.1.:10:; DOC'91 _ .
. Si\e. PLf\tJ
.~ , , , \
n \\' \
Ir\ ,\,.,
'-.--'-r -,. --rn-
F\' \",
... ,\ \ \ \ , \ 1
~ : ~ I
~ 1 I J
'.. n.
.,...-
J
A-
Il>
rJ.
~
...
.....1
,~
\,0
...
.p
.,
0:.
~
1'"
,
~
:
.
!
1
! "
'\c
,
~
~
--,
I
.---.,.....,-
~.i
. ~ "'--~
1---- '
;-
---
-
.-. I _ \.~.J\.\)(i
... -:.:~:~.~7~ :~~\..\:I'..tJ
. :.;~'~~; I~' ~':;:~~.~ 'I
.':: " ~ : ".' .:. "1~
,~.. 'i' .....1..... ...... fl.
;~'~<J
."':01;
,:::;'
~...
" .:
'. \0
~7i!
.~
~
" " . ':.
''-.,: ,,,,.;
'..... . J.
. "
.,
~
".","
.;'111 -'...
t.'.' J...,_ ___..
,
.'/,',1
....l.J.J,J..
:':!..~ ' .\ 11 ~
_....~....-...r:.., '-- ;. J
.. , .. -_,"="-1;0-""-." \II
- ~ ...
l~ ~: ffVA ~
..... ::!} . ~
Cl
11!-.." en
t II "".
"\
I.\"~I ~
"....t-..... ._...~..
..... ....,..
L.\'. \
r'
....:
, ,
"
"
"
"
,:-.
,: to'
'0
0::'
u.
0(
0:
,..
8NI)( t138t1ns
\ \',,~\1
~\":I.jl
\\\l'J
..
.'
:.
r \k,
1\""
~:\
,.
'.~' '~
I \1:, \'t..,.,'~
. , \ \" . p.. ...
I _I." \ \.. 1 \' I
. "':'___.:',:("':.___________'.....'\;,~. ,'.1
I .. .'. \ \ \ \"\';: .
'" ' \ \.\ \ \1
- l.":. "
"
,'\
"~':
~, "
I
, .1.----_.
I. .' .
..'.~--------l'. -- . -1" ,I?!.' Ii
________ I I
. -,.. . ----.":'" ------r} ,....,1
. . ..,. '.~ I, I I I I .
.' J. . I ~ I..J.
........
. "
.....
r)
"
,',
II
"
1-
o
.J
-.
~.
.. ,
~'
..
L.
-.0... . .... \ \ .. '"' r,
__________ . \ \ \ \, \ \1
___N' -r----,.'.."'""\-r'c
\\\\\-1
\ \ \ \ ,. \I
(')
"'/'
.--- - - __...-r....
"
i
j
~f'
. ,
.,
'\"
~C .~
0' ,
_( -------,--t..r::-
;i.. . . :7 "~"I
..
.__t~::
.t -......
- ,
" '
,
I,..,
.~
j
~l
'" \ L-,,--.__
,
,.
.
~
Q
;
'; I-'ll"" _n.~__.'_"_' I-'--~'- -~_.~-_.~ I -.-.--.---.-......-.-.----...-.--.- .~~,
I : I! i 111:$:1> lllL-IIIM ;UU~1ol \'11 1\\1 .d.nJ,' .4i~,",~\J ~~.., . il!~!
'" !: ! i I I n~;~;llO;~-- __'''" "~"~""~-':'--.:':::'~~"",oo, _'''~'.'__ ~ jt! ,:1 '7
~, .L3)fHVWH3dnSSllViS3^I~llO~ . '~:',.l; l 'i. <(
; II, . _n ",J 1__i~3rolldi~:W:~~~dWI~~vl~:ia3s~~o~d i [iil!!!! ;'(3)
~ lit ~ ~:~ ~ ~ ~ € ~ ~ ~ .. ~
.;.:, ~ ~ I ~ ~ tl .... .. ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ ,. ...ii; t:::-..
1-, ~ ~ I ~ ~ .. ~ .. ~!; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~; ~ '\\\ je~E~ c;;-'
<'li, ,:! 1.", f., II -."! "..,' 'l ,,' I ~\.,\ "'l' ~
,,'. '" " ".' 'I" I" . 'Il i ! , :', .'", \ \'~~ ,'i" "'"
<;: !! I;' 01:: 1 '! !. ~ ;1' !!'I!!i""1 I!' 51 ,! I ,'1 ! l' ~ t "ll !ll!~ n"
91 I ~ .. ! ~ i". : i ! I! Ii. I ~ Ii!i i: I'" ~11U1 ti .. Ii i ~ i ~.. I t I ~ _ : = ' ';, \~ St ~ll ~
3i!!,i,:'illilliIEIII,ill'! ,li"!!US'li:ll!ij I!'j! !! ,!: j'll: ~\~\11 'I!;l I!!!!I
mle.~ i~ .....lili'Jlt _ 12""fil!~egll~ J:R I" ~.:. 5! I~ -. "'l\l\"i E!I ~
: II: 10 C,,)!J' . <I " . ("!' !10 : ' , I!! '1 l~ i! l!! Ii'. !!.! ! \~\I !"i. ~
, , , ,I .... i " ." i. . I I I ! i; ! i ' l' i . I i' ,1 . I' I 'I i'ill I'
~ . -3- .. \ i -'1!Z. = Illi s" I~ _U I; i: I. i J E "I I ~ al 3 ! I II ,.. Il'l
"I~ -,.--; . l Idiwl";;<1" !lilll"!', ,I, "PIIi .. J .::.l z
:' ~ 'I' l!i ~ l" · If I'" II!I I jl! l' 1 I I Ii' , I lil": oCt
~:~!!( If{ I!; II -j II: · ! ~;,:,: l;:~' !;.:::;. :l::! !:!~ !;.: !::! il ~
- .: =-[H T-~;=-1-::-=f"1 =- _:=~l /
--t'-1
. I .1
r;-~; .I
1...:-11 ; I I
IL.-,~ i I
'[(11--4:;1 ~
r'"....-...'1 if_I ", ._...~.," ,_"i~.JI~, II
w =:rr~1 ~,~~J-. - I
~.u,,>>"' l----:Jl I"
l~?: [~ l~ [~ " '" ~;
;[.~-1r { {I ~~,~'" ft'; '\
~
J
I
~,
,
;11 I!
Iii II
II .
Iill
,iI
illi
;;;'.1
I
"
"J
~_.'''',I''''''_'' (-'
w '
~
I
,x'
I
~ 'l I . .
~ -i P
"I
i
,
I
I!
~'.~i
i! ., ~
1 !i ,0:.. I
,;'~! '
I
(j, OIL.
''.c':
-... =~
"
~
~.
!
'.
i
:;.
.',
.~I
. I
01
___l"ll
I -'=-::'-:':']
------t;---
;l ' ~'
-- W
s,..~.
--l---~-"'l'. V'~ .
G> "r,';~..... ':J.~ "
.. _ @ .....;..-> ". ""c"
"'-"'"--I.. ,~":'-":"
..-,. .... i:'-. ...~
-,j,-
~Ol.Jv. .........). '7~Q
It'..~ '.,,,.
.....
'"
~~. "'"
1l $....
, ,-
;' t
o .
. 1
'I~l .,."
. ,
" {
'.;;;~;-;-- ._.~---..---i-_u
...
,."
~-,.,
..~
.O-MI
,., ~~
g ~~!&
:::: i~!
~ !li
-' ~~
;; 58
t
\
~
Q
\-\
A-
P.
~
.
,
r
'l',
. .
ATTACHMENT C
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
Development Permit Type I No. 03-140
1. This approval is for an ABC Type 21 license for La Palma Foods located at 1003
North Waterman Avenue. The hours of operation are limited to 7:00am to 10:00pm,
seven days per week.
2. Within two years of this approval, all necessary building permits must be obtained
and commencement of work/construction shall have occurred or the permit/approval
shall become null and void. In addition, if after commencement of
work/construction, the work/construction is discontinued for a period of one year,
then the permit/approval shall become null and void. However, approval of the
Development Permit does not authorize commencement of construction. All
necessary permits must be obtained prior to commencement of specified construction
activities included in the Conditions of Approval and Standard Requirements.
EXPIRATION DATE:
January 5, 2006
3. In the event this approval is legally challenged, the City will promptly notifY the
applicant of any claim, action or proceeding and will cooperate fully in the defense of
this matter. Once notified, the applicant agrees to defend, indemnifY and hold
harmless the City of San Bernardino (City), the Economic Development Agency of
the City of San Bernardino (EDA), any departments, agencies, divisions, boards or
commission of either the City or EDA as well as predecessors, successors, assigns,
agents, directors, elected officials, officers, employees, representatives and attorneys
of either the City or EDA from any claim, action or proceeding against any of the
foregoing persons or entities. The applicant further agrees to reimburse the City for
any costs and attorneys' fees which the City may be required by a court to pay as a
result of such action, but such participation shall not relieve applicant of his or her
obligation under this condition.
The costs, salaries, and expenses of the City Attorney and employees of his office
shall be considered as "attorneys fees" for the purpose of this condition.
As part of the consideration for issuing this permit, this condition shall remain in
effect if this Development Permit is rescinded or revoked, whether or not at the
request of applicant.
4. The licensee shall be responsible for posting of signs prohibiting litter and loitering.
Management shall be responsible for enforcing this provision and maintaining the
area free of litter and graffiti.
~.
'.
5. All graffiti must be removed within 24 hours of its occurrence. The management shall
take a photograph of the graffiti and provide to the Police Department before
removing the graffiti.
6. Exterior lighting shall be sufficiently and properly maintained to illuminate all areas
of the exterior of the building and property. A minimum of I foot candle lighting is
required during hours of operation, and Yz foot candle lighting after hours. No
spillover of lighting is permitted.
7. No alcoholic beverages shall be consumed on the licensed premises or any property
adjacent to the premises.
8. The licensee shall be responsible for posting of signs prohibiting drinking on the
premises as presently stated in San Bernardino Municipal Code Chapter 9.32, Section
9.32.020 or in any successor sections.
9. The percentage of physical retail space devoted to the sale of alcohol shall not exceed
10% of the retail space.
10. The sales of beer, malt beverages, or liquor in containers ofless than 750 ml. cannot
be sold by single containers, but must be sold in manufacturer pre-packaged multi-
unit containers/quantities.
II. There shall be no exterior advertising or signage of any kind or type, including
advertising directed to the exterior from within, promoting or indicating the
availability of alcoholic beverages. Interior displays of alcoholic beverages or signs
which are clearly visible to the exterior shall constitute a violation of this condition.
12. The windows shall provide an unobstructed view to the inside of the premises at all
times. Window signage may not comprise more than 25% of the window area.
13. If, in the opinion of the Chief of Police, a security guard becomes necessary, it shall
be the responsibility of the licensee to provide the security at the hours to be listed by
the Chief of Police.
14. All pay phones shall be out calling only, with no incoming calls allowed.
IS. Automatic teller machines, if provided, shall be located inside the premises.
16. Video cameras and/or security guards may be required during hours of operation and
Yz hour after the business closes.
City !,f Sl1Il Benwdilw
, ,
Devell~plllellt seJl'ices
Departlllellt
. ~\ \ N-t-\~\ D
Alcohol Beverage Sales
Supplemental Application
DIRECTIO~S TO APPLICA"'T
This fonn must accompany your City application for a Conditional Use Permit or Development Permit
(whichever is applicable) for the sales of alcoholic beverages.
Fill in the "Section to be Completed by Applicant." and take this form to:
Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control
Riverside District Office
3737 Main Street. Suite 900
Riverside, CA 92501
(909) 782-4400
SECTIOl'i TO BE COMPLETED BY APPLICANT (printed)
Applicant's name: LA PALMA Ft>t>P5/-./-.C.,
Address of premises : / ~O:3 A/o ~71t JM A 71:'. f<. /'^ AN A ViE
5A~ t3C:I~NAR[)INO
C?A <:;')..'11(7
SECTIO:\ TO BE CO:\IPLETED BY ABC REPRESE~TATI\'E
"'ote to ABC Representative: The purpose of this form is to assist the City of San Bernardino Police
Department in their investigation by providing some preliminary inforn1ation and the Planning Division in
determining whether the applicant will need a Finding of Public Convenience or Necessity (PCN) from the
Mayor and Common Council. Your assistance in completing this form is greatly appreciated.
Type or License (circle one): 1iL?G 40 42 48 59 61 Other:
Census Tract: 6oto f-{. 0 I peN ~ ~ r;;
Number of Licenses allowed: ~ 9n. J 3 c? J 71 7 cr-I 15-c/ p~
I ~ 0 I'
Number of existing Licenses:
Based on the above, the premises 0 are or )(are not !n an area which has an overconcentration of alcoholic
beverage licenses of the type sought.
Si",'Moo' ABC R'P"re,"6'" ;f{#;, J A; , 0,,(1)){ / 03
. ~p-or~7~
5,1101
.
.
> .
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
RACHEL G. CLARK, C.M.C. - CITY CLERK
300 North "D" Street. San Bernardino' CA 92418-0001
909.384.5002' Fax: 909.384.5158
www.ci.san-bernardino.ca.us
SM
January 6, 2004
Mr. Harold W. Willis
La Palma Foods, LLC
1003 N. Waterman Avenue
San Bernardino, CA 92418
rU.,,~
Dear Mt'./Willis:
At their meeting of January 5,2004, the Mayor and Common Council approved
Development Permit Type 1 No. 03-140 and made a determination that the public
convenience or necessity is served and directed the Development Services Department to
send a letter to the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control for a Type 21 license (off-
sale general) for La Palma Foods located at 1003 North Waterman Avenue.
If we can be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this office.
Sincerely,
~h.~~
Rachel G. Clark, CMC
City Clerk
RGC:ls
cc: Development Services
CITY OF SAN BERNARDINO
ADOPTED SHARED VALVES: Integrity' Accountability' Respect for Human Dignity' Honesty